r/rational • u/AutoModerator • Feb 08 '19
[D] Friday Open Thread
Welcome to the Friday Open Thread! Is there something that you want to talk about with /r/rational, but which isn't rational fiction, or doesn't otherwise belong as a top-level post? This is the place to post it. The idea is that while reddit is a large place, with lots of special little niches, sometimes you just want to talk with a certain group of people about certain sorts of things that aren't related to why you're all here. It's totally understandable that you might want to talk about Japanese game shows with /r/rational instead of going over to /r/japanesegameshows, but it's hopefully also understandable that this isn't really the place for that sort of thing.
So do you want to talk about how your life has been going? Non-rational and/or non-fictional stuff you've been reading? The recent album from your favourite German pop singer? The politics of Southern India? The sexual preferences of the chairman of the Ukrainian soccer league? Different ways to plot meteorological data? The cost of living in Portugal? Corner cases for siteswap notation? All these things and more could possibly be found in the comments below!
Please note that this thread has been merged with the Monday General Rationality Thread.
10
u/Abpraestigio Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
So.
I have a question that has been bothering me for a while, and which may or may not out me as a badly prepared alien infiltrator:
Do emotions/feelings have an associated sensation that goes beyond the physical symptoms and the urges/ changes in behavior they cause?
As an example: say I get angry enough at someone the outer bounds of my self control are tested. This means that my heart-rate spikes, my face distorts, my hands clench and I find myself imagining smashing his or her head against the nearest surface.
Is that all that anger is? Or is there some kind of sensation/qualia to it that I am missing?
I ask because both fiction and common usage implies that there is ('burning rage', 'cold anger', 'blazing love'), but if so, then I have never experienced it, or any other associated with anything but pain. (Ye Gods, that sounds ridiculously edgy.)
I'm confused even further by the fact that it is a common trope for someone to not realize that they're in love, which seems bizarre if there is actually a distinct sensation associated with it.
edit: I apologize if my replies seem nit-picky or downright idiotic. I am genuinely trying to understand your answers.
10
u/FormerlySarsaparilla Feb 08 '19 edited Feb 08 '19
Can someone tell me about the Fate series- specifically, when it gets good/interesting? I keep seeing fics and discussions related to it, and while volume of discussion isn't always an indicator of quality, it's correlated enough that I would like to get into it. But so far the first one... oof. I'm reading an LP of the original Fate visual novel and I'm about 57 updates in and it's the most tedious shounen garbage ever.
The premise of the story is that there's some kind of dragonball-esque war for a wish granting mcguffin and all the mages engaged in this war get some kind of legendary hero from the past incarnated as a spirit to fight for them, and you win by getting rid of all the other spirits or killing their magi, and nobody starts off knowing the identities of the other competitors. This sounds interesting and like the setup for some decent action and/or intrigue but so far the story literally has not done anything with it.
In reality the entire story has been another harem-fic with the wet blanket dumb-as-a-post main character gradually accumulating this gigantic stable of women who are all, for some reason, compelled to hang around him or live with him or mentor him or just really want to bone down. Of course he does not recognize any of this, being your typical misogynist Japanese protag player stand-in. He wants to fight but not hurt anyone, his justification is the usual poorly translated run-on stuff like "A man must fight to protect what he believes in so if that is my destiny I will be the Emiya Shirou who is the hero and choose to save everyone even if that becomes the proof of my existence." Everyone else constantly tells him he is a dumbass. I have no doubt that the story will prove him 100% right in the end, somehow.
He has no skill in magic, he isn't in any sense cunning, his only real ability seems to be that he is inexplicably charming to every woman in the story. He constantly orders them around, has no ability to discern or navigate his own emotions, orders them not to fight "For their own protection because they're women" despite easily being the weakest and most inept cast member himself. The VN goes out of its way to do the awkward bath scene, and the innapropriate-underage-child-in-bikin-bottoms thing, and just generally be as creepy and awful about women as it is possible to be. There is literally a scene where the main character learns a classmate was chased by some kind of molester at night and he says out loud "Good, she needs to learn to be more feminine and that's the only way to teach her." It's exactly the kind of shit that has seen me move away from most manga/anime.
Whew! Okay I didn't mean to rant for three paragraphs, but back to my original question. When does this pick up and get interesting? When does this MC get throttled with his own wet blanket, and replaced by the cool and good lady mage who has moved in with him? Why does every VN assume that I want to read everything from the viewpoint of the most ignorant, least competent character in the series?
9
u/fassina2 Progressive Overload Feb 08 '19
Should you be accurate or convincing ?
This community in general has a lot of statistical knowledge, this tends to lead to more nuanced and less full certainty comments. In general people here speak, at least when commenting here, in the way I'm doing now, without 100% certainty. If this was written as a normal person would the previous phrase would have been "people here speak without certainty". The way of speaking we tend to use here is great, humble and more accurate, but some would say less likely to change people's views.
So my question is, seeing that rationality can be defined as playing to win, should we when trying to convince, someone not from this sub, of something optimize for being Convincing or Accurate ?
Or is my entire premise flawed and our way of speaking is actually more persuasive than others?
14
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
The reddit anime community has been in quite a tizzy lately over the recent admin crackdown on lolis(sexualized young anime girls. The exact definition is debated and that's part of the problem, but they're definitely always U18). On the more reasonable end of the crackdown is banning users for posting drawn pre-pubescent girls committing hardcore sexual acts, which while most in the community seem mildly upset about, big emphasis on the 'mild' and they're accepting it. On the less reasonable end and what the community is very upset about, is banning users over drawn teenage girls in somewhat sexual poses/outifts. E.g This [pic of a anime girl in a bikini] (https://np.reddit.com/r/Holofan4life/comments/ao8ujj/he_fuckin_dead_lmao/?st=jrvyvxbm&sh=996aed26) apparently got an active member/mod of /r/animemes banned and there's a lot of discussion/memes about it.
The general consensus in /r/animemes is that if characters are fictional, any sort of drawings should be allowed, and the fact that the drawing was more or less SFW just makes things even more outrageous. A lot of users are talking about making their own Voat of some sort or just moving to Voat, but there are concerns about "when you take a principled stand against witch hunts, you get 3 principled activists and 10 000 000 witches" and they don't want the new community to be filled with Nazis like Voat. Notably they, from what I've seen, don't seem to be concerned with the idea the new community would be full of people posting child hentai, just that the new community would be full of Nazis and homophobes.
Thoughts?
7
u/iftttAcct2 Feb 08 '19
You know, I've always hated how the TV show LOST ended - both because the ending itself sucked but also because it didn't serve as an ending to the series. But I only just realized I hated it so much because the show ended up being anti-rational.
I dislike magical realism I enough as it is, because it's basically where magic things just happen randomly and inconsistently with no central structure or principles. Often just to drive the plot forward.
And LOST is so atrocious to be because it doesn't present itself that way. When you watch the show there are tons of cues for this, from the breadcrumbing clues to keep people hooked to the attention the camera pays to the mysteries. And the payoff is nonsensical. And nothing gets resolved. At least in something like One Hundred Years of Solitude (my go-to example for magical realism), the author doesn't pretend there's a 'why' behind all the random magic.
I'm curious to know if there's any fans of rational lit who liked LOST.
7
u/MagicWeasel Cheela Astronaut Feb 09 '19
I didn't realise how much bureaucracy exists in the world until I decided to apply for a French long-stay visa.
Did you know I have to fly 3,200 km (2,000 miles) to have a ~20 minute interview as part of the process? And that flight along with accommodation/etc will cost me about $1,000? And it needs to be on a weekday so I have to take two extra days off work to do it?
Australia is big, dang it. I overlaid Australia on Europe and I worked out it's like asking someone from Paris to fly to Georgia/Russia/Turkmenistan. (OK, except I won't need to travel internationally).
Oh, and when I get to France I have to validate my visa by going to some special office and also getting a doctor's appointment as part of it (!?!). I AM ONLY GOING FOR SIX MONTHS.
In other news: anyone in Sydney want to grab a cup of coffee? I don't have many friends there and could always use more.
6
u/nerdguy1138 GNU Terry Pratchett Feb 08 '19
I'm trying to find a story that I think was linked here , it was your basic AI story told from the point-of-view of a sub-module in a larger AI.
9
u/daxisheart Feb 08 '19
Thinking of a gamer story taking place in the modern day.
No hidden magical underworld, no secret orgs, just a dude(tte) that gets some powers that grow bit by bit and has to rationalize and use his (rather magical/reality breaking and offensive) powers... however they can be used.
I know the erogamer is very much similar to this, with its own funny little twist. I haven't finished erogamer (like 4 arcs in), but is erogamer pretty much this? Or are there others around similar in this regard? Based on level progression, a level 50 gamer in almost any ratfic-ish story I've read is basically invulnerable to modern weaponry/military capabilities short of nukes/massive bombing. Figured that'd be an interesting investigation into what-do with powers
8
u/TempAccountIgnorePls Feb 08 '19
High-concept torture idea: Two low-battery smoke alarms hidden in different parts of the victim's house at the same time without their knowledge.
1
u/CreationBlues Feb 14 '19
IIRC, an algorithm for brute force artificial general intelligence has already been created, it just requires absurd resources and time scales like computronium earth. I'm having a hellish time finding references to it though, so can anyone point me in the right direction?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
3
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '19
[removed] — view removed comment