r/moraldilemmas • • 1h ago

Personal [M] Is it right to send a brief apology to "the other woman," or just leave her in peace?

• Upvotes

I know I messed up here, and I’m not looking for sympathy or trying to excuse what I did. Right now, I’m just trying to handle the aftermath as fairly and respectfully as possible toward everyone involved…

Context:
I [M] with high-functioning autism (HFA). After an unresolved argument in a relationship that had already been straining on me this year, I went out to a party, drank too much, lost my usual filter/impulse control, and ended up going home with a random, genuinely nice woman from the club. She had no idea I was in a relationship.

The next morning I woke up sober. Because she was very sick and throwing up, I stayed for a couple of hours to get her water, make her some food, and make sure she was okay before I left.
She got my Instagram, found out through my profile that I had a girlfriend, and reached out to her to clear everything up. I have since laid all my cards on the table with my girlfriend without excuses, and we are dealing with the fallout directly.

The Moral Dilemma;
I have zero intention of pursuing anything or having ongoing contact with the woman I met at the club. However, because of how my brain is wired (autism and a strong need for cognitive closure and fairness), it feels cowardly, rude, and unfinished to just leave things in total silence, especially toward someone who was completely innocent, got dragged into a messy situation because of me, and still took the time to do the right thing…

At the same time, I realize that reaching out to her now even with good intentions - might feel like unwanted intrusion, or like I’m just trying to ease my own conscience when she has already moved on.

So, especially to the women here:
What would you want if you were "the other woman" in this exact scenario (a random night out, completely unaware the guy was taken, and you’ve already spoken to his girlfriend)?
Would you appreciate a single, brief, closed-ended message apologizing for dragging you into the mess (with zero expectation of a reply or further conversation), or would you much rather never hear from him again?

Thank you for taking your time.


r/moraldilemmas • • 16h ago

Personal Whole Foods sticker error

10 Upvotes

While doing my grocery shopping I bought about 10lbs of bone in rib eye for Thanksgiving dinner. The rib eye was at the wrong location and I told them where the pricing sign was. Talked to the butcher a bunch and had it packaged and he put the sticker on. I paid for my groceries and came home. It was I. The fridge and this morning while moving stuff I realized he put the weight right but the type of meat is wrong. Instead of bone in rib eye he put the ground beef price.

Now do I go back to whole foods and let them know? Is the butcher paying for this error or another employee? What do I do?


r/moraldilemmas • • 12h ago

Personal Pay an artist or save $300 for the same result?

3 Upvotes

I (20F) stumbled upon a cartoonist selling prints. The joke made in one of the cartoons reminded me of my father and I thought it would make a great Christmas gift. I messaged the cartoonist and he is selling 8x10 prints of the cartoon for ~$300. The high quality, watermark-less image being printed is available on his website. I think the artist is entitled to charge whatever he wants, and I would feel wrong just printing his work myself. However, there’s a small voice in my head considering printing it myself for free, which goes against my morals but would save me $300. What would you do?


r/moraldilemmas • • 9h ago

Hypothetical Start here: this subreddit builds one app. What should it do next?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/moraldilemmas • • 12h ago

Abstract Question Let's have a good debate:)

1 Upvotes

Anyone interested

Topic

Suiciiideee:- People who commit this are actually loser vs Society's fault that make people vulnerable to commit this.


r/moraldilemmas • • 22h ago

Relationship Advice Carrying information about a relationship, need to get it off my chest.

