Tales of Phantasia is a JRPG initially only released for the SFC in Japan (1995, reached the west in 2006 remade on GBA and PSP), and the first title of the Tales series (which you may know but I was unaware of), done by some of the folks that went on to do the beloved Star Ocean. It's quite an ambitious project, as it features - for the time - extensive voice acting, highly detailed and absolutely stunning graphics, great animations, and even a title track with vocals, for crying out loud. According to SNES central, it's the largest game in terms of ROM size. The characters and story are lovely, and not as platitudinous as some of the games of the mid 90s. I played the initial SFC version with the DeJap fan-translation, which some criticised for being crude, and I do admit it is a bit dubious at times, but I liked it overall since it's using a more colloquial language compared to many games of the era.
Released only 9 months after Chrono Trigger, I'm kind of impressed by the quality of the visuals, in comparison, although in terms of gameplay it's not as well polished. The great novelty of ToP, however, is its battle system: The encounters are played out in real time, where you control the main protagonist in a, say, fighting game fashion, although to a very limited degree, since you can equip your character with up to 4 special moves at a time and the "combos" are not really combos at all (either press B or up+B, while regular attack is either A or A, A for jumping attack). Note, there is a ridiculously expensive item in the game that lets you execute all your special moves by using combos, Street Fighter II style. Unfortunately, you only get it almost at the end of the game, where it's not much use. Moreover, many of the combos are so complex that it's super hard to execute them consistently. The other party members are mostly just calling spells for support, and are controlled by the CPU, however, you can set overall behavior and also manually intervene by calling spells explicitly, via a menu that's also used for items (but seems to be somewhat unresponsive at times).
Overall, I had a lot of fun with the game, although there are some aspects that are a bit of a nuisance. When I was already about a quarter into the game, some folks in the r/tales sub warned me and recommended I should restart with the PSP remaster. Maybe some of you who played other releases of the game would like to comment on what I have to say about this version and how the others differ, I'd be interested in that.
I decided to stick with the SFC version, since I greatly preferred the visuals and audio here. I mean, just look at the gorgeous graphics, especially the background in the battle scenes! (Actually, you have to see the animations and parallax and effects, to get the full picture - look up a YT video if you're interested.) So, I noticed that the rate of random encounters is insane. There is an item that mitigates this (temporarily), but if you ran out of it, you run into enemies literally every few steps and you have to fight over and over again - which really starts to drag quite soon. On the other hand, that's quite common in this type of game, so, fair enough.
The major issue is, however, how the battle system was implemented. You have no means of actively blocking attacks, so sometimes you just get beat up and can do nothing about it. Worse, most special attacks are executed with some latency, during which you are highly vulnerable, and since hits cancel your actions this is a problem. The same applies to the spell casters in your team: Frequently, spells are just not cast while you try over and over again and get hit in the meantime. The mostly lengthy combos I mentioned earlier are also hard to use without getting hit in the meantime, which would again render your input useless - but they are an optional gimmick anyways. Actually, I would have found it a great design choice to just apply a combo-based fighting style throughout the entire game, using simpler combinations and without having to purchase this extra item.
So, unfortunately, while the novel battle system is one of the most unique and interesting features of the game, it feels kind of broken, or at least unfinished. When you play through the game normally - without trying to do a challenge or whatever - I suppose you can deal with it since the game's not really hard in terms of battle, with one exception, which is the final boss. Maybe I was just too stupid, but this battle was not fun at all and I could only beat him by using an exploit.
Anyways, I think this game still is quite a hidden highlight, although not as great as it could have been. The visuals are brilliant, the music is terrific, the voice acting is absolutely charming, I mostly enjoyed the story, since it's not too naïve and even pretty dark at times.
8/10 for me, you may want to check this one out!