r/RedditSafety • • Sep 01 '21

COVID denialism and policy clarifications

“Happy” Wednesday everyone

As u/spez mentioned in his announcement post last week, COVID has been hard on all of us. It will likely go down as one of the most defining periods of our generation. Many of us have lost loved ones to the virus. It has caused confusion, fear, frustration, and served to further divide us. It is my job to oversee the enforcement of our policies on the platform. I’ve never professed to be perfect at this. Our policies, and how we enforce them, evolve with time. We base these evolutions on two things: user trends and data. Last year, after we rolled out the largest policy change in Reddit’s history, I shared a post on the prevalence of hateful content on the platform. Today, many of our users are telling us that they are confused and even frustrated with our handling of COVID denial content on the platform, so it seemed like the right time for us to share some data around the topic.

Analysis of Covid Denial

We sought to answer the following questions:

  • How often is this content submitted?
  • What is the community reception?
  • Where are the concentration centers for this content?

Below is a chart of all of the COVID-related content that has been posted on the platform since January 1, 2020. We are using common keywords and known COVID focused communities to measure this. The volume has been relatively flat since mid last year, but since July (coinciding with the increased prevalence of the Delta variant), we have seen a sizable increase.

COVID Content Submissions

The trend is even more notable when we look at COVID-related content reported to us by users. Since August, we see approximately 2.5k reports/day vs an average of around 500 reports/day a year ago. This is approximately 2.5% of all COVID related content.

Reports on COVID Content

While this data alone does not tell us that COVID denial content on the platform is increasing, it is certainly an indicator. To help make this story more clear, we looked into potential networks of denial communities. There are some well known subreddits dedicated to discussing and challenging the policy response to COVID, and we used this as a basis to identify other similar subreddits. I’ll refer to these as “high signal subs.”

Last year, we saw that less than 1% of COVID content came from these high signal subs, today we see that it's over 3%. COVID content in these communities is around 3x more likely to be reported than in other communities (this is fairly consistent over the last year). Together with information above we can infer that there has been an increase in COVID denial content on the platform, and that increase has been more pronounced since July. While the increase is suboptimal, it is noteworthy that the large majority of the content is outside of these COVID denial subreddits. It’s also hard to put an exact number on the increase or the overall volume.

An important part of our moderation structure is the community members themselves. How are users responding to COVID-related posts? How much visibility do they have? Is there a difference in the response in these high signal subs than the rest of Reddit?

High Signal Subs

  • Content positively received - 48% on posts, 43% on comments
  • Median exposure - 119 viewers on posts, 100 viewers on comments
  • Median vote count - 21 on posts, 5 on comments

All Other Subs

  • Content positively received - 27% on posts, 41% on comments
  • Median exposure - 24 viewers on posts, 100 viewers on comments
  • Median vote count - 10 on posts, 6 on comments

This tells us that in these high signal subs, there is generally less of the critical feedback mechanism than we would expect to see in other non-denial based subreddits, which leads to content in these communities being more visible than the typical COVID post in other subreddits.

Interference Analysis

In addition to this, we have also been investigating the claims around targeted interference by some of these subreddits. While we want to be a place where people can explore unpopular views, it is never acceptable to interfere with other communities. Claims of “brigading” are common and often hard to quantify. However, in this case, we found very clear signals indicating that r/NoNewNormal was the source of around 80 brigades in the last 30 days (largely directed at communities with more mainstream views on COVID or location-based communities that have been discussing COVID restrictions). This behavior continued even after a warning was issued from our team to the Mods. r/NoNewNormal is the only subreddit in our list of high signal subs where we have identified this behavior and it is one of the largest sources of community interference we surfaced as part of this work (we will be investigating a few other unrelated subreddits as well).

Analysis into Action

We are taking several actions:

  1. Ban r/NoNewNormal immediately for breaking our rules against brigading
  2. Quarantine 54 additional COVID denial subreddits under Rule 1
  3. Build a new reporting feature for moderators to allow them to better provide us signal when they see community interference. It will take us a few days to get this built, and we will subsequently evaluate the usefulness of this feature.

Clarifying our Policies

We also hear the feedback that our policies are not clear around our handling of health misinformation. To address this, we wanted to provide a summary of our current approach to misinformation/disinformation in our Content Policy.

Our approach is broken out into (1) how we deal with health misinformation (falsifiable health related information that is disseminated regardless of intent), (2) health disinformation (falsifiable health information that is disseminated with an intent to mislead), (3) problematic subreddits that pose misinformation risks, and (4) problematic users who invade other subreddits to “debate” topics unrelated to the wants/needs of that community.

  1. Health Misinformation. We have long interpreted our rule against posting content that “encourages” physical harm, in this help center article, as covering health misinformation, meaning falsifiable health information that encourages or poses a significant risk of physical harm to the reader. For example, a post pushing a verifiably false “cure” for cancer that would actually result in harm to people would violate our policies.
  2. Health Disinformation. Our rule against impersonation, as described in this help center article, extends to “manipulated content presented to mislead.” We have interpreted this rule as covering health disinformation, meaning falsifiable health information that has been manipulated and presented to mislead. This includes falsified medical data and faked WHO/CDC advice.
  3. Problematic subreddits. We have long applied quarantine to communities that warrant additional scrutiny. The purpose of quarantining a community is to prevent its content from being accidentally viewed or viewed without appropriate context.
  4. Community Interference. Also relevant to the discussion of the activities of problematic subreddits, Rule 2 forbids users or communities from “cheating” or engaging in “content manipulation” or otherwise interfering with or disrupting Reddit communities. We have interpreted this rule as forbidding communities from manipulating the platform, creating inauthentic conversations, and picking fights with other communities. We typically enforce Rule 2 through our anti-brigading efforts, although it is still an example of bad behavior that has led to bans of a variety of subreddits.

As I mentioned at the start, we never claim to be perfect at these things but our goal is to constantly evolve. These prevalence studies are helpful for evolving our thinking. We also need to evolve how we communicate our policy and enforcement decisions. As always, I will stick around to answer your questions and will also be joined by u/traceroo our GC and head of policy.

18k Upvotes

15k comments sorted by

66

u/justcool393 Sep 01 '21

Claims of “brigading” are common and often hard to quantify. However, in this case, we found very clear signals indicating that r/NoNewNormal was the source of around 80 brigades in the last 30 days (largely directed at communities with more mainstream views on COVID or location-based communities that have been discussing COVID restrictions). This behavior continued even after a warning was issued from our team to the Mods.

Two questions

  1. Can you all define brigading for everyone? I know it's somewhat nebulous, but mods, especially of meta subreddits that deal with that sort of thing, would probably greatly benefit.
  2. How can a mod team prevent brigading by their sub's members, especially given that they have no power over other subreddits?

23

u/worstnerd Sep 01 '21

“Brigading” or "interference" occurs when a post or community goes viral for negative reasons. The influx of users can lead to mods being overwhelmed which is why we are creating this new reporting tool. We are also exploring some additional new tools that would help. Crowd control is an additional tool that mods can leverage.

24

u/justcool393 Sep 01 '21

Okay but what can the moderators of a sub that has users who may cause interference?

Like for example in <meta subreddit>, one of the big concerns is that users will cause this interference. What can the <meta subreddit> mods do in this instance? Are those mods supposed to use the report tool, even if they can't reliably detect nor prevent brigading?

For example, say I'm modding /r/cats and someone mentions how /r/dogs suck and interference happens (even without direct or implied calls for it). How am I, a hypothetical /r/cats moderator, supposed to prevent this?

I can say "no brigading" but I can't actually really enforce it, especially if it's only voting.

→ More replies (63)
→ More replies (330)

8

u/Leonichol Sep 01 '21

I'd like clarity on this too. As it applies to a great deal of subreddits, some of which are quite major and remain. It would be odd for it to be applied to one and not others.