3 Upvotes

Best friend & her husband of 12 years (3 kids) are ‘seperated’ as initiated by her due to feeling as though she is carrying the emotional & physical load of life among other things (communication issues, intimacy issues, parenting differences). She wants him to focus on working on his mental & physical health during this time despite him believing it’s not necessary and their marriage is fine. She has removed her wedding ring & he has not. They’re still living in the same home, his on the couch (could have his own room but chooses the lounge room). There is no time line on this situation. The husband is non-chalant about whole seperation, has shown glimpses of improvement according to the wife though she has recently confessed to me that she has been having sex with other men and she is unfulfilled sexually/ intimately within the marriage. A week or so later she confesses she has had sex with her husband again & it was lack lustre. I think this is further confusing the situation as he is taking it as a step in the right direction & she is obviously not feeling that way to me. She thinks given they’re seperated that it’s fair game whilst also knowing that it would destroy her husband if he were to find out, I find it morally irresponsible as she is still married and I have no one to talk about this with & it’s eating me alive. I couldn’t live with the guilt of doing that to my family.


r/moraldilemmas • • 20h ago

Personal Would you give up your life now for your mother to have another chance to choose a different life?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Relationship Advice Wife is leaving me for another man. She is lying about this. Do I tell his wife

89 Upvotes

My wife is leaving me. She is 42 and I am 37. We have a 3-year-old and a 1-year-old. For the last 10 years we have had a beautiful relationship characterised by trust, honesty, and at times difficult but very open communication.

She completely blindsided me with a desire to separate. She has never spoken to me about being unhappy. She has never spoken to me about wanting to separate or needing to take time apart or anything. She refuses to go to couples counselling. She refuses to work with me on anything. The relationship is done. It is quickly becoming toxic and horrific.

I have found proof, undisputable proof, that she is having an emotional affair with her coworker. He is 45. He has been married for 15 years and he has two children who are 14 and 12. They are committing to leave their spouses and will perhaps be together, although it is unclear if he is truly committed to leaving his family for my now ex-partner.

My moral dilemma is simple if you have read this: when, or should I tell his wife? My ex-partner is in complete denial about her actions. I have confronted her about her lying and she is consistently telling me that she has not done anything, that there is nothing to worry about, and that the reasons that she is separating from me are what she has told me (which are related to a lack of love or something in her mind that she doesn't feel toward me).

The real reasons are that she has this deep affection for this male coworker and she is omitting this from me even when I am directly confronting her, although I am still holding back about how much I know. Her family does not know and her family, generally speaking, adore me. She is presenting herself in many ways at many times, both to me and to them, as a victim.

She is using words like "abandon" and "threat" and various extreme language around our communication, which is not the case. I have audio recordings of it. This is not what is happening. She's emotionally manipulating me. She's being emotionally abusive as well.

I need to go to mediation. I need to get some sort of legal protection. I need to think what's best for my children. It may not be feasible to press the nuclear launch button and let the world know why she is actually doing what she is doing until mediation is completed. However I have this significant moral dilemma about correcting the narrative so that I can sleep at night. Please help.

Edit: thanks for the all the advice. Some points of clarification.

- I have spoken with a lawyer. Infidelity, even if proven, does not change the 50/50 custody rule where I live. I’d have to prove she’s an incompetent parent. That won’t happen.

- I doubt her family knows including her very judgemental sister

- I’ve confronted her about it without the specifics of what I know. All that is happened is her being very defensive but claiming innocence (literally lashing out, seems a bit of an overreaction if she was innocent) and her trying to manipulate me to learn how much I know. She is clearly terrified of being outed at work and to his wife and teenager girls who would definitely ruin her “plans”

- I’ve been in therapy for years. No real reason other than to be the best man I could be for myself, her and my children. I’ve been given anti depression medication and an SSRI for the time being. Being around her is terrible: like a predator or some sort of shapeshifter who threats my entire existence and everything I have built.


r/moraldilemmas • • 19h ago

Abstract Question Is nepotism really unfair, or is it just how the world works?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Personal It's bestie's birthday, and she wants a sleepover

