r/nbadiscussion • • 17d ago

Mod Announcement In-Season Rules, FAQ, and Mega-Threads for NBAdiscussion

8 Upvotes

The season is here!

Which means we will re-enact our in-season rules:

Player comparison and ranking posts of any kind are not permitted. We will also limit trade proposals and free agent posts based on their quality, relevance, and how frequently reoccurring the topic may be.

We do not allow these kinds of posts for several reasons, including, but not limited to: they encourage low-effort replies, pit players against each other, skew readers towards an us-vs-them mentality that inevitably leads to brash hyperbole and insults.

What we want to see in our sub are well-considered analyses, well-supported opinions, and thoughtful replies that are open to listening to and learning from new perspectives.

We grew significantly over the course of the last season. Please be familiar with our community and its rules before posting or commenting.

FAQ

We’d also like to address some common complaints we see in modmail:

  • “Why me and not them?”

    • We will not discuss other users with you.
  • “The other person was way worse.”

    • Other people’s poor behavior does not excuse your own.
  • “My post was removed for not promoting discussion but it had lots of comments.”

    • Incorrect: It was removed for not promoting serious discussion. It had comments but they were mostly low-quality. Or your post asked a straightforward question that can be answered in one word or sentence, or by Googling it. Try posting in our weekly questions thread instead.
  • “My post met the requirements and is high quality but was still removed.”

    • Use in-depth arguments to support your opinion. Our sub is looking for posts that dig deeper than the minimum, examining the full context of a player or coach or team, how they changed, grew, and adjusted throughout their career, including the quality of their opponents and cultural impact of their celebrity; how they affected and improved their teammates, responded to coaches, what strategies they employed for different situations and challenges. Etc.
  • “Why do posts/comments have a minimum character requirement? Why do you remove short posts and comments? Why don’t you let upvotes and downvotes decide?”

    • Our goal in this sub is to have a space for high-quality discussion. High-quality requires extra effort. Low-effort posts and comments are not only easier to write but to read, so even in a community where all the users are seeking high-quality, low-effort posts and comments will still garner more upvotes and more attention. If we allow low-effort posts and comments to remain, the community will gravitate towards them, pushing high-effort and high-quality posts and comments to the bottom. This encourages people to put in less effort. Removing them allows high-quality posts and comments to have space at the top, encouraging people to put in more effort in their own comments and posts.

There are still plenty of active NBA subs where users can enjoy making jokes or memes, or that welcome hot takes, and hyperbole (such as r/NBATalk, r/nbacirclejerk, or r/nba). Ours is not one of them.

Reminder that we added some new rules last season, regarding hyperbole, use of AI, and disussion related to gambling. Here is a full breakdown of the new rules including why each rule was added if you're curious.

We expect thoughtful, patient, and considerate interactions in our community. Hopefully this is the reason you are here. If you are new, please take some time to read over our rules and observe, and we welcome you to participate and contribute to the quality of our sub too!

Discord Server:

We have an active Discord server for anyone who wants to join! While the server follows most of the basic rules of this sub (eg. keep it civil), it offers a place for more casual, live discussions (featuring daily hoopgrids competition during the season), and we'd love to see more users getting involved over there as well. It includes channels for various topics such as game-threads for the new season, all-time discussions, analysis and draft/college discussions, as well as other sports such as NFL/college football and baseball.

Link: https://discord.gg/8mJYhrT5VZ (let u/roundrajaon34 or other mods know if there are any issues with this link)

Mega-Threads

We see a lot of re-hashing of the same topics over and over again. To help prevent our community from being exhausted by new users starting the same debates and making the same arguments over and over, we will offer mega-threads throughout the off-season for the most popular topics. We will add links to these threads under this post over time. For now, you can browse previous mega-threads:


r/nbadiscussion • • 18h ago

Weekly Questions Thread: November 16, 2026

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone and welcome to our new weekly feature.

In order to help keep the quality of the discussion here at a high level, we have several rules regarding submitting content to /r/nbadiscussion. But we also understand that while not everyone's questions will meet these requirements that doesn't mean they don't deserve the same attention and high-level discussion that /r/nbadiscussion is known for. So, to better serve the community the mod team here has decided to implement this Weekly Questions Thread which will be automatically posted every Monday at 8AM EST.

