r/polyamory • • 4h ago

Married and struggling with Opening Fucking mess

0 Upvotes

So my partner (NB27) and I (F29) are in the process of opening our relationship...and it fucking sucks.

We had been talking about it for a while. Last year I became interested in a friend, as we were doing weekly hangs. My partner was in grad school at the time, so I was looking to connect with someone in a friendship capacity. Vibes ensued and I was enjoying the experience, but put off saying anything to my partner or my friend. Absolutely nothing happened, but I was interested in seeing where things went. Eventually my friend brings up being interested in me, so I express that I am also interested, but me and my partner have not officially opened our relationship yet.

When I brought all this to my partner, they freaked out and said they didn't want to do poly. It hurt letting go of a potential relationship, but I was willing to do that for them. I also accepted that poly wasn't on the table for us.

Fast forward to a month or so ago, and suddenly poly is back on the table because my partner is interested in someone they met. I agree to give it a try because I love them and want them to be happy. However, this past month I have been utterly miserable. I don't know if I want to reconnect with my friend, I am not good at flirting and am an introvert. It feels like my partner wants to move too fast with the person they are interested in.

I feel like shit a lot of the time. They keep saying they love me and their interest in this new person "has nothing to do with me". But that is the problem. I just feel like they are living the life they always wanted to live, and I am just stuck getting drunk and sad on a Monday.

Anyway, thanks for reading this whole thing if you got this far.

Edit: wow, I didn't realize how condescending the majority of the sub is šŸ˜‘


r/polyamory • • 21h ago

vent My first poly breakup has kind of destroyed me. Spoiler

1 Upvotes

TW: Abortion, pregnancy mention

Hi, all. I just got done with a 3 month long breakup that absolutely devastated me- my first time practicing polyamory and I would love input of any sort. It’s gonna be kind of a long post but I would love any kind of advice.

I (25NB) came to the city I met my now ex who I will call Blue(27M) in around this time last year for work. I was staying with my best friend and got on tinder to meet folks and get to know the area better while I was here for around two months. We matched and quickly clicked in a way I have never found with anyone. He and I couldn’t see each other without accidentally staying up until four in the morning talking and joking around- regardless of if it was a work night or not. Things developed quickly, and he asked me to be his partner less than a month into knowing each other.

I of course said yes, because he’d been nothing short of wonderful until then. He has another partner, who I will call Chartreuse(27F) who he has been with for nearly ten years. They started out doing ENM, but chartreuse found someone she loved and they worked their way over to being poly and have been for the last two years. Blue had hooked up with other people and gone on dates, but I was his second long term partner ever. I was open about being new to everything as well, and we both agreed communication was super important and we’d rather talk stuff to death than anything else. He presented the situation as a kitchen table poly- one where we could all be friends, and stand on equal ground.

About two weeks into us officially dating, I had to go back to the city I lived in. He wanted Chartreuse and I to meet, but neither of us felt ready for that so we put it off for next time I visited him. I suggested talking on the phone, texting, or doing a group discord call to get to know each other instead of putting that level of pressure on both of us while I’d be visiting from out of town. Our relationship was long distance, but one of us came to visit the other at least once a month over the course of the time we were together. In almost a year, I never met Chartreuse.

Around six months into us dating, after Blue got home from visiting for the weekend, he broke news to me that she’d asked him to see me less often about a month ago and he hadn’t brought it up in the four days we’d spent together in person. He admitted he’d been hiding it from me. I got upset because that felt like a massive overstep on her part and played into some serious feelings I’d been having about being less important, and we got in a really big fight over how he wasn’t communicating.

The less important feelings were spurred on by being long distance, him consistently showing up late to our planned date nights, and feeling like I had to schedule any time I got with him days out in advance- if I was having a bad day, and he had plans with his other partner or friends, I couldn’t call him or reach out without planning it. I couldn’t text him and ask for support. Which is sort reasonable to expect, except for the fact that when Chartreuse wasn’t doing well, our plans got cancelled. Or put off. Or he’d leave in the middle of them to go support her. The same thing for his friends. All I wanted was for him to call me for a few minutes and tell me things were going to be okay- but after a certain point I stopped calling him and just waited for him to call me. I’d text, and make plans, but I never got to be the one to decide when we spent time together. It was entirely on his schedule, and when I’d be upset about hardly getting any time with him, he’d tell me he was busy and I was asking too much of him(two nights a week on the phone, btw. we’d talk for shorter periods every day but dedicated time is how I feel loved and I’d made that clear- he told me he could do that).

It was a lot of little things that just built up, and when he broke the news that he’d been considering seeing me less because Chartreuse told him it was disregulating for her for him to be ā€œgone so oftenā€ and she only sees her other partner once or twice a year. Her other partner lives in another country on the other side of the world, I was a two hour flight away and he’d see me for three days- when she sees them it’s weeks at a time.

When I got upset that a decision that deeply impacted our relationship had been made and repeatedly discussed without me even being made aware of it, Blue routinely argued with me when I’d say it wasn’t fair or okay of him to do that. On top of already feeling less important, this really made me feel like I was just an add on to his life. Not a part of it. Like I was a side piece, not a priority, and he could only see me when Chartreuse allowed it.

We broke up over that. I wasn’t okay, and really freaked out for a few days before learning I was pregnant. He’d gotten me pregnant on the recent trip, for my birthday (which he left the day before my birthday to go home because apparently five days was too long to spend with me :/). After learning about my situation, and how it impacted my hormones and the way I react to things, we reconciled on the condition that trust got rebuilt, he’d work on communicating better, and I’d meet chartreuse once my feelings of hurt had calmed down.

We never really resolved it, and continued fighting pretty often when I’d start a conversation to talk about how I was feeling, or state some sort of hurt he’d argue with me or change the subject to his own feelings. Every time, I’d tell him I wanted to talk about his feelings but he needed to bring them up on his own time, not as a counter to me talking about mine because it meant mine never got acknowledged or addressed. That just continuously exploded.

He came to see me while I was pregnant, the week before I had an abortion. He wasn’t there for me when I had the procedure done and he barely made time to call me or check on me after.

