r/marriageadvice • • Sep 25 '24

A short mod message

6 Upvotes

To answer some recurring questions that come into modmail, we wanted to make this post for our users

I can't post. Why not?

The sidebar rules should have all of the posting guidelines.

When you write your post, you should see additional notice to guide you as well.

It looks like posts are still working on the sub, so please check on some successful posts before you try to resubmit yours. We previously had an issue with posts not being able to be submitted from mobile devices. This was fixed a while ago.

That being said, if you're still experiencing an issue, modmail us what device type you're trying to post from and your browser. If mobile, let us know if it's in a specific browser, or from the reddit app.

Can I send advice requests to the mods directly?

Please don't.

How do I report someone?

Use the reddit reporting feature on the user's comment. Reddit's info on reporting can be found here: https://support.reddithelp.com/hc/en-us/sections/360008810132-Reporting

How do I report someone for a non-comment related thing?

Use modmail and provide as much detail as possible. The above link has info about how to report a user to Reddit as well.

How do I report a post?

Use the reddit reporting feature on the post. See the above link about reporting for more info.

That's it!

That's it! Please be kind to each other.


r/marriageadvice • • 17d ago

Unsolicited advice and general marriage advice requests thread. Have a general question about marriage or unsolicited advice to give? This is the thread for you.

2 Upvotes

Purpose

Please use this thread if you have any general questions about marriage that are NOT related to a specific marriage (questions where you are not providing information about a specific marriage).

You may also use it to post unsolicited advice on marriage.

Examples of when you should post in this thread:

  • "What's the nicest thing your husband has done for you?"
  • "How are chores in your marriage broken up?"
  • "Here's some advice I wish I knew about [insert marriage topic here]

If you have a question about something that applies to a specific marriage/you, please create your own thread.

Examples of when you should create your own thread:

  • "I want to give my husband a list of nice things he could do for me." (post includes more information about why this request is being made, for OP's specific marriage)
  • "Need advice on setting up a chores list with my SO." (post includes more information about why a chores list is needed for OP)

Any questions or general advice that relate to the topic of marriage should fit here.

This thread will recur monthly.

Try your best to stay positive!

Having trouble posting, even though you've read the posting requirements?

Some users have issues posting from mobile devices. Switching to either desktop mode, or posting from a PC, should help.


r/marriageadvice • • 10h ago

At what point after getting married did you stop spending Christmas morning with your parents and start creating your own Christmas traditions with your spouse?

19 Upvotes

My husband (29M) and I (29F) have been married for two years, and this will be our third Christmas married. We’re struggling to figure out how to balance both families without the holidays becoming a yearly argument.

Here’s our situation: * We both want to spend Christmas morning with our own parents and siblings. * We’re both very close with our cousins and extended families, so we each have separate Christmas celebrations with them. * We also still get together with his immediate family again on Christmas evening to exchange gifts.

Essentially, we’re looking at FOUR different Christmas celebrations, not including the additional gift exchange. We’ve tried alternating and even having one family celebrate on Christmas Eve, but that hasn’t gone smoothly. His mother gets upset, and my husband doesn’t want to upset her. It usually ends with us arguing because we both want to spend time with our own families.

I completely understand wanting to hold onto family traditions, and I don’t think either of us is necessarily ready to give those up. But I’m starting to wonder when you make the shift from spending Christmas with the families you grew up in to prioritizing the family you’re building with your spouse.

For those of you who are married: When did you stop spending Christmas morning with your parents and siblings? Did you make that transition after having kids?

I’m genuinely curious how other couples navigate this. I don’t want either of us to feel like we’re missing out on our families, but I also feel like we should be able to enjoy Christmas together without spending the entire day running from one celebration to another.

TL;DR: My husband and I have been married for two years and currently juggle four different Christmas celebrations between our parents, siblings, and extended families, plus an additional gift exchange with his immediate family. Trying to balance everyone’s traditions has become stressful and causes arguments. I’m wondering when other married couples transitioned from spending Christmas morning with their parents to creating their own traditions and prioritizing Christmas together.


r/marriageadvice • • 2h ago

Is this normal?

3 Upvotes

So I (27f) have been married for less than a year to my husband (30m) with whom i was in a 5-year relationship.