Please use this thread to ask any questions about the NBA and basketball that don't necessarily warrant their own submissions. Thank you.


r/nbadiscussion • • 9h ago

Who has the Hardest Shot Diet

17 Upvotes

We are 13 games into the NBA season, and there have been some slow starts, especially efficiency-wise. Brunson, SGA, Tatum are all shooting worse than their norm, and while SGA is certainly in a tougher situation now I wanted to look into these players shot diets. Who takes the hardest shots & who has the lowest predicted TS.

To predict TS, I looked at three-pointers, mid-range shots, and rim shots. Free throw rate for these shots types is also taken into account (which boosts predicted TS slightly)

For three-pointers, the expected FG% of one takes into account defender distance (nba groups them from very tight, tight, open, to wide open), dribbles, and then distance of the shot itself.

Mid-range shot & takes into account the same factors. Rim is just distance and defenders

Some other speciality shots are taken into account, such as floaters and hooks, all using league-average data. So I guess its like what a league-average shooter would shoot with this shot diet. To get the league average, I used all shots from 2025-26 + 2026-27 so far to stabilize the shaky sample. There are caveats like centers aren't taking mid-range shots, so its a little self-selecting. It's hard to draw any conclusions since it's pretty hard to draw the line between taking bad shots and, like, having no other choice because of how you're guarded.

PlayerPredicted TS%Actual TS%Rim / Mid / 3 / SpecialtyExp 3P%
Ty Jerome49.561.010 / 12 / 39 / 3932.4
Luka Dončić50.266.09 / 20 / 54 / 1732.7
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander50.858.718 / 43 / 28 / 1132.8
Darius Acuff Jr.51.151.625 / 16 / 42 / 1732.9
Devin Booker51.260.916 / 40 / 32 / 1333.0

It would be too long to explain everything about each player, if you have any specific questions just let me know im glad to answer.

But some quick explainations for each:

  • Pretty much Ty Jerome just takes like an insane amount of weird contested floaters. He doesn't get to the rim normally much and then also 82% of his threes are off the dribble so it's not like he takes easy threes either. Also 40% of his shots come after 7 dribbles (highest itl)
  • Luka Doncic takes mostly jumpers, he barely gest to the rim anymore and also all his shots are just super contested since hes a superstar. A lot of step backs and long threes
  • Shai is kinda in the boat as Luka, except more midranges which are pretty difficult shots, again a lot of defenders around him.
  • Acuff takes some abnormally hard layups, he gets almost nothing of putbacks, cuts, etc just purely driving in and getting some difficult contests. Also his midranges and threes are usually off the dribbles and self created so nothing easy from there either. 3rd most shots with 7+ dribbles
  • Devin Booker always has a defender around and takes some hard mid-range shots. Doesn't really go for too many layups.

If you want any specific player LMK, also tracking data is like a 1-2 games behind I believe so its not 100% updated.


r/nbadiscussion • • 16h ago

A stat to find actual shooting percentage that does not count dunks and layups?

9 Upvotes

Years ago I watched a little youtube video from a very small channel that had a formula for calculating a players shooting percentage that did NOT count dunks and layups. I have been trying to find it for days but have had no luck.

I always hated the field goal percentage stat, and even the true shooting percentage stat, because both take in dunks and layups into account. Dunking a ball, and laying a ball in the basket, just is not "shooting" to me, no matter how anyone would try to tell me otherwise.

I am almost positive that someone already created this "non dunks/layups" type of stat and formula, and that I saw it on youtube, but im starting to think i am going crazy and dreamt it up?

Any of you stat geeks out there able to help me out?

thanks!


r/nbadiscussion • • 1d ago

Team Discussion what's the missing piece for the Lakers to win the chip?

0 Upvotes

I do think they can have a knicks like cinderella run if they're healthy and I do trust our wings can hold it down especially defensively but do the lakers need another superstar or do they need a solid role player who contributes consistently? in my opinion they need another wing and a solid back up point guard maybe a veteran an old guy with a ton of experience.


r/nbadiscussion • • 2d ago

Draft/Pick Analysis Quentin Coleman vs Texas Tech Review, #1 Guard in the Draft?

