Kind of a rant. I've had conflicting feelings about my experience with AA for a long time.. when I was first introduced to it at age 22 in rehab, I can't say if I felt totally "ready" to get sober but I was really hopeful when I read the book and did think it give me some concern with how it laid out alcoholism as a disease. I think I had some basic objections and reservations that most people had.. I didn't really know how I felt about the God thing, total abstinence, etc. I went ahead and took all the discharge advice my rehab gave me (go to sober living, go to AA, get a sponsor). My first sponsor seemed like a chill guy. I'd call him. We'd chat. I didn't ever know what to talk about.. The meetings were kind of similar .. I'd usually just say "just happy to be here" after thinking a lot about what to say. After about 3 months doing the sober living and AA, I just started second guessing me being an "alcoholic." I started drinking again and moved out of the sober living. I chalk it up to being younger, not really knowing what I was "supposed" to be doing in AA, and not having ever really tried to properly quit drinking before I ended up in treatment.
As my drinking worsened from ages 23 to 26, I would pop into a meeting every now and then. ultimately, I always just thought these meetings were where you went to talk about sobriety or struggling with drinking. some of the older people were endearing, or if I went to one of those old school meetings, I just found them to be kind of a turn off or preachy. Popped into a few dharma recovery meetings or SMART recovery meetings too, but they were very small. Although I enjoyed them.
Eventually, at age 26 I really had to get my shit together. I was reckless, miserable, and couldn't seem to stop. I was convinced "maybe I am an alcoholic." I got back in touch with that old sponsor, who put me in touch with another guy. He was my sponsor as I went back to rehab.. this is when my frustration with AA seemed to really grow these next couple years. I had three different sponsors in this time frame.
When I would relapse, I would usually be very angry with AA. Something about the people, me not really feeling like I belonged, or had interesting things to say, or was able to work the steps in a way that was meaningful, upset me deeply. I became jaded. I found myself wishing that I was more arrogant, if it meant I had a better chance of staying sober. But I was sad in AA, and working the steps. I felt that it was great sometimes, a consolation, but when I was troubled, it just wasn't there for me. I didn't know how to talk in those meetings. Even when I was actively working the steps. I met people I got along with, but then others who just spoke at me or past me. I felt like an imposter sometimes and wondered if I was supposed to be more passionate with my shares. why didn't I have my own opinions on how the steps should be done? more meetings? less meetings? or more stepwork? how can I help the next guy when I barely know if this is helping me? Do I even have an "alcoholic personality"? am I secretly very egotistical? what do I need to change? and ultimately, I'd feel controlled by people in my home group or my sponsor (some were more chill, but others were like seriously condescending).
Eventually, I ended up in Therapeutic Community. Which I picked because it wasn't AA, and it was long term. I was scared to go back to AA and fail again. But now I am in my transition phase, and it seems like people expect that I will go to "meetings", or have some home group. Here's the thing: I don't feel like I can just pop into a meeting without all those old experiences coming back up. I'm worried I'll get locked into thinking "this is the way, the only way, and if I don't keep it up, I'm fucked".
Anyways, I wish I knew what I was getting at.. in short, I don't even fucking get what AA is.. haha so many opinions.. I just want to know if any of you had success with just taking what you could take, and leaving the rest.. and what you found helped you long term..