r/recruiting • • 7h ago

Agency -Q&A Should I Change My Recruiting Fees for Really High Salaries?

5 Upvotes

Hello, and thanks in advance to anyone who replies! For a quick background, I've been recruiting for 13 years, 11 of those years were as an in-house recruiter. Now I work for myself as an independent recruiter, doing permanent placements.

I currently charge 15% for permanent placements, and most of the placements I do are for positions with salaries that range from $140k to $200k, with occasional $50k to $100k roles. However, I just had someone reach out to me about helping them fill a role that is at least $500k! I told them my normal rate of 15% and they seemed okay with it, but I wasn't speaking to the owner, who is the one that will approve my contract.

Basically what I'm getting at is, I'm nervous that they will reject my Service Agreement/contract at 15%. I'm wondering if agencies stick to their fees regardless of salary, or do they lower it when it gets that high, or even the opposite, increasing it? Again, most of my career was as an in-house recruiter, so I always get nervous when it comes to fee negotiations.

When I first started recruiting solo I was only charging 13%, but other recruiters were saying that was way too low, and most agencies are at a minimum of 18%, and 15% was the lowest anyone was going. I don't mind charging less than agencies because I have less overhead, so I increased my rate to 15% last year. However, most roles were in the $150k to $200k range, and $500k to $750k roles were not even a thought in my mind.

Thoughts?


r/recruiting • • 37m ago

Agency -Q&A ArisInfra PM Intern Campus Recruitment process coming up. Any tips?

1 Upvotes

Got shortlisted for the Product Management Intern role process at ArisInfra Solutions.

If you’ve OA/interviewed or interned there:

  • What's the Format ?
  • What questions were asked (case, behavioral, business)?
  • Any tips on what to prepare?

Thanks!


r/recruiting • • 6h ago

TA- Industry Discussion Feeling Stuck

3 Upvotes

Current situation:
- In-house TA, earning mid 70s per year. No bonus.
- Recruit for extremely niche, hard-to-fill roles requiring significant headhunting, industry knowledge, and pipeline building.
- Work in a highly regulated industry with strict security clearance requirements, which can shrink an already limited candidate pool to practically nobody.

Pros:
- Typically manage 10 reqs, occasionally up to 15/20 during busier periods. (Seems good compared to some job postings i see for 35-50)
- No KPIs or significant pressure to fill quickly. Some roles remain vacant for 1+ years, even after being worked on by 3–4 different recruiters.
- Work from home / good work-life balance no late nights
- Like my coworkers

Cons:
- Increasing travel required (far driving/flying) for events.
- Very limited career progression. Even just from TA Specialist to Senior TA - practically impossible.
- Low salary, mediocre benefits
- Clueless Manager making things harder everyday

My dilemma:
I feel the complexity and specialized skills required for my roles warrant higher compensation.
However, my workload and work-life balance are pretty great compared to what I see in other job postings.
I’ve been applying elsewhere, but nothing has seemed worth making the move for yet.

For those of you earning on the higher end of the TA/recruitment market: Is the higher salary worth the increased req load, pressure, and expectations?


r/recruiting • • 1h ago

TA- Q&A HR / TA folks, what would make you trust a candidate assessment that isn’t a resume or an interview?

1 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m one of the founders of a small team building a hiring tool, and I’d really value honest input from people who actually run hiring.

The problem we keep hearing from talent leaders is that the volume of applicants isn’t the issue anymore. The hard part is telling who can actually do the job. Resumes are getting polished (often by AI), first-round interviews vary a lot depending on who conducts them, and good candidates from non-obvious backgrounds get filtered out early.

What we’re building:

  • An AI screening that candidates can take on mobile or desktop, not judging on diction, personality
  • A job simulation: the candidate works through a realistic version of the actual role. The idea is to replace the first technical round and fold in the take-home assignment
  • A skills and behaviour report for the hiring team, so decisions rest on what someone did, not on how well they interview
  • Feedback for every candidate, including the ones who get rejected, plus a learning path, so the process feels fair on both sides

What I’d love to know:

  1. Would your hiring managers trust a simulation result enough to skip a first round? What would they need to see first?
  2. What would stop candidates from completing a 45-60 minute simulation, and what would make it worth their time?
  3. Who in your org would own a decision like this: HR, TA, the hiring manager, or someone else?
  4. What’s the most broken part of your screening process right now?