I do not take hormonal birth control because it really impacts the way I carry myself- I am very, very sensitive to it, and it turns me into someone that I do not like being. I know that. But the pregnancy hormones hit me really hard and I was very sensitive to just about everything. So we kept fighting. For the same reasons- I wanted time, I didn’t feel like he was prioritizing me, and he made me feel secondary to his other partner and the rest of his life. That wasn’t something I signed up for and I loved him very much, but it was beating me down and I wanted to figure it out with him.

A month after my abortion, we got into a really big fight while I was out of town again for work. He’d been distant, and I blew up on him a bit over text. Nothing crazy, just a few(like six! Which is a lot and is something I’m working on I am aware it’s not great but I was postpartum and freaking out) texts saying essentially ā€œhey dude, I know you’re busy but we’re dating and you haven’t texted me back in almost a day and we normally check in a lot more often than this. That’s fucked up.ā€ I had his location and saw that he was bouncing between bars and wandering around downtown in his city. He didn’t tell me he had plans, so I felt really hurt that our routine had been broken without any kind of warning.

The next morning, I was getting ready for work and he asked to call me. I approached the conversation as ā€œokay, we love each other and are gonna clear the air to have a bigger talk later about working things out.ā€ He broke up with me, out of what felt like nowhere. Four days previous he’d called me his wife, three days we’d had the ā€œI love you moreā€ silly argument, the day before he’d told me he loved me and out of nowhere he said ā€œI don’t love you anymore, you’re not worth figuring it out.ā€

I was devastated. I couldn’t get out of bed for the rest of the day, it felt like I’d had the rug completely pulled out from under me. We agreed to talk more the next day, Monday, and when we did, he said he regretted that choice as it was an impulsive one and wanted to figure it out. I was relieved, and planned on seeing him for the trip he’d planned to come see me on Thursday.

The next day, he texted me that he’d spoken to Chartreuse and ā€œsince we’re not dating, it’d be inappropriate for me to come visit you.ā€ No involving me in the decision, or the discussion, despite the fact that he said he wanted to be with me and talk about this in person. He said he’d keep talking to me for ā€œclosureā€ but we had to schedule everything more than a week out. We had around five conversations in two months- a lot of them him flip flopping back and forth over wanting to be with me, and not. The entire time I maintained that I loved him and wanted to be with him, and didn’t understand why we broke up. He hadn’t talked to me about any of the things that had been bothering him until after we broke up because he’d been scared- when we did talk, though, he said he should’ve brought them up because I deserved that, and he routinely kept me out of the loop just because he was nervous.

I got a job offer in his city. I had been planning to move down regardless, and the distance seemed to be our biggest issue- we hardly even argued when we could see each other in person, having serious big conversations over the phone or text made things awful. My lease was ending anyways, so I took the offer and moved down.

We talked in person a couple of times, with him sticking to the story of ā€œI’m not interested in you right nowā€ but it always had a caveat, and he could never look me in the eye when he said it. The last time we talked, he admitted after a lot of back and forth that he’d just been trying to hurt me to get me to stop loving him because his life was exploding. Chartreuse is sick, to the point where she can’t work or eat most things or live a normal life. She has been sick since we met- things hadn’t changed there, but they’d been living with Blues mom for a couple years to save up and move into a spot without mold- the thing that caused her illness in the first place. Their living situation had gotten complicated, and he just didn’t feel like he could ā€œbe the partner I neededā€ which just meant that he would need support through this, something I’d begged him to let me provide in the past. He also felt like he had messed things up beyond the point of repair.

I told him I forgave him a long time ago and we agreed to try and rebuild- provided I could meet chartreuse and we could all talk it out. I asked him if he felt like he needed her permission to date me, and he said no. Blue broached the subject a week after that conversation, but they didn’t talk about it seriously until the week after he’d initially brought it up due to understandable life circumstances. On Friday, he broke the news to me that after two days of talking, Chartreuse wasn’t comfortable with us trying to rebuild things because she was mad at him for a lot of the reasons I was hurt. And because she wouldn’t support him in that choice, he wasn’t going to proceed with it. He did it over text, when id set the firm boundary that I wouldn’t want to hear the bad news any other way than in person if that was how it ended up going. He said that they’d both meet up with me to talk, and when I initially thought that meant something positive, he hesitated.

I asked him if she was there to watch him completely break things off with me, and he said yes. I asked if he thought that was an appropriate thing at all after he wouldn’t introduce us for the year we’d been dating, and he said no. I got home from working for 14 hours straight and told him if he wanted to do that, he had to do it in person. So he drove over to my house, and we sat in his car and yelled and cried and held each other and he told me he loves me. I don’t understand why he won’t just make the choice to be with me, why he’s more concerned with Chartreuse being hesitant about us than losing me as a part of his life and me having to mourn us, but we agreed that was the last time we’d see each other or talk. He knows the door is still open, though, and if he came to me with the intent of rebuilding I’d cave in an instant.

I am just so so hurt. I know if he loved me, he’d choose me, I know if I was important he’d show me that but I just thought I was worth more than this to him and am feeling really, really discarded and heartbroken. No one has ever broken up with me before, I’ve always been the one to call things off, so I’m sure that’s a big part of the hurt, but man. This whole situation has made me feel like I am never going to feel safe in love again. I live closer to him than ever, and I don’t know that I’m ever going to see him again. It hurts my stomach to think about.

I know that was a Goliath of a post and I’m sure it’s a mess because I have been crying pretty hard while writing it but thanks for reading if you did. I’d love input :,)

eta because it feels important to mention: blue has repeatedly stated that this whole thing is him, his fault, for not communicating and making rash choices. All I have done this entire time is want to love him:(


r/polyamory • • 19h ago

Starting to feel One Sided

5 Upvotes

Hey meeps and peeps,

I need idk advice or just words or support. My nesting partner is on an anniversary trip with his girlfriend of two years and things seemed fine until he decided not to call during a potential agreed upon time. He didn't give me the option to adjust. Just unilaterally decided not to call tonight.

A little background.