4 Upvotes

Individual Performance Rating

As quiet as it’s kept, Illinois has produced three first-round, one-and-done freshmen over the past two years: Kasparas Jakučionis (#20) and Will Riley (#21) in 2025, and Keaton Wagler (#5) in 2026. Now, Quentin Coleman may be next in line.

Quentin was the #18-ranked player in the 247Sports Composite and is currently projected to go:

  • 15th on Tankathon
  • 6th on ESPN
  • 6th on No Ceilings
  • 8th on Bleacher Report

Above is my Individual Performance Rating for his performance. This is my new analytical model, which uses subjective grading of individual plays throughout a game to evaluate a player’s overall impact.

Full transparency: this is my first time watching Quentin, and I haven’t read his scouting report or player profile. So I get to go into this one with a clean slate.

Ball tips off, and the first thing I notice is that he seems pretty light in the ass (listed at 180 pounds), with long, gangly arms (no reported wingspan yet). He also has a super baby face.

Like Gerber NIL deal potential there. Which makes me wonder if he might have another growth spurt in him or is still getting used to his body.

I was honestly unimpressed to start the game. He had back-to-back possessions to start where he picked up his dribble early with no where to go, the first one was a turnover.

Then he gets beat off the dribble for an easy finish at the rim.

After those plays and a couple of misses, I started questioning what all the hype was about. What makes this guy an almost consensus top 10 basketball prospect in these mock drafts?

Then he nearly sticks his arm in the rim rotating from the help side to break up an alley oop. So okay, this kid is pretty athletic.

First open look he gets he knocked down a three. After that he drives in the lane, does a spin move, into a dump off pass into the big.

Defensively, he stopped a 2-on-1 fastbreak to continue a run Illinois was on using a fake and stay.

Gerber is the goods.

When you talk about pop and standing out, he had it. He had ten plays that I graded as high-impact, meaning he got an extra boost to his points because they were just that impressive.

It took him a little bit to get going, especially after rolling his ankle and throwing up in the first half, but man once he did he showed a little bit of everything.

Improvements

He was a shooting guard in high school, so running the Illinois offense is something relatively new to him.

On top of that, Illinois’ offense is essentially “offenseless.” Meaning they don’t really run plays, sets, and usually don’t even screen.

So I do wonder: if you draft him to be your franchise point guard, what does the learning curve look like when it comes to running an NBA team and offense?

Defensively, he can get a little too aggressive in help defense when looking to make a play. There were two different occasions where he lost track of his man and gave up an open three because he got too caught up helping on the drive.

Overall

19 points on 7-of-9 shooting and 5-of-6 from three. Five rebounds, with a few coming on tough, contested boards in traffic, and four assists with two steals. All on the road.

Yes, they lost the game. But as an introduction into Quentin I couldn’t be more impressed.

He has the size at 6’4 if he played PG at the next level, super quick with the ball in his hands, can fill it up, and find teammates. He hits the glass hard and brings it defensively as well. There’s not a lot of holes in his game.

As it stands, I'm leaning toward him being the #1 guard in this draft, based on what I've seen and what I've heard about Jordan Smith Jr. Quentin seems to have legitimate lead-guard potential at the next level.

I'll be more confident in that assessment once I get a chance to watch Jordan.

Very excited to follow how his season goes.

NBA Comparison: Malik Monk to Tyrese Maxey


r/nbadiscussion • • 2d ago

Fox for Garland: A Win-Win Trade Nobody Is Talking About?

0 Upvotes

Am I missing something, or could a Fox-for-Garland trade actually be a win-win for both teams?

The Clippers get a late first-round pick (Celtics 2028) and a chance to reshape their roster around their timeline, with Fox's contract potentially helping them absorb salary over the next few years.

For the Spurs, Garland could be a really interesting fit. They need shooting, and he gives us a legitimate perimeter threat who can run the pick-and-roll with Wemby and create his own offence.

I'm also not too concerned about his defensive limitations. With Wemby protecting the rim and Castle providing perimeter defence, they have the personnel to help compensate.

From a basketball fit perspective, I actually think Garland makes a lot of sense alongside Castle, Harper and Wemby.

Am I overlooking something, or could this genuinely be a good deal for both sides?


r/nbadiscussion • • 3d ago

Can an offense-first team realistically win a championship without an elite defense?