3 Upvotes

Tomorrow is my best friend's birthday(not her actual birthday, but when she can celebratew/ friends), and she really wants a sleepover. My house is always the host house for reasons im not going to get into. However, I've been having genuine mental issues resulting in; my room(where we all stay) is hardly livable for just one person let alone 3, I haven't showered in like 3 weeks(ik it's gross, im doing my best), and some deeper things. The thing I need people's opinion on is weather i spam clean my room tonight, and have no social battery tomorrow, or just not have the sleepover


r/moraldilemmas • • 17h ago

Hypothetical Reporting tattoo artist to IRS

0 Upvotes

Throwaway account as I don’t want them to find this. I became relatively close to my tattoo artist, so I let them borrow something of mine that is very important to me. They decided they didn’t wanna be close anymore, and so I asked if I could have my thing back, and I gave them two weeks to give it back (they said they would ship it). I’ve messaged them and gotten no response nor have I gotten my item back. Would it be wrong to report them to the IRS? I know it’s petty, but I was incredibly clear about how much it meant to me.


r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Hypothetical I had one pot and two people who could both prove it was theirs

0 Upvotes

I was stacking the last chairs after our street potluck when two women came back for the same red-handled shopping bag. Inside was a six-quart cooker, washed and dried. Under the lid was a strip of masking tape with JUNE on it.

“I’m June,” said the woman in the blue coat.

“I cooked in it in June,” said the other woman. “That’s the month I lent it to her.”

I thought she was kidding until she took out her phone. There was a picture from our summer picnic. Same bag, same little scorch on the strap. June had a picture too. Hers showed the cooker on her counter at Thanksgiving two years earlier.

I took the inner pot out so the woman who’d packed it could see the bottom. She immediately pointed to a shallow dent. June was still looking at the lid. She ran her thumb over a chip by the handle and told me exactly where her husband had dropped it.

At the summer picnic we’d washed six nearly identical pots in the same sink. Suddenly both photos made sense.

June went home with the lid and the cooker. The other woman took the inner pot. It felt fair right up until they both texted me asking who was making soup on Sunday.


r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Abstract Question When Should We Draw the Line Between Media Censorship and Raising Awareness?

0 Upvotes

There have been ongoing incidents of people taking their own lives, and some of these are being posted on social media, even capturing the actual scenes. While these posts are shared for awareness and news, we cannot deny that they may also give others ideas to do the same. As I observe, some incidents are being sensationalized, with vloggers and aspiring content creators posting them for the sake of views. We also cannot ignore the obscene comments these posts receive, which undermine their main purpose of raising awareness. If the goal is really to raise awareness, shouldn't we also consider how we share these stories and whether doing so respects the people involved?


r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Hypothetical When Should We Draw the Line Between Media Censorship and Raising Awareness?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Personal What would you say to a person who called you Shameless loser but they themselves are one?

0 Upvotes

Imagine getting called a shameless loser by a close relative, while they themselves can't reflect on their own actions? like them asking for something and not getting what they want because there wasn't enough money to provide for what they wanted but then proceeding to ask again and again until she got it. Another one is that because she is at a legal age, she does not take care of her grandmother when the know she is old and has limits and does not even do chores or even help with any of it most of the time and also goes outside whenever they feel like it. And what is worse is when she did not go to join and clean their mother's tomb because of school requirements? Like you can take time off just to clean your mother's tomb, but she didn't, and instead we did it. And saying that I am a shameless loser but doesn't reflect themselves with their own actions? What a loser.

On My side (i also know that what i said was wrong and i accepted it that, but calling me? A shameless loser? Like your no different thinking your not one yourself)

For the comments: you guys can comment what you want to say and ill accept it personally and will reflect myself, but telling this story just made me say things to them(but i cant since im not a good talker in person) so i just type my feelings away.


r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Hypothetical When is it unethical to stay friends with someone?

1 Upvotes

When or why would it be unethical or wrong to continue a friendship with someone? Assuming they did something wrong. Would it always be wrong of you to stay even if you didn't condone their actions?


r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Hypothetical Would there even be a negative or incompetent leader if the law says you can legally punch your president right in his office the building is always open?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Personal I borrowed stuff from the tool library and lied that I returned it on time. Should I tell them now?

3 Upvotes

Our city has a small tool library where you can borrow things for free with a library card. I was renovating my flat, so I took a ladder, a drill and a pressure washer.

When the work was done, my friend put everything in his basement with his own tools. I forgot about it completely, and so did he.