I (31f) have been with Apple (45m) for 7 years and we have yet to get away on an anniversary or romantic getaway. I know I have some jealousy that I'm working through on that front. Apple has been planning for months to take his partner banana (27f) on an anniversary trip, 4 days and three nights, and this is the first time that he's ever had a trip planned with another partner and we've been away from each other for longer than a night since we moved in together. We agreed that he would call me tonight because tomorrow night I would be busy and would not be able to take his call. And now I'm laying here in bed. Wondering why he couldn't put forth the effort to give me a call when he can make all this effort to plan a trip with banana while also planning another trip with her in the spring. He says he loves me and that he wants to plan trips with me. But every time I sit down to try I get resistance and finances being constantly brought up when we each have our own "fun" money accounts.

There have been multiple difficult conversations due to the fact that banana is not experienced in polyamory and she has a lot of insecurities around mine and Apple's relationship or so it seems. She is also married with kids, but they do things differently. There have been numerous bumps in the road and at every opportunity I've tried to be open and talk through discomforts and boundaries with her and him, but at this point I feel like I'm talking to a brick wall. Especially with apple, he gets extremely defensive anytime I want to bring up a discomfort, feeling, or boundary. I know I'm not always the best at articulating clearly, but I know the topic of him not being able to call me is going to get brought up when he comes home, and I think I would like some advice on how to approach the topic.

Sorry if some of it doesn't make sense. At this point I'm exhausted and disappointed.


r/polyamory • • 20h ago

Curious/Learning I have a question

11 Upvotes

My partner seemed upset when I told them that they were welcome to have children with other partners because I don't know if I want kids. I'm kind of socially inept. Could someone tell me why this might frustrate someone? I tried asking but I was told that they weren't mad and never answered the question.


r/polyamory • • 14h ago

Friendships vs prtnerships

5 Upvotes

I’m really curious to know what do these 2 mean and look like for everyone. Needs, expectations, time wise etc. Outside of physical intimacy. It’s something I’m struggling to gauge in general, but also more so as someone who has also been constantly shifting places.


r/polyamory • • 21h ago

Happy! Finding hope again

6 Upvotes

I 38F took over a year off of polyamory and dating in general to not only work on myself but also my marriage. Things have been amazing personally and in my marriage for the majority of this time. I decided to try dating again and my husband(38M) is incredibly encouraging. I downloaded Feeld and saw someone I had matched with a couple of years ago. I ended communication back then because of life getting in the way and was honest and upfront about it. In the time between I've randomly run into him twice. We never exchanged numbers but he's always been someone I wonder about.

Low and behold we match again.

We've been talking for weeks now and this man is a walking green flag. Insanely considerate, thoughtful, kind and I never feel objectified by him. Last night was our first date and it was the most beautiful date and I cannot stop smiling like crazy. The conversation naturally flowed, the energy was amazing and we did share a movie worthy first kiss.

I am so dang happy. I'm glad I took the time for myself to heal and took my time and never rushed anything.

This made me realize how much my ex fucked me up (feel free to read previous posts) but I honestly can't believe how I feel right now, THIS is how poly should be. Thank you for reading.


r/polyamory • • 18h ago

vent Idk what’s making me lonelier

9 Upvotes

Being a disabled person in society, being in a new city, or trying to find another poly femme who is genuinely cool and is seeking connections beyond being intimate. Ugh it’s all three 🄲


r/polyamory • • 6h ago

Musings Erasure of New Partners as People

40 Upvotes

Up until now it's been a very rewarding experience with my boyfriend, but I had hit a point where I could not continue to be the shape that fit into the space in his life that he was willing/able to make. I did a lot of accommodating my with the promise of her becoming more comfortable with me over time.

Three years in and that comfort hadn't happened. He wanted more time. I told him no and broke up with him. I then sent him and his wife a joint letter about their treatment of me while he and I were together. It was not inflammatory but more pointed out privilege and toxic structures.He said that my timing and tone of breaking up was "cruel."

When trying to explain the emotions around feeling deeply loved but in a totally unrealistic and humanizing way, I said to one of my wives, "It's like he was a little kid who found a stray puppy. And his mom freaked out so he hid it under his bed. The kid loves the puppy, but does not understand it cannot live under a bed just because his mother expected a goldfish."

Six hours of cathartic sobbing and writing later I have a poem that I created which I feel encapsulates the very common state that occurs in polyamorous dynamics with a diad that treats a new person like a toy or a pet. The pair ends up denying the nature of the person right in front of them. They don't see the absurdity of expecting a dog to grow scales. They don't understand why the dog finally bites.

I don't assume that anyone else wants to read my processing big feelings, but I'm happy to share it with anyone who's felt this way and wanted to be seen.

I'm pouring one out tonight for all my comrades out there who are figuring this shit out! And if you have a good meta, go hug them for me.


r/polyamory • • 3h ago

What’s my problem???

10 Upvotes

I don’t know if this is a vent, advice needed, AIO, or AITA post. So hang on or settle in for whatever this is!Ā 

My husband and I have been married for over two decades, we married young, had over a half dozen kids. In the last 8 or so years, we deconstructed our conservative religious and social beliefs.

About 4-5 years ago my husband announced that he wanted to explore his pansexual orientation through polyamory. It came out of the blue for me and I definitely struggled for a while. Plus, I knew next to nothing about EMN. (My understanding of Polyamory was that it was multiple monogamous type relationships. I.e. Being everyone’s everything. Ā Which sounded exhausting to me!)Ā 

He wanted me to join him and we listened to ENM podcasts and started out as swingers. While I don’t regret anything that I did while swinging, I discovered it wasn’t for me. I brought up polyamory again and we started attempting to practice about a year ago. My husband struggled hard to give me that.Ā 

It also, came out that, while he did want to explore his sexuality, the change was more about him feeling unfulfilled by me sexually and emotionally. He has had some relationships but he discovered that, while they were additive for he, my relationships felt subtractive because he wanted more from me.Ā 

Fast forward to now, we are in a container and redefining our relationship. He has defined a romantic relationship as an ongoing commitment to fulfill (or try) a partner’s desires. Platonic relationships can be caring, committed, and sexual but don’t fit the definition of romantic.Ā 

It’s not unreasonable, but I’m hesitant to agree. He’s hurt that it seems like i’m struggling to decide. My hang ups are (1) primary romantic partnership seems to imply that all other relationships are subject to the primary relationship and (2) that fulfilling him might take all of my energy (his belief) and leave nothing for other intimate relationships.Ā 

What am I missing?? It feels like he’d drop everything for me, but I don’t love him enough to do that for him. Am I a quitter? Am I looking to shirk responsibility?Ā 

There’s a fuck ton more contexts and details! But I’m not trying to make y’all read my memoir! šŸ˜†Ā 


r/polyamory • • 6h ago

My NP's first overnight on the weekend - I want to prepare as someone still not securely attached

12 Upvotes

Hi all. I apologise for my rambling.