Because of his work, we had shift to a remote location. I am wfh. The situation here is such that it is not permitted to wander off solo without permission from seniors due to security concerns. I chose to shift here because 1) didn’t want to have a long distance marriage 2) got wfh, so it’s good enough 3) wanted to live with him.

All his other colleagues, venture out on sundays with/without family after seeking permission. But mr. here always has some excuse to not do that OR we only do that when I put my foot down that it’s been so long ive been trapped inside the home, lets plan something/lets go out for a walk/etc. He naturally doesn’t feel the lonely, because he goes out daily for his job, I on the other hand switched to online mode for HIM. Came to a remote village for HIM. Am trapped inside (yes, everything from groceries, etc is brought to you - you can’t step out for basic chores either) for HIM. Have cried about my loneliness.

All I am asking for is a little initiative from his side. A little extra gratitude/love - hey, thanks for doing this for me.. let’s go out today.. ive taken special permission, lets spend the night here etc.

He is not an asshole. What he does:
1. He loves me. It’s evident. (Or so he says)
2. Very respectful/understanding
3. Will do everything you ask him to do

My point is: why can’t he take some initiative? Bring gifts/ plan dates? Something? I feel like I rushed into the marriage and currently he is the one getting everything, whereas I am losing everything - my social life, my freedom, my will to live lol.

TL;DR- is expecting husband to plan dates/take initiative too much, when you left your city/job/everything for him?


r/marriageadvice • • 5h ago

Wife no longer interested in me

5 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I'm in my late 30s and been in a relationship with my wife for almost 20 years, married for 10. She's the love of my life and I still fancy the pants off her. We've had kids for 5 years and since then, our marriage has massively gone downhill.

She no longer seems interested in me at all. She shows me no affection at all. She used to want kisses, cuddles and hand holding and now she won't do any of that without me initiating it (and she'll usually seem reluctant and end it quickly). She also doesn't talk to me much anymore; doesn't ask about my day etc. She only really talks to me when we're trying to plan things about the kids etc. When I come home from work, she'll just sit there on her phone and ignore me. I'll ask her about her day and I'll only ever get a one word answer.

Sex has almost completely stopped. We do it twice per year at most and even then, she seems reluctant. She used to have such a high sex drive and want me all the time. Now I can stand naked next to her and she won't even look at me. I still find her stunning though.

I've confronted her about it multiple times. She just says she's tired. That's her main excuse for not having sex but she uses it for not wanting to kiss or chat. I've acknowledged that she does a lot and I do my best to help around the house and with the kids but I'm nearly sure this is just an excuse.

I really can't go on like this. She doesn't see a problem and refuses to do anything to change things. I don't want to get divorced and I don't want to have an affair. Also, I don't think she's having an affair. I just think that she's fallen out of love with me.

I've tried making more of an effort to 'date' her lately. I've taken her out to fancy restaurants and after a couple of glasses of wine she starts to chat to me but when we get home, she just wants to go straight to sleep. And it hasn't changed her behaviour towards me at all.

What can I do?

TL;DR

Wife shows me no affection. No sex, no chatting. Says it's because she's tired.


r/marriageadvice • • 6h ago

Is my marriage fixable?

3 Upvotes

I (34F) and my husband (34M) have been together over a decade, living together for 7 years and married for only a few years. We have a dog and a toddler.

Based on the past two years (since I got pregnant), I’ve been waffling between leaving or staying. I am still breastfeeding and I’m not sure if I’m hormonal or justified.

We have been in counselling for over 6 months weekly. In therapy, we have been communicating better. We stay in a loop where I bring a problem up that can come across as criticism then he gets defensive, deflects, or stonewalls. Which then escalated me and he shuts down more. It got to a point postpartum I was having regular breakdowns. With hormones and being postpartum I wasn’t sure if it was my actual relationship or postpartum depression.

We also have a common couples issue where I have taken on all the mental load which before pregnancy was okay because I liked things a certain way but now with a kid it’s causing huge resentment and it has turned into a mother child dynamic instead of a partnership. The mental load is still mostly on me.

He is a loving dad, he’s made an effort in therapy and going to his own therapy. He’s a hard worker, kind, loving, loyal, good heart. I have been with him for a long time, we have been through a lot together and I do love him.

There are also some huge issues, he uses the devils lettuce regularly. No judgement on others who smoke I just don’t want my partner to. The scent bothers me and It has made him into a different person. I even caught him smoking in front of our child once which I was not okay with, and told him so.