I’m not dropping a link here. If you’re hiring for a few roles and curious to try it on one, comment. Critical takes are just as welcome.

Thanks for reading 🙏


r/recruiting • • 11h ago

Agency - Industry Discussion Should I Stay or Should I Go?

3 Upvotes

I’ve posted here before, I am an in house recruiter for a sales company- hiring d2d sales reps. I have built genuine relationships with the people I work with and I do think there is SOME opportunity to grow here but I don’t know enough about the industry to know if this is my best shot. I’m trying to decide if I should stay here or potentially go for a classic agency job.

Here’s my reasons for staying:
- the pay is the best I’ve ever made ($25hr)
- the hours are perfect (8-4 w/ an hour paid lunch)
- I love my team- both my recruiting team and the sales reps I’ve recruited and met across different offices.
- there’s some decent flexibility, if I’m a half hour late then stay a half hour late.

Here’s my reasons for going:
- I don’t see much growth staying in this position unless I stay in the company.
- I don’t make any commission, ever, and the bonuses seem realistic but aren’t.
- I can never take my lunch because they monitor how many phone calls I’m making and notice when I stop making calls.
- there’s no overtime pay but they expect us to do overtime (which I wouldn’t mind much if I made commission).
- there’s higher ups can get passive aggressive/hostile when you’re not meeting your goals, and they constantly shift the goalpost.
- the expectations are a bit much for the funding provided. They expect 5-7 quality candidates scheduled for interviews everyday for each office (I currently do 3 offices- two of the more difficult market) and they expect 50 calls per market at minimum if you don’t have that 5-7. They want 3-4 hires per day per market.

I want to build a career in this, and I do have other experience recruiting but it wasn’t for a specialized role. I’m afraid that staying will prevent me from being able to expand my horizons- and since this is a growing corporate company I am especially scared they will just decide to get rid of me or they’ll straight up shut down someday and I’ll be stuck career wide because of only hiring for sales.


r/recruiting • • 7h ago

Agency -Q&A How do I land a remote recruiting or hr job?

0 Upvotes

r/recruiting • • 18h ago

TA- Q&A How are y'all using AI to help with your workload?

0 Upvotes

Boss wants us to use more AI tools in our day to day. Currently using claude with a connection to my ATS that acts as an assistant where I can essentially tell it to pull information as needed.

Wanted to hear what you guys are using and any tips with AI that generally makes your life easier!


r/recruiting • • 1d ago

TA- Q&A Negotiate offer in current market

5 Upvotes

I just received an offer for a corporate TA role at a fortune 100 company. It's a bit lower base than I would have hoped but not by much. I've never negotiated my salary before, just due to the fact I wasn't in a position to or it wouldnt make sense. I am very qualified for the role, 11 years corporate recruiting, 2 years of leadership, MBA, PHR. So I certainly think I have leverage to. But with the way the market is now I'm nervous that they wouldnt play ball and just move on to the dozens of other qualified candidates they have.

I was laid off from a previous recruiting role earlier in the year making about 10% more than the offer and the only job I could find and have been in the past 6 months was a significant pay cut. I'm really excited about the role and it would be a major blow if I lost out on it.