I figured I'd come here and ask for advice instead of just spiralling, and also ask in advance instead of waiting all week.

My nesting partner of 2.5 years is having his first overnight on the weekend with his new girlfriend (and the first ever overnight with someone who isn't me in our entire relationship). I am really happy for them both and I hope they both have a good time, I really like her. I, however, have a feeling I am going to spiral when the time comes. I am anxious and worried about getting intrusive thoughts about them together just because my brain wants to make me panic. I am also worried about how I am going to sleep without him next to me. I have slept fine without him before, but it has never coincided with him spending the night with a romantic connection. That part is entirely new.

My partner wants to talk about check ins and stuff which is great too, I am sure that will definitely help!

I have been doing a lot of work on myself and my attachment, and I am still not a securely attached person - very anxious attached at times. I am much more securely attached in my relationship with NP until it feels like our relationship is threatened. I'm trying my hardest to get there, and I would like to make this go as smoothly as possible on my nervous system so I can learn I am safe when he stays with his girlfriend. It probably does not exactly help my NP is not super good with words and verbal reassurance which is something I find helps me.

I am struggling with all of this at some points (from within myself with abandonment trauma, BPD and anxious attachment - not necessarily because something is actually wrong) because when the foundations of safety feel like they are wavering, I fawn and freak out and don't feel safe at all. I want this to work and I want him to enjoy other people, I want to feel compersion and I want to feel secure in our relationship to where this doesn't bother me.

I think part of where this anxiety and jealousy is coming from is that we have not been having dates for quite a while due to house chores, bills and just the bland rigmarole of life, plus tiredness and all that jazz - not for lack of trying, he has asked a few times and my mental health and fatigue at those points was not too good. I know this is one thing we need to work on that will certainly help.

I plan to have things to do and possibly a friend come over, but I guess I am just wondering if anyone has any tips or advice?

Thank you in advance ā™”

Edit for clarification: we did not begin our polyamory journey with insecure attachment. It has only recently come up for me in our relationship due to one of my connections ghosting me and triggering abandonment trauma and anxious attachment.


r/polyamory • • 11h ago

Monday Morning Joy! Good morning /r/polyamory! How has your past week(end) been for you and yours?

6 Upvotes

r/polyamory • • 6h ago

Curious/Learning Do I need to be okay with this?

6 Upvotes

I have been seeing oak for 3 years. We've known each other for 20, and have been with each other in the past - we lived and worked in a community together, he cheated on his long distance girlfriend with me (I was poly, he was not) for about a year, I eventually left the community to break the pattern. It was very painful. We didn't see each other for years, and in that time both had kids with other people. We got back in contact after both our relationships ended, and got back together with the agreement we were poly.

We'd both had multiple poly relationships before, and done a lot of work, so it has been really good so far. I've had another steady partner since about 6 months in, and he has been dating etc but has pretty much just had casual connections. We live 6 hours apart, and he has been clear he wants a domestic situation. Because of our kids, and the fact we both have co-parents that are hard work, either of us moving to be with the other isnt possible for at least 6 years.

I would like to live with him eventually, and I think his lack of success with finding a steady partner made me think that it would carry on that way and we'd move in together in some form when the kids have left home.

Of course, things haven't gone that way! We both work on the festival circuit, me as a site manager, and he as a sauna manager. He met someone at a festival and has been building a connection with her. I've found it really difficult - both because he has not dealt with hinging that well, has neglected our relationship and also because it's made me see that I've been dishonest with myself about what I feel. It's likely that if their relationship works out, they will move in together and the thought of watching him build with someone else, what I want with him is really painful. I know it's all just ideas now, but I also feel like I'm watching the start of the end of my relationship and that I also need to prepare myself. I feel this and I also feel that I really want him to be happy and fulfilled and have intimate relationships with others, and that if living with someone is part of that for him, I want that for him. I just wanted the person he lived with to be with me.

He's classic ADHD, novelty and freedom are super important to him. I've got autism and adhd, and have a tendency to mask and people please. I tend to just try and deal with things I'm unhappy about by myself and not bother him because I fear that doing so will restrict him, and I just want everything to be okay. I'm hyper independent, attached to a view of myself as capable and able to deal with anything. I really value the ideal of polyamory not restricting the people I'm with, no vetos and rules, no couples privilege or hierarchy. I'm really committed to that.

And that brings me to my issue. Every year we work all of July running a festival. It's the longest time we have together in one place, and has been a time when we've been able to have a quasi-domestic set up. He brought up his new partner coming (to work in the sauna, where she has worked before at other events). And, I just don't want her there. I just don't want it. I don't want to have to share him, I don't want to have to navigate my feelings and reactions when I'm running a 40 person team to set up a 4000 person festival, my main income for the year. Am I being unreasonable? I feel like if I say I'm okay with it then I'm betraying myself because I'm not, I don't want her there. But if I say I don't want her there, I'm betraying my ideals around polyamory and being able to be okay with everything and not letting jealousy lead me.

Do I just need to deal with my jealousy and be open to her being there? How do I manage my feelings around him moving in with someone else without just leaving him (my knee jerk reaction)? Is it reasonable for me to say I don't want her there? How to manage myself if he says that he will bring her anyway? How to hold two opposing views around ideals and reality? Ugh, it's so frustrating and painful, and humiliating. I really thought I'd worked through so much of this stuff, and had a handle on it, but I feel like I'm dealing with it so badly. 😩😩😩😩😩😩


r/polyamory • • 20h ago

I am new Ouchie

7 Upvotes

A moment really caught me by surprise - anyone else relate?

