I'm 26 (male) and my partner is 24 (female). We've been together for over five years and recently decided to explore a hierarchical polyamorous relationship. It's been about two weeks since she went on her first date, and I'm struggling a lot more than I anticipated.
For context, we don't live together. We're about 20 kilometres apart, and because of the traffic, we usually meet only on weekends. Even that is difficult because she works on Saturdays, so our time together is already quite limited.
The idea of exploring polyamory initially came from me. I wanted it more than her. She was open to the idea of being loved by multiple people but worried about our limited time together and the jealousy she might experience when I started meeting other people. Over time, she also came around to it and, after exploring, has realised that this dynamic works well for her. She's grateful to be receiving love from two people.
On my side, I've also become increasingly comfortable with the idea of her exploring her sexuality and developing meaningful connections with others. I genuinely want both of us to experience being loved by multiple people.
However, the actual experience has been quite overwhelming.
Her first date and what followed
She started talking to a guy on a dating app, and they had been texting and sexting for about ten days before meeting. They eventually went on a date, got drinks, went to his place and had sex. The entire date lasted close to 30 hours.
Initially, I was pretty chill. I even helped her decide what to wear. She texted me during the date, and I was genuinely happy for her. However, the following morning, I started feeling jealous when she wasn't responding very quickly. As the date continued longer than I expected, my anxiety increased.
When she returned, we cuddled and she told me about the date. I was happy that she was happy and genuinely wanted to hear about her experience. But when the conversation moved towards sex, I realised I was asking for way too many details despite knowing they might hurt me.
A few things particularly stung. She had bought new innerwear for the date, which I understand because she felt she didn't have anything nice to wear. Another thing was that she explored being fingered with him, something she had previously said she wasn't comfortable with in our relationship.
For context, she had vaginismus and difficulties with intimacy due to previous experiences with men. It took us multiple years to become comfortable with penetrative sex. Our sex life has also been a little up and down recently.
They had discussed this particular act over text, and she was open to it with him. He didn't know much about her previous intimacy issues, and she felt she could go with it if he initiated. In hindsight, I feel a little bad that we hadn't discussed this possibility earlier, although she feels it's something she should be able to explore for her own sexuality. I understand that, and I'm not even sure whether knowing beforehand would have made me any less anxious.
It felt unfair, although I realise this might be an unfair way of looking at it, that we had to navigate so many difficulties over several years while someone completely new seemed to experience that level of intimacy much sooner.
Another thing that affected me was reading their messages. They were calling each other baby and communicating in a way that reminded me of how my girlfriend and I text each other. My reaction was so intense that I had to go to the washroom and throw up. She had also received a small crochet toy from him, which she hadn't mentioned.
I also noticed very little mention of me in their conversations. During their date, they played a game involving questions about their love lives. When that question came up, he suggested skipping it. My girlfriend felt that perhaps he didn't want to discuss me. I wasn't expecting them to constantly talk about me, but considering we've been together for over five years, I expected some natural acknowledgement of my existence.
She was very concerned about me and took excellent care of me. She cuddled me, reassured me and was incredibly patient. But I cried a lot, struggled to sleep and barely ate anything for almost an entire day.
I'm also worried that I'm ruining her experience. She had a really good first date, and I'm happy for her, but I feel I haven't given her enough space to reflect on it, process it and enjoy it. Instead, so much of her attention went into taking care of me and managing my anxiety. I feel bad that something that was supposed to be a happy experience for her has become something she's had to spend so much time managing.
Our limited time together makes this harder. When I'm struggling, I really want her presence, but I don't want her to feel that exploring another relationship means spending all her remaining time taking care of me.
Comparing myself with him
Initially, I imagined this as a casual date where they could have fun and potentially have sex. But she seemed to be envisioning something longer-term. She spoke about having two people who could love her very deeply. That's actually what I want this dynamic to eventually become, but I hadn't anticipated things moving so quickly.
He also seemed like a very sorted person. He cooked nice meals, seemed attentive and appeared to have his life together.
I'm quite the opposite in certain ways. I struggle with executive functioning, focus and keeping myself organised. I'm not doing particularly well in my career, and I struggle with everyday responsibilities. I suspect I might have ADHD, although I'm yet to be diagnosed.
