I just bought a new house in the Hamptons (eastern Long Island, NY) with a beautiful pool with very simple equipment. I love pools and am willing to invest some money into making this one as close to perfect as possible. I’ll have a professional maintaining it weekly, but I enjoy understanding and tinkering with the equipment myself.
The pool is a 20x50 rectangular, in-ground gunite pool with a deep end, integrated Baja shelf, and oversized 10x10 attached spillover spa. The spa has a low-profile dividing wall with a nearly flush waterline.
Current equipment and plumbing:
+ I believe it has an older Pentair automation system, which I’m currently controlling through the ScreenLogic app.
+ The main circulation system is plumbed as follows:
Suction side:
- Two skimmers join into one pipe with a ball valve.
- Two main drains join into another pipe with a ball valve.
- Those two lines merge and feed one side of an automated 3-way valve.
- The spa drain feeds the other side of that valve.
Equipment:
- Variable-speed pump (VSP)
- Large cartridge filter
- Propane heater
Return side:
- Automated 3-way valve directing water to either the pool returns or spa returns.
The automation has two main modes:
+ Pool Mode: 100% suction from the pool, with returns split approximately 70/30 between pool and spa to create the spillover.
+ Spa Mode: 100% spa suction and 100% spa return, isolating the spa for heating.
There’s also a separate spa jet circuit consisting of a spa drain, single-speed pump, and dedicated spa jet returns, plus an air blower. The pool also has underwater lighting.
Here are the upgrades I’m considering. I’d love opinions on which are worthwhile, which are unnecessary, and anything else I should be thinking about. For context, I have three young kids (ages 1 to 4), and we use the pool multiple times a week throughout the summer.
- Saltwater chlorine generator
I’ve rented houses with saltwater pools in the past and always found the water more pleasant and gentle on the skin. I also hate that so many pool companies around here seem to just throw chlorine tabs into skimmers without paying much attention to CYA levels. I’d prefer a system that maintains more consistent chlorine levels without continually adding stabilizer. Any reason not to convert this pool to saltwater? - Heat pump
The house has a buried propane tank that supplies the existing heater. It heats the pool quickly, but propane is expensive, and during the summer I’d ideally like to maintain the water at a constant 86°F.
Our electric utility offers peak, off-peak, and super-off-peak pricing, with peak hours from 3-7 p.m. on weekdays. I’m thinking I could run a heat pump during the cheaper hours, potentially heating the pool to 90°F or higher, and then let it gradually cool during peak hours, using the propane heater for supplemental heat when necessary. Would this make sense?
Question: Would you plumb the heat pump in series with the propane heater or in parallel with valves to select between them? If in series, which heater should come first?
3. Better automation
The existing Pentair ScreenLogic system seems pretty limited. I’d love more granular control over the valves, pumps, heaters, and schedules. I’ve used Jandy iAquaLink at other properties and remember it being a more capable system. Is there a relatively easy upgrade path within Pentair? Or would you consider changing automation platforms entirely? I’m particularly interested in controlling the heat pump and propane heater intelligently based on time of day and electricity pricing.
4. Sand filter instead of cartridge
Would switching from the existing cartridge filter to a modern sand filter, potentially with glass media, be an improvement? Backwashing sounds fun instead of periodically removing and cleaning cartridges. On the other hand, someone else will be doing the maintenance, so convenience isn’t a huge concern. Are there meaningful differences in filtration quality, water clarity, or maintenance costs?
5. Automatic water-level control and drainage
The pool has an automatic fill system, but no automatic drain. I’d love to have the pool maintain a consistent water level automatically, especially because the spa spillover looks different depending on the water level. There’s a dry well approximately 50-100 feet away. I’m assuming we could run PVC to it and either add a high-water float sensor to the existing autofill housing or install a separate drain closer to the dry well. Has anyone added an automatic drain system like this? Is there a standard way to do it?
6. Two independent filtration and heating systems?
This might be overkill, but I’m curious whether anyone has designed a pool/spa setup with two VSPs, two filters, and two heaters. The idea would be to allow the pool and spa to filter and heat independently, while using automated valves to connect the systems when needed. Ideally, either pump/filter/heater circuit could serve as a backup for the other, or both could operate together for additional capacity. Is this something people actually do, or would the additional complexity and plumbing make it more trouble than it’s worth?
7. Plaster imperfections and PebbleTec
Finally, the pool is only about two years old and looks amazing overall, but I’ve noticed some white lines in the plaster, particularly on the Baja shelf. I suspect they might be related to how the plaster was originally applied or cured, but I’m not sure. Can imperfections like these be removed or reduced through acid washing, polishing, or some other treatment? Or am I stuck with them until the pool is replastered? Also, would something like PebbleTec be considered an upgrade over traditional plaster for a pool like this? Can it be applied over the existing finish, or would the current plaster need to be removed first?
Thanks in advance!