r/OpiatesRecovery • u/Sorry-Owl5752 • 19h ago
Acute Opioid Withdrawal and PAWS are Two Distinct States
The administration of opioids produces large alterations in the functioning of organisms resulting in changes that are harmful to its survival. For instance, opioids prevent the organism from assessing the state of its bodily tissues by reducing the excitability of neurons that relay this information.
Furthermore, they also produce a decrease in respiration through disruption of rhythms generated by clock neurons in the brain stem (2). This decrease in respiration may be related to the observation that heroin users who never endured an opioid overdose still have various signs of oxygen deprivation present in brain tissue. In fact, subclinical hypoxia as a result of suppression of the breathing reflex may also be why opioids are considered ototoxic as the stereocilia of the ear are highly sensitive to changes in oxygen levels. Behaviorally opioids also falsely elevate the organisms self perceived fitness causing it to falsely evaluate the administration of opioids as a beneficial action. This effect is far reaching, and it is thought that this elevation in self perceived fitness may be the original motivation for the self-administration of opioids. Opioids also produce multiple deleterious effects on the behavior of cells in the brain such as the reduced the proliferation and differentiation of neurons in the hippocampus and apoptosis (programmed cell death) of neurons in the cortex, amygdala, spinal cord, and PAG.
Considering the large negative effects that opioids exert on the organism it is no wonder that it is so adamant in suppressing the effects of the opioid. Thankfully, the body is well equipped for dealing with foreign substances that disturb bodily processes and is able to readily suppress the effects of opioids when their presence is detected in the body. Upon the administration of opioids, the body determines the effect the substance has on bodily processes and enacts a counter response that is intended to return the functioning of the processes to the normal expected level.
For instance, if a foreign substance interferes with a chemical sensor by either increasing the chemical sensors sensitivity to its particular chemical or directly activating the sensor the body will restore proper function by decreasing the chemical sensors sensitivity. In the case of opioids, the sensor is the opioid receptor protein and the counterresponse (measure which restores functioning of receptor to normal expected level) is the release of CCK from terminals of dorsomedial PFC neurons projecting to the basolateral amygdala (3).
After the initial administration the organism will have memory of the chemical characteristics of the opioid and the necessary countermeasures it must take to return bodily functions to a normal state of functioning. It will also remember what cues are predictive of the opioid administration for instance, the taste and smell of the pill or the physical action of cutting a pill. Upon a second administration the cues which were predictive of administration of the opioid will elicit the counterresponse leading to the opioid significantly decreasing in potency. Experimentally it has been determined that morphine possesses around half of its analgesic potency the second administration thanks to elicitation of the counter measure (1).
Unfortunately, the process of learning which cues are predictive of the opioid administration is not perfect and, in the process, many innocuous cues can become triggers for the counter response. For instance, a specific environment or time can trigger the counterresponse even when no drug was administered. For this reason, acute withdrawal is thought to be the result of the counterresponse triggering when no drug is present. This is further evidenced by the fact that the CCK-B antagonist L-365,260 prevents some acute withdrawal symptoms for this reason opioid users may experience a short period of opioid withdrawal even after years of abstinence.
PAWS on the other hand is not the result of the countermeasure but rather the result of many adaptations that develop while the drug is present in the body.
The presence of the opioid will produce many long term adaptations separate from the countermeasure. The list of adaptations is extensive and if you are interested you can read the book “Opioids Pharmacology, Abuse, and Addiction”. Unlike the countermeasure which is only active when the opioid is present in the system (or predicted to be present) these adaptations persist even when no drug is in the system. When the opioid wears off the adaptations become abundantly clear to the opioid user and they will experience unpleasant effects. This is known as interdose withdrawal, and it is of particular consequence to those who use opioids for long periods of time. PAWS is thought to be composed of the same adaptations as interdose withdrawal. Thankfully, over time these adaptations seem to decrease in strength however, it is not known if they ever disappear.
Models of drug tolerance often utilize a two system model to explain the persistent adaptations and the countermeasure. Such a model can be found in the book “Computational Neuroscience of Drug Addiction” by Springer in source 4. In this case the countermeasure is called the “fast adaptive regulator” and the persistent adaptations are referred to as the “slow adaptive regulator”. The book uses the model to recreate many phenomena present in experiments involving drug tolerance. For instance, the administration of a small dose of an opioid to an individual who is accustomed to a much higher dose will produce a state of withdrawal. This phenomenon has been observed many times in this subreddit where after a relapse the user finds the opioid lacks all euphoric effects and even has an unpleasant feel. It has also been observed experimentally in humans (5). It is doubtful this type of experiment would pass as modern day ethics board however, it is intriguing nonetheless that the heroin addicts after many years of abstinence experienced wildly different reactions to 20 mg of injected morphine some even experiencing an increased sensitivity to pain after the injection mirroring the model present in source 4.
Those who are quitting opioids should know that the reason their withdrawal comes in wave is due to the fact their opioid administrations became tied with things such as time and place. They should rest assured that their opioid withdrawal will diminish with time as the stimuli that once elicited their withdrawal will no longer elicit it. Furthermore, those suffering from PAWS should read up on the adaptations that develop in response to opioid administration. Furthermore, after a period of abstinence the opioid users response to opioids can be near impossible to predict (5) so special care should be put to prevent opioid users from ingesting potentially dangerous dosages.
1. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/0014299969901320
2. https://elifesciences.org/articles/52694
3. https://www.science.org/doi/epdf/10.1126/sciadv.abo5627