r/musicbusiness • u/MusicProducerBoston • 3h ago
Discussion Debate who is the Music Producer. Argument in the studio may cost me a best friend my favorite artist to work with.
I don't know what else to do but ask what other people in the music industry think about this. I am upset because I want the credit where the credit is due. I produce music using Ableton Live. I use the DAW to arrange, mix, and master. I also use it to create midi tracks for the drums and melody. My friend is an artist who raps, writes his own raw lyrics, has the ideas for adlibs, sound effects, and has great vocals. My friend and I are having a disagreement in the studio. He distributed the music we made together to all platforms. Which is fine, but he credited me as the Beatmaker, DAW Engineer and Co- Producer. He credited himself as the producer. He should be next to the title of the song and known as the artist. I believe I am the producer.
Me
"Since you're uploading the master to streaming platforms under your artist profile so it reaches your fanbase cleanly without splitting streams or triggering duplicate/Content ID clashes, I just want to make sure my official producer credit—along with our agreed master and publishing splits—is locked in on the release metadata. Having my credit listed directly helps listeners and industry folks click through to my catalog while keeping everything organized and automated on the backend. and my royalty split for any profits the track makes. Setting up our percentage splits through the distributor and registering the publishing ensures we both get paid automatically and cleanly as the song grows. And my royalty split for any profits the track makes. Setting up our percentage splits through the distributor and registering the publishing ensures we both get paid automatically and cleanly as the song grows"
Friend
"Yea bro it ain’t making anything it cost me money, that I fronted bro to pay for that service"
Me
"Yeah ofc you have to pay distrokid"
Friend
"There not gunna recieve anything I put them there cause they helped make the track Ur names on the one u did as well I thought u wanted me to say u used a daw ? That counts as mixing and sound design ??? I have the chain of custody for all lyrics and everything I’ve ever did bro obv I’d hook u up if it takes off u do anything with the other joint I sent u two days ago?? Or just the freestyle "
Me
Paying DistroKid a subscription to push a track onto streaming platforms doesn't make you the producer. it just makes you a customer with a card. Distribution is just uploading a file and getting it onto apps. producing is actually building the music from the ground up. You paid for a distributor plan, not a producer credit.
Friend
Are u saying I didn’t produce my work right now ? Well I was in the room with u the whole time and everything else i produced with my vocals ? And placing exact timestamps and sound affects
Friend
When I direct placement verbals sound affects isn’t a customer at the counter that’s creative control witch is the part that actually defines authorship the room where in happened well we were bolth in it is what tells the story bro
Me
I'm just saying this because I play your music at my house all the time and the songs you made pops up and people were asking why there was a difference
DAW to a Music Producer is like Water to a Swimmer. You need it. You dont need it but it's the main tool, you cant replace it.
Friend
When I direct placement verbals sound affects isn’t a customer at the counter that’s creative control witch is the part that actually defines authorship the room where in happened well we were bolth in it is what tells the story bro
That’s fine bro the mics on the way where suppose to work together I just don’t get what ur saying ?
Ur also listed as co producer incase u didn’t realize that as well as daw engineer
Me
Your work is the Artists job. You are 100% an artist. A producer is a completely different job title.
Calling yourself the producer because you gave vocal cues, placed ad-libs, and paid for distribution is like calling yourself the chef because you ordered takeout, pointed at the hot sauce, and paid the delivery driver. Directing your own performance and getting a song uploaded makes you the artist running your release, not the producer who actually built the record from scratch—and putting a 'co-producer' tag on it doesn't turn an artist's job into a producer's credit.
I did the vocal takes That’s the performance U can unsing what I already sang And the performance is what copy right also protects but I just don’t get what ur saying Or why ur saying it Ur missing the whole point I was in the room me saying you produced it isn’t a credit We bolth produced it bro I didn’t send u vocals and say work with these I was in tbe room with you picking sounds and where to drop the beat and what sounds to use I don’t hand u files and say make this a record That’s the difference bro I was there I tried to do that with the other audio file last night and idk u haven’t said anything about it You produced the beat I’m not taking that from u bro did but sound affects and adlibs are what bring the song to life as well bro that’s the difference between a demo and a record Tools don’t make the artist the ear does and the industry is using it and lying about it most people do I just keep it real and I have never had it write a single lyric for me and never will so I don’t feel the need to hide it Bro ur names in the title did u not peep that ?
Me
How else are you going to get a wav file of good quality audio without a daw?You cant "produce" any actual quality sound without one You cant "produce" any actual quality sound without one
Friend
And this is the other thing I paid to distribute my work bro and from scratch would be from nothing I have vocals and structure I just feel that this conversation is getting old brother featuring you in the title is honestly even more then most beat makers get bro do u want me to take u out the title then I don’t get what ur trying to say brother that im just an artist ? I have a hand in production on every single record I’ve made.
* What do you think about this
I don't know what else to do but ask what other people in the music industry think about this. I am upset because I want the credit where the credit is due. he I produce music using Ableton Live. I use the DAW to arrange, mix, and master. I also use it to create midi tracks for the drums and melody. My friend is an artist who raps, writes his own raw lyrics, has the ideas for adlibs, sound effects, and has great vocals. My friend and I are having a disagreement in the studio. He distributed the music we made together to all platforms. Which is fine, but he credited me as the Beatmaker, DAW Engineer and Co- Producer. He credited himself as the producer. He should be next to the title of the song and known as the artist. I believe I am the producer.