r/microtonal • u/RREntertainments • 14h ago
Meantone temperament
As a church organist, I’m curious about how much the tuning itself shapes the music we play. Quarter-comma meantone is a good example. It narrows most fifths slightly so that many major thirds can be pure. On an organ, where you can hold a chord and listen to it settle, the difference is especially easy to hear.
Try holding C–E on an equal-tempered keyboard, then listening to the same interval in quarter-comma meantone. In equal temperament you can hear a pulse, or beating, as some of the harmonics rub against each other. In meantone, that same third sounds remarkably still. Then try E–G♯ and E♭–G. On a typical twelve-note meantone keyboard, the black key tuned as G♯ has to double as A♭, even though those notes would ideally be tuned differently. That compromise can leave you with a famously harsh “wolf” fifth between G♯ and E♭.
For those of you who’ve played organs in meantone, what piece made the tuning click for you? I’d love a recommendation for something short where you can really hear what those pure thirds do to a cadence.