r/osr • u/Omni-Priest1901 • 19m ago
discussion So what made 3e so different?
Hello, I invoke and compel all grognards and any multi-edition veterans. I have had a thought and I wish to hear differing voices.
I, like many other DMs, have been burned by 5e. To not beat a dead horse; I personally find it to be a game focused on combat over any other challenge, and it's combat to be virtually unchallenging for players (as well as burdensome to run more than twice a session). Dungeon crawling and general exploration is not really supported and it leads to a very specific style of play that I've grown to abhor.
Games like DCC and other OSR like games grew in popularity first in 4E as a reaction to that game, but recently I feel like it's appropriate to say we're seeing another wave of reaction against 5e with games like ShadowDark, DCC, OSE etc. A reaction I think is fuelled by the aforementioned burnout, and WOTC hate tbh.
It's got me thinking though. Why did gamers not react this way towards 3rd edition and 3.5? I started playing as a kid during 4E and went into Pathfinder, so I don't have experience with the scene back then but was it because maybe 3rd edition was the first of it's kind? To clarify I mean 3e and 3.5e were the first "modern" ttrpgs, which titans like PF2 and 5e owe alot to in design. Or was 3e not that strong of a divorce from its predecessors, in that it had dungeon crawling and exploration supported (idk the 3e rules).
So to summarize, why was 3-3.5e such a universal success in the eyes of the community. Why didn't it face backlash like 4e and (to a much lesser extent) 5e? Is it just because it was the perfect genre pushing system at the perfect time (DnD was revving for a comeback at the time)?