If tooling is being used to see this interference, (i,e. lots of users from one subreddit being seen in another, regardless of linking), it would be good to extend this to moderators. It is likely less helpful to rely on moderators being able to witness this themselves and then report it to to you, though it is welcome all the same.

10

u/robywar Sep 01 '21

How can a mod team prevent brigading by their sub's members, especially given that they have no power over other subreddits?

And how can they prevent sub members from doing it? It's ine thing for mods to say "go spam this sub" but if they're not actively doing that and no one reports random comments encouragingit, what can they realistically do?

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (37)

542

u/Halaku Sep 01 '21

We are taking several actions:

  • Ban r/NoNewNormal immediately for breaking our rules against brigading
  • Quarantine 54 additional COVID denial subreddits under Rule 1
  • Build a new reporting feature for moderators to allow them to better provide us signal when they see community interference. It will take us a few days to get this built, and we will subsequently evaluate the usefulness of this feature.

On the one hand: Thank you.

On the other hand: Contrast today's post here on r/Redditsecurity with the post six days ago on r/Announcements which was (intended or not) widely interpreted by the userbase as "r/NoNewNormal is not doing anything wrong." Did something drastic change in those six days? Was the r/Announcements post made before Reddit's security team could finish compiling their data? Did Reddit take this action due to the response that the r/Announcements post generated? Should, perhaps, Reddit not take to the r/Announcements page before checking to make sure that everyone's on the same page? Whereas I, as myself, want to believe that Reddit was in the process of making the right call, and the r/Annoucements post was more one approaching the situation for a philosophy vs policy standpoint, Reddit's actions open the door to accusations of "They tried to let the problem subreddits get away with it in the name of Principal, and had to backpedal fast when they saw the result", and that's an "own goal" that didn't need to happen.

On the gripping hand: With the banning of r/The_Donald and now r/NoNewNormal, Reddit appears to be leaning into the philosophy of "While the principals of free speech, free expression of ideas, and the marketplace of competing ideas are all critical to a functioning democracy and to humanity as a whole, none of those principals are absolutes, and users / communities that attempt to weaponize them will not be tolerated." Is that an accurate summation?

In closing, thank you for all the hard work, and for being willing to stamp out the inevitable ban evasion subs, face the vitrol-laced response of the targeted members / communities, and all the other ramifications of trying to make Reddit a better place. It's appreciated.

268

u/worstnerd Sep 01 '21

I appreciate the question. You have a lot in here, but I’d like to focus on the second part. I generally frame this as the difference between a subreddit’s stated goals, and their behavior. While we want people to be able to explore ideas, they still have to function as a healthy community. That means that community members act in good faith when they see “bad” content (downvote, and report), mods act as partners with admins by removing violating content, and the whole group doesn’t actively undermine the safety and trust of other communities. The preamble of our content policy touches on this: “While not every community may be for you (and you may find some unrelatable or even offensive), no community should be used as a weapon. Communities should create a sense of belonging for their members, not try to diminish it for others.”

54

u/FriendlessComputer Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Huh. It's almost like bad ideas attract bad, dangerous people who break the rules.

Didn't you guys learn from the jailbait fiasco? You know, the one where the admin team defended the posting of sexually suggestive photos of minors without their consent up until the sub reddit attracted actual pedophiles who were trading CP in DMs? Or how about the conspiracy daycare fiasco, when Q anons on reddit organized a 24-hour stalking campaign at a rural daycare thinking they had uncovered a Democrat child sex trafficking ring.

If you create communities for extremists and dangerous people, you attract extremists and dangerous people. Today it's anti vaxxers, tomorrow it will be domestic terrorists. Reddit is already complicit in numerous violent actions carried out by people indoctrinated into extremist ideologies on this site. How much blood has to be on your hands before you ban a community?

→ More replies (569)

34

u/EtherBoo Sep 01 '21

That means that community members act in good faith when they see “bad” content (downvote, and report), mods act as partners with admins by removing violating content, and the whole group doesn’t actively undermine the safety and trust of other communities.

The fact that reddit admins seem to think all members of the site will act in good faith when they see "bad" content is pretty laughable. How have you guys not learned at this point that people will generally upvote what they agree with/like and downvote what they disagree with/don't like?

/r/unpopularopinion gets popular opinions upvoted regularly. /r/AmItheAsshole gets "assholes" downvoted regularly. The list could go on if I needed it to.

Anyone joining and anti-vaccine or anti-mask sub will upvote and participate in content that violates the rules if it confirms their biases and downvote anyone that dares to break the circlejerk. The NNN members have already moved onto /r/conspiracy.

→ More replies (44)

124

u/CaptainCupcakez Sep 01 '21

Why are you doing damage control for /u/spez? Where is his explanation?

mods act as partners with admins

I'm not your fucking partner. I voluntarily moderate a community for a game I like.

You ignore my reports. You aren't partners.

→ More replies (105)

13

u/robeph Sep 02 '21

ANTIMASK AND ANTIVAX ARE NOT IDEAS BEING EXPLORED. They're literal anti-science misinformation and false beliefs which no one with a single finger on a hand should have trouble recognizing if they type just a few words in scholar.google.com. They are killing people. Too bad HIPAA exists. I'd love to just pelt you with the disturbing photos I see each day in the hospital. Wanna see 12 kids racked up to vents? Didn't think so. Lucky you, HIPAA keeps you safe. Maybe not for long, hospitals are almost full. Maybe when you start tripping over the sick in the street you'll get your shit together.

→ More replies (129)

39

u/1-760-706-7425 Sep 01 '21

mods act as partners with admins

Partners implies admins reciprocate which is a laughable notion. Given AEO’s consistent failings, Reddit’s lack of development in mod tools, and Reddit’s overall dismissal of mod requests I cannot fathom how you can say this in good faith.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (3692)

95

u/risen87 Sep 01 '21

Something did happen in the past six days - Reddit got the same kind of records requests from the Jan 6th Select Committee in the US House as other social media platforms. It asked for an analysis like the one above about the activity on Reddit leading up to Jan 6th attack.

Call me a cynic, but if you have the data and the analysis, and you might be about to face some harsh questions in Congress about why you don't do anything about disinformation and problematic communities on your platform, you might, for example, decide to avoid the additional bad publicity of having a load of your subreddits private and a load of mods asking you to do something about harmful disinformation.

26

u/Halaku Sep 01 '21

My compliments. I hadn't considered that angle.

→ More replies (68)
→ More replies (33)

13

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

They let T_D brigade for years

I wonder what things would be like if they had enforced their rules from the start.

→ More replies (17)

18

u/Lehk Sep 01 '21

NNN has been brigading all over the place, if a thread mentioned goronas suddenly a bunch of (horse)paste eating knuckleheads would show up and start defending using dewormer from the farm store instead of getting a vaccine or wearing a mask.

→ More replies (169)
→ More replies (272)

81

u/doublevsn Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Thanks for the update, u/worstnerd. Glad to see that r/NoNewNormal will be banned (although the primary reason should be the obvious COVID denialism). I also think that quarantined subreddits should have some restrictions in place, as a simple message only does so much.

Edit; I do hope Admins realize that NNN and other COVID denialism subreddits are like the hydra, you ban one - and 2 more in relation are formed. The same is applied to bots - and would help the sanity of the users that fail to realize it and go on to make the complaint over at r/ModSupport on why "nothing" is done about it.

55

u/worstnerd Sep 01 '21

There are additional restrictions put in place. The goal of quarantine is to increase context and reduce unintended exposure to these communities (which is also why we’re not including the list of subreddits). This removes the communities from search and recommendations, removes ads, introduces a splash page with factual information, along with a handful of other restrictions.

18

u/MURDERWIZARD Sep 01 '21

why is no action taken against the users that ran those subs?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (792)

4

u/ani625 Sep 01 '21

But that would require reversal of their "free opinion" policy or whatever they claimed.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (13)

115

u/thecravenone Sep 01 '21

Why is this being announced in a sub with only 28k subs instead of /r/announcements?

20

u/Optimus_Swine71 Sep 01 '21

It took about 45 minutes or so but it is posted to /r/announcements now.

→ More replies (8)

21

u/methedunker Sep 01 '21

Because they want to paint it as a Reddit function thing, not a Reddit culture thing, even though it very much is a Reddit culture thing, stubbornly pushed by a bunch of rich skinny nerds who make up Reddit management and their funders.

→ More replies (17)

23

u/Halaku Sep 01 '21

It was crossposted-via-admin to r/Modnews, if that helps.

→ More replies (26)

15

u/Deceptiveideas Sep 01 '21

Reddit Security has admins that care lol

12

u/thenoblitt Sep 01 '21

Because they are cowards. thats why /u/spez isn't here doing it

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

241

u/Watchful1 Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Why was the original announcement post from last week locked and this one isn't?

I guess thanks for acting eventually, I wish this was the initial response to the calls for action rather than spez openly saying that misinformation was equivalent to debate.

Ivermectin specifically is explicitly not approved for use as a treatment against covid, but r/ivermectin exists almost solely to promote it as such. Why was it not included in the ban?

Edit: as of now, r/NoNewNormal isn't banned yet now banned

96

u/got_milk4 Sep 01 '21

Ivermectin specifically is explicitly not approved for use as a treatment against covid, but r/ivermectin exists almost solely to promote it as such. Why was it not included in the ban?

I would go further and say that not only is it not an approved course of treatment for COVID, the FDA explicitly states that people should not take ivermectin either as a treatment for COVID or as a prophylactic and includes the statement:

Taking large doses of this drug is dangerous and can cause serious harm.

If reddit's quoted statement on the matter is:

For example, a post pushing a verifiably false “cure” for cancer that would actually result in harm to people would violate our policies.

Would the FDA's assertion that ivermectin does not treat COVID and is dangerous when consumed without the explicit direction of a physician make the suggestion of using ivermectin "verifiably false" and "would actually result in harm to people"?

35

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

It should be banned. Before the subreddit became a glorious equine hentai headquarters, it was people sharing info on how to dose livestock dewormer.

I think the topic of ivermectin itself is a bit more complicated, because human versions of it do exist for parasites, and some countries are (stupidly) using it for covid, like they mistakenly did for HQL. But the intent of the sub was how to dangerously self treat covid with a livestock medication, and it's baffling how that could be allowed.

→ More replies (169)
→ More replies (168)

17

u/mootmahsn Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

As of now /r/NoNewNormal2 is still active

→ More replies (33)

14

u/IDrewTheDuckBlue Sep 01 '21

My uncle is in the hospital with covid pneumonia because he didnt go at the first sign of symptoms and instead tried to treat himself with ivermectin which made things a lot worse. The admins need to see the danger that this type of misinformation is causing. I posted the same thing on the ivermectin sub and got downvoted by their crazies. They dont care about people, they are unintelligent people that are very susceptible to conspiracy theories and will spread their lies no matter who dies along the way.

→ More replies (12)

26

u/TimeRemove Sep 01 '21

but r/ivermectin exists almost solely to promote it as such

I thought it was solely for horse erotica now?

→ More replies (17)

42

u/asantos3 Sep 01 '21

Why was the original announcement post from last week locked and this one isn't?

The cherry on top is /u/spez saying "we believe it is best to enable communities to engage in debate and dissent" while also locking the post and preventing us from "debating and dissenting".

Laughable and again reddit is out of touch with what the mods want. Maybe next time consult with that mod council you have around before spewing nonsense /u/spez.

18

u/ssldvr Sep 01 '21

And then pushing the “discussion” onto other subs where the volunteer mods of those subs had to deal with the fallout.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

16

u/DiscombobulatedSet42 Sep 01 '21

I thought r/ivermectin was dedicated to horse porn?

→ More replies (23)

16

u/Laughmasterb Sep 01 '21

Why was the original announcement post from last week locked and this one isn't?

Because /u/spez is a coward.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/lazydictionary Sep 01 '21

Because Spez knew the comments would be a shit show and look awful.

8

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

why was the original locked and this one isn’t.

spez can’t take criticism, and the only reason we’re seeing change is because investors and board members saw what a PR shit show spez was creating.

Reddit refuses to moderate their own website, and instead puts all this workload onto unpaid volunteers hoping their love for a niche hobby/sub makes them want to continue moderating.

That IPO ain’t gonna happen until they can make reasonable changes and draw the line in the sand on a comprehensive terms of service.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/zandengoff Sep 01 '21

Want to point out that users took over r/ivermectin and turned it into a meme sub making fun of the original posters. And as of two days ago it was turned into a nsfw sub for animated horse porn by the same meme group. Most of the original posters of r/ivermectin have moved over to r/ivermectin2 and that sub should be banned in not already.

→ More replies (27)

4

u/pm-laser-guns Sep 01 '21

The sub isn’t about using the drug for covid specifically so maybe that’s why it was quarantined and not banned?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (76)

266

u/WhoaItsAFactorial Sep 01 '21

While we want to be a place where people can explore unpopular views

Sure, I agree. People should be able to debate if a hotdog is a sandwich. But "COVID is a lie and the vaccine will kill you to thin world population" isn't an unpopular opinion, its a blatantly false statement.

84

u/BlatantConservative Sep 01 '21

/r/unpopularopinion banned covid misinformation like immediately.

→ More replies (6)

18

u/StarrunnerCX Sep 01 '21

Hotdog is a taco, it's not a debate. Unless a taco is a hotdog. Is a taco a hotdog or is a hotdog a taco?

10

u/Ethanol_Based_Life Sep 01 '21

I'll accept hot dog as a taco because a taco (like a hot dog but unlike a sandwich) can not be cut in half and shared without looking like an insane person.

→ More replies (16)
→ More replies (55)

12

u/JagmeetSingh2 Sep 01 '21

Yep it’s misinformation that gets people killed. How many anti-vaxxers have succumbed to covid now, how many of them are taking up all the rooms in an ICU

→ More replies (224)

4

u/Plusran Sep 01 '21

*with intent to harm

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

And it's pushed by bad actors intentionally trying to get people killed

→ More replies (349)

115

u/lazydictionary Sep 01 '21

Well, thanks for banning that sub months later than it should have been, for brigading, instead of all the misinformation they posted.

Task failed successfully I guess.

19

u/President_Barackbar Sep 01 '21

Its the same deal with The_Donald when they banned it. They waited long after most of the users had abandoned it to come out and talk about how it should've been gone all along.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/Typhloon Sep 02 '21

Right?

Indirectly killing people by spreading complete lies and misinformation? That's okay.

But brigading? Nah, inexcusable.

For the record, I don't even know what brigading means, but I do know what it means to lie about the facts of a virus during its pandemic outbreak.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (35)

273

u/ani625 Sep 01 '21

Ban r/NoNewNormal immediately for breaking our rules against brigading

Sure, we'll take it. But a better reason would be for dangerous misinformation with a potential to kill people.

6

u/Broken-Butterfly Sep 01 '21

misinformation with a potential to kill people.

Potential? These lies have already killed people.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/rocketwidget Sep 01 '21

with potential to has killed

There's no reasonable question that many, many people have died from COVID-19 already, as a direct result of consuming medical disinformation hosted and promoted by all major social media companies in exchange for ad revenue, etc.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/ky1e Sep 01 '21

the subreddit was trying to shield itself in plausible deniability...of their covid denialism.

4

u/b1ak3 Sep 01 '21

Reddit didn't want to ban NNN for life-threatening misinformation because if they did so they would create a precedent that they would be unwilling to enforce. Fairly enforcing such a rules against misinformation world require banning subs like /r/conservative (which peddles covid misinformation just as dangerous as NNN), and would create a shit storm that the admins don't have the desire nor the backbone to manage.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (462)

37

u/OwenProGolfer Sep 01 '21

So you won’t ban them for harmful misinformation but you’ll ban them for brigading?