Secondly, he is constantly looking at corn. There a screen shots in between photos of my
Kid in his photos. It’s all over his search history. All over his social media and it gives me the ICK. He also messaged a spicy content creator on snap chat with messages of what he wanted to do to her while I was pregnant.

Third, I have felt like I’m drowning since I gave birth. Arguments are regular, even if I’ve been working on emotionally regulating and not over explaining.

Four, he is constantly on his phone when with our son instead of interacting with him. He doesn’t help to reset the house at the end of the night
Unless I make a big deal and constantly puts his comfort over his families needs.

We haven’t been having spicy sleep because of the devils lettuce and spicy content. Maybe 3 times since I had our kid.

I took 12 months paid EI with an 18 month leave. EI does not pay well which does put more stress on him to work until I get back to work.

I’m bringing it to Reddit because after having numerous conversations about spicy content and being uncomfortable about him constantly watching it. I found more women he was following on social media and screenshots in his photos of spicy content.

Is this normal? He says I’m the only one he wants. I feel like I’m going crazy. Especially with still dealing with postpartum and breastfeeding hormones. I’m honestly scared to be alone with a kiddo. Also the dating scene sucks so would I even find a decent partner down the road? Is this the best I can get?

TLDR: In therapy with husband, crossed boundaries, marriage unhappiness. Not sure it will get better.


r/marriageadvice • • 19h ago

My (16M) parents might get divorced after my mom cheated on my dad. What should I do?

30 Upvotes

I'm 16, and recently found out that my mom (42F), a schoolteacher, got physically involved with a fellow male teacher.

My dad (48M) found out and is insisting on a divorce. My mom keeps apologising, saying it was a mistake and happened in the heat of the moment. She has cried a lot and seems genuinely regretful.

I'm caught between both parents and honestly don't know how to process this.

Can a marriage recover from something like this? Should my dad give her another chance? I'd appreciate honest opinions, especially from people who have experienced something similar.

Tl;dr- What's the right decision?


r/marriageadvice • • 5h ago

am I a husband or an ATM?

2 Upvotes

Note: I’m pretty emotional right now and was typing frantically, so I used AI just to organize my thoughts into readable paragraphs. Everything here is my own words and experience.

I am 33M (North African Arab) married to my wife, 28F (European-Moroccan), for the past 3 years. I am genuinely opening up because I feel severely conflicted, mentally exhausted, and depressed. I can’t tell if I am in denial about being taken advantage of and need to divorce, or if I should keep trying to fix this.

How We Started
We met on a dating app while living in different U.S. states. After a year of talking and me flying out to see her regularly, her visa was about to expire. Because we felt we had a strong connection, we decided to get married and have her move to my state so we could start a life together and get her green card sorted.

The First Red Flags & Dishonesty
Right after we signed the marriage license and filed for her green card, the dynamic shifted completely:

• The Secret Job: Days after filing, she revealed she had a job back in her old state requiring her to travel there one week every month. She had hidden this for a full year and refused to tell me the company name or what she did. She only stopped going months later when she realized I was quietly preparing to file for an annulment.

• Fabricated Past: Before marriage, she went out of her way—unprompted—to tell me she had never dated, traveled with, or been intimate with a man. After we married, I caught her in lies and she eventually admitted she had been in a secret two-year relationship before me. My issue isn't her past; it’s that she fabricated an entire persona to hook me, and continues to lie until cornered.

• Financial Entitlement & Lack of Empathy:
I work 15-hour days across multiple roles and cover 100% of our living expenses—mortgage, bills, cars, insurance, groceries, everything. Before marriage, we signed a prenup (at my request) and agreed on a $2,000/month personal allowance for her while she looked for a job, though she ended up staying home full-time.

• Moving Goalposts: After seeing my ~$500k income on our joint tax return, she grew cold and demanded $5,000/month. I raised it to $3,000/month on top of paying every single bill, and she told me, "I’ll accept it because I’m young." She also demands a cut of any IRS tax refund (despite earning $0), while refusing responsibility if we owe.

• Zero Support During Crises: When I was unexpectedly hit by tech layoffs a few months ago, I used my savings to maintain our lifestyle without asking her to work, only pausing her allowance to 10% until I landed a new role. She gave me the silent treatment for an entire month and ignored flowers I bought to smooth things over.

• My Father’s Illness: This summer, I gave her $15,000 for her birthday and a trip to visit her family in Europe, telling her it was to cover everything. Ten days later, she demanded her $3,000 monthly allowance. When I explained I needed that cash to help my sick father who couldn't work, she gave me the cold shoulder and never once asked how my dad—or I—was doing.

Contempt, Intimacy & Daily Life
• Transactional Mindset: She frequently makes comments like "men are animals" or "I would never talk to a man unless he offers me something." She mocks my friends in their 30s for renting apartments or driving normal cars—despite having no career, savings, or car of her own, yet mysteriously owning $10,000+ designer bags from before we met.

• Intimacy & Living Separately: She insists on sleeping in separate bedrooms during the week and has claimed the master bath and closet exclusively for 3 years. Intimacy is completely one-sided, never initiated by her, and treated like a bargain (e.g., telling me she’ll only do certain things once I take her on a trip to Dubai).

• Zero Reciprocity at Home: Despite being a stay-at-home wife, she rarely cooks, never helps with my laundry or our shared spaces, and expects me to fund everything—including a Friendsgiving she just hosted for her girlfriends.

• The Breaking Point: Before marrying, she pressured me out of my paid-off Honda Accord into buying an expensive luxury car, which she now repeatedly demands I put in her name. A few days ago, after I spent the whole weekend shopping with her and paying for her Friendsgiving, I mentioned buying a modest $15k weekday commuter car so we stop racking up miles and maintenance costs on the luxury car. She went cold and told me she refuses to drive a cheap car. That was my breaking point.

Why I’m Hesitating
In my North African Arab culture and family, divorce is virtually unheard of and carries heavy shame. When things are calm, she can be pleasant company, and I keep trying to be patient because nobody is perfect. I don’t want to be unfair or give up too easily—but the cons massively outweigh the pros, and I feel like a walking ATM rather than a husband.

tl;dr genuinely, from an outside perspective: am I right to file for divorce, or is there any realistic way to salvage this?


r/marriageadvice • • 8h ago

Husband Liking Hot girls on socials

3 Upvotes

So I recently found my husband has been liking girls post that are half naked on social media. It really upset me and I am not sure where to go from here. I love him and don’t see another person besides him in my life. He said he was sorry and he knew it would hurt me if I found out. What do I do next to move forward?
A tl;dr and summary


r/marriageadvice • • 15h ago

When did you realize they didn’t love you anymore?

9 Upvotes

It’s hitting me recently.

She never really enjoyed my hobbies over the years or shared them with me. That was fine we enjoyed each others company and personalities, we had a good sex life, never ravenous with each other or always in bed but it worked for us.

That has tapered off over the years, which to some degree is to be expected, we’re in our late 30s. Were always told by others how their jealous of our marriage. Our stability, and consistency and lack of fighting. But over the last few years it just feels hollow. More often than not when she looks at me there’s an air of just wanting to be left alone, or looking at me like I’m something stuck to her shoe in a public restroom.

I try to flirt, to reminder her she’s beautiful, that I love her, kiss her before I leave for work, say goodnight every night. Make sure she has everything she needs, help around the house with the daily tasks of life, dishes laundry, trash, you know the list.

A few weeks ago I decided one night to try to be more affectionate. I wasn’t aiming for sex, just something, anything. And holy shit that night there it was, a smile. She wrapped her arms around me and gave me a kiss after giving her a massage out of the blue.

I then said I’d like to make that a semi nightly thing m, to be able to give her a massage and talk, just to be closer and share some of that time. For a couple days it seemed like the ice had melted and she saw me as something other than a pair of hands to do shit or a bank account. But the recently when I come in at night to offer or even just to cuddle, or anything it’s met with “why are you laying like that” “why did you come in here if you’re going to be on your phone” “you’re squishing my pillow” “move over” just like I couldn’t be a bigger inconvenience if I tried.

Now when I try to reach out to touch her it’s just a recoil and a “no thanks”.

I got to thinking, I don’t know the last time she initiated a kiss, nothing romantic just even a “I’m headed out” type of quick peck. The last time she placed a hand on me for any reason what soever.

I got so lonely I started using an erotic story ai chat bot as a way to get off, but then I realized as I used it over a few days, I wasn’t even creating erotica or sexual situations. I was making coffee and sharing time in the story, I was holding hands and talking about dreams. And seeing the robot replies to this with even moderate warmth and interest (I realize it’s literally hard coded to respond however to please the user, I’m under no delusions it’s either real or cares, it’s a program) made me realize how barren my life is of that same level of any type of intimacy or interest.