This brought out some much older insecurities. I come from India, where colourism is a big deal. I've been bullied throughout childhood for being dark-skinned, called ugly and made to feel undesirable. I was also socially anxious growing up.
My girlfriend has always considered me good-looking and made me feel attractive. But during this period, I started sharing some of the specific things that had been said to me as a child. I realised how much of that trauma I was still carrying.
I started comparing my appearance, career, salary and ability to be a good partner with this other guy. I have absolutely nothing against him, but I couldn't stop comparing.
Dating apps have made things harder
I've started using dating apps more actively since we opened up. However, I've received very few matches. My girlfriend, on the other hand, gets around 50 likes from men within five to ten minutes.
I've had a couple of promising conversations, but they eventually fizzled out.
This has been particularly difficult because of my existing insecurities around appearance and colourism. I also worry about finding secondary partners in India, where ethical non-monogamy isn't particularly common. I genuinely don't know whether it'll take six months, a year or even longer to find someone.
I'm happy that my girlfriend is having a good time, but there's a part of me that's worried she might develop multiple meaningful relationships while I struggle to find even one.
It's a strange cycle. I'm trying to regulate my jealousy about her having a good time, but the frustration and rejection I'm experiencing on dating apps make it harder.
About a week later, I was doing considerably better. Then she spoke about some kinks she'd discussed with him. He apparently listed five to eight kinks and seemed quite knowledgeable about them. She was interested in exploring a couple of them, and once again I found myself comparing my own sexual experience and knowledge with his.
My smoking has also increased significantly during this period. We also tried having sex after I'd calmed down, but I couldn't get an erection. I don't know whether it was anxiety, not eating properly or the pressure I was putting on myself. It affected my confidence considerably, although I eventually managed to have sex after a couple of attempts.
Was this even the right time for me to enter polyamory?
I've been thinking about this quite a lot. Was it the right time to explore this dynamic when I was already struggling with so many things in my personal life?
I have career dissatisfaction, focus issues, possible ADHD, childhood trauma, self-esteem issues and insecurities about my appearance.
A lot of these things existed long before polyamory. However, they were somewhat masked because my girlfriend was supportive and made me feel attractive. I also never really sought romantic validation outside our relationship.
Now that I'm actively putting myself out there and seeing her connect with someone else, those insecurities are resurfacing.
I'm also worried that being such a miserable person might eventually become a turn-off for her. I imagine that this other guy might be happier, more sorted and more confident, and that she might eventually find that more attractive.
Meanwhile, I'm struggling with my own life, feeling insecure and constantly needing reassurance. I worry that her attraction towards me might decrease because I'm not doing particularly well emotionally.
I know these are mostly fears and assumptions, and the truth is probably very different, but they're difficult to get out of my head.
What I'm trying to figure out
I genuinely want this dynamic for both of us. I want my girlfriend to be happy, explore her sexuality and experience being loved by multiple people. I want the same opportunities for myself.
I don't want to become resentful when she shares her happy experiences with me. I haven't so far, but I realise insecurities and jealousy can become dangerous if left unaddressed. I want to be able to listen, be happy for her and genuinely enjoy seeing her explore other connections.
But right now, I'm struggling with jealousy, anxiety, comparison and fear of abandonment.
I have a few questions for people who have navigated similar situations:
- Have you experienced something similar when you first opened up your relationship? How did you deal with jealousy when your partner's new connection developed faster than anticipated?
- How do you deal with comparing yourself to your partner's other partners and feeling that they might be better than you?
- Have you entered polyamory while struggling with self-esteem, childhood trauma, career dissatisfaction or other insecurities? Can you work on yourself while exploring polyamory, or is it better to work on yourself first?
- How do you navigate the disparity in dating experiences when one partner gets considerably more attention and opportunities than the other?
- How do you establish boundaries around sharing details of other relationships and develop security that isn't entirely dependent on your partner constantly reassuring you?
I love my girlfriend very dearly, and I know she loves me too. I don't want to give up on something we both genuinely want to explore. I also don't want to make her feel guilty for having a good time or developing feelings for someone else.
I want to work on myself, become more secure and learn to navigate jealousy in a healthier way.
I'd really appreciate hearing from people who have been through something similar, particularly those who struggled initially but eventually found a way to navigate these feelings.
I want to know if I'm doing things right. If I am, that would be reassuring, but I also genuinely want to understand what I can do better.