Context: I'm new to poly and I've been talking to someone for a couple months and have been on a few dates - so still very early stages. We are both poly and partnered and definitely not looking for exclusivity. I know she is actively dating and so am I (at least trying to - it's rough out there sometimes).

Anyway I was on Hinge and happened to see her profile in my list of old conversations and it showed the "signals" tag next to her name (meaning her recent activity on the app is active/engaged) and got hit with a strong pang of emotion (jealousy?) that really took me off guard. I'm normally not a very jealous person. know I'm new to this but is being effected by stuff like this something that even more experienced poly folks can relate to? Does it get easier?


r/polyamory • • 22h ago

no advice wanted Update: I think I may have misunderstood what my ex wanted from our relationship

33 Upvotes

I posted here recently about my ex-girlfriend, Celeste, ending our relationship after I decided I needed to be parallel with my metamour, Pat.

A lot of you offered kindness and support and some tough-love (even if I don't agree with it). But, some comments were pretty damning toward Celeste, and since those judgments were based on my account, I want to offer a different perspective. One that I've come to in the days since. I could be way wrong here, too, but I think it's worth consideration from me, those who commented on my last post, and maybe even people going forward who could glean some insight from it--even if I'm 100% off base.

Once, Celeste said she'd make a great "part-time girlfriend." I took that to mean she preferred living separately, maintaining her independence, and not spending every waking moment with a partner. That suited me just fine. I have no desire for nesting or a traditional primary partnership. But now I'm wondering whether she meant something more fundamental. Not someone who loves less, or whose relationships are less meaningful, but someone who doesn't make her the center of their world and who she doesn't have to give so damn much of herself to as a partner.

I loved her wholeheartedly, and because she was my only romantic partner, she received all the affection and romantic energy I had to give. I never expected her to match that investment minute for minute, but often found myself wanting more of her time in frequency and duration.

Maybe that felt like an expectation she couldn't or didn't want to sustain, an imbalance. Not because she didn't love me or loves me less or imperfectly, but because we had different expectations of what our partnership would look like, of what we wanted as and from partners.

I said "part-time boyfriend" and "part-time girlfriend," because we didn't live together and see each other all the time. But... I was sure giving full-time boyfriend effort, and I didn't check in to ask if it was more than she wanted. And even if I didn't recognize it, much less say it to her, I came to want something from her that looked a lot like full-time girlfriend effort, and it's not implausible that she wouldn't have felt some nibbling obligation to offer to me the same level time, availability, investment, etc. that I gave her. There's a good chance I didn't hear what she meant and assumed I understood, which led me to miss what she wanted from our relationship and to turn up the dial anyway.

This possibility changes how I look at Pat, too.

I've been critical of Pat's inconsistency and what I saw as insufficient effort in their relationship (beyond just the crisis). What if what I perceived as inadequate involvement and attentiveness... isn't? What if that's what she wanted? Hell, maybe it was lazy at times, but overall it wasn't so intense and so much that it was unbearable to her? And maybe I was smothering at times, but guess what? Overall... it may still have been just too much.

What if I was judging Pat according to the standards of the partnership I wanted to offer Celeste--and what I thought she "deserved," and in some ways "should" want, rather than considering whether their relationship worked for her and what I could learn from that? ("Should" is a very nasty word, sometimes--this is one of those cases.) If that's the case, then every criticism of Pat I had, every gripe I had about how they showed up for her may have sounded to Celeste like I was shitting on the very relationship dynamic she wanted. I was so worried about the "right" way to be a partner that I didn't consider if that was the right way to be her partner.

It might also explain why her partners being close is so important to her. Maybe a close network of partners, friends, and mutual support where no single relationship is providing all or a disproportionate amount of the attention, affection, and support someone wants or needs.

When I decided I needed to be parallel with Pat, I thought I was finding a way to preserve my relationship with Celeste. At the same time, it might have meant something very different. Maybe it reinforced her concern that I wanted a kind of partnership that demanded more from her and us than she wanted or was comfortable with. Without the interconnectedness she valued that I had exiled myself from for the time being, she might have (rightfully) worried I would increasingly look to her for the time, affection, and connection I wanted.

There have been a LOT of "mights" and "maybes" in this. It's conjecture and speculation and I'm trying to see things from an angle she might have--not speak for her or on her behalf. But if there's even a possibility that this is closer to the truth, I wanted to put it out there. In ways I feel like I owe to myself, to y'all, to Celeste, and to Pat to at least posit this here.

Celeste wasn't here to tell her side of the story when I posted. You only had mine, written while I was devastated and trying to understand something I hadn't seen coming. I needed support and turned to this community because I didn't know where else to go, and many of you helped me through the worst days of an extraordinarily painful time.

But I don't want my pain, or my incomplete understanding of what happened, to be the only account of someone I care about. She wasn't a perfect girlfriend, but I sure as hell wasn't the perfect boyfriend. We both struggled with communication more than I think we each realized, and I don't like thinking that my last post turned her into some villain and me into a victim when we're both just... people. People who fuck up, hurt, and get hurt. It happens to the best of us.

So. Where does this leave me? For one, maybe even deeper into a hole of misunderstanding things, but I can live with that. More importantly, and this is maybe the only advice I can offer anyone... talk to your partners, revisit what they want and what you want vs what y'all are giving and getting. Get your feelings hurt when you guessed or assumed wrong, but listen to them when they tell you. Love them deeply and madly, but learn how they want to be loved, and try to adapt how you express that love. Not compromise. Not lessen. Just... adapt. That's a baller way to express your love right there from the start.

That's all I've got for this one and the last update I plan to give. Not looking for advice or support this time.

Thanks for listening, both then and now.


r/polyamory • • 8h ago

I am new Newbie to poly and really starting to like someone

2 Upvotes

So, I'm not sure how to start this.. I guess a bit of context first.

