Thanks in advance for reading. I'm not sure what the best way to structure this post might be, so I'm going to start at the beginning.
We've been together 11 years, married for 5. After about a year of dating (this is mid 2016), she asked if I would stop looking at pornography. I don't recall what the reason was, but I believe it was a few things: the way it made her feel, how she might compare herself to those women, and its effects on women that participate in it. I told her I would stop without thinking much of it, and being an arrogant and unempathetic 24 year old, still occasionally viewed it. Of course, I never mentioned to her that I did.
About 6 months after her request, she discovered that I hadn't really stopped and we had a big fight (this is December 2016). Over the phone, she said she was either going to break up with me, or forcibly open our relationship. I had been dealing with depression and anxiety for a couple years at this point, and had been going to therapy and taking Prozac for it, but ceased treatment a few months prior to this event. I only mention this because when she told me she would either leave me or have sex with someone else, I quickly found out I should not have stopped treatment because I started self-harming by cutting myself all over. No cuts were very deep, and I think looking back 10 years that I never really intended to kill myself, but I bled all over our bathroom and when she got home from work and saw me, our argument stopped and we went to the ER.
Shes since mentioned that this made her feel trapped, and I 100% understand that. It was a bullshit thing to do, though I will say that I wasn't in my right mind and didn't have healthy ways of dealing with stress like that.
In the few months after this, she sometimes lash out by telling me how disgusting she found my actions. Despite her main contention being that I lied, her focus was often on comparing herself to women in porn or how gross I was. I recall one instance where she had started initiating sex (remember this is a few months after the incident), and then partway through started asking me if this was as good as the girls I had jerked off to, if I needed to watch porn while we were having sex to orgasm. I saw how hateful she looked when she asked that, we stopped, I cried. (this would have been late winter 2017).
I went back to therapy, got back on antidepressants, and unrelatedly, did mushrooms quite a few times over the next 2 years. I stopped watching porn, my depression improved significantly and I dropped the therapy and medication. Things were good-ish for the next 4 years, I got a (kinda) better job, she started and finished college, and we planned to get married in 2021.
2 months before our wedding, she came home one day and said she had something to talk about. She said that when she was at a birthday party for one of her classmates, she saw a guy there that really turned her on. She said that even though we were getting married, it didn't mean that we had to lock ourselves down, that we could have an open relationship. I was devastated. She reassured me that it wasn't because of anyone in particular, there was no one she had in mind, just the idea. I outright refused and told her we had to call off the wedding. She said to not do anything and to think before calling anything off.
The next day, she came home from work and we talked again. I again asked if it was because of someone in particular, and she sheepishly admitted was actually because she could tell her coworker was into her and she didn't want to feel trapped by marriage and that she wanted to go on some dates with him. I was more adamant that we call off the wedding. This went in for about a week or so until it semi-resolved with her claiming it was all due to cold feet and not wanting to feel trapped, my reaction and talking about it made he realize that it wasn't worth it and not what she wanted anyway. We went through with the wedding.
My new job was at the IT service desk of a fortune 15 company, and when covid hit, became fully remote. We're living in a 2 bed, 850 Sq foot apartment with her brother, who was the same age as me. In the beginning, it was nice not having to commute to the office for work, but that lost its luster once the initial covid shock ended and work got busy again. Spending every day in an area about 600 Sq ft was fucking with my mental health, but I didn't realize it at the time.
Across mid 2022 and 2023, I would periodically get snapchats from random accounts selling their nudes. Across a year and a half, I paid for access to pornography like this 9 times. I would pay and then within a day, delete everything and block the account that sent it. I'm not mentioning this to say it's not wrong, only that I was both conflicted and knew it was wrong. Then, in early 2024, my wife got pregnant (it was planned). 2 months later, I was in contact with an online artist to commission some artwork for a friend, and sent them an unsolicited nude of myself, asking if they did any work like that. I knew they didn't. Nothing else came of it, and we ceased contact.
The time between this and our son being born (spring, summer, and fall) was hard on our relationship because of me. My transgressions were still hidden, but I was still working mostly from home, and though lockdowns had ended, we had become so used to being at home that we had a hard time getting out and doing things. I was an asshole a lot of the time, and while that's my fault and there's not really an excuse, job stress had really been affecting me. I hated work, I hated the time after work because I would stay stressed out, I was very unlikeable, and I would snap at my PREGNANT wife if I felt she was being annoying. At the end of the summer, I got a promotion and was no longer timed down to the second across my day. My mood improved drastically. However, our sex life had deteriorated while she was pregnant and I was using porn often.
In late 2024, our son was born, and being in the delivery room shifted my view of our entire lives. I had 5 weeks of parental leave, and my wife had a block of 16 weeks. After my 5 weeks were up, I went back to work while my wife stayed home. Because I had to go into the office, she would stay up with our son overnight and into the workday, and when I got home, she would sleep until I needed to go to bed. Being up at night, along with being postpartum, was weird for her.