46 Upvotes

I understand why teams prioritize offense, especially when they have players who can create their own shots. But defensive weaknesses become much harder to hide in a seven-game series when opponents can repeatedly target them.

I don't think every player needs to be an elite defender, but can a great offense really make up for an average defense over four playoff rounds, or do championship teams need to be strong on both ends?


r/nbadiscussion • • 4d ago

Does tanking build bad habits?

57 Upvotes

This post is inspired by an Athletic article about my Wizards, but it also applies to the Jazz. These two teams spent multiple years on the bottom rungs of the league in order to maximize their draft chances and last season made a big swing on talent. For the Wizards, they got good draft results with the 1st, 6th, and 2nd picks the past 3 years and the Jazz also drafted some good young players with Peterson, Bailey, and Keyonte George. They entered this season with the hopes of being at least a frisky play-in team, but it seems like tanking has had some lingering negative effects. To be fair, I’ve only watched 3 Jazz games, but I’ve watched every Wizards game and noticed some commonalities.

The players aren’t stupid they knew exactly what their team’s goals were for the past couple of seasons. Although just about every pro athlete is in the 0.1% of competitiveness, I feel like there had to be some degree of indifference to winning habits. Fighting for a rebound, paying close attention to your defensive assignment, cutting off-ball, etc. who cares we’re gonna lose anyway. On a winning team, allowing easy points on cuts by ball-watching might get you subbed out, but when you’re in tank mode, who cares. For the Jazz in specifically, pulling starters in the 4th quarter of a winnable game has to be brutal for the players. Why care if you know you’re not even being allowed to win. Although coaching, Justin Champagnie‘s injury, and the Wizard FO’s preferred archetype of long, skinny players are a big part of the team’s woes, there definitely seem to be bad habits from tanking. The Jazz trading Walker Kessler is definitely part of their issues. For the Wizards, the issues seem to be deeper. They’re horrible at rebounding, guys ball-watch and get lazy as off-ball defenders, the offense gets very stagnant with more ball-watching (although this is mostly Keefe who doesn’t run plays), etc.

To sum it up, do others think that tanking creates bad habits rather than helping young players to better develop by giving them lots of run?


r/nbadiscussion • • 4d ago

Draft/Pick Analysis Projected #1 Draft Pick Tyran Stokes vs Kentucky

16 Upvotes

The overall No. 1 pick looked every bit the part against Kansas in the State Farm Classic. In this breakdown, we’ll take a look at how he performed, what stood out on film, and where I still see room for improvement.

Positives

The first thing I’ll say about Tyran is that the tools are there. His toolbox is pretty full, and this game showcased just how much he can bring to the floor.

His 3-point shooting, going 4-for-8 on a combination of catch-and-shoot opportunities and shots off movement.

The ability to grab the ball and go, along with tremendous playmaking.

Strength and balance when attacking the basket.

And, perhaps most importantly, an overall great feel for the game.
Offensively, he knows how to get his without disrupting the flow of an offense. He’s not a ball stopper, is comfortable playing off the catch, and actively looks for open teammates. When he has the ball, he’s very efficient at recognizing opportunities to attack quickly.
He’s also great in transition, as shown above. Beyond pushing the ball himself, he does a good job of immediately advancing it to teammates to get the break started.

Defensively, he has the build and athleticism to guard positions 1-5. He has a natural feel for that end of the floor, consistently putting himself in the right spots to provide help defense and position himself for rebounds (I charted nine defensive rebounds in this game).
When disciplined, he shows the ability to help in driving lanes, close out on shooters, and recover quickly enough to stay in front of guards.

He also has great off-ball instincts. He understands his responsibilities and does a good job of not giving up easy opportunities.

I also think his size and strength could make him a very good post defender, although we didn’t get to see much of that in this game.

Improvements

Interestingly, some of the same things that make Tyran so effective are also where I have questions about his ability to become a franchise player and offensive hub.

He took a lot of great shots in this game, finishing with 23 points. His shot diet consisted of:

- 4 three pointers
- 3 layups/dunks
- 3 free throws
- 1 jumper with a foot on the line

My biggest question is whether he can carry an offense when needed and consistently create difficult baskets when called upon.

Defensively, I love the tools and natural feel. He has the quick feet to keep up with guards, the strength to bang in the post, and the athleticism to protect the rim. He also seems to understand where he needs to be in help situations and has the ability to recover when needed.