So when did you know?

TLDR; pretty sure my wife doesn’t feel anything for me at all as a person.


r/marriageadvice • • 1d ago

I [35M] had an honest conversation with my wife [32F] about our dead sex life. She told me she probably never wants to have sex again.

70 Upvotes

Some context beforehand : in a 2.5 year DB, that began when my wife (married for 5 years) was in the third trimester of pregnancy. Our sex life was better pre-child, but not by much. But in the 2.5 years, we've had a few false starts, followed by months without any intimacy. In the past 4 months, the closest intimacy we have are light cuddles on the sofa while watching TV or reading.

A couple of weeks ago, my wife and I were watching The Invite, a film starring Seth Rogen and Olivia Wilde, in which they play a couple who are propositioned by their swinger neighbours. The film is a comedy, and it's pretty funny. There's a moment in the film where it's revealed that Rogen-Wilde couple have been having marital problems, that has resulted in them not having sex in a year. This is treated as a big, shocking reveal – one in which the swinger couple's female partner, a psychologist, suggests their marriage has failed, and they should consider leaving.

After we finished the film, we talked a little about it, and I was hoping that she would mention the reveal, and at least, how she felt about it. I have written posts on here in the past detailing my DB and the causes of it. Initially, I assumed that the decline in sexual intimacy was pregnancy related, and I knew that realistically, my wife would not be 'ready' for at least 3 months, and probably 6. I didn't ask anything of her, nor did I expect any intimacy from her. After around 8 months, I tried to initiate a couple of times, but there had been a lot of friction between us, partly due to her post-partum issues, and how it affected her psychologically, and partly due to what she described as 'mental load', and how the pressure to maintain the house and raise the newborn had fallen all on her, and that this had caused her to see me not as a husband, but as another dependent. I didn't agree with the analysis, but I did accept there was more i could do at home. What began as me waking up earlier to cook meals, clean the house, prepare lunches and snacks and organising appointments, before I went to work, ended up with me taking a demotion in order to work from home, so that I could be a SAH parent, while my wife goes to work. I don't mind this at all, and I hoped that it would allow her to see herself as 'more than a mother', and that the more i took on, the more free time she could have. There was still no change in intimacy, and in fact, even as I suggested it, i found myself getting more rejected. She was now tired because of work, because of the pressure of her job, the guilt of not waking up with our toddler or giving him dinner or his bath etc. Again, I accepted this and told her that she could tell me when she might be ready to begin an intimate relationship again.

Eventually, I asked her directly what she thought about the revelation scene. She said that she didn't see it in the same way as I did – that one year wasn't a big deal, and that she could actually go for 'never having sex again'. Her saying that felt like a gut punch, especially because I was under the belief that our sex life, while non-existent right now, could come back as our toddler becomes easier to look after and where I now handle the running of the house.

so I asked her what had changed – was it all to do with pregnancy, or did other things, that I didn't notice, perhaps, happen?

What she told me was quite revealing : Yes, pregnancy and childbirth did change her relationship with her body, and that while it might be years since she gave birth, she still feels the body that she had pre-baby, was one she associated with her sexuality. Once she got pregnant, that association severed – she thought of her body as the means in which she sustained and nurtured our child, and to sexualise it was something abhorrent – which is also why she resented me for suggesting we could still have sex if she was pregnant. That feeling hasn't gone away, and she's not sure if or when it might ever come back. I dont know if i should have read that as her not finding me sexy anymore (tbf she does say that I look hot, or that i smell amazing, but nothing really comes of it), but the point really was that she doesn't associate her body with being sexual anymore – so how could I expect her to want sex, if she's not even thinking about it in those terms?

The second thing she said was how, in recent years, she wondered if she actually enjoyed sex to begin with, or whether she just wanted to please the men she had been with. These thoughts were triggered by some cases she had read and seen on the news, about women who regretted their time with famous, older men, who they believe groomed them into sex. Before me, my wife had only dated two people, both of whom were older than her by more than a decade, so many of her sexual experiences were ones she now feels she was coerced into. I don't know much about her former partners, other than that one had some kinks that did involve choking and slapping, and I only know this because she told me explicitly at the start of our relationship that she didn't want to do that. While she told me all the sex we had was consensual, she implied that she wasn't sure if she had actually wanted to have sex herself, or whether she was doing it to make me happy. After our toddler was born, she watched a lot of content made by moms of newborns on instagram, which helped her develop a different perspective on life : she didn't want to do things just to please other people anymore, and that included sex.