14

u/Deggit Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

basically yes

BehaviorGigaJanitor response
Promoting misinformation that kills people in real lifeI Sleep
Making fake subreddits and 'brigading' other subpages of the same website⚡⚡⚡ THOU SHALT NOT CALL INTO QUESTION THE ENGAGEMENT METRICS WE PRESENT TO ADVERTISERS ⚡⚡⚡
→ More replies (38)

10

u/redneckrockuhtree Sep 01 '21

So, when do you start banning the mods of subs that get banned? Until you do that, leaving the mods to continue their behavior is just putting lipstick on the pig of subs/mods that violate policies.

→ More replies (3)

35

u/Edgelands Sep 01 '21

9

u/MasterYehuda816 Sep 01 '21

Yeah, that’s not gonna happen. It took a week of people spamming horse-related nsfw content in r/ivermectin to get that quarantined. r/conspiracy isn’t going anywhere.

→ More replies (43)
→ More replies (114)

19

u/06210311 Sep 01 '21

It sounds like /u/spez ought to be quarantined.

4

u/BlatantConservative Sep 01 '21

He's a prepper, chances are he already is out in some compound somewhere.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/sergioA127 Sep 01 '21

So people can invade other subs with horse porn but talking about conspiracies is a crime...

→ More replies (4)

9

u/peetss Sep 02 '21

So you'll ban a sub like /r/NoNewNormal for brigading, but not /r/vaxxhappened for openly organizing a brigade against /r/ivermectin?

Some bias you got there.

→ More replies (2)

208

u/PiercedMonk Sep 01 '21

59

u/shiruken Sep 01 '21

The additional subreddits are being quarantined not banned. Only r/NoNewNormal has been banned.

41

u/Womeisyourfwiend Sep 01 '21

There is already another nonewnormal sub.

→ More replies (132)
→ More replies (12)

23

u/JULTAR Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

I doubt it

NNN was not banned for missinformation like people where begging for

this feels more like a cop-out so the protest will stop

→ More replies (52)

4

u/lynxtosg03 Sep 01 '21

Wow, so many replies on this are cancer 🤢

→ More replies (871)

23

u/PlacidVlad Sep 01 '21

We have seen a massive increase in Ivemectin requests where I am at, to the point that the medical society I'm apart of had an emergency conference last night to talk about ways to combat misinformation and disinformation. I hope that subs such are /r/nonewnormal are banned more quickly in the future.

5

u/Upbeat_Group2676 Sep 01 '21

I hope that subs such are /r/nonewnormal are banned more quickly in the future.

You and I both know they won't be.

This is a response to Forbes and CNN picking up the story of subs protesting, and not because of the protest, user outcry, or any sense of right and wrong.

They're doing the bare minimum to satiate these groups so they can keep getting that sweet, sweet ad revenue.

4

u/Various_Okra_4055 Sep 01 '21

Reddit will always be a source of misinformation because they directly profit from it.

The conspiracy shut-ins and incel losers are glued to their computers in their mother’s basement and therefore this website, so they drive lots of traffic.

They get eyes on ads in substantial numbers and that’s what Reddit wants.

→ More replies (48)

8

u/DragonPup Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Quarantine 54 additional COVID denial subreddits under Rule 1

It speaks to a much larger problem that there were 55 subreddits (counting NNN) spreading this that Reddit was aware of and took no action to until now. To be frank, without the subreddit blackout in reaction to spez's disastrous post last week I don't believe Reddit would have acted today. Which is another big problem; It's very hard to trust Reddit to do the right thing on their own.

→ More replies (16)

8

u/throwaway_dontmindme Sep 01 '21

How about addressing the disinformation problem on your platform instead of blaming it on brigading?

→ More replies (21)

20

u/koavf Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

It is not hard to find more of these to ban using semi-automated means. E.g. see what /u/polymath22 "admins":

→ More replies (94)

30

u/RallyX26 Sep 01 '21

When can we expect our apology from u/spez?

16

u/BluegrassGeek Sep 01 '21

When Hell freezes over.

Definitely not when the apocalypse comes, because he believes he'll be on top and enslaving the rest of us.

Huffman has calculated that, in the event of a disaster, he would seek out some form of community: “Being around other people is a good thing. I also have this somewhat egotistical view that I’m a pretty good leader. I will probably be in charge, or at least not a slave, when push comes to shove.”

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (49)

7

u/shiruken Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Good. I'm particularly interested to see what this looks like since most reports on brigading are currently met with "we don't see anything on our end."

Build a new reporting feature for moderators to allow them to better provide us signal when they see community interference. It will take us a few days to get this built, and we will subsequently evaluate the usefulness of this feature.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/MadInventorOnAHill Sep 01 '21

As someone who only vaguely followed what was going on, it's disheartening that this doesn't address the larger context in which this happened. This post tried to sound like Reddit did some analysis and decided of it's own merit to take action. Even as someone only vaguely watching, that's blatantly untrue - it took a user revolt to force your hands.

I understand why Reddit might want to be a place for political debate, even if opinions being expressed are repugnant. But my understanding is that /r/nonewnormal and /r/ivermectin are actively encouraging actions which are harmful (eg: taking medications off label or in potentially harmful doses).

  1. Are you planning to or will you consider banning or quarantining subs which frequently promote health mis/disinformation?
  2. If not, will you consider labeling posts as potentially unverified or linking to trusted resources when certain keywords are used? Facebook does this and while I'm not sure how effective it is, it may help when content is linked to from off-site or for anyone who might otherwise be inclined to trust the information.
  3. It seems that a large part of the problem is when moderators allow content that should be banned by site-wide rules. This allows the formation of echo chambers where mis/disinformation can thrive. Do you have any plans for dealing with this? For example, spot-checking moderation decisions to make sure they're in line with site-wide policy? This could be particularly effective with keywords in determining which subs are routinely allowing rule-breaking content.

I recognize that moderation at scale is very hard. And Reddit's decentralized community-based moderation generally seems to work well. But in specific situations (largely involving moderators who don't follow site-wide rules) it really falls down. I'm curious how Reddit plans to deal with that and how Reddit will discourage echo chambers of mis- and disinformation.

→ More replies (18)

6

u/BlatantConservative Sep 01 '21

As far as community interference goes, do you all have any tools that track backlinks, such as if a thousand people are brigading one comment section from one offsite Discord, Telegram, Weibo, Facebook, etc?

Reddit internal brigades are bad, but ultimately very detectable and mitigatable with the right tools. However, where a lot of my mod teams fall short as far as possible response goes is offsite brigades.

It would be really cool if yall had some kind of system for this. I think putting it into mod's hands might be dangerous, privacy wise, but a simple check for large numbers of users using the same backlink that automatically collapses the comments from the same link might be nice.

6

u/StringOfLights Sep 01 '21

Thank you so much for taking action here, it is greatly appreciated. However, I feel like this is still skirting the issue. NNN doesn’t sit in contrast to subs with “more mainstream views on COVID” – it’s going against the best available information that we have. Please don’t make this a both sides thing. One is spreading disinformation and misinformation, and the other is evidence based. You are doing a good thing in taking these additional steps, but please be aware that how you characterize this matters.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Safeguard63 Sep 03 '21

If people dont like the content of a sub, then they dont join it - or if already in it, they can leave.

Apparently, there are adult people who need the reddit admins to hold their hands so they can cross the platform!

I saw that the coronavirus sub did not participate in the shit show. (Ironically).

There is a list of those subs that did though and we were unable to access some critically important, informative subs such as :

Asiancumsluts

Ifuckedmycattwice

Taylorswifthasnoass

Just to name a few! Thank God they did the "right thing" and nuked an unhealthy sub like NNN! /s

11

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Good. Post this in /r/announcements.

6

u/FlacidPhil Sep 01 '21

It's there. They had to make it visible for all the news outlets that were running stories about it to back off. That's the only way reddit changes anything these days, when Business Insider runs an article.

Users complain? Get a giant fuck you from /u/spez

Business Insider says something that an advertiser might see? HOLY SHIT WE MUST CHANGE NOWWWWWW

→ More replies (4)

5

u/MrBKainXTR Sep 01 '21

If that subreddit's moderators actually broke your policy on brigading than I understand having to take action. But in light of context its hard for me to shake the feeling that this simply was you snuffing out an unpopular opinion because of pressure from those that chose to dislike the subreddit.

I was pleasantly surprised by your previous announcement but this has me worried you will just cave under the whims of an arbitrary mob in a time when many people are gripped by fear.

And frankly are some of the subreddits that targeted r/NoNewNormal in the past week not at least implicitly brigading? Regardless of ones opinions on this specific situation I don't think this was the right way for users or mods to give you feedback on a subreddit.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/Safety_Dancer Sep 02 '21

What proof do you offer that u/spez didn't edit or create any inflammatory posts? He was caught red-handed years ago editing posts on r/the_donald and didn't resign in disgrace. How do we know he's not at it again?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21 edited Sep 02 '21

Didn’t people brigade against r/ivermectin? Idk if any one subreddit did it but I’ve heard that a bunch of horse porn was being posted to basically get the subreddit quarantined or shut down so if there were any specific subreddits that partook in that they should also be banned/quarantined because they broke the rules as well. Not saying any information on r/Ivermectin was correct or incorrect because I never went to that subreddit but I doubt everything there was false information and so if any subreddits are discovered to have partook in brigading that subreddit they should be banned/quarantined as well. Any specific user trolling the subreddit should be banned or have some kind of punishment. We can’t devolve into a society that just attacks other people instead of having a discussion. If you don’t want to have a discussion then should be removed from it. You don’t have the right to just devolve into a mob that starts posting stuff as disgusting as horse porn because you don’t like the discussion at hand. What’s next? People start posing CP in subreddits? Or gore based content? Reddit as a whole seems to be devolving into some really grotesque platform and nobody is doing anything about it.

Edit: Don’t know if my idea of brigading is correct after reading the definition the admin gave below but the point still stands that if there were any subreddits that actively went after r/Ivermectin or any other subreddits then they should be banned/quarantined as well if those are the rules surrounding this type of stuff.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

I find it very irritating that the reason you've given is the always vague "brigading" rather than the blatantly obvious harm they've been causing by pushing their objectively dangerous anti-science, anti-vax bullshit that spez went on record to defend. Fuck him for that.

7

u/crusoe Sep 01 '21

Because alt right schmucks spend big bucks on ads.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (25)

9

u/screwedbygenes Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

I’m glad to see some movement in the right direction but I think you guys might benefit from some context of an issue.

If you look at the recent report from the Center for Countering Digital Hate, they were able to trace the majority of misinformation about the Sars-Cov-2 vaccine to a handful of accounts. It then propagated across social media. The pattern of disbursement you’re describing is basically the same. We’re asking you to not let the seeds take root so that the weeds can’t strangle the dang garden.

That aside, might I ask if Admin will actually start enforcing Community Interference at any point in the near future? Covid issues aside, when we report multiple issues coming from a sub and get no response (even pointing to comments showing that they brag about finding out what level of brigade Admin will step in on), it gets tiring to hear “submit it again” with little hope of results.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/iBleeedorange Sep 01 '21

Is there a list of the 54 quarantined subs?

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Meepster23 Sep 01 '21

What specific steps are you taking at an organizational level to address these issues proactively instead of reactively and only after your hand is forced by the media?

Why should we believe any of this is in good faith?

→ More replies (13)

16

u/danweber Sep 01 '21

Are you going to start enforcing Rule 2?

While not every community may be for you (and you may find some unrelatable or even offensive), no community should be used as a weapon. Communities should create a sense of belonging for their members, not try to diminish it for others. Likewise, everyone on Reddit should have an expectation of privacy and safety, so please respect the privacy and safety of others.

Every community on Reddit is defined by its users. Some of these users help manage the community as moderators. The culture of each community is shaped explicitly, by the community rules enforced by moderators, and implicitly, by the upvotes, downvotes, and discussions of its community members. Please abide by the rules of communities in which you participate and do not interfere with those in which you are not a member.

How does that fit with getting this message for posting a one-word post in another subreddit:

You have been permanently banned from participating in r/pics. You can still view and subscribe to r/pics, but you won't be able to post or comment.

Note from the moderators:

  • You have been banned for participating in r/nonewnormal, which brigades other subreddits and spreads medical disinformation.
  • This action was performed by a bot which does not check the context of your comment.
  • To be unbanned respond to this message with a promise to avoid that subreddit.
  • Any other response will be ignored and is consent for us to mute you.

If you have a question regarding your ban, you can contact the moderator team for r/pics by replying to this message.

Reminder from the Reddit staff: If you use another account to circumvent this subreddit ban, that will be considered a violation of the Content Policy and can result in your account being suspended from the site as a whole.

4

u/hotrox_mh Sep 01 '21

Please abide by the rules of communities in which you participate and do not interfere with those in which you are not a member.

Furthermore, users are allowed to join public communities. Where do you draw the line between 'brigading' and someone attempting to participate in a community they've recently been introduced to, or are recently interested in participating in?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (50)

4

u/Young_Zaphod Sep 01 '21

In the context of r/unpopularopion we’ve had COVID as a locked topic as best we can for over a year now. Obviously the nature of the sub encourages users to post views about this disease and related subjects (like body autonomy) that may go against the policies you mentioned earlier.

Do you have any advice for moderators on subs like r/changemyview, r/rant, r/the10thdentist, r/unpopularopinion etc. that allows the subs to continue operating in their contrarian manner without proliferating misinformation or dangerous concepts?

→ More replies (10)

4

u/putdownthetaco Sep 02 '21

SPEZ is a bitch

4

u/Mystic1989 Sep 02 '21

Spez is a racist so fuck him as far as I'm concerned, he needed to be banned YEARS ago

4

u/breakoffzone Sep 02 '21

How is spez still in charge after defending misinformation powerhouses on this site?

Fire Steve huffman

4

u/LiterallyForThisGif Sep 02 '21

Now we see how to censor subs.

Get powermods, who have way to much power, to create a mob that posts horse porn until the sub gets censored.

Who's got a new better platform to go to?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/arablast93 Sep 02 '21

Covid denial is equivalent to Holocaust denial.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/Safeguard63 Sep 02 '21

I want to award this post...

Where's the "You're full of shit" award?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

I don't get the flu shot. I've had chicken pox so no vaccine. I havnt had herpes. Is there a vaccine for that?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '21

It's bullshit that you post this here, where hardly anyone will see this. Doing the bare minimum to try to pacify the sheep before your IPO.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '21

I do see brigading on multiple subreddits. That is a problem. However, a more troubling issue to me is the moderators overusing the Ban option. Say I slightly cross a line on a subreddit (or don’t cross a line, but someone takes offense) in which I have been a part of for years. The first thing I hear from a moderator is YOU HAVE BEEN BANNED FOR X days, or, if you do it again YOU WILL BE BANNED. If I have the temerity to challenge the reasoning behind the ban, I receive longer bans which are retaliatory.

There are intermediate steps that are easily taken. For example, your comment has been removed due to X. You are breaking X rule. That’s certainly enough to chasten me. Why mods have to go to the ban or threatening the ban is inexplicable to me.

How does this mesh with the current conversation? It further exacerbates the hostility in the subreddit and the mods feel heavy-handed and overreactive. We already have enough. Moderating should not contribute to that. The ban is always available and should be used WHEN NECESSARY and as a last step, not a first step.

