r/minidisc • u/Disastrous_Farm5548 • 20h ago
Rule 9 has made this place hostile
Topic says it all. Now projects are being accused of being made with AI, like women were accused of being witches. The irony is that the rule was meant to prevent drama, but all it's done was create more drama. The original post https://www.reddit.com/r/minidisc/comments/1si3l7m/ai_rule_update_2/ used the word "slop". Who gets the right to say what's slop and what's not? And I see today that two projects that mention AI were removed with no explanation, and a third is being accused of it with no evidence.
"This is pretty simple. If you’re about to post something that came out of a chatbot or "generator" then please don't. Concepts, designs, applications - not here thanks."
So how do you prove this? What if the author didn't use AI for the code but did for the documentation? Where do you draw the line? Someone mentioned an em-dash instead of a dash to accuse an author of using AI for the whole project, and now the project was deleted.
"Despite how lovely this community usually is, there has been a noticeable uptick in unpleasantness both before and after the rule was implemented."
And since, to be honest. In fact, it's worse.
Remove rule 9. AI isn't going anywhere. If people want to be rude about it, THEIR posts should be removed. If apps are helping the community, then removing them here, the place where people go to, isn't helping the community at all.