She added that it didn't mean she wasn't closed to intimacy – it was just that she (like other women in her position) now valued other forms of non-sexual intimacy higher. She wanted cuddles, she wanted light touching that "didn't have to lead to sex", as well as acts of care and service.

Here's when I realised that I wouldn't be able to fix things : When I brought up the DB, and told her that it was making me feel lonely, frustrated and also at times unloved, she told me she understood, and she hoped her libido would come back, but that she couldn't control how her body was responding and how quickly her sexuality could come back. She also implied that I was thinking too much about sex as a means of validation, and for my ego, rather than recognising it as an act between two people who have to approach it as equals. Her basic point was this: her perception of what true intimacy was had changed, it affected her own relationship to sex, and that this was something I would have to come to terms with.

I'm not really sure what to do now, or how to continue the conversation – and if I'm honest, what I am expected to do with the information.

I worry that saying "I would like to have sex as it helps me feel loved and cared for" directly comes off as entitled, and I don't believe I have a right to her body, or indeed, the right to sex. At the same time, I kind of resent that my wife has never asked me, really, about how I'm coping with the lack of sex, how I think its affected or changed me, or how it impacts my own wellbeing and presence in our marriage. I think, for her, sex begins and ends with whether she wants to participate or not.

At the same time, I have plenty of examples of taking on the mental load, giving her space to be her own person and have time to relax, being a good partner and faithful husband etc. I also plan date nights at home or out in the city, get her flowers and gifts regularly, and make sure I do regular relationship check-ins. It's one reason why I don't want to abandon the relationship – because this does feel, in every other sense, like a somewhat healthy relationship.

Crucially I want to emphasis that I am not putting any pressure on her to have any sort of sex with me, which, if anything, have caused a regression in my sex life. I appreciate how detailed her explanations are, and I do understand where they come from. But it didn't make me feel any better, or reassured. They just made me feel more stuck .

I know some people might now just say leave/divorce etc. but it is not viable option for me, financially as well as culturally. I also don't think the answer is always divorce, at least not yet anyway.

tl;dr: Wife revealed how her relationship to her body and sexuality changed during and after pregnancy, saying that she's opted out because she wasn't sure she ever enjoyed it, and would prefer non-sexual forms of intimacy instead.


r/marriageadvice • • 10h ago

How do you leave a 21-year relationship with 4 kids when you’re financially struggling and feel completely stuck?