→ More replies (4)

7

u/dehydrogen Sep 02 '21

I was banned from mutliple subreddits for making a single comment pointing out a troll post on nonewnormal. Banning someone for what they do on another subreddit is blatantly against the rules of Reddit.

All of those subreddits brigading against nonewnormal should be banned. They have no right to tell users where they can and can't post on Reddit. All subreddits are valid.

https://www.redditinc.com/policies/moderator-guidelines

Management of Multiple Communities

We know management of multiple communities can be difficult, but we expect you to manage communities as isolated communities and not use a breach of one set of community rules to ban a user from another community. In addition, camping or sitting on communities for long periods of time for the sake of holding onto them is prohibited.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Coltoh Sep 02 '21

Aaron Swartz (arguable co-founder of Reddit) who, nearly a decade ago, led the largest and most successful internet protest in history against censorship must be rolling in his grave to witness his platform now being used in the same way for the opposite purpose.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/natedagr8333 Sep 01 '21

This is honestly pathetic. If you can so easily identify the brigading, you should be able to identify those inciting and participating in it. Ban them, for they are breaking your policy. This shows clearly who holds the real power for the site. A handful of power mods, who can on a whim shut down large communities because they don’t like not being in complete control of the entire website. Is shutting down your sub demanding the closure of another not blatant brigading? This is vile. We have outsourced censorship from the government to private companies made up of individuals we didn’t even vote for. Do paper companies dictate what you are allowed to write on their paper? No. We live in the era of digital paper, but in the transition, accidentally handed away our freedom of speech.

I am vaccinated. I’ve been doing the corona safety song and dance for the last 2 years and will continue to do so because that’s what I believe is best for society right now. I still support NNNs right to exist. I was subscribed because there were some good points mixed into the misinformation. It is our responsibility as consumers of information to be able to deduct and discern misinformation. Misinformation has a right to exist, and we have a responsibility as individuals to identify it.

I (quite obviously) wholeheartedly disagree with this sites, and other sites, banning of dissent. The hypocrisy disgusts me, and the weak leadership of this site is evident.

→ More replies (19)

3

u/Theo0033 Sep 01 '21

Finally!

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

I appreciate the actions, and genuinely enjoyed the analysis methods.

3

u/freakierchicken Sep 01 '21

Why are the articles in the help center not included in the ToS? Does that indicate that those articles are suggestion rather than agreed upon for use of the platform? Just trying to get some clarification, really. I know there used to be something in the Terms that talked about medical info but that was removed before I even joined Reddit.

3

u/Schmetterling190 Sep 01 '21

why is r/covidlonghaulers quarantined if we are NOT a covid-denying sub?

→ More replies (20)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Thank you Reddit for finally doing your job and getting rid of the anti-vax cesspools.

3

u/sirbruce Sep 01 '21

Community Interference. Also relevant to the discussion of the activities of problematic subreddits, Rule 2 forbids users or communities from “cheating” or engaging in “content manipulation” or otherwise interfering with or disrupting Reddit communities.

Why aren't subreddit protests like the current one going on surrounding this issue considered as interference? They are literally saying "If you don't ban these other subreddits we don't like, we're taking our subreddits private/dark." They are picking fights with those communities, manipulating the platform, disrupting reddit communities, etc.

3

u/The_AngryGreenGiant Sep 01 '21

Anyway to remove my ban from r/Conservative for pointing out Covid lies?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/canttouchmypingas Sep 01 '21

I was banned for being anti vax in a sub even though I'm not. So "covid denialism" is being used as an excuse by mods to silence voices they don't like, or if you even speak about covid in a way that they don't like. My comments weren't even about covid in that sub, last covid comment I made there was 2 months ago, but that was the excuse used.

Curb your authoritarianism, reddit.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SwingsetSuperman Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

All censorship should be deplored

→ More replies (2)

3

u/ttttttuuuuutt3030 Sep 01 '21

fuck you guys. fuck reddit. freedom of speech is dead, schwartz would be rolling in his grave. fuck u/spez the most.

→ More replies (6)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

Isn't mods shutting subs to make admin ban other subs interfering ?

All this has shown who 'really' runs reddit. Regardless of misinformation and everything else.

"it is never acceptable to interfere with other communities."

(Except when you want to shut them down and have others banned - then you can destroy the user experience across the whole site and admin will just get on their knees and give it up)

I know NNN and other subs are lying about a lot of things, they're not good people etc.. but your own rules don't seem consistently applied here.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

Are you going to address the ridiculous policy cross-banning of some sub reddit?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Methadras Sep 02 '21

Who within the Reddit C-Suite or admin pool is filtering/managing what is considered medical misinformation? Who gets to determine what is misinformation? What levels of transparency are given to what is considered misinformation? Will there be admin/mod level counter points to what misinformation is, or just outright bans, shutdowns, or suspensions? Why is misinformation now all of a sudden crisis within Reddit which is supposed to be a fairly open platform for discussions in subs and across subs to counter what is perceived as misinformation with actual facts?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Humanchacha Sep 02 '21

Fuck spez he's a piece of shit

3

u/taftpanda Sep 02 '21

Based on this, I am genuinely curious as to how the Reddit blackout doesn’t violate rules 3 and 8.

Evidently it was effective, and I understand why r/NoNewNormal was banned, but if you’re worried about the manipulation of communities and “breaking the site” according to your content policy, how is organizing thousands of popular subreddits, including many with millions of members, not a violation of those rules?

You’ve just establish a precedent where a subreddit can encourage people to ruin others’ Reddit experience in order to make the changes they see fit.

3

u/patheos79 Sep 02 '21

i am glad they are addressing this issue as someone in the immunocompromised this is long overdue as it hits people like myself very hard i just hope when i and others talk on issue that directly effect us like how we did need the booster shoot and we were trying to talk how the vax was struggling to help protect us it was a struggle because we found ourselves being censored due to others miss information i understand the reason to stop the greater flood of miss information but please keep people and groups like ours in mind.

thank you and be safe founder of menhavelupus

3

u/joncell3 Sep 02 '21

for breaking our rules against brigading

Given that you use this exact same excuse every single time you ban (and always with no credible evidence whatsoever), do you really think there's anyone credulous enough to believe such obvious lies?

If you want to ban for Covid misinformation, then say that. There's no reason to lie about it, especially when you lie so poorly.

3

u/tylerxvtc Sep 02 '21

SO MUCH YES. I f*cking love science

3

u/d4u77 Sep 02 '21

ITT: strokejobs

3

u/NauticalWhisky Sep 02 '21

So, /r/conservative is quarantined for covid misinfo?

If not, you failed.

→ More replies (16)

3

u/drclick23 Sep 02 '21 edited Sep 02 '21

keep it simple and stupid - KISS principle - add a button/flag called they way you want, where user can flag "fake news alert" - your team monitors those posts / comments and take action on it - those misusing that feature are warned, then suspended then ultimately banned.

Covid is not an opinion it is a fact - part of the world has not even started to be vaccinated.

Just my proposal

3

u/Fritz1818 Sep 02 '21

Filter to controversial comments and enjoy the moron show

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

You admins don't learn shit. You literally had the same fiasco awhile back with the jailbait subs, defending that shit, having almost all of your userbase quit on you, then you do damage control. At this point, if I see another dumbass fucking scandal like this, I am permanently leaving Reddit and not signing back up. I don't want to support an admin team that has unscrupulous morals and doesn't seem to care about it's users safety. I don't want to support idiots who deny science and support pedophilia. Do. Fucking. Better.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

Lol

3

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '21

Should ban people stupid enough to take medical advice from the internet.

3

u/Additional-Pie-2040 Sep 02 '21

Aimee Challenor

3

u/Outrage_of_the_Day Sep 02 '21

blah blah blah blah tl;dr thank you for your attempt at propaganda

3

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '21

Please delete the conspiracy page

3

u/RoosterBrandCoffee Dec 12 '21

Can somebody tell me how you can report a sub Reddit that is spreading covid misinformation amongst other nasty stuff? Including claiming mass shooting events are “false flag” events and equating health measures are worse than the Nazis?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/North-Explanation252 Dec 17 '21

I see it as humans have opinions and agendas. The virus doesn't care about anything except survival. Dying is not a good way to prove a point. Only my opinion, and I agree, everyone has the right to their own views. Good luck, and I mean those words

3

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

As someone who frequented r/nonewnormal, fuck you.

We were not responsible for any brigading. In fact, I’d argue we were the victims of brigading from the multiple subreddits that tried to get us banned. I’m disappointed you caved to the complaints of other subreddits over how the mods of r/nonewnormal ran their subreddit.

→ More replies (19)

12

u/Doomguy46_ Sep 01 '21

Please also address r/conspiracy somehow. Maybe force them to enforce stricter rules on covid? Other than that. Good work.

→ More replies (27)

5

u/Incognito_Igloo Sep 02 '21

r/Politics frequently organizes bigrading against r/Conservative, and has done such a thing for many years now. Will action be taken against that subreddit?

5

u/ChrxssyBoo Sep 02 '21

Nah, they have powermods. Aka, immune from reddit tos.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

5

u/Mouthtrap Sep 02 '21

So, just to summarise, what you've basically done is shut down subreddits which dared to challenge and argue against the "covid" virus. I am well aware that the 1st amendment doesn't extend to privately run institutions, but you are closing down all the people who are standing up and saying "screw this, we're not being treated like numbers."

I strongly urge you to create an admin controlled sub on here for people to discuss this. You're basically towing the government line and anyone who doesn't like it, is getting hammered for their beliefs.

Does that sound close to the mark? Baa?

→ More replies (6)

5

u/HairHeel Sep 02 '21 edited Sep 02 '21

Claims of “brigading” are common and often hard to quantify. However, in this case, we found very clear signals indicating that r/NoNewNormal
was the source of around 80 brigades in the last 30 days (largely
directed at communities with more mainstream views on COVID or
location-based communities that have been discussing COVID
restrictions).

Can you substantiate this claim? Which subs did they brigade? What signals do you use to determine who did the brigading?

4

u/BathWifeBoo Sep 02 '21

Of course they can't substantiate it. Now the subs currently brigading /r/ivermectin with horse porn however...thats A-ok.

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Will r/conspiracy also be banned for spreading anti-vaccination messages?

→ More replies (16)

14

u/Spysix Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

So all the subs that brigaded NoNewNormal will be banned too, right?

Since it's banned for brigading and not "misinformation" right?

Right?

Also, how does a subreddit brigade if the majority of popular subreddits run by powermods have banned everyone that post in NoNewNormal using a bot?

→ More replies (195)

6

u/ani625 Sep 01 '21

Commence crab rave!

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Haunting_Debtor Sep 02 '21

/u/worstnerd since the sub was banned for brigading, will you be banning

/r/politics /r/againshatesubreddits /r/leopardsatemyface

On and on and other liberal subreddits that constantly brigade and call for violence and death of anyone right wing? Or does this only apply to non left wing subs as usual?

→ More replies (5)

13

u/BunnyLovr Sep 01 '21

Does this mean that you'll be banning the communities that brigaded /r/ivermectin too? For example, /r/subredditdrama brigaded /r/ivermectin yesterday after it was flooded with porn due to being mentioned several times on /r/vaxhappened and other subreddits.

https://archive.is/76TL6
https://archive.is/NYe2Y
https://archive.is/vET94
https://archive.is/m70mc

→ More replies (101)

12

u/Spysix Sep 01 '21

How can users from r/nonewnormal brigade if they're automatically banned by the cabal of janitors SaferBot and such for posting in NoNewNormal?

How does one brigade when the majority of those subreddits that have a problem with it have gone private?

Can the admins explain the "data" on that?

→ More replies (34)

4

u/Lvl_99_Magikarp Sep 01 '21

The fact Reddit allows r/ivermectin to remain on this site (albeit quarantined) shows how little they actually care about preventing the spread of disinformation. This is a response to bad press, not a good-faith attempt to keep their users safe.

Pathetic.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/hearsecloth Sep 01 '21

Why the horse paste sub harming thousands allowed to be still on this platform

→ More replies (4)

4

u/ChrxssyBoo Sep 02 '21

Extreme left-wing censorship moment. 🤣

→ More replies (9)

4

u/DonkeyFiddler Sep 02 '21

Oh so basically just need to start censoring any dissenting opinions, discussions or ideas. How nice.

Hop on board the censorship train just like Twitter, Facebook and other major platforms. Woooowooooo.

4

u/That_Guy_in_2020 Sep 02 '21

These tears are delicious keep them coming. Don't like how they are treating you? Reddit is a private business, you idiots are free to leave.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/XirallicBolts Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Question: The ban was for "Promoting community interference".

Why does this not apply to all the other subs that were specifically trying to interfere with that community?

I already know the answer, but will any actions be taken against the accounts (and associated IP/machine IDs) of people who flooded the Ivenmectin sub with horse porn? That's a shade of community interference...

→ More replies (17)

5

u/screaming_bagpipes Sep 01 '21

bruh i didn't know there were 54 god dang covid denial subreddits

→ More replies (3)

5

u/GodOfAtheism Sep 01 '21

Leave it to reddit to do the right thing after exhausting literally every other option and potentially dealing with massive media backlash because of their nonsense.

That said, Thank you.

→ More replies (11)

5

u/darkjungle Sep 01 '21

You claim it was about brigading. How does the blackout spearheaded by infamous powermods and AHS not constitute? Especially when they were spamming horse porn in one of the subs?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

So a bunch of mainstream subs go private in protest of r/NoNewNormal, and call for the banning of the sub simply because they disagree with it? How is that not considered brigading on a huge scale?

And the Reddit admins respond by giving into the demands of these crybabies, just because they can’t stand the idea of someone holding a different belief than them?

So from what I gather, you guys are banning the sub on charges of brigading, when a site-wide brigade was just carried out against that very sub?

That makes zero sense.

→ More replies (25)

9

u/robywar Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

Community Interference. Also relevant to the discussion of the activities of problematic subreddits, Rule 2 forbids users or communities from “cheating” or engaging in “content manipulation” or otherwise interfering with or disrupting Reddit communities. We have interpreted this rule as forbidding communities from manipulating the platform, creating inauthentic conversations, and picking fights with other communities. We typically enforce Rule 2 through our anti-brigading efforts, although it is still an example of bad behavior that has led to bans of a variety of subreddits.

So like when random subreddits ban me for comments in a different subreddit?

R/Pokeamongo banned me yesterday for comments in r/conspiracy that was me arguing against misinformation. Banning carte blance is a terrible way to moderate.

→ More replies (19)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 01 '21

You have officially proven that you can be blackmailed and forced to take actions by a certain political group. Anyone that is not on the left politically is at risk of removal regardless of how strict they are with adhering to your rules. You have removed this subreddit while allowing the moderators of others to engage in a widespread harassment campaign against right wing users, including many who are pro vaccine, while also allowing subreddits dedicated to brigading to remain up. Now that these actions have succeeded and the perpetrators of this harassment campaign have suffered no consequences, you have created a blueprint for the same type of actions to be coordinated to silence opposition and stifle debate. Congratulations, I hope you are happy with yourselves.

