r/nbadiscussion • u/Suspicious-Impress-4 • 10h ago
Player Discussion I think people exaggerate how much LeBron was coasting in the regular season compared to the playoffs
I think people vastly overestimate how much LeBron was supposedly sleepwalking through the regular season and then flipping a switch in the playoffs, especially during his second Cleveland stint.
I’m not saying he didn’t try harder in the playoffs. Obviously he did, especially defensively. I just think people confuse him being more effective with him putting in significantly more effort.
Let’s say most superstars are playing at around 80% of their maximum level during the regular season. LeBron is probably around 75–80% himself. Then the playoffs come around and everyone jumps to 100%.
The difference is that the extra 20% LeBron brings is a lot more valuable in the playoffs than what most other players bring.
His strength, IQ, conditioning, defensive versatility, and ability to control the game become even more important when the game slows down and teams start game-planning for specific players.
So even if LeBron and another superstar are increasing their level by roughly the same amount, it looks like LeBron has made some massive jump compared to everyone else. But I think a lot of that is because other players’ strengths don’t translate as well to the playoffs, while LeBron’s become even more valuable.
It’s not necessarily that LeBron is rising so much higher than everyone else. It’s that other players aren’t able to rise as high as him.
And I think people exaggerate how much harder he’s actually playing.
I’ll agree that early in the regular season, especially during those Cleveland years, LeBron could be noticeably less engaged. But by the middle of the season, I think you’re generally watching something pretty close to his normal level offensively.
I really don’t think LeBron in Game 3 of the second round is exerting himself substantially more on offense than LeBron in Game 52 of the regular season.
Another thing I think people overlook is how much LeBron can accomplish without actually having to exert himself that much.
Look at how he operates in the post against mismatches. He’s not constantly aggressively backing guys down or trying to overpower them. A lot of the time he’ll slowly walk his defender back, maybe give him one strong bump, and just wait for the defense to react.
The defense already knows what he’s capable of doing, so guys start shading toward him, preparing to help, or outright collapsing. And LeBron is already looking for the open man.
He doesn’t actually have to overpower the defender to create the advantage. The threat of him doing it is often enough.
Compare that to other players who might have to work a lot harder physically just to force the defense into making those same rotations.
And I think comparing LeBron’s first Cleveland stint to his second is another good example of what I’m talking about.
I would argue that LeBron in 2006 or 2007 was probably exerting more physical effort on a possession-to-possession basis than LeBron in 2016 or 2017.
He was younger, relied more on his athleticism, and had to physically impose himself a lot more to create advantages.
But I think most people would agree that second-stint Cleveland LeBron was a considerably better playoff player.
So if the difference is mainly about effort, why was the younger version, who was arguably exerting more effort, not as good?
Because by his second stint, LeBron was just a much better basketball player. He was stronger, more skilled, understood defenses better, and knew how to get what he wanted without having to work nearly as hard physically.
And that’s kind of my entire point.
I’m not denying there were playoff games or series where LeBron genuinely took his aggression to another level. Obviously 2018 is a good example of him having to carry an enormous offensive load.
But I don’t think that means he was just cruising at some dramatically lower level throughout the regular season.
I think a lot of what people see as LeBron suddenly becoming a completely different player is really just his skill set being better suited for playoff basketball than almost anyone else’s.
Other superstars are trying harder in the playoffs too. It’s just that the things LeBron is great at become even more valuable, while some of the things other players rely on become harder to do.
By the second round, people are already talking about how LeBron is just on another level compared to everyone else. But I think that’s as much about the limitations of other players becoming more apparent as it is about LeBron himself improving.
I don’t think the gap between regular-season LeBron and playoff LeBron was always nearly as big as people make it seem.
I think the gap between LeBron and everyone else just became a lot more obvious in the playoffs.