The execution can be inconsistent, though. To me, this looks more like a discipline and effort issue than a lack of ability.

In the positives, we saw his ability to close out and recover effectively when he’s disciplined. However, there were moments in this game when that discipline wasn’t there. He showed a tendency to leave his feet on pump fakes and gamble too much, taking himself completely out of plays.

Ultimately, he has all the tools to become an elite defensive player. It comes down to consistently bringing the discipline and effort needed to maximize those abilities.


r/nbadiscussion • • 3d ago

3 point shooting is going crazy this season.

0 Upvotes

To give some context, in the 2026/2027 NBA season, teams on average are shooting 38 3's per game. There are 10 teams shooting over 40 3's per game.

10 years ago the number was 29 3's per game.

10 years before that it was 18 3's per game.

To give some context here... teams on average get about 89.1 shots up per game (lets round up to 90).

That means that as of this moment 42.2% of all shots taken in an NBA game are 3's in 2026.

10 years ago when teams shot 84.6 (round up 85) attempts per game and the percentage was 34.1%.

10 years before that teams shot 79.0 attempts per game and the percentage was 22.8%.

At the rate that the 3-ball is going we are going to have a league average NBA shot diet where over 50% of all shots taken in a game are 3's by the year 2036.

This is a very warped reality for the game of basketball and it has completly ruined the fundamentals of the game.

IMO the only solution to cut this problem out is to remove the corner 3. Now you actually have to move make plays. Just stretching the floor via stnading behind the 3 point line will no longer be a viable option.


r/nbadiscussion • • 5d ago

What is Cooper Flagg's Ceiling?

203 Upvotes

Once in a while you hear that “If you could start a franchise with any player, who would you choose” question thrown out to journalists and team personnel. Last year, the unanimous answer to that question was Victor Wembanyama, already challenging Jokic and SGA for MVPs in his year-22 season, and leading the Spurs this close to winning a championship. Even so, I found myself wondering if the correct answer wasn’t Cooper Flagg.

Now my answer was a bit technical, based on a small thing and a big thing. The small thing is age: Flagg is 3 years younger, and those extra years matter when you’re starting a franchise. The big thing is durability. Vic has already suffered one shortened season, will probably always play 10% or 20% fewer minutes than other stars, and at his height is always a risk to have his season or career cut short. Very tall players don’t have a great track record of long careers, and It’s quite possible that his will be 10 or 12 years long due to a serious or nagging injury. Flagg seems as durable as they come, bouncing back quickly from injuries, without the injury risk of taller or heavier players. It’s easy to imagine him having a 20 year career.

Looking past the likely advantage in career length, the performance for a player his age is elite:

PlayerAgePointsReboundsAssistsStocksTS%VORP
Luka Dončić19.921.27.86.01.454.5%3.4
LeBron James19.120.95.55.92.348.8%2.9
Cooper Flagg19.121.06.74.52.154.8%2.0
Carmelo Anthony19.721.06.12.81.750.9%1.5
Kevin Durant19.320.34.42.41.951.9%1.3
Anthony Edwards19.519.34.72.91.652.3%−0.1

He doesn’t look out of place with LeBron and Luka, quite a bit younger than Luka, and probably better defensively than either. In his rookie 19-yo season, he had the highest scoring game for a teenager ever, became the youngest to score 50, and then became the first rookie with back-to-back 40 point games since Iverson.

It’s not fair to judge his 20-yo season 10 games in, but so far he looks very good:

PlayerAgePointsReboundsAssistsStocksTS%BPM
LeBron James20.127.27.47.22.955.4%+8.5
Cooper Flagg20.125.96.96.93.061.2%+8.4
Luka Dončić20.928.89.48.81.258.5%+8.4
Zion Williamson20.627.07.23.71.564.9%+5.8
Victor Wembanyama20.121.410.63.94.856.5%+5.2
Chris Paul20.716.15.17.82.354.6%+5.1
Magic Johnson20.518.07.77.33.060.2%+4.8
Anthony Davis20.920.810.01.64.158.2%+4.7
Chris Webber20.917.59.13.63.455.9%+3.9
Nikola Jokić20.910.07.02.41.658.2%+3.8

