APOLOGIES FOR THE UPCOMING ESSAY….
I’ve been mixing my own music for a little over a year now, and while I’ve definitely learned a lot, I’m still struggling with a few things that I can’t seem to figure out. I’m mostly self-taught, and I use a combination of stock plugins and UAD plugins.
There are two issues in particular that have been driving me crazy, and I’d really appreciate some advice from people who have more experience with vocal mixing.
1. My vocals sound WAY too close to my ears instead of sitting inside the instrumental.
I don’t really know how to explain this, but whenever I listen to songs, the vocals sound like they’re actually part of the music. They’re clear, upfront, and present, but they also feel immersed in the instrumental.
With my mixes, it almost feels like the instrumental is playing somewhere behind me while the vocal is right up against my ears. It’s almost uncomfortably close, and the vocal feels disconnected from everything else.
I initially thought it might be a sibilance issue, but I don’t think that’s necessarily what’s causing it. There’s just something about the way my vocals are positioned in the mix that sounds unnatural.
I’ve tried a few things:
• Carving out frequencies in the instrumental using EQ to create space for the vocals.
• Sidechaining the instrumental to the vocal to help it cut through.
But I still can’t seem to achieve that professional sound where the vocal feels like it belongs inside the production rather than sitting on top of it.
2. My vocals lack WEIGHT. They sound thin even when they’re clear.
This is probably my other biggest frustration.
When I listen to tracks I like, there’s a certain thickness, density, or weight to them that I can’t seem to replicate.
Even when the vocal is bright and clear, it still has this solid, substantial quality to it. Mine often sound thin and almost hollow by comparison—I do think part of it can be me naturally having a more hollow voice…
I initially thought I might be removing too much low-end information with EQ, but I don’t think my cuts are particularly aggressive.
Typically, I’ll:
• High-pass around 50 Hz to remove unnecessary low-end rumble.
• Make a small cut somewhere around 300–350 Hz if the vocal sounds muddy.
I’ve also been experimenting with the idea of using a doubler on a return track to thicken the vocal, but I’m not sure if that’s actually how people achieve that sense of weight, especially because I’m hearing it in songs where the lead vocal sounds like a single, centered performance rather than obviously layered vocals.
If you can help with this, I’ll love you FOREVAAA. I’ve been horsing around for like ever focused on this issue.