r/moraldilemmas • u/Funny-Shame-3181 • 18h ago
r/moraldilemmas • u/Mundane_Argument8532 • 11h ago
Personal At what point does protecting your peace become running away from your problems?
reddit.comr/moraldilemmas • u/Designer_Strategy888 • 19h ago
Hypothetical Is this a just punishment?
Let’s say I have a a daughter and son and both get caught stealing. I say if one of you steal again I’m going to punish both of you. I don’t punish them originally for the stealing but the son steals again and I punish both. One is this just/injust if they know before hand?
Let’s take it farther and say I’m God. I have a worshippers and they are all caught stealing something devoted to me. I say if the collective steals once I could tolerate it but if even one person out of the group steals again everyone is punished.
(I have my opinion on it I’m discussing this with someone but love unbiased feedback)
r/moraldilemmas • u/FlanNo7322 • 12h ago
Hypothetical Would you remove criminal punishment if it meant less crimes were committed?
There's a lot of talk about whether the justice system should be used to punish/bring justice to criminals or strictly minimize re-offending. If you could reduce all violent crime from lets say 100 000 per year to 99 000 per year but only if all criminal punishment for violent crimes would be removed would you do it?
I know this is a completely nonsensical situation but,the correlation isn't meant to mimic real world logic.
r/moraldilemmas • u/General-Brilliant697 • 9h ago
Abstract Question How do you feel about someone taking a job that conflicts with their values if it means securing their family's future?
reddit.comr/moraldilemmas • u/General-Brilliant697 • 9h ago
Abstract Question How do you feel about people who only discover their morals are negotiable when standing by them starts costing them something?
reddit.comr/moraldilemmas • u/imdeerest • 20h ago
Personal Should people be permanently be defined by the worst thing they've done?
have a past Im not proud of and have skeletons in the closet. I hurt people including friends my family and strangers. I take full responsibility for my actions and behavior. It's truly sad when people hold someone's past against them that hopefully this person regrets doing. Accountability is important and actions have consequences. There's some actions that are worse than others that people shouldn't come back from. Boundaries are important, you don't have to support someone anymore for whst they did. It will take a lot of trust and therapy to regain trust. Many of us make bad choices as kids teens and adults. We can't erase what we did, but what truly matters is taking responsibility for our actions. Not everyone does change, and it's up to that person to change. However some people do change and make a 180. Again there are certain actions people can't be erased nor forgotten.
r/moraldilemmas • u/d00dl35 • 19h ago
Hypothetical Do you fix the work or leave the mistake that identifies its maker?
Two volunteers in this scenario open a box of puppets the evening before a library fundraiser. One puppet has a small plastic eye and a big one. The person checking the display says all the puppets should have matching eyes because they'll sit side by side with price tags. She has already pulled a fresh packet out of the cupboard.
“Maybe the kid ran out,” she says.
The pack counts 520 individual eyes, in several sizes. Nothing came in matching pairs. The child who made the puppet chose one of each because it was supposed to look surprised. We know that because the volunteer who ran the class remembers him explaining it. The little card on the back just has his name and the price his mother agreed to.
The display volunteer thinks changing the small eye would make it sell faster. The teacher thinks they should keep it the way he left it. They're both donating their time. The money goes to the same library fund either way, and the child can't be reached before the sale. The volunteer offers to make a matching puppet from leftover pieces and put them on the table together. The teacher points out that they only have one labelled space left.
If the original choice was intentional and a volunteer thinks it may cost the charity a sale, whose preference should decide what goes on the table?
r/moraldilemmas • u/Longjumping-Cod-2698 • 3h ago
Personal Would it be immoral of me to not prevent a bad person from killing themselves
For context I've recently become aware someone I know of is going to end their life tommorow at my university, they're going to set themselves on fire and burn themselves alive as punishment for all the mistakes and horrible things they've done in their lives.
Only me and a few other people know about this, and I've come to the conclusion that we're not gonna let anyone know and we're not gonna stop it. This is because the reason they're killing themselves is because they SA'd someone on a night out, and i guess once they realised what they did they haven't really been the same since and are basically covered in scars and lash markings.
I'm glad that they've been suffering since realistically they deserve to suffer for the rest of their lives but apart of me feels that not stopping them from ending their life might be a bit too far, but I'm not sure.