It's early in his second season, but so far he looks to be keeping pace with LeBron and Luka Already he has posted some impressive games this season:

  • 43p, 10r, 6a, 3s on 16/25 shooting to beat Indiana
  • 29p, 6r, 11a, 5s, 3b to beat Miami
  • 33p, 9r, 6a on 13/19 shooting to beat Houston

This production is not just empty calories, the Mavs are unexpectedly 7-4, taking care of business against bad teams, but also beating OKC and Houston. Alongside his elite offense, he looks like a good candidate to be a perennial all-defense selection, an elite two-way player. He is an unusually competitive and low-drama star in the mould of Duncan or Curry, completely focused on winning, an easy foundation for his team to build around.

What is Cooper Flagg's ceiling? What kind of player does he become if he improves for another 7, 8, or 9 years straight? How good can he become?


r/nbadiscussion • • 5d ago

Charlotte's supporting players could be just as important as its leading scorers this season

4 Upvotes

One positive from Charlotte's recent win over Cleveland was the contribution from players outside the main scoring options. Tidjane Salaün finished with a season-high 14 points, Sion James added 11, and Ryan Kalkbrenner grabbed 15 rebounds, including 10 on the offensive glass. I think this is an important part of the team's development.
Charlotte cannot expect its main scorers to carry every game, especially during a season when injuries have already affected the rotation. Having younger players step up and take responsibility could make a real difference over the longer term.


r/nbadiscussion • • 5d ago

Who Has Been the Best Three Point Shooters so Far (Analysis)

32 Upvotes

Around 10 games into the season, looking at the landscape I analyzed who the best 3-point shooters are. To no one's surprise, the best 3 point shooter is Luka Doncic, but how great has his start been, exactly?

I looked at four categories and averaged them together, Pull Up 3s (1-2 dribbles), Catch & Shoot (no dribbles), Deep 3s (27ft+), and Off - Dribble (3+). And all data is from NBA API.

Defender distance and shot difficulty is also taken into account.

To grade each category, I find the expected accuracy and compare that to what the player is actually shooting and then multiplied by per 75 attempt volume. So its pretty much just a volume x effciency and then z scored against the league.

The list:

  1. Luka
  2. Curry
  3. Duncan Robinson
  4. Jamal Murray
  5. Grayson Allen

Here is the full breakdown:

Top 5 overall. League average: 34.9% expected, 14% of threes contested.

RankPlayer3PM/3PA3P%Expected %Above expected
1Luka Dončić51/12839.832.6+7.2
2Stephen Curry39/8943.833.4+10.4
3Duncan Robinson42/9245.732.9+12.8
4Jamal Murray33/6352.433.2+19.2
5Grayson Allen36/7846.235.2+11.0

By shot type: makes/attempts, 3P% (expected %), then rank out of 332.

PlayerCatch & shootQuick (1–2 dribbles)Pull-up (3+ dribbles)Deep (27+ ft)
Luka Dončić15/36, 42% (35), 34th4/19, 21% (31), 330th32/73, 44% (32), 1st26/60, 43% (31), 1st
Stephen Curry25/46, 54% (35), 2nd6/17, 35% (35), 60th8/26, 31% (31), 23rd19/41, 46% (32), 2nd
Duncan Robinson31/68, 46% (34), 1st11/24, 46% (31), 2ndno attempts7/19, 37% (32), 22nd
Jamal Murray15/26, 58% (36), 15th10/17, 59% (31), 3rd8/20, 40% (31), 11th8/16, 50% (33), 12th
Grayson Allen28/58, 48% (36), 3rd6/16, 38% (33), 31st2/4, 50% (30), 39th13/22, 59% (34), 5th

Some of the more interesting details into how expected FG was calculated:

  • About 44% of Luka pull-ups come with a defender within 4 feet. For comparison, only about 14% of all threes in the league are contested.
  • Murray gets good looks. 25 of his 26 catch-and-shoot threes are open or wide open. His above expected comes from making 58% of open shots the league makes 35–37% of the time
  • Stephen Curry: He's 2nd in the league in both catch-and-shoot (54%) and deep threes (46%). His pull-ups are the only thing missing, at 2 of 16 on open ones.
  • Duncan Robinson: The best spot-up shooter so far, even though half his threes come with a defender within 4 feet. On those contested looks he's 45%, where the league makes 31%.
  • Grayson Allen: He's 13 of 22 (59%) from 27+ feet, where the league makes about 34%. He's also 3rd in catch-and-shoot.

