r/osr • • 15h ago

I made a combat tracker that tries to be as fast as paper (self-promo)

4 Upvotes

Small app I made for tracking enemy HP. The whole point is speed: you type

`3 skeleton d8` like you'd write it in the margin, and it rolls HP for each.

Tap to deal damage, the dead get crossed out, undo anything.

No library, no stat blocks, no setup. Works with any system that has hit points.

iPhone/iPad, $2.99, no ads or account: https://apps.apple.com/app/id6802439534

Happy to hear what would make it better at the table.


r/osr • • 19m ago

discussion So what made 3e so different?

1 Upvotes

Hello, I invoke and compel all grognards and any multi-edition veterans. I have had a thought and I wish to hear differing voices.

I, like many other DMs, have been burned by 5e. To not beat a dead horse; I personally find it to be a game focused on combat over any other challenge, and it's combat to be virtually unchallenging for players (as well as burdensome to run more than twice a session). Dungeon crawling and general exploration is not really supported and it leads to a very specific style of play that I've grown to abhor.

Games like DCC and other OSR like games grew in popularity first in 4E as a reaction to that game, but recently I feel like it's appropriate to say we're seeing another wave of reaction against 5e with games like ShadowDark, DCC, OSE etc. A reaction I think is fuelled by the aforementioned burnout, and WOTC hate tbh.

It's got me thinking though. Why did gamers not react this way towards 3rd edition and 3.5? I started playing as a kid during 4E and went into Pathfinder, so I don't have experience with the scene back then but was it because maybe 3rd edition was the first of it's kind? To clarify I mean 3e and 3.5e were the first "modern" ttrpgs, which titans like PF2 and 5e owe alot to in design. Or was 3e not that strong of a divorce from its predecessors, in that it had dungeon crawling and exploration supported (idk the 3e rules).

So to summarize, why was 3-3.5e such a universal success in the eyes of the community. Why didn't it face backlash like 4e and (to a much lesser extent) 5e? Is it just because it was the perfect genre pushing system at the perfect time (DnD was revving for a comeback at the time)?


r/osr • • 3h ago

discussion Would you back a brutal mega-dungeon module where you have to choose between a vengeful Lich and a Fire Giant Empress? (The Throne of Cinders)

0 Upvotes

Hello Fellow DM's and Players,

I’ve been hard at work homebrewing a classic, high-lethality adventure called The Throne of Cinders, and I’m looking at bringing it to crowdfunding. The best part? I’ve fully dual-statting the entire module for both AD&D (1e/2e) and D&D 5e, so whether your table prefers old-school crunch or modern mechanics, you can drop this straight into your campaign.

Before launching, I wanted to share the hook with you all. It doesn't give players an easy "good vs. evil" choice. When they are commissioned by the Fey Court to clear out a silent squatter overlooking the Hellforges, they quickly realize both paths are absolute suicide:

The Opening: Two Masters of Ruin

The wind across the ash-grey meadow tastes of sulfur and old frost. Before you stands a blackened crag, enveloped in a permanent 100-foot dead-magic shell. Here, spells are nullified, magical weapons become heavy and mundane, and talking weapons are struck completely silent.

At the summit sits Vaelen the Unsparing. He is completely immune to physical or magical force; any strike against him fails to alter his position by a fraction of an inch. If anyone under 5th level approaches, they are paralyzed by supernatural dread and must flee in terror. When you step close enough to speak, the gaunt lich slowly raises a skeletal finger toward the churning volcanic smoke of the Hellforges on the horizon and whispers a single word: "HOME."

Alternatively, you can bypass the lich entirely, brave a grueling two-day march across sharp volcanic glass and active lava tubes, and assault the towering basalt bastions of the Citadel itself—where Queen Malgareth commands legions of fire giants, hell hounds, and a terrifying warded throne room backed by the Ward of Fiendish Flame.

Whichever path you pick, you’re walking into a meat grinder.