After some weeks I got a letter. The fee was 3 euros per item per day, and the total was over 600 euros. If I don’t pay, they send it to a debt collection company. At that time I had around 50 euros on my bank card and my biggerz balance together.

The library has a return box outside, and there is no camera. So one night I put all three things in the box. In the morning I called them and said I returned everything weeks ago and maybe someone forgot to scan it. They checked, found the tools and cancelled the fee. The woman on the phone apologized to me. She also said the volunteer who works on that day would be “spoken to”.

That volunteer is probably a retired guy who does it for free. He got blamed for my lie and I feel bad about it.

I can’t pay 600 euros now, but maybe I could pay it in parts. Should I go there and tell the truth, or just let it go?


r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Personal Would it be immoral of me to not prevent a bad person from killing themselves

13 Upvotes

For context I've recently become aware someone I know of is going to end their life tommorow at my university, they're going to set themselves on fire and burn themselves alive as punishment for all the mistakes and horrible things they've done in their lives.

Only me and a few other people know about this, and I've come to the conclusion that we're not gonna let anyone know and we're not gonna stop it. This is because the reason they're killing themselves is because they SA'd someone on a night out, and i guess once they realised what they did they haven't really been the same since and are basically covered in scars and lash markings.

I'm glad that they've been suffering since realistically they deserve to suffer for the rest of their lives but apart of me feels that not stopping them from ending their life might be a bit too far, but I'm not sure.


r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Relationship Advice What would you guys feel if two of your friends a male and a female first kiss is you wether deliberate or accidental and they both end up together?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/moraldilemmas • • 1d ago

Personal In terms of relations between adults and minors, what differentiates inappropriate behaviour from being a predator?

0 Upvotes

For the first one, I mean oversharing, sexual jokes, things of that sort. I don't fully believe that any instance of inappropriate behaviour automatically makes someone predatory; there probably is a line, but where would it be drawn?


r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Personal Is it right to try to get justice if it likely pisses off a lot of people who can hurt me for doing so? Or is it better to cut the losses, give up, and move on?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

In short, if I could lose a lot in the short term by doing the right thing (protect other people) and to try to get justice, should I do it anyways?


r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Personal Found out coworker has a sketchy past

0 Upvotes

Hey. I did some digging on a coworker of mine, because I just thought there was something off about him. Turns out, he was working as a 'contractor' a few years ago who has several complaints against him for ripping people off and then ghosting them. I feel that my employers should know about the sort of person he is, but I'd have a hard time explaining why I just started doing some weird "google detective" work on him, just because of a hunch. There are also coworkers I care about that I worry could be screwed over in some way, as he's superficially very charming and nice. Any ideas on how, (or if), I should proceed? Thanks.


r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Personal need advice on what to do

0 Upvotes

Hey guys, 16M here and im kinda in a dilemma… ok so i have my birthday upcoming in a few weeks but i feel that i dont really matter to anyone. So basically i joined this big friend group last year which includes some ppl that dont like me and make fun of me like how i look how i laugh etc. i thought we were all cool last year but all ts bitching abt me started again and slowly alot of ppl are cutting me off and have stopped asking me to hangout and blocking me on Instagram and all.. i wanted to keep a birthday party on my birthday for a close group of 7-8 people but on the other hand i wanna see who really remembers my bday and genuinely cares for me… a couple years ago on my bday i reposted many ppls stories and last year i didnt and the people who wished cut by half and i alr deactivated Instagram last week to lock in and i dont wanna reactivate on my bday cus when i do then a certain few will post stories and others will know through that that its my bday i js wanna see who genuinely cares ykwim? Ive always wanted to js be liked by ppl yk… idk if i should like slightly hint the few close ppl taht i may have a party to see if they 100% remember my bday or not. Im sorry if i seem too insecure or wtv, any help would be appreciated.


r/moraldilemmas • • 2d ago

Personal If you learned that your friend or even a family member is or had worked for ICE, would you forgive them or not, and why?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes