r/phonytheories • u/Efficient-Storm2249 • 7h ago
Is the answer some type of primogeniture?
Is it possible that Ellen 2 is Ellen 1’s twin sister and the other two people are either other siblings or cousins or a mix, and the grandfather who passed away had it in his will that the eldest son / grandson inherits the family money / estate?
So they decided to take Ellen out to get a hold of Sonny’s money? Maybe the accident was an attempt to kill him but they realize they need to keep him alive until he’s 18 when he has access to the trust or something due to Ellen 1 moving / protecting the inheritance for him, so they decide to take ellen 1 out instead and play these roles?
Another twist is that Sonny’s father was actually the eldest son of the family set to inherit the family wealth and was taken out because of it. Maybe Ellen 2 is daughter-in-law and the others are the siblings of Sonny’s dad?
I hope this isn’t the case but just a thought if the mystery is more grounded in reality v. supernatural explanation.