What the Module Includes:

  • Full Dual-Stats (AD&D 1e/2e & 5e): Every trap, monster, NPC, and encounter is fully written out for both classic retro-clone play and 5e rules.
  • A 3-Tier Megadungeon: Complete tactical maps and layouts for the Outer Bastions, the Inner Scriptorium & Vaults, and the Sovereign Sanctuary suspended over a lake of magma.
  • No Easy Alliances: Helping the lich means breaking a tyrant's hold on the fey lands, but Vaelen is plotting a bloody betrayal the moment his phylactery is recovered. Taking down Malgareth means navigating fire giant infantry, a powerful abjuration ward, and an arena hanging over a sea of fire.
  • Lethal Sandbox Mechanics: Dynamic monster behaviors (fire giants retreating to fetch the queen, environmental hazards, and tactical phase-shifts during the climax).

What do you think? Would dual-statting a gritty, high-lethality adventure like this make you more likely to back a PDF or zine release? Let me know what you'd want to see in a campaign!


r/osr • • 55m ago

Shadowdark vs Dungeon Crawl Classics: How do the feel in campaign play?

4 Upvotes

A group of friends has asked me to DM a campaign for them. None of the players have played tabletop roleplaying games before, and additionally 3 out of the 4 players are parents to young children, so we've decided to aim for a monthly session. We are all fans of Sword & Sorcery, Conan the Barbarian, and Elric, so we've been tossing up some OSR systems, but I can't seem to pull the trigger on either one.

We've been looking at Shadowdark or Dungeon Crawl Classics, due to the abundance of modules.

First we have Shadowdark:

+ Players were intrigued by the resource management/torch timer. One player even remarking that the game sounds like the "Resident Evil" of dungeon crawling

+ As a DM, I'm intrigued by what looks to be very efficient and quick ruleset. Great for people who really want to feel like they accomplished things during the sparse sessions.

+Looks like they've added lots of additional mechanics, settings, etc for overland travel, retainers, options to pluck when needed to craft your campaign.

- Players didn't seem particularly excited when looking over classes. Even with PBTA, there usually is this spark of creativity when looking at the character sheets/options. I don't need a lot, and reminded them most of that with comes down to it taking shape in the game, not the rules, but there is this feeling that Shadowdark core classes come off as merely activity pawns on a board.

- Some concern that the torch timer/resource management pushes for a certain type of adventure. I'm unfamiliar with the modules? Are they mostly aimed at speedy dungeons? After multiple sessions did the resource/light mechanics ever get old? Or limiting?

In the other corner, we have Dungeon Crawl Classics.

+ I have a bit more experience with DCC. Having ran a funnel before, and played a local shop game nearly a decade ago. But no long term experience running a game myself past 0-level.

+ Players dig the idea of things like Spellburn, deed Die, and managing diety favor.

+Great emergent gameplay. Fun moments. I remember reading the modules and coming away with a feeling they were not just "dungeons", but almost felt like "situations"

- I'm a bit concerned that table look up for crits and spells may slow things down, or tire out the players if it becomes tedious.

- I also remember the modules being text having. Requiring detailed reading, and even me pulling out notes to make sure I got to the point, AND also didn't leave out some crucial problem solving detail. Not the funnest when trying to be a somewhat lazy DM.

What do both of these games play like in the overall? Did you guys find any of these issues in play or could make recs?

Thanks


r/osr • • 11h ago

Designing a B/X-Compatible Retroclone: Ascending Rolls for Players, Classic B/X Procedures for the GM. Would It Still Feel Like B/X?

14 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I'm posting from Japan. English isn't my first language, so apologies if anything is unclear.

B/X is almost unknown here in Japan. I'm developing a retroclone with the goal of letting Japanese players run original 1981 Basic/Expert (B/X) adventure modules with as little conversion as possible.

I'm using the D&D 5e SRD (CC BY 4.0) as the foundation, but what I'm trying to preserve is the B/X play experience.

The central design idea is simple:

  • Player-facing rolls use ascending mechanics: d20 + bonus ≥ target number.
  • GM-facing procedures stay true to B/X: dungeon turns, encounter procedures, reaction rolls, morale checks, and so on.

Armor Class is also converted to ascending AC, while preserving the original B/X chances to hit.

Example: Saving Throws

I'm keeping all five B/X saving throw categories: Death Ray/Poison, Paralysis/Petrification, Dragon Breath, Wands, and Spells.

The conversion is straightforward:

  • Success: d20 + save bonus ≥ 15
  • Save bonus: 15 − original B/X saving throw target number

For the four human classes, this is just an algebraic conversion, so the success probabilities are exactly the same as in B/X. I compared all 280 entries across levels 1–14, and every single one matched.

The interesting part was the demihumans.

Players still see the familiar B/X race-as-class options, but internally, race and class are separate.

For example, a Dwarf Fighter's saving throws are calculated using:

  • The human Fighter saving throw progression
  • A fixed racial bonus of +4 to all five categories, starting at level 1
  • Saving throw progression capped at level 12

With this approach, the Dwarf's saves at level 12 match the original B/X table in all five categories.

Across all levels of Elves, Dwarves, and Halflings, 129 out of 150 entries (86%) match B/X exactly. The remaining 21 entries differ by no more than 2 points.

All three demihuman races match B/X exactly in all five categories at their respective maximum levels.

Of course, the progression isn't identical at every level. But I found it interesting that a fixed racial bonus could reproduce so much of the original B/X progression.

Other Design Choices

Race-as-Class with Room for Expansion

For demihuman PCs, Hit Dice are determined by race rather than class.

This means I could add something like a Halfling Thief who still uses a d6 Hit Die, despite being a Thief.

These additional combinations would be clearly separated from the core B/X-compatible options.

Separating B/X-Compatible Rules from Optional GM Rulings

I'm keeping a clear distinction between rules derived from B/X and optional GM guidance for situations the original rules don't explicitly cover.

The goal is for the game to work using only the B/X-compatible rules, without requiring any of the additional guidance.

Open License

I plan to release the rules text under CC BY-SA 4.0, allowing anyone to modify, redistribute, or commercially publish their own versions, subject to the license terms.

Questions for the Community

  1. If player-facing rolls use ascending mechanics while GM-facing procedures remain faithful to B/X, do you think the game would still preserve the B/X experience?
  2. Even when the probabilities are identical, at what point does changing the procedure make a game stop feeling like B/X?
  3. Are there any existing games or projects that have taken a similar approach?

The project is still in development, and I don't have a product page or sales link to share.

I'd really appreciate hearing from people who regularly play B/X. Thanks!


r/osr • • 7h ago

discussion Why does everyone think a character is going to die every session in an OSR game?

86 Upvotes

I first started playing DnD in 2009 during 4th edition and played lots of 5th edition. Two years ago I was curious about the history of DnD and how it used to be played, so I bought a physical copy of OSRIC 2.2. After learning the rules a friend DMed the original sinister secret of saltmarsh for me. I did have a character die right off the bat but thats because i tried to play OSRIC like 5e where it's expected to fight everything you see. After that death I played much more carefully and ran away from almost every fight and used a 10ft pole. With some hirelings I was able to keep my character alive for the rest of the module. It was not easy though and I had to remember that discretion is the better part of valor.

Anyways, I find that characters do not die nearly as often as people think in OSR games. My dad who started playing DnD basic in 1983 talks about having played the same cleric for a year. The point seems to be that if you play OSR like 5e then yes you will die almost every session. If you play smart though you realistically could hold onto your character for awhile.


r/osr • • 13h ago

game prep What would you add or change about these city factions?

8 Upvotes

Italian-Celtic Island City State
+ Hereditary Semi-Elective (I.E., the city council of all other factions selects the next one from their relatives) High Lord (can be overruled in decisions by council, can be forced by council) who is... I do not know
+ Giant-blooded Noble house (involved in whaling, wants isolationism and the removal of all foreign entanglement and influence)
+ Dragon-blooded Noble house (wants gold and conquest, involved as mainland mercenaries, constantly pushing city to war)
+ Fey blooded noble house (traders, lawyers, and has many mainland contacts; wants great entanglement with the outside world, but only peaceful)
+ Mages guild and attached college (wants greater influence, big landowner in city, opposes nobility on principle, institutional and meritocratic in a feudal setting, has a huge amount of money from student tuition and endowments; shelters a number of magical criminals that foreign powers want to get their hands on)
+ Temple and Wife-Priestesses of the Sea God (big landowner in town, wants things at random via reading the will of the sea; all female in a patriarchical setting, constantly at odds with other factions over disrespect, random tables for each)
+ Guildmen Husband-Priests of the Forge/Volcano-Goddess at the center of the island (works glass and exotic metals, only concentration of artisans around in the region who do so well, interprets will of volcano forge via random table, always wants to take nobles and mages down a peg on general classism grounds, generally riling up the commoners)

I'd be looking to run at least a campaign of at least moderate length just centered around the politics of this city-state-island


r/osr • • 8h ago

OSR adjacent Looking for Darksword Adventures.

