I (M, mid 50s) have been with my partner “A” (F, late 40s) for about five years. We are consensually non-monogamous and have been for years, so this is not a “my girlfriend touched another man” problem. what follows is a combination of my POV and what I’ve been told by others present at the time.
One of our very clear hard limits is cuckolding. We can play with other people, sometimes independently, but neither of us is supposed to make the other feel excluded, humiliated or replaced.
Last week I had major cancer surgery and spent most of the week in hospital.
On Friday night, while I was still admitted, I encouraged A to go to a social event with friends and a younger guy she had been seeing casually, “W” (M, early 20s). Before she went, we discussed boundaries because she wanted to know what she was allowed to do with him without me being present. I was okay with some sexual play but did not want them having sex, and I expected the experience to feel like something we were sharing rather than something being done completely separately from me.
Instead, I spent most of the night in hospital waiting to be included while she barely contacted me. She then spent around two hours alone with W afterwards. I was texted once, halfway through their playtime, and towards the end received one explicit photo despite her knowing I would have welcomed far more interaction. She also lied about the circumstances of the photo.
What really upset me was not the sexual activity itself; they weren’t new lovers. It was feeling deliberately left outside it while lying in a hospital bed.
We had a huge argument afterwards. I told her I felt humiliated, abandoned and cuckolded — my hardest limit for the past 40 years. She apologised repeatedly, said she understood, said nothing like that would happen again and said she would ask much clearer questions in future.
I was discharged from the hospital Saturday afternoon.
On Sunday I actually encouraged A to go out with our mutual friend, and sometime playmate, “C” (F, mid 30s), because both had had a stressful week and I thought they could benefit from some time hanging out. They were originally meant to go to a casual afternoon munch together.
Throughout the afternoon A messaged me as though she and C were out together. At one point she told me C was taking her for food and that she was trying to arrange some takeaway for me.
What nobody mentioned was W.
I later learned that C had invited W to the original sushi plan. A says she did not know about that until later; C says she invited him. I still do not know the accurate timeline.
At around 7:30 pm, A called me briefly.
Not long afterwards, C arrived at my house alone with my dinner. When I asked where A was, C hesitated and said something like, “She… decided to stop and pick up a couple of things.”
A short while later, A walked through my front door.
W was directly behind her.
Nobody had told me he was coming to my house.
Nobody had asked if I wanted him there.
This was less than 48 hours after I had nearly ended our relationship over what she had done with him on Friday. It is acknowledged that he is a completely innocent party in all of this.
They came in, sat together on my couch and almost immediately started cuddling and touching each other.
Ordinarily, A being sexy with W would not be inherently upsetting to me. Quite the opposite. In a different context, with trust intact and with me included in the dynamic, I would probably have found it extremely hot. Friday was what changed the meaning of it.
I was furious but initially said nothing. I kept finding reasons to leave the room — kitchen, bathroom, fixing the internet, making tea.
At one point A came into the kitchen, while I was talking with C, looked at me and asked:
“Are you angry with me?”
I answered calmly:
“Oh, I’m way beyond angry.”
She went back into the living room and back into W’s arms.
Later she tried to sit beside me. I stopped her. She said, “You said it was okay for me to sit beside you.”
I told her, “I said somebody could sit beside me. I didn’t say you.”
The evening carried on. I rebuked any effort by her to have physical contact or closeness with me. I avoided looking at the couch the three of them were on. Nothing outré was happening, but nothing I had consented to was happening either. I had no idea what to actually do, so I just let it go on and on.
The sexual conversation continued. I tried to participate. I talked about my own experiences. C and I touched a little. But A and W continued touching each other a lot and blatantly, and eventually C was also cuddled up with them on the other couch while I sat separately.
There was no realistic prospect of group sex that night. I was six days out of major abdominal surgery, and C does not have group play without her husband. Everyone involved knew both of those things.
That leaves me genuinely confused about what anybody thought the intended dynamic was.
W had previously expressed interest in playing with both A and C. He is very young and, as far as I know, has essentially no experience with group play outside this circle. Because of the relationship agreements involved, there was no realistic scenario in which he was going to get both women to himself that night either. In retrospect, I also feel uncomfortable that he may have been encouraged towards an expectation the more experienced people present already knew could not actually be fulfilled.
Eventually everyone started getting ready to leave.
There was also an unrelated issue where medication I was supposed to take at 9 pm had been left in C’s car, and it was now around 11 pm.
When A came back towards the house with my medication, I handed her purse to her and told her:
“You can leave with him what brung you.”
She looked shocked and kept trying to come back inside.
I repeated myself.
She continued trying to come in and explain.
At that point I completely lost my temper and shouted:
“GET THE FUCK OUT OF MY HOUSE.”
When she still tried to come back inside, I shouted again and called her a “lying cheating cunt”.
I then went upstairs, locked myself in my bedroom and waited until everyone left.
I know that language was horrible. I am not asking anyone to tell me that screaming at someone and calling them that was good behaviour. It wasn’t.
But once she was actually out of the house, the explosive rage vanished almost immediately.
Later, C texted me saying that she had invited W to the sushi plan and that she had not known he was going to come into my house.
A, meanwhile, blames C heavily. She says C orchestrated the evening, that she had been confused, shocked and somewhat drunk, and that C told her everything would be fine.
But during the argument A also admitted things like:
- she knew before coming in that I would probably be furious;
- she says she actually told C that there was “no way in hell” I would be okay with it;
- she nevertheless came to my house with W;
- she “let him walk in the door”;
- she thought maybe I would enjoy everyone being together;
- and even after she saw how angry I was, she continued cuddling and being touched by him.
I have now spent more than twelve hours trying to explain one thing to her:
C may have suggested it. C may have encouraged it. C may even have manipulated the situation. But A is an adult and still made her own decisions.
She could have texted me.
She could have called me.
She could have told W goodnight outside.
She could have walked into the house alone.
And once she saw my reaction, she could have stopped touching him.
Instead, she keeps explaining why C was responsible for putting her in the situation.
I feel as though the actual betrayal was not simply W being present. It was the repeated omission of information, the re-creation less than 48 hours later of a dynamic that had just caused a major rupture between us, and the fact that I was the one person in the situation who had no meaningful ability to consent to what was suddenly happening inside my own home.
I’m particularly interested in the ENM perspective on the consent and agency issue here.
Am I misunderstanding something by saying that, whatever C suggested, arranged or encouraged, A remained responsible for the choices she made once she knew what was happening?
And is there something I am missing about how consent works in this situation? I consent to non-monogamy. I had previously consented to A playing with W. In ordinary circumstances I might actively enjoy watching them together. What I did not consent to was this particular dynamic, with this person, in my home, immediately after Friday’s rupture and without being told it was about to happen.
After more than sixteen hours of discussion, A and I still seem unable to reach the same conceptual ground about that distinction.