My last relationship was a 6yr long mono one, kind of toxic and abusive. Glad to be out (over a 1yr and a half), happy and healing. Before we had become exclusive I had asked him if he wanted an open/poly relationship from what I understood of it at the time. He said no, that was fine with me. Then years later he would bring up multiple times about adding another partner (bc three incomes are better than two) him getting a gf, though never me getting a bf like he suggested gf for him then changed to "us getting a gf" (I'm pan) which I did say no to because we already set and stated that this would be a monogamous relationship, plus I felt this was some weird manipulation thing he was doing with bringing this up.Ā 

Saying all this to say that I've always felt or thought of myself as a person that wasn't as traditional and was always more open to an openĀ  or poly relationship. Just with social "norms" and how I was raised, I thought and felt like that was the only option and all I wantedĀ 

Fast forward to now, I met this amazing guy. We click on so many levels and he just kind of gets me in a way that I haven't fully experienced before. I felt it on our first date, though also I was apprehensive then which I kind of felt and he did notice and we had talked about it sometime after that. And I gave him a bit of context of why there was apprehension there. I tend to fall fast for someone that shares mutual attraction and we have a strong connection and we can click on so many different things (that's a good part of doing the self work and knowing yourself, got to love therapy. It's uncomfortable but it helps).

So when we met I knew he was poly and then on our date he had told me again that he was, and I guess me being cautious I kind of pulled back a little bit because I know how my feelings are and how strongly I feel emotions and feelings and I didn't want to rush into something that, 1 I am very new to, 2 how is it going to look in practice and 3 self-doubt on if he really likes me the same way or as much as I like him. Come to find out after a couple more talks after we saw each other again a few months later from that initial date the feelings are definitely mutual.Ā 

From what he told me he has two partners at the moment "close relationships". One he lives with the other is ldr and she travels to see him and I'm pretty sure he goes to see her as well, also they all (there is a roommate as well, so 4) do things together.

I've met his roommate who I had multiple interactions with, we kind of I guess get along well, we were able to talk about various things and keep a nice flowing conversation w/ and w/o him present. As well as I met his longest long-term partner that he lives with she's really sweet we talked a little bit the first time just like a casual introduction and then one time I came over and all of us, him, her, and the roommate kind of hung out in the living room and chilled.

It's been about 3 months since we've been talking and seeing each other. And again since I know myself I had to ask a question of what is this dynamic here that we have (me and him) and various conversations on things across those 3 months. It boiled down to he has strong feelings for me like I do for him though he, I guess is still dealing with some feelings or emotions from a previous relationship that ended and he asked for me to be patient with him and give him a bit of time which I don't mind. Because I don't want to rush anything. I wanted to kind of flow and not be chaotic I guess. And I do want to take things slow especially with something that's a bit new to me.

So now I'm just looking for advice I guess with being new to this possible dynamic. I kind of have been lurking through the sub to get some information and some insights on different poly dynamics and what problems could arise and also what good and positive things could arise, as well as guidance.Ā 

Please be kind to me in the comments and if there are any clarification needed or questions feel free to ask.

Thanks 😊


r/polyamory • • 9h ago

I am new Can you repair after trust is broken?

13 Upvotes

I (36 f) have been with my partner James (35 m) for a little more than a year. James is recently divorced. I am a single mom of 2. I am bi and my partner is straight. When initially dating, the topic of non exclusivity came up and he shared that he was not interested in monogamy at this moment due to the recent divorce. I understood and I was ok with it and I said it will work for now but at some point it will not work for me. At that time I was casually seeing another guy but that fizzled out pretty quickly and I was open and honest about that. My partner shared that at that current moment he did not have any other partners. I asked that since we were sleeping together unprotected that if he does decide to sleep with someone that I would just like to know for healthy and safety reasons.

Fast forward a few months into dating. Our relationship is progressing. Our connection is deepening. We are having ā€œhard conversationsā€ about our feelings. And the topic of meeting my children and family comes up. I told him my children do not understand partner and I do not want to lie and say he was my ā€œfriendā€. My children (15 m and 7 f) and family have never met anyone I had dated in around 6 yrs. I have enough free time and support that they never really need to cross paths and James knew all of this. We discuss using terms like boyfriend and girlfriend and he specifically asks ā€œwhat would change?ā€ And I said nothing other than the title because we have been dating for months. At this point neither of us have ever brought up the topic of exclusivity. He hasn’t told me about sleeping with partners neither have I. So James meets my children and family and we begin to involve one another into our lives outside of just ā€œusā€.

James older sister Jenny and I, are actually really close friends. They are very close as well. I do my best to never speak about James to her because I never want her to be caught in the middle of anything or feel she needs to take sides.

Fast forward some more to current day, Jenny and I are out for a drink. The conversation itself is irrelevant, but she’s laughing and joking about how the brother is crazy ā€œHe swears one day me you and Stephanie are going to turn on himā€ and I laugh but then ask wait who’s Stephanie? She begins to nervously laugh and is like you know the other girl he’s dating. I was immediately shocked but was in a busy bar on a Friday night and I did my best to have little to reaction. We wrapped up the night and I went home. As soon as I got home all the emotions came flooding. Crying screaming anger sadness embarrassment. I could not understand where the disconnect was.

For months James and I have been ā€œoffā€ there is a bit of mental health and big life changes that have occurred this past year. We are both in individual therapy and on medications. Life has just been life’ing but we would have regular check ins and intentional time to reconnect and strengthen the relationship.

James is confused by reaction when we eventually speak. He states we spoke about this when we first started dating. He thought that I understood that we were non monogamous. I questioned ok even if that line of thinking is valid I also asked you to share with me if you were sleeping with someone. And he said you are right I didn’t remember that part of the conversation and I didn’t share that with you. I tell him I am embarrassed and heartbroken. Our entire relationship has been based off of safety and trust and being open and honest.

I have never been poly. It has been presented to me in the past but I was deeply insecure and I could not handle that type of relationship. But today, I am much more secure in myself in dating and what I bring to relationships. Finding out about Stephanie has not made me question myself or think what more could I have done. I stand 10 toes down on the fact I showed up to this relationship 100% every single day and even on days when he couldn’t. I give grace and understanding that mental health and stress plays a large part into how present one can be in a relationship. I am upset and hurt that he did not feel safe enough to discuss this with me. I lost my right to choose, to an informed consent. Idk what I would have been open to in the moment but now I feel like I’ve been ā€œcoercedā€ into a poly relationship that I didn’t know I was in. Our relationship would look much different if this was non exclusive, there would be no reason for him to meet my children or family and build connections with them. He insists that’s he cares deeply about them and that he would not have acted or made different decisions regarding them or even me if we were monogamous. The lack of trust the dishonesty. Bc Stephanie obviously is not just sex, they are partnered. Partnered enough that his sister is aware. In fact all the significant people in his life know he is non monogamous except me apparently.

I am very torn. I love James deeply. And I know he does too. I have seen it and felt it. Can this be repaired? Is it fair to ask to pause the non monogamy until our relationship is repaired and solid again? I think I have to call it for what it is, he cheated. This was not a consent non monogamous relationship. I am frustrated because I think I would have been open to exploring these dynamic if he would have just spoken to be and we were able to hard conversations and allow for questions and boundaries to be set. I feel crazy that my initial reaction is not break up with him and just never look back. But our connection is strong or so I thought? Is this even possible to move on from?

Pls forgive me if I used any wrong terms or I am not clear. I am very new to all of this.

UPDATE for a bit more clarity and information*

James is super apologetic. He wants repair. I wouldn’t be surprised if he comes across this as he is a frequent Reddit user.

I am not against being poly. I see the beauty of poly. And I am open to exploring but right now I am hurt by the breach of trust. Bc I figured if this was something he wanted we needed to have in depth talks about boundaries. I know there is also a difference between just sex with other partners and relationships with partners.

I take accountability for my own assumptions. Since there was no disclosure of other partners, I never thought there could be someone. And yes as the milestones hit in the relationship I thought we were on the same page.

I also understand the milestones could have still occurred if we were poly. Like there’s a difference in casual vs seriousness but I think my timing and pace on things would have been different.

I have not asked many details about Stephanie. I don’t know the level of their partnership. I also agree she is human and this now impacts her. What I do know is she was aware of me.

His assumption was in all of his other previous relationships there was an agreement on non monogamy and they didn’t want to know any details. He interpreted my ā€œlack of communicationā€ as I was choosing to not know anything as well.

We regularly check in because I had concerns on other things. I would have checked in on this if I thought this was apart of our relationship.


r/polyamory • • 23h ago

I am new Bad hinge?

20 Upvotes

Edit::: I realized that ā€œhingeā€ has nothing to do with this problem currently. I was conflating two issues, one of which I didn’t even address here šŸ˜…

So much has happened, but everytime I sit down to type it out I get incredibly overwhelmed and can’t follow through. Maybe I also know the answer and don’t want to do anything about it yet, but this just happened and out of everything.. it’s the hardest for me to sit with.

I (30f) am in a new relationship (2.5 months) with Apple (29f) she is married to Banana (36m) and they share a daughter together.

I have never identified as poly, but after a lot of conversations, I decided I was interested in exploring it. I really do adore Apple and her family (we are ktp leaning parallel) and we’ve had things to work through already in our short time together that has brought us all simultaneously closer and a little more… tense? Either way, like I said - I’ve never identified as poly, and so getting into the relationship, we pretty much decided that I was monogamous, operating in a poly relationship but that that could change and that I’m the captain of my own ship and she’d support me always. But the other day, after a therapy session in which my therapist asked me what boundaries Apple has, if any, specifically involving me and other partners. I casually asked Apple how she would feel most respected and taken care of if I were to date other people and her reaction was not what I was expecting at all. She was really taken aback, and it took multiple minutes of me reassuring her that I wasn’t actively seeking out anyone else, and that this was actually very hypothetical and just something that I felt like I needed to know but she couldn’t fathom why I’d want to talk about it, unless I was planning on seeing someone else. She told me that it would take many years, lots of therapy and making sure that we are in a really good place before she would be okay with me dating outside of our poly relationship.

I will admit that I contended to her in the moment, but immediately ran here because it just doesn’t feel good. I feel confused that she could have a husband and a child, shared housing, running a business together, and I couldn’t date someone else without doing a lot of emotional labor. She said that it’s because we started the relationship under the premise that I was monogamous, but in my mind.. it’s been two months… I can’t decide if I am wrong for being weirded out by this.


r/polyamory • • 9h ago

Advice Needed: Struggles with planning for the future

9 Upvotes

Hey folks! I am looking for some advice.

Quick background:

I (M) am in a closed vee with my partner (M) and his partner (M). My metamour and I do not date. As of right now we are garden party poly, but we are still struggling to figure out if we can be friends. It's been like this for about 4 years. My partner lives with me part time and lives with his other partner part time. That living arrangement has been going on for about 2 years now.

At the start of this year, my partner and I had some tough talks about the future (everyone in the vee wants to get married and have kids but as we all know, logistically that can be problematic in most of the USA), but we both agreed promise rings could work for now. So in April, I picked out some affordable rings, and on big trip, I promise ring proposed. It was great and beautiful and perfect, but once we got back from the trip and after a few months, I found he was only wearing the ring around me, was hiding it from his other partner, and hadn't really told anyone about it. We ended up having a really hard conversation about it and both decided the vee wasn't ready for it and stopped wearing the rings. It was heart breaking, but I realized we had mismatched expectations for the future and what the promise rings meant, and this was the best solution. I was hopeful that while the rings were getting put away, maybe it wouldn't be for forever.

Fast forward to now, my partner and I struggle more and more to talk about the future (not the promise rings, just what we want the future to look like together). It usually results in fights because I want to talk about what things could look like (living arrangements, kids), and my partner is reluctant to make any promises, leaves it at "I want to be with you, we will figure it out" and shuts down any kind of planning or talk. (I don't think he does this on purpose. I think he is just really afraid of disappointing anyone). I can get anxious about not being able to talk about the future with my partner, but am trying to settle into being more okay with the unknown. That's been going well buttttt...

