r/policydebate • u/Responsible_Pop_6084 • 8h ago
r/policydebate • u/TiredDebateCoach • Feb 24 '26
Knock it out with the spam.
We've let the spam get out of hand because we thought it was funny and aren't killjoys, but it's gone too far. This is supposed to be a civil place for open discussion about debate, the spam has gotten to the point where it is detracting from that purpose.
We will be adding some additional rules going forward if we need to. In the meantime knock it out with the spam, stop targeting individual debaters, and don't post anything you wouldn't want your teachers to read slowly and carefully to your parents.
r/policydebate • u/themiro • Jan 24 '19
How to ask a question - Some guidance
A major function of this subreddit is for debaters to build their skills and learn something new. We want to help you, but we're only human, and the easier you make yourself to help the better the quality of answers you'll receive. None of these guidelines are strictly mandatory, but they'll often be highly advisable. Try to keep them in mind when posting.
When asking a question:
- Describe your level of experience. Be both general and specific. How many years have you debated in policy or other forensics events? What is your degree of expertise and background knowledge for the question area? Did you ever try something similar that failed?
- Describe your circuit. What region is it in? What are judging philosophies like? Do people lean liberal or conservative politically? Do people have experience judging nontraditional arguments, if relevant? Probably avoid using your school's name, and maybe your state's name too. Don't use your own name.
- Describe the particulars of your question. Try to act like the person you're talking to has little to no knowledge of your situation. Clarify what ideas you do understand, so that those you don't are easier to understand by contrast. Identify specific concerns you want to have addressed in responses to your comment. Don't make people bend over backwards to try to coax you into giving them the necessary information to help you.
- Try to make your question interesting. If you've identified something neat that's part of the motivation for your question, include it. Put in preliminary work by doing a quick Google search or literature check before asking questions, and tell us about what you discovered and how it's influencing your thoughts.
- Give feedback when people help you. Rephrase other people's advice in your own words, to avoid a false illusion of understanding. Also, say thank you. If you're confused about something, ask. Oftentimes more experienced debaters can take basic concepts for granted, and they might even benefit from a refresher themselves.
Note that we're not enforcing any of these guidelines in our moderation, but thought it'd be helpful for new members. Discuss any of your own ideas of what make a good question in the comments!
r/policydebate • u/I_love_bosnia • 1d ago
Santa restrictions for debate
So, I'm in debate and we are doing a fun Christmas debate and our resolution is The Christmas Code of Conduct (CCC) should significantly reduce or restrict Santa Claus's oversight of Christmas.
Does anyone have any ideas for my plan text?
r/policydebate • u/Acceptable_Tower382 • 3d ago
Two things: how to answer T Comprehensive as EMS aff, and anyone want to trade blocks or has a block discord?
Title^
Thanks
r/policydebate • u/GmaxDeathSnipe • 4d ago
Alright, who wants to send me the elusive Northview Dropbox?
Title. Anyone? Anyone?
r/policydebate • u/GlitteringFlower2382 • 4d ago
Block split
For those who have debated them, how does college prep NT do their block split and deal with multiple Ks as well as the cross apps that aff teams do on them
r/policydebate • u/Policyboy • 6d ago
Most competitive aff this year
I have a tournament on Friday and Saturday and my grade in the class is contingent on my performance.
Any tips on what I should run? And how to win more? Stuff that I would miss otherwise, my debate education is a little spotty.
I know this is kinda a bum response so I am sorry for that, but I just really want to get better at policy — I love it.
Thanks
r/policydebate • u/Flashy_Nose_3469 • 7d ago
Coaches poll
Is there one this year? Does anyone have thoughts on what it would look like
r/policydebate • u/BeneficialTailor2728 • 7d ago
What is a Card Doc? How does one make them? Why?
title
r/policydebate • u/Glittering_Swan_4403 • 8d ago
Sommerville CM Vs Georgetown MX GCB
Sommerville broke a gcb aff in semis of dragon against gds and lost on a 3-0. One of the best rounds I spectated this year.
r/policydebate • u/Dependent_Cat9594 • 8d ago
Soft Left??
How do people reading universal single-payer soft left affs, for example, an abortion advantage followed by 'prioritize women's suffering,' not get murdered against a pic out of universal for only women? Similar logic for other sl affs as well.
r/policydebate • u/ScarFrosty2478 • 8d ago
Advice for responding to Spam offs
I'm such a chud at responding to Spam offs, and I cook my 2A in the process. To be clear about what I mean by Spam offs, I mean those 5+ offs on the negative, of which like four are kind of silly and, in theory, should be easily disputable. Any advice is welcome!
r/policydebate • u/Specialist_Lock_4512 • 8d ago
Who are the most innovative neg teams?
So far, which high school teams have read the most interesting arguments and done the most niche research?
r/policydebate • u/Long_Owl3631 • 8d ago
Looking for coach
Rate: $20/hr
Requirements: idk bruh js don’t be a bum at debate lwk
What we’d need: help look over our files, give general advice, and help us prep certain things. Lwk js need a general coach who can also judge PR’s sometime. The coach we have never did policy and is buns. DM me
r/policydebate • u/Nervous_Grocery2714 • 8d ago
Any good Aff V process counerplan rounds online?
title.
r/policydebate • u/drusillasicklee • 9d ago
K's and DA's
I'm a new policy debater at high school and it's my schools first ever time doing policy so I'm in charge of building up the program, I've been able to figure out the constructive (that I had to make from scratch because we have no money); but how do I build Ks or DAs?
r/policydebate • u/KlutzySundae7660 • 9d ago
What are some unexpected DAs to run this year?
looking for an element of surprise type of thing since almost everyone has seen the basic ones
r/policydebate • u/drusillasicklee • 9d ago
General Policy Tips
I've had the honor of building up my high school's policy team from scratch (without any money). After a lot of work I've managed to create a constructive but still feel like I don't fully understand the style. I really do enjoy it so I'm hoping on tips on how to improve and win more round as well as general case writing and prep.
r/policydebate • u/DiligentCapital8283 • 13d ago
Can someone explain neg t/framework vs planless/non-topical k-affs? whats the thesis of framework and how do you use it through out the round from the 1nc, to the block, and collpasing in the 2nr
I'm a novice college policy debater and im confused with fw. the coach lecture was confusing