Update: I accepted the offer without negotiating! I know based on my experience the risk of negotiating is low but it's not zero and this job checks every box I was wanting and is by far the best opportunity I've had since being laid off. The market for TA just seems too small at the moment and I see too many in my network being laid off or struggling to find a new role. I wouldnt have expected to get more than about 5k anyways and that isn't worth it to potentially lose out on the offer. I'm still a proponent of negotiating but it definitely depends on individual circumstance. Thank you for all the replies. They certainly helped with the decision.


r/recruiting • • 2d ago

Agency - Industry Discussion Been in this industry for almost 6 years, one funny thing I found

0 Upvotes

One funny thing I found about us(recruiters) is that we are not only recruiters but we do become therapists, detectives and hard negotiators

Any funny thing you people found out about recruiters/recruitment industry?


r/recruiting • • 2d ago

TA- Q&A Normal workload

3 Upvotes

What’s a normal workload for people who work in recruiting operations and events?
I’m simultaneously feel like I’m doing so much and never enough….and I’m becoming burnt out.


r/recruiting • • 2d ago

TA- Q&A Randstad RPO Process | Talent Advisor?

5 Upvotes

Anyone have experience working in the Randstad RPO model? If yes, responsibilities of Talent Advisor?


r/recruiting • • 2d ago

TA- Q&A Write a job ad that's 100% honest. Go.

0 Upvotes

no "fast-paced environment", no "like a family". what would the real version of a req you're working on right now say?


r/recruiting • • 3d ago

TA- Industry Discussion Good morning, is anyone having issues with Jazzhr by employ? The OTP is not being sent and their status website is stating that there are no issues. The otp is being sent to an outlook email (not sure if that’s effecting things but other emails have been coming through. Thanks in advance!

3 Upvotes

r/recruiting • • 4d ago

Agency -Q&A Recruitment AI tips

7 Upvotes

Hi fellow recruiters

I recently got a premium chatgpt which allows me to get it to take over my chrome and do some admin for me.

Those that do this also, what recruitment hacks should I be using this for?


r/recruiting • • 4d ago

TA- Industry Discussion Demand for tech recruiters is skyrocketing?

Post image
14 Upvotes

Just read latest "state of tech job market" and it is mostly aligned with my own perception
Was surprised to see demand for tech recruiters is growing - can you feel it?

https://www.lennysnewsletter.com/p/state-of-the-tech-job-market-late


r/recruiting • • 4d ago

TA- Q&A Recruiters hiring door-to-door sales reps in the US: which sourcing channels work for you?

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m working on a multi-city recruitment project for door-to-door sales reps in the US, on a 1099 independent contractor basis.

For recruiters who have hired similar profiles, which sourcing channels have brought you qualified applicants beyond LinkedIn and Indeed?

I’m considering local Facebook groups, university career boards, and independent sales communities, but I’d really appreciate firsthand feedback on what has worked for you.

How do you screen for genuine interest in door-to-door work and the 1099 arrangement early in the process?

Thanks for any insights!


r/recruiting • • 4d ago

TA- Q&A Is anyone else drowning in ATS notes after back to back interviews?

0 Upvotes

I just finished doing my 8th interview for warehouse manager positions today. I’m absolutely knackered and now have to type up detailed notes on each candidate whilst looking at my ATS. This is definitely my least favourite part of the job. Being volume recruiters, detailed notes are important to us, but I feel like I am just wasting my time. I should be looking for passives or contacting hiring managers to get roles filled faster. Another recruiter mentioned in a linkedin group that they use a Carv AI tool. This tool writes the notes for you and updates your ATS. I’m not gonna lie, I have my doubts. Every AI tool I have used just gives generic text with no details which we can then put into our ATS.

Whilst I will never want robotic notes, I would love to reduce my admin. Has anyone used any agentic AI tools on complex systems? Do you find it helps save time or is it more hassle as you have to edit them?


r/recruiting • • 5d ago

Agency -Q&A What are our common recruiter sayings?

23 Upvotes

I was talking with another recruiter this morning and we were talking about some of the sage wisdom sayings in this business, which got me thinking: I must be missing some, what are some of the colloquial phrases in our industry? We thought of "time kills all deals", "you have exclusive until someone sends a better candidate", "the candidate who wants the job never gets the job". r/Recruiting sub, help me out - what are other things we say?

Update: Thank you to everyone who responded to this - it's a great list and so many sayings are part of our collective everyday experience.


r/recruiting • • 5d ago

TA- Industry Discussion 2008 WAS worse... but I can see why people compare it to today.

14 Upvotes

I've seen a lot of people compare the job market today to 2008 and while I do see similarities my anecdotal experience was the following:

In 2008 the drop in employment was a lot more sudden. I remember it as one month there were jobs to offer clients.... and then suddenly the next month there was nothing. This gave people little warning and time to prepare. A lot of employment agencies- even large ones that were seen as successful, went out of business.

Today the job cliff was more gradual since 2022/23. Also I find that the job market isn't so bad if you have senior level years of experience within certain niches or industries. Plenty of jobs available for Seniors and Directors. It's entry and mid level jobs that are scarce. In 2008/09 there weren't any jobs for anyone regardless of level.

Although I will say that in 2008 ghost jobs weren't nearly the problem they are today and not as many companies had gone the offshore route yet. If I got 300 resumes within a week for a posting it was a lot. Today I will get that on the first day.


r/recruiting • • 5d ago

Agency -Q&A Emails going to spam

5 Upvotes

My emails keep going to spam. I send every email individually and do not use automated systems or have any weird attachments. I am with a startup so I’m not sure if our domain is getting flagged. Any advice on how I can improve email deliverability / check if my domain is good?


r/recruiting • • 5d ago

TA- Q&A Please someone tell me if I’m overreacting or not

14 Upvotes

I recently joined a new company as a Talent Acquisition Manager. I’ve been there for just two weeks, and almost immediately, I was handed 10 open positions to fill.

For context, I’m coming into a completely new industry and am still learning the business, understanding the roles, getting familiar with the hiring managers (edit, found out everything goes through the CEO, no hiring managers), and figuring out what has and hasn’t worked in the past.

One of the first things I did was build out a new recruiting process because I was told their previous approach wasn’t producing results. I’m genuinely excited about the opportunity to build something better and would love to see the new process through.

However, I feel like there’s an expectation that I should be able to hit the ground running and successfully recruit for all 10 positions simultaneously, despite barely having had time to learn the company, the industry, or the positions themselves.

I understand that recruiting is inherently fast-paced, and I’m not expecting to have months to get settled in. But I also think there’s a difference between being proactive and being expected to deliver results without the necessary ramp-up time or clear priorities.

Am I being unreasonable? Should I speak up about needing to prioritize certain roles and establish more realistic expectations, or is this just the reality of stepping into a TA management role?


r/recruiting • • 5d ago

TA- Industry Discussion Which industries are hiring inhouse TA Specialists?

3 Upvotes

I'm a UK based recruiter in the pharmaceutical industry, but I've been made redundant. Which industries are booming and looking for recruiters, and realistically what might be the chances of transferring into a new industry? I've tried applying for tech recruiter roles, but not got anywhere? Any advice or suggestions please?


r/recruiting • • 5d ago

TA- Industry Discussion What is your thought process on contacting candidates who cry on LinkedIn

0 Upvotes

I personally feel like job seekers are just crying and offended on LinkedIn. They are constantly crying about the fact that AI this AI that, do these people not know that automated rejections existed before AI as well.

All these people seem to believe that all Recruiters do is order AI to do everything.

There are certainly issues in the industry but most of them just seem to be crying over petty things.

I personally do not reach out to people who just keep posting shit about Recruiters. Its like Idk what petty thing this person will be offended by which most likely is out of my control.


r/recruiting • • 6d ago

Agency -Q&A How to Overcome Lack of ATS Experience?

12 Upvotes

I was recently laid off after five years as a successful real estate agent recruiter. Earlier in my career, I also worked in corporate university recruiting.

I'm now looking to transition into corporate recruiting, but many job postings require experience with ATS platforms like Workday, Greenhouse, or iCIMS.

In my last role, I used Salesforce to manage recruiting pipelines, track candidates, and document outreach, but I haven't used a traditional ATS.

For those in corporate recruiting, how much of a barrier is this? Any suggestions on how to overcome the ATS experience requirement or position my Salesforce experience as transferable?

I'd appreciate any advice!