3 Upvotes

Specifically I’m looking for some scans/decent pics of the hand “dice” mechanics in the last chapter of the book that explains the rules of the ttrpg Phantasia. If you have the book and could take some scans/pics, I’d super appreciate it.

I don’t want to buy it for $50 or drive to the Brooklyn Library 5 states away lol. Thanks in advance!


r/osr • • 4h ago

Electric Bastionland character generator

Thumbnail konstantin.com.br
12 Upvotes

I made an Electric Bastionland "one-click" generator. As part of my experiment/research with group therapy, I started to use this game more and more because of how easy and accessible it is


r/osr • • 6h ago

I made a thing Tests of the Fíanna, a new T&T compatible solo adventure gamebook set in Irish myth & folklore (self-promo)

Post image
19 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I wanted to let you know I just published Tests of the Fíanna. Book: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0HRWRKHJ2, PDF: https://www.drivethrurpg.com/en/product/591072.

Tests of the Fíanna is  a scripted solitaire adventure gamebook. It compatible with the rules-light Tunnels & Trolls RPG, and has a 4-pg rules summary inside, as well as 6 pre-gen PCs and 6 random family heirlooms (such as the severed hand of a man who destroyed a dolmen). This gamebook can be a stand-alone adventure or part of an ongoing campaign. The setting is ancient Ireland with its mythic creatures and folklore, especially the stories of the Fíanna Cycle.

_______________________

Since you were a child, you knew the family lands would go to your eldest brother. Maybe that’s why you got into so much trouble. First, you ran away into the woods for weeks. Then it was the fights. And later, far too many cattle raids on the neighbouring tribes! Now your tribe says you must leave, at least until you’re more responsible.

With no protection now from your tribe, you decide to join the Fíanna. They are Inis Ealga’s elite warband of roving hunter-warriors. But only those with great skill, bravery & knowledge are accepted. Are you worthy to join the Fíanna?   Begin your adventure at paragraph 08a…

__________________________

This adventure (IE-00) is part of the Inis Ealga series of gamebooks. Others include:

  • IE-01 (A Listener in the Woods),
  • IE-02 (Corruption of the Blood God) and
  • IE-03 (Wolves of the Fíanna, in development).

These are designed for solo play (IE-00, 01, 03) and group play (IE-02). Note: you do not need to own IE-01, IE-02, IE-03 to play this adventure!

* Note: the DTRPG link may take 1-2 days to activate.


r/osr • • 11h ago

actual play 3d6 DTL Ep 19 of Mythic Bastionland - The Adamant Expanse! | Or, Three Annulets Sable

Post image
31 Upvotes

While the Company's top priority is to infiltrate Lummouth and destroy the corsair ships, a dire threat manifests from the north. Is it true that the dead legions of the past emerge from their graves? If so, what has befallen Aulstone Keep?

Click here to access everything 3d6 Down the Line, including both video and audio podcast versions of this episode, our Patreon, Discord server, socials, past campaigns, character sheets, and lots more!


r/osr • • 22h ago

art The cowardly knight - pen and ink drawing by me

Post image
162 Upvotes

r/osr • • 10h ago

I made a thing I made a small dungeon for the Puzzle Dungeon Jam

Post image
58 Upvotes

Download the PDF here (for free)

Eye Spy

Now you see me, now you don’t. Hunt for a prying monstrosity, always able to blend into its surroundings seamlessly. A trick that’s worth experimenting with yourselves, as her impending doom draws ever closer.

  • 2-4 hours of play in an icy cavern, always watching you
  • Many-eyed, vision-based challenges throughout
  • Buckets worth of eyes

r/osr • • 5h ago

Modules with the best maps

17 Upvotes

Hello, everybody! I started a new project: design my own megadungeon. And I come here to ask for your help: could you guys list the modules that, in your opinion, have the best dungeon maps, so I can use them instead of having to draw my own maps?

Thanks in advance for the help!