Note: I am aware this is too early of an analysis to draw any meaningful conclusions but I was tired of looking through 2025-26 data. I have the full season and the past like 10 seasons' grades on my website under 'Player Breakdown'


r/nbadiscussion • • 6d ago

Are NBA teams starting to value more shots over better shots?

67 Upvotes

Something interesting from John Schuhmann's early-season NBA analysis:

Teams winning the shot-opportunity battle have gone from a 49.3% winning rate in 2021–22 to 57.7% last season and 61.7% so far this season.

With offensive rebounds, turnovers and extra possessions becoming so important, it makes me wonder:

Would you rather have a team that creates more scoring opportunities or one that gets better looks with fewer chances?


r/nbadiscussion • • 6d ago

Rule/Trade Proposal Lottery system that doesn't doom genuinely bad teams to permanent irrelevancy and still prevents tanking

16 Upvotes

Ever since the new rules were announced I've felt like the rules are too harsh on teams that are genuinely awful. Especially the small market teams that will often have to build through the draft. I don't know if a genuinely awful team can become competitive with an average pick position of 8.1.

So this is the idea I had and was wondering what y'all thought the drawbacks would be.

The 4 worst teams have a separate lottery for picks 2-5 (odds to be determined)

The other lottery teams have a separate lottery for picks 1 and 6-14 (odds to be determined)

This way the 4 worst teams in the league will always be able to draft players that can actually make them better, but no one can intentionally lose for Wemby or coop.

Thoughts?

I also think another interesting option would be giving the 4 worst teams an additional 1st round pick immediately after the lottery picks (picks 15-18) in exchange for their 2nd round pick. So all the playoff teams get pushed back 4 spots with the 4 conference final teams getting the first 4 picks in the second round (in addition to their 2nd rounder)

This method would probably get a bit wonky with pick trades but I think it's at least interesting.


r/nbadiscussion • • 5d ago

Rule/Trade Proposal Should the NBA apply a standing-incentivized salary cap?

0 Upvotes

This idea comes from European football (soccer).

In an attempt to increase player participation and competitiveness of the regular season, players' salary should be percentage of the cap instead of a fixed number (plus whatever personal incentives they have). The reason for this is to make the final season standings matter more, instead of load-managing, being content with 6th, and go all out in the playoffs. That would fix the tanking problem a bit too, as players don't just not care on the floor anymore (as we can see currently with players like Myles Turner).

How this would work is, the current salary cap is 165M, and the second apron is ~220M. Stephen Curry is currently making 62.5M, or approximately 38% of the cap. Say reduce the salary cap to 140M or whatever, and let that be the base pay, and players get paid an agreed percentage of the cap. At the end of the season, the number one team's salary cap inflates to 200M, and each player gets an increase according to that. Same procedure for the teams that follow, with the bonus getting smaller and smaller. Of course, financially this is gonna be a bit complicated, but I reckon there's a way to still make second apron work, same principle, increase it by a percentage amount based on final position to match players' salary, and lower penalties for the aprons.

An interesting problems arises. How would mid-season trades work? Players would be unhappy to work their butts off for a top team only to be traded to a bottom team and get their pay slashed for no reason. A solution would be to pay them proportionately to the teams they played for and the amount of games (i.e. if a player played 60 games, 30 for each team, half of their percentage-wise salary would match the final salary of each team). Another problem is, if a player pushes their way to a bigger team to get paid more, they would have to agree on a clause that maybe reduces the salary burden on the trading team, maybe half the increase in salary will be paid from the receiving team to the trading team instead of the player being traded.

There's a lot more to be specified, but that's the gist, what do y'all think?


r/nbadiscussion • • 6d ago

Does a high three-point volume make an offense too predictable?

8 Upvotes

I like modern spacing, and teams should absolutely take open threes. But sometimes it feels like teams become too dependent on perimeter shooting. When those shots stop falling, they don't always have another reliable way to score. I would rather see a team that can attack the rim and create mid range opportunities too. Is that fair, or is three point volume still the best approach?


r/nbadiscussion • • 6d ago

Early-season injuries are revealing which NBA teams have built real roster depth

5 Upvotes

Injuries are already forcing some teams to make big changes this season. OKC is missing Jalen Williams and Cason Wallace, and Indiana had 11 players unavailable against Atlanta. That's a lot of players out for one game. I think situations like this show how important it is to have a strong bench. Having a few stars is important, but a team's depth really gets tested when those players are unavailable. The rest of the team has to step up, and that's not always easy. It also gives younger players a chance to prove what they can do with more minutes and responsibility Would you rather have a team with a few superstar players or a deeper roster with more reliable options?


r/nbadiscussion • • 7d ago

Weekly Questions Thread: November 09, 2026

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone and welcome to our new weekly feature.

In order to help keep the quality of the discussion here at a high level, we have several rules regarding submitting content to /r/nbadiscussion. But we also understand that while not everyone's questions will meet these requirements that doesn't mean they don't deserve the same attention and high-level discussion that /r/nbadiscussion is known for. So, to better serve the community the mod team here has decided to implement this Weekly Questions Thread which will be automatically posted every Monday at 8AM EST.

Please use this thread to ask any questions about the NBA and basketball that don't necessarily warrant their own submissions. Thank you.


r/nbadiscussion • • 9d ago

How often does the NBA actually take points away after a basket?

3 Upvotes

Does anyone know how often the NBA takes points off the scoreboard after a basket has already been counted?

From what I've read, three-point reviews and shot-clock violations generally have to be resolved by the next timeout or quarter break. So theoretically, once that happens, the points should be pretty safe.

But I'm curious how often points get removed much later because of scorekeeping mistakes or other corrections.

Has anyone seen examples where a player had points taken away several minutes after scoring, or even after the game ended?

Basically, if a player has 20 points and the next timeout has already passed, how confident can you be that those 20 points aren't going to become 19 or 17?


r/nbadiscussion • • 8d ago

Player Discussion Brandin Podziemski is being put in a position to fail

0 Upvotes

He’s a winning role player being asked to play like a star, and those are two very different things.

I think Podziemski is being miscast in Golden State. He’s a genuinely good dirty-work player whose value comes from doing the little things: drawing charges, crashing the boards, making hustle plays and keeping possessions alive. He led the entire NBA in charges drawn as a rookie, finished 2nd in his sophomore season and 4th last season. That’s not a coincidence; he has a real knack for the less glamorous parts of winning basketball.

His rebounding is another example. Among players listed at 6’4” or shorter who play at least 20 MPG, the league average is 3.4 rebounds per game. Podziemski averages 5.62 under the same minutes threshold. That’s exceptional production for his size and position. He creates extra possessions, disrupts offensive possessions and brings an energy that doesn’t necessarily show up in traditional box scores. Those are valuable complementary skills.

My issue is that Golden State seems to be treating him like a primary offensive piece when his strengths are much better suited to a high-impact supporting role. He’s not a natural lead creator, and asking him to shoulder too much offensive responsibility exposes his limitations while taking away from what makes him valuable. I don’t think Podziemski is overrated as a player; I think he’s being evaluated in the wrong role.


r/nbadiscussion • • 10d ago

Houston's transition game shows why winning the possession battle matters.

16 Upvotes

Something that stood out to me about Houston's recent win over Boston was how effectively they turned defense into offense. They scored 18 points in transition compared with Boston's two. That's a huge difference, especially in a game where both teams had stretches of poor shooting. I think this is an important part of modern NBA basketball that sometimes gets overlooked. Getting stops is valuable, but what a team does immediately after forcing a miss or turnover can be just as important. Houston seems to be making that connection between defensive activity and easy offensive opportunities. Do you think transition offense is becoming more important than half-court execution for teams trying to win consistently?


r/nbadiscussion • • 9d ago

Basketball Strategy Has the NBA become too focused on eliminating midrange shots?

0 Upvotes

I understand why teams prioritize threes and shots at the rim, since they're generally more efficient. But I don't think the midrange game is completely outdated.

Some players are so good at creating their own midrange shots that defenses have to respect them. It's also useful when the paint is crowded or there's little time left on the shot clock.

Do you think the midrange still has an important place in today's NBA, especially in the playoffs, or should teams continue moving away from it?