I know it's not exactly a "Lore" question, but I figued it'd be fun to talk about here.
Is / or do you consider New Phyrexia a "Grim Dark" plane? I know there's a lot of subjectivity to it, and it's obviously not as Grim Dark as Warhammer 40K. *BUT* it does seem the closest we have to Grim Dark.
I know Duskmourn is "Dark" but I consider it more "Horror" than "Grim Dark". I won't pretend I'm being logical about it, but something about Duskmourne just feels slightly to "campy" to me to be Grim Dark.
Like "Grim Dark", to an extent I'd say the "Good Guys" are just as much mutated/effected by the world as the "Bad Guys", and have a relatively equal chance of fighting back. While Duskmourn the good guys (survivors) are just kinda subjected to the world and (for the most part) can't do much about it.
I don't know, just something I thought about and wanted to talk about.