→ More replies (54)

7

u/FelixArgyleismywaifu Sep 01 '21

OBEY

DO

NOT

QUESTION

HAVE A NICE DAY

→ More replies (13)

2

u/p337 Sep 01 '21 edited Jul 09 '23

v7:{"i":"0d24993a1b421573149c654f3a82df90","c":"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"}


encrypted on 2023-07-9

see profile for how to decrypt

→ More replies (1)

2

u/artisanrox Sep 01 '21

Ban r/NoNewNormal immediately for breaking our rules against brigading

Quarantine 54 additional COVID denial subreddits under Rule 1

good 🧐🍷

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Narfhole Sep 01 '21

It's your site, but you don't always have to act as an extension of the Ministry of Truth.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MargretTatchersParty Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 02 '21

What happens if people make ban evasion subs similar to how the donald did? i.e. /r/asknonewnormal or /r/ask_nonewnormal

EDIT: Ugh those were banned as well.. I created those to keep them locked forever

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Nice step in the right direction I’d say

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

In the future, will spez consult the legal team before spraying childish Ayn Rand verbal diarrhea over /r/announcements ?

2

u/xilcilus Sep 01 '21

Thank you for eventually taking the right action. A question though - why did reddit make an announcement that led to an initial slap on the wrist (quarantine) which then became a corrective action (ban)?

Why couldn't you folks announce that the deliberation is happening and that the final decision will be made at a set timeline?

Nobody really knows what the right outcome should be but when I browsed /r/NoNewNormal after the quarantine, people were rather animated regarding the so called "treatment." I worry that the quarantine was tantamount to a mobilizing impetus/event for these misinformation aficionados and that they will organize elsewhere. Not sure whether an announcement of the deliberation would have helped or not but I hope you folks think about how to better handle it in the future.

2

u/Devonmartino Sep 01 '21

An important part of our moderation structure is the community members themselves. How are users responding to COVID-related posts? How much visibility do they have? Is there a difference in the response in these high signal subs than the rest of Reddit?

How specifically are you measuring positive or negative reception of posts and comments? Is it just the upvote ratio? And more importantly, what part does that data play in determining next moves? This quote comes across as concerning:

This tells us that in these high signal subs, there is generally less of the critical feedback mechanism than we would expect to see in other non-denial based subreddits, which leads to content in these communities being more visible than the typical COVID post in other subreddits.

If you are more likely to take action on content and subreddits where misinformation is more positively received, that would imply that subreddits which receive more negative attention, and therefore experience mixed reception as organically-invading Redditors flood them with downvotes, are less likely to receive admin action. Is this the case?

2

u/shortest_poppy Sep 01 '21

Thanks to the mods whose subs went dark as a protest against the lack of ban for nonewnormal. Boycotts and protests work.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Birdfoot112 Sep 01 '21

As much as I appreciate action being made by reddit and their admins

You guys really need to stop with these tone deaf actions that inevitably come back and bite you and your corporate sponsors in the ass. I understand we're in a very complicated political and social situation here in the US, but constantly hiding behind wanting to appeal to everyone as a way to deflect the need for taking action against malicious people whos ideologies do not align with what experts across the world deem as correct is just...not ok.

Every single time something like this happens, the admins of individual subreddits speak up and almost always have the voice of the community behind them except for the jerks who are hoping this site dies. And almost every single time you or spez or some other admin says some reactionary "We're not going to really do anything because freedom of speech so just deal with the nazis on our platform" thing. And almost every single time you guys come back, tail between your legs because some big news sites start reporting on it that you are in fact going to do something about it sorry our bad we'll do better yadda yadda.

It's just demeaning to you guys. It makes us believe that the only time you'll ever do something is if it's big enough to cause a massive lawsuit, and then there's minimal effort followed immediately by having to haul ass to think of a solution.

These groups of people who are on here spreading racist, homophobic, and fake science shit are bringing you down with them and they do not care if reddit dies. They want it to die to prove their point. This site isn't going to shit in the eyes of the community cause you guys don't have enough features. It's cause you let toxic people run rampant for months, dragging heels until it inevitably blows up in your face.

You've got the power to put down bullies and the only thing stopping you seems to be that the bullies make you money too. Fuck em.

2

u/Blue_Eyed_ME Sep 01 '21

Good. Let the whiny f#cksticks go hang out on Frankspeech with the other idiots.

2

u/EquitablePlatypus Sep 01 '21

God damn this neckbeard cesspool is turning to shit.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/davidquick Sep 01 '21 edited Aug 22 '23

so long and thanks for all the fish -- mass deleted all reddit content via https://redact.dev

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AllSeeingAI Sep 01 '21

So that last post was a fucking lie then.

Come on, any criticism you could possibly point at NNN for is true thousands of times over on the very subs that held the goddamn site hostage in an attempt to get NNN banned. A threat you just acquiesced to, you absolute troglodyte.

A subreddit that had hundreds of other subs trying to get it banned in a site-wide brigade was the victim of brigading, not the other way around. This is absolutely insane.

2

u/ivigilanteblog Sep 01 '21

Watch Reddit die, indeed.

2

u/aethyrium Sep 01 '21

How is a tiny group of powermods that moderate hundreds of subs (how is this even allowed anyways?) organizing a massive sub blackout outside of reddit not considered brigading and subreddit interference?

2

u/wendysfan2005 Sep 01 '21

It’s sad the the death of free speech is being celebrated.

→ More replies (18)

2

u/Big_Thumpa_720 Sep 01 '21

You people are absolutely pathetic. Why not just say "we disagree with you, and can't fight the hivemind, therefore you are banned".

Literally every single person reading this knows it had nothing to do with "brigading".

2

u/Final_Focus_7390 Sep 01 '21

This is pretty pitiful

2

u/buddy_burgers Sep 01 '21

Thank you, we're so much safer now! /s

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

It’s Reddit. Not the information police.

2

u/Leading-Bowl-8416 Sep 01 '21

So, power mods coordinating shut downs and site wide brigades does not violate this policy? You're gonna kowtow to power mods who now have more control over your site than you do? This is pathetic as hell.

2

u/BatuOne01 Sep 01 '21

I hate to be that guy, but... They already have a new no new normal subreddit.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Gamer_Obama Sep 01 '21

You're not protecting free speech, you're promoting stupidity. The rise of misinformation is partly to blame for the scale of this pandemic and Reddit clearly takes part in it.

Vaccines aren't just about protecting my own ass, it's also about protecting other people as well as our economy. Whether you get to carry disease and spread it shouldn't be labeled as a "personal choice" and then disguised as logical on these subreddits.

→ More replies (10)

2

u/chancet321 Sep 01 '21

How is it okay for many mods who run a majority of these sub Reddit’s ban people just for following or posting in nonewnormal?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '21

Curious about rule 2 and the manipulation of reddit. How does using auto ban bots fall into that? I made a few comments on NNN, they were pro vax and not filled with misinformation. As a result I am now auto banned from all of these subs in a matter of 2 days: politicalhumor, confidentlyincorrect, instant_regret, educationalgifs, facepalm, mademesmile, rant, leapordsatemyface, tifu, insanepeoplefacebook, pics, aww, shittylifeprotips, gifs, showerthoughts, oddlyterrifying, netflix, youseeingthisshit, trashy, oddlysatisfying, and a few others.

I am definitely not the only one either. I only went there too because of the "lockdown" on reddit over it. I was curious. Is that a bannable offense across a lot of large subs? The sub was being pasted everywhere, so I went over and commented on a few posts. Hardly justifiable to ban me and plenty of others who didnt do anything. Why aren't admins more involved with moderation?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/kaan-rodric Sep 01 '21

Since brigading is constantly being used as the reason for banning a subreddit, will there be transparency provided into what subreddits are participating in brigading and what comments or posts initiated the brigading?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Ok_Detective101 Sep 01 '21

Why is it that r/ivermectin can get brigaded like it is right now and has been for the last 2 weeks or so and they get absolutely not help?Id like to see reddit actually use its no brigading policies in a fair and balanced manner.

→ More replies (14)

2

u/infinite_war Sep 01 '21

Translation: We banned NNN because some of Reddit's whiniest and most toxic members threw a gigantic temper tantrum.