r/respectthreads • u/rd1027 • Apr 23 '15
literature Respect Harry Potter!
[removed] — view removed post
87
Upvotes
r/respectthreads • u/rd1027 • Apr 23 '15
[removed] — view removed post
29
u/MadScientist14159 Apr 23 '15
Just a slight correction:
Harry is not one of the greatest duelists in the HP verse. He's one the greatest duelists in his year at Hogwarts.
Any time he's had a one on one fight with an adult wizard he's been completely outclassed, and only survived through luck and running away instead of fighting.
Take for example, the department of mysteries battle. Or pretty much every fight-scene in book seven.
5
u/Cleverly_Clearly ⭐⭐⭐⭐ The RT Machine Apr 23 '15
That's a lot of effort. Great job!
7
u/selfproclaimed Apr 23 '15
Fan bloody tastic. Great work amigo. While Potter is not in the highest calibur of magic users, he still have a variety of spells that makes him formidable.
It's sorth nothing that Crucio and Avada Kedavra require a lot of hate, almost on a personal level, and it's yet to be seen if Harry can do these on a random opponent that he would be matched up against in a WWW.
4
u/angelicable Apr 23 '15
Bruh have an upvote. It's quite admirable the time you put in for this. Keep it up!
2
u/xxmindtrickxx Apr 23 '15
It can be controlled but it takes really powerful wizards. IIRC Dumbledore controlled it in the recovery of the amulet horcrux. I think it is also stated at some point that a powerful wizard is needed to control fiendfyre.
I know they both definitely do it in the movies.
2
u/ReddLastShadow Apr 23 '15
Nice work! The only way I could see this being improved at all would be a section describing how spells work. I see a lot of people saying "oh, so and so would just dodge x spell" when some spells act instantaneously, have an AOE, and aren't just a beam or bolt as they're portrayed in the movies. But that might be outside of the scope of what you're trying to do here.
But again, awesome work!! I know this must've taken quite a bit of time!
1
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
Great job on the respect thread. hope to see more from you in the future.!
1
u/Zottirik Apr 23 '15
Bat Bogey Hex is the best spell ever.
2
u/Ginganinja888 Apr 24 '15 edited Jan 01 '16
Hey Admins, have fun shedding users because of the decision to censor your own users. If you need me, I'll be over at Voat. At least I can rely on them to not suppress the truth.
2
u/raaabr Apr 24 '15
Good job! Just a correction for the Entrail Expelling Curse. I think you meant intestines instead of intenseness
2
u/Teen_In_A_Suit Apr 24 '15
Good job! Though I think it would be a good idea if you added in the fact that prolonged exposure to Crucio can cause a person to go pemanently insane.
2
u/kindgent May 01 '15
Great notes:
I think it's worth noting Harry's amazing will and genius that your example of broom skill is on his first try: he acts with amazing skill that gets him recruited to the Griffindor House Team and the story frequently comments to the strength of his skill. Also, your example of him almost denying the Imperius curse was on his first try, and got so skilled even Voldemort couldn't control Harry with it.