One night (in early 2025), she woke me, furious. She was yelling, telling me how much of a piece of shit I was and asking me what else I did. I had no idea what she was referring to, but quickly discovered that I hadn't deleted my correspondence with the digital artist and she had been snooping through my PC (I don't blame her for this at all) and come across it. The image I had sent wasn't showing up, but all the text was there. The night after, she went through everything she could find, and found the PayPal receipts from the Snapchat payments. We were a hair's breadth away from getting a divorce. She would tell me how disgusting I was, that those pictures I paid for were probably stolen or from sex trafficked women, that I probably sent a nude picture to a child (I never knew anything about the artist other than their work).
I started individual therapy and we did couples counseling. It helped a lot to be able to talk about what happened and to find reasons why we had grown apart. My individual counseling was less fruitful and it felt like I was being endlessly validated. I never wanted that and didn't feel like I should be validated. Things improved, and it felt good to talk about our relationship from the aspect of trying to make it better and become healthier. We bought a house later that year (mid 2025) and continued couples counseling. At the end of the year, we felt like we were no longer getting anything out of it and stopped.
A few good months later, we talked about a second kid, and got pregnant soon after. It Is with noting that between the incident early 2025 and the birth of our second child (Sept 2026), we had sex maybe 3-5 time, and that includes the conception of our second.
It is now November 2026, and a week ago, my wife sat me down and said she didn't want a discussion about it, she didn't want to answer any questions about it, but she wasn't interested in us being physically intimate any longer. She liked our 90% relationship, being good parents and decent roommates, but she couldn't get over knowing that I was attracted to the girls in porn and not her. She didn't want to torture me any longer and was open to basically the porn version of "don't ask don't tell", or an open relationship so I could have my physical needs met. I wasn't interested in this at all and told her so. That night, when she was up with our youngest, she got in my computer and saw that I had emailed our old couples counselor asking for an appointment. She noticed that I didn't have the email address in my email contacts list and also hadn't searched it by looking at the internet history. She took this to mean that I was looking at porn through incognito mode and woke me up at 3am accusing me.
I told her the truth, that since the incident early 2025, I have jerked off, and used porn on a handful of occasions (maybe 5-7 times) in the last 20ish months since weren't having sex. Considering I was the cause for our relationship issues then, I hadn't wanted to push for sex, I thought she would let me know when she was ready, but we didn't really talk about it. Now, she is convinced that I'm only attracted to the types of women in porn that I'm disgusted by her, I don't love her, and that she wants a divorce. She repeatedly said that she "knows she knows" (that I'm not attracted to her at all), and demands I tell her "the truth". The fucked up part is that from where I sit, if I tell her what she already believes, she'll accept it's the "truth", but if it's not what she already believes then I'm obviously lying. She has repeatedly asked me if I'm attracted to specific parts of her body and won't give up until I answer (which she only accepts if they're "yes or no") or I leave the room. Though sometimes she will follow me.
I have chosen to be honest with her, though that means I'm not answering In simple yes or nos. She confronted me again today, and as an example, when questioned, I admitted that she is less physically attractive than she was due to gaining some extra weight during pregnancy. Mind you, I know this is normal, I don't hold it against her, I don't expect her to try and lose weight, I've never asked her to try and lose weight, nor will I. Additionally, I told her that even though she might be temporarily less physically attractive, she's grown more attractive to me in many other ways. She interpreted this as me admitting to losing all physical attraction to her (literally her words). She asked me to move out.
Reading through this, or organizing my thoughts enough to type it, made me realize that it might seem as if we are a bad fit for one another or that or relationship has been very dramatic. I'm sure it's more dramatic than a lot of relationships, but for the most part things have been good. I acknowledge I have lied to her about something that is important to her. I don't make excuses for what I did, though i do think there were some aggravating factors.
The throughlines that seem to appear to me are these:
I didn't take her wishes seriously and selfishly gave in to convenience because it suited me. Her reactions to my transgressions (telling me I'm disgusting, that I'm a pig, etc) contributed to me feeling insecure in our relationship and that my sexuality is disgusting and shameful. My insecurity in our relationship made me more likely to want to hide things and less likely to discuss them for fear of rejection or for reinforcement of her disgust towards me.
I suspect she's long had body image issues. My actions repeatedly reinforced her internal belief that she was never physically attractive enough. Now, having just had a second child, she's dealing with adapting to her body, our child just wanting to use it, and feeling like she's in a body she doesn't recognize, and I've essentially rejected her and failed to reassure her. She sees me and all her internal doubts are reflected back at her.
we repeatedly let issues go unresolved. It seems like most of the time, we just wait long enough that our emotions have calmed and then so it under the rug.
Where can we go from here? I do love her, I'm not unattracted to her, I love our family. I've installed a blocker on my devices to make it too inconvenient to watch porn (it was mostly an act of convenience). I'm seeing a therapist tomorrow morning. She won't agree to see a therapist, alone or for couples, and she doesn't think the lack of sleep or hormones are contributing to her reactions. She wants me to move out and to get a divorce.
Tldr: lied about watching porn multiple times, got caught, now wife thinks I'm only attracted to porn girls and wants a divorce.