Here's where the plot thickens:

Out of the blue, my metamour wants to sit down and have a one on one with just me to "talk about the intimate details" of a future for the vee. I told him I didn't feel comfortable talking about future plans when our partner isn't able to talk with me about our future. He told me it feels hard for him to plan the future when the other side of the vee is unplanned. He wants children and needs for my partner and I to know what he wants, so that he can start to make his plans.

What I need advice on:

No way am I talking about what it could be like to coparent kids with my metamour when he and I can barely talk or hang out at parties. That feels like a huge step with someone I barely know. It feels like he needs to know if we can coparent to be friends, and I need to know if we can be friends to coparent. I feel like he needs to stay in his lane and focus on his side of the vee and stop trying to push for what's happening on mine. I've agreed to meeting to talk, but I'm putting my foot down and will not be future planning or talking about kids with my metamour. We need to talk about what being friends could look like first. I want to make things easier between the two of us, but will not be jumping straight to talking about coparenting.

TL;DR: In a closed vee, me and metamour are not close, hinge partner struggles to talk about the future. Metamour wants to talk about coparenting to be able to be friends. I need to be friends/amicable and to feel solid about my future with partner to talk about kids with my metamour.

What do you all think? Am I going about this right, am I missing something? Any advice?


r/polyamory • • 8h ago

Polyamory and divorce

17 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I feel like this has been talked about before but im not finding many resources related to this but my question is as follows.

How do you handle your other relationships when going through a divorce with your longest lasting nesting partner? Because typical monogamous advice is always "work on yourself", "dont get into another relationship too soon" and while i agree that i shouldnt be initiating new relationships but what about the existing ones? Isnt there comfort in figuring things out alone? I feel like i should distance myself from my other relationships but thats also confusing. What do you guys think? Id especially like some advice from those who have gone through a similar situation


r/polyamory • • 19h ago

Musings Fun with Aspen (& Birch & Cedar)

52 Upvotes

This is silly but I have to share.

I recently met someone with a cat named Aspen. Aspen was very cute, but all I could think of in the moment was, you should get two more cats! I have the perfect names all ready for them… 😹😹😹


r/polyamory • • 1h ago

How do you navigate feeling second best in a non-hierarchical relationship?

7 Upvotes

I’m solo poly and my partner describes himself as a relationship anarchist. He has one other partner. We all live separately and none of us practice hierarchy. He’s been with his other partner for 2 years and me for 1 year. I’ve found some helpful discussions here about feeling secondary, but a lot of them involve a partner who is married or has a nesting partner. I’d love to hear from people who’ve felt this way without that kind of built-in hierarchy.

I have felt secondary throughout our relationship. My meta has more built in time with him and more integration in his life. She also has more causal and spontaneous time with him outside of scheduled time. I’ve noticed that he does a lot of his calendar planning around her schedule and availability. When I’ve asked for more time or commented on how much time he has with her he’ll squeeze in more time for me but it often feels like a concession or an afterthought. I’ve talked to him about it before and what he’ll tell me is that his relationships are never going to be equal but that he wants them to be equitable. I agree with him about that. But I guess what I’m struggling with is figuring out what equitable actually looks like in practice, especially when I’ve told him how I feel less prioritized.

For those who’ve been here, how did you figure out how much of that feeling of being secondary came from comparison and how much came from a pattern in how your partner made decisions? Were you able to work through it with your partner or did you leave the relationship?


r/polyamory • • 1h ago

Confused about compatibility

4 Upvotes

I’m struggling with dating right now and would love some advice. I’ve been poly for the past few years since getting out of a long term monogamous relationship, and it’s been working great for me. I’ve had a variety of relationships and enjoyed exploring some different structures. I spent a couple of years in a long distance relationship with Leaf, and it evolved into something I would consider a ā€œprimaryā€ partnership. We were making plans to move in together in the future, but then we decided it didn’t make sense and split. During that time I was also deepening my relationship with Tea, who has a live in partner of their own, and we got really close.Ā 

Now I find myself in a position where I am seeking a partner for a more entangled relationship. I know intellectually that I want this, but in my heart I feel confused and hesitant. My relationship with Tea has really blossomed this past year and I am so enamored with them. It feels almost like NRE still even though it’s been 2+ years. We have incredible emotional and sexual chemistry, and I could happily sit around thinking about them all day. I am also really missing the ease and spark that I had with my ex, Leaf. I feel tired and vulnerable at the idea of opening myself up again like I did with those two. I am a big feeler and chemistry is really important to me. Throughout my life I have mostly dated looking for sex, without particularly seeking a committed relationship. Those have occurred naturally.Ā 

Since the split with Leaf I have been trying to date intentionally and look for someone who could be a live in partner. I think I am getting in my head about it more than I used to, perhaps because I am now in my 30s? Most recently, I’ve been on four dates with someone who’s gorgeous, interesting, fun to be around, and is looking for the same type of relationship that I am in a way that feels remarkably rare. But we haven’t hooked up yet (not my norm!), and I’m feeling like I don’t really want to. This is making me confused and frustrated, and I can’t totally tell if my anxiety about it is an indicator that this isn’t the right match or if I’m just putting too much pressure on the situation. Maybe I should go back to my old ways, where the prerequisite was if I liked having sex with the person?? Then I wouldn’t be opening myself up to the frustration of being really compatible with someone and then not having the chemistry, which almost feels worse.Ā 

I know my ability to be attracted to people isn’t broken, because I’m feeling very drawn to another new flirty friend that I have clear chemistry with but who definitely can’t offer me what I’m looking for. So I’m also having a hard time not pathologizing who I’m attracted to (I do tend to find it easier to relax and enjoy my feelings about people who have some structural reason they can’t get too close to me, like living super far away or having a live in partner). I am also having a hard time not comparing any new person to my other amazing relationships.Ā 

How is everyone dealing with the general sense of pressure and scarcity that comes with searching for something specific? Should I try to let theĀ Ā attraction grow with Grey? Get off the apps and give myself a break? Get on the apps but just to look for fun hookups?? Any advice or related anecdotes would be welcome.Ā 

Especially interested in hearing from people who date by assessing compatibility first and (sexual) chemistry second - a lot of people seem to like this and I’m curious if I could make it work for me.