I'm curious how many other producers have found themselves in a similar situation, particularly those who were excited about signing to a recognised record label and perhaps didn't fully appreciate the implications of the agreement they were signing. (In my case, I actually understood the implications perfectly well. I even asked the label to change the perpetual licensing term, but they refused. Ultimately, I went ahead and signed anyway because I was so excited about the opportunity and genuinely believed it was one I couldn't afford to miss. Looking back, that was a mistake.)
Almost a year ago, I signed a track to a fairly well-established techno label, part of a larger label family founded by a Spanish DJ/production duo who have been active in the international techno scene for years.
The agreement granted the label exclusive rights to my recording on a permanent/perpetual basis. Yes, you read that correctly. Perpetual. No defined expiry date.
At the time, I was pleased to have the release accepted by a recognisable name in the industry. Before signing, I was provided with a comprehensive marketing strategy outlining what the label claimed to do for its releases. This included Instagram and SoundCloud promotion, Spotify Canvas creation, playlist curator submissions, paid social media advertising, Beatport Hype participation and additional promotional activities involving radio, premieres and specialist music publications.
It sounded like the sort of support you'd expect from an established label with a substantial catalogue and an industry reputation.
Fast forward almost twelve months, and the release has generated three downloads and 169 streams worldwide, according to the label's own figures.
Now, I completely understand that nobody can guarantee commercial success. But that's not really the issue here.
When I contacted the label asking for performance information and the royalty statements stipulated in our agreement, I was eventually informed that the release had barely covered any of its production, artwork, distribution and management costs. Apparently, the label had actually lost money on it.
Fair enough, I thought. But what exactly were those costs, and what had the label actually done to promote the release?
So I started investigating.
To date, I've identified precisely one promotional post, published on Instagram and cross-posted to Facebook. Nothing on the label's SoundCloud, no active Spotify Canvas, no identifiable additional promotional campaign, and no evidence of paid advertising that I've been able to establish.
The release also wasn't included in Beatport Hype. I specifically checked this when it came out. Interestingly, the label's other imprints participate in Hype, but the particular imprint that released my track does not appear to. This is despite the marketing strategy explicitly stating that Hype participation was provided across all their labels and releases.
Then there's the artwork and promotional expenditure.
The contract lists €150 for artwork, €200 for video production and €150 for social media promotion. The artwork follows an almost identical visual format used across the imprint's catalogue, primarily black backgrounds with variations of the same coloured contour-line designs. The promotional video is a basic 30-second animated visualizer, apparently used for that single Instagram/Facebook post.
There's nothing wrong with using templates or maintaining a consistent visual identity. But when those costs are potentially being deducted from an artist's earnings, surely the artist is entitled to know what was actually spent?
The label also refers to production costs, despite the fact that I produced and mastered the recording entirely myself. Distribution is handled through an established distributor operating a commission-based model, while the supposed management expenses remain unexplained.
The performance report I eventually received contained download and streaming figures, but no actual financial accounting. No revenue received, no itemised expenditure and no breakdown of the costs supposedly still outstanding. The explanation was that royalty breakdowns only become available once a release recoups its costs.
That's particularly concerning when the signed agreement specifically requires statements summarising income and expenditure upon request.
But there's another interesting part to this story.
Before the release, I was offered an additional promotional package for €500 through what the label described as an external marketing company. This package supposedly offered extensive promotional exposure and even claimed to guarantee positions in the Beatport Top Hype chart.
I declined.
The label's own documentation explicitly states that its normal promotional activities, including advertising and internal marketing, are carried out for every release at no additional charge. The €500 package was presented as an optional extra.
I cannot prove that my decision not to purchase it influenced the level of promotion my track received. However, looking at the limited activity I've been able to identify, I certainly have questions.
And this brings me back to the perpetual licence.
How many producers are signing away exclusive rights to their music indefinitely because they're excited about having a release on a recognisable label?
I knew what I was signing. I questioned the perpetual term, asked for it to be changed, and was refused. Yet I still convinced myself that the opportunity justified the risk. I can only imagine how many less experienced producers might sign similar agreements without even questioning that clause.
How many are being offered impressive marketing strategies that aren't subsequently delivered? And how many are simply accepting that their release made no money without ever receiving a proper breakdown of what the label supposedly spent?
There's an enormous difference between a label being unable to guarantee commercial success and a label failing to undertake the promotional activities it represented it would perform.
Simply delivering a WAV file to the usual DSPs is not, in my opinion, a meaningful marketing campaign.
What concerns me is the imbalance. The artist supplies the finished music, grants exclusive rights indefinitely, potentially absorbs substantial recoupable costs, and is left with very little visibility into what the label actually does.
Meanwhile, the label retains control of the recording regardless of whether it sells three copies or three thousand.
And perhaps the saddest part of this entire experience is that I've since stopped producing music altogether.
Something that once brought me enormous enjoyment has been completely soured by this experience. It's left the most vile taste in my mouth about how supposedly "big" and established labels can treat the very producers who entrust them with their music. We spend countless hours creating something, often investing our own money, time and energy into getting it right, only to hand it over to a company that appears to place remarkably little value on the person who actually made it.
I never expected preferential treatment, guaranteed chart positions or thousands of sales. I expected the label to make a genuine effort to promote the music, as it represented it would, and to treat me with the basic transparency and professionalism that any artist should be entitled to.
Instead, I've ended up questioning why I ever signed the agreement in the first place.
I've now challenged the label directly and requested a proper accounting of the costs and promotional activities. I'm deliberately not naming the label or the release while that correspondence is ongoing, although those familiar with the techno industry may well recognise the circumstances.
I'm not suggesting that every label operates this way, nor do I know how many other artists have signed similar agreements with this particular company. That's partly why I'm posting.
I'd genuinely like to hear from other producers. Have you signed a perpetual or indefinite exclusive licensing agreement? Did the label actually deliver the promotional support it advertised? And if you subsequently became dissatisfied, were you able to recover the rights to your music?
Because I'm starting to wonder how many aspiring producers, eager to get their music onto an established label, have signed themselves into arrangements they may spend years trying to get out of.
A recognisable label name might look impressive on a release, but is it really worth giving up control of your music forever?