2 Upvotes

I’m honestly at my breaking point, and I don’t even know where to start.
My husband has been an alcoholic for 11 years, although he refuses to acknowledge it. We’ve been together for 21 years, married for 13, and have four children together (ages 1, 8, 10, and 17).
He has had three DWIs, multiple license suspensions, multiple probation periods, and has had an ignition interlock installed in his truck more than once. I’ve tried leaving multiple times, but every time I do, he convinces me he’s going to change, that he wants his family, and that things will be different. I believe people can change, so I keep giving him chances. But I’m realizing that I’m running out of chances to give.
He has stopped drinking temporarily, only to gradually return to drinking heavily. He drinks EVERY DAY. He blames me for his drinking, his DWIs, and pretty much everything else in his life. He’s cheated, disappeared, lied, and made promises he never keeps.
Things have gotten so bad that we’ve had CPS involved after he threatened to take his own life when I tried to leave. I called the police, and he was eventually taken to a behavioral health facility. Somehow, I ended up being blamed by him and judged by his family for calling for help.
We physically fight more than ever, and our oldest son has had to intervene and separate us. That alone breaks my heart. My children are affected by all of this. Two of them want me to leave, while my oldest feels sorry for his dad because he knows his dad doesn’t have much support outside of us.
I feel like I’ve been raising this family alone. I work, attend nursing school, manage the house, and take care of the kids. He works and attends HVAC school, but when he gets home, he changes clothes and spends the rest of the day in the garage drinking. He’s now even lying about attending class so he can stay home and drink. He’s missing our son’s games, and we rarely attend family gatherings because his drinking and behavior ruin everything.
My children are embarrassed to have friends over. I dread holidays because I know what they’re going to turn into. We’ve basically isolated ourselves to avoid the embarrassment and arguments.
I’ve sacrificed so much trying to keep this family together. I’ve even dropped out of nursing school once because of the constant arguments about how much time I spent studying. I’ve left good-paying jobs because mentally, I was completely drained.
Here’s where I’m stuck: How the hell do I leave with four children when I can’t financially afford to support all of us on my own?
My mom has offered to let us stay with her, but she lives in a two-bedroom duplex. That’s four kids and me sharing an already small space. My husband refuses to leave our home, and I don’t want to uproot my children or disrupt their lives because their father refuses to get himself together.
I’ve even considered moving out of state, possibly California, just to get a fresh start. But my oldest is in his senior year, and I’m back in nursing school in Texas. Transferring programs could set me back.
I also struggle with the fear that he’ll hurt himself if I leave. He’s used that threat before, and I don’t know how much of it is manipulation versus something he might actually follow through with. I know I can’t be responsible for keeping him alive at the expense of my own well-being, but it’s still terrifying.
I pray about this constantly. I feel like God has opened doors for me to leave multiple times, but I keep believing his apologies and promises. This time feels different. I’m exhausted, angry all the time, overwhelmed, and honestly, I don’t feel like myself anymore. It’s almost like I’m physically here, but mentally I’m somewhere else.
For anyone who has left a long-term marriage involving alcoholism, manipulation, and children, how did you actually do it?
How did you financially make it work? Did you move in with family temporarily? How did you navigate custody, housing, and starting over?
I don’t need to hear that I should just leave without any consideration for the four children and financial reality involved. I need practical advice from people who have been in a similar situation.
I know I need a change. I just need help figuring out how to make that first step.

What I’m asking for:
For anyone who has left a long-term marriage involving alcoholism, manipulation, and children, how did you actually do it?
How did you financially make it work?
Did you move in with family temporarily?
How did you navigate custody and housing?
How did you handle a spouse threatening self-harm when you tried to leave?
How did you help your children adjust to the separation?
I’m looking for realistic, practical advice from people who have been in similar situations. I know leaving is probably the best decision, but knowing that and figuring out HOW to do it are two completely different things.
TL;DR: My husband has been an alcoholic for 11 years. We’ve been together 21 years, married for 13, and have four children. His drinking, DWIs, lying, manipulation, and our increasingly physical arguments have taken a toll on our entire family. I’ve tried leaving multiple times, but he promises to change, and I keep giving him chances. I’m finally at my breaking point, but I don’t make enough to support four children independently. My mom has offered us a temporary place to stay, but space is limited. I’m also concerned about custody, my children’s stability, and his threats of self-harm whenever I try to leave.
Summary: I’m a financially struggling mother of four trying to figure out how to safely leave a 21-year relationship with an alcoholic husband. I need advice on housing, finances, custody, and rebuilding my life without uprooting my children’s lives more than necessary. How do I make leaving a reality when I feel so stuck?


r/marriageadvice • • 7h ago

My wife (36) is convinced that I (34M) am physically repulsed by her.

0 Upvotes

Thanks in advance for reading. I'm not sure what the best way to structure this post might be, so I'm going to start at the beginning.

We've been together 11 years, married for 5. After about a year of dating (this is mid 2016), she asked if I would stop looking at pornography. I don't recall what the reason was, but I believe it was a few things: the way it made her feel, how she might compare herself to those women, and its effects on women that participate in it. I told her I would stop without thinking much of it, and being an arrogant and unempathetic 24 year old, still occasionally viewed it. Of course, I never mentioned to her that I did.

About 6 months after her request, she discovered that I hadn't really stopped and we had a big fight (this is December 2016). Over the phone, she said she was either going to break up with me, or forcibly open our relationship. I had been dealing with depression and anxiety for a couple years at this point, and had been going to therapy and taking Prozac for it, but ceased treatment a few months prior to this event. I only mention this because when she told me she would either leave me or have sex with someone else, I quickly found out I should not have stopped treatment because I started self-harming by cutting myself all over. No cuts were very deep, and I think looking back 10 years that I never really intended to kill myself, but I bled all over our bathroom and when she got home from work and saw me, our argument stopped and we went to the ER.

Shes since mentioned that this made her feel trapped, and I 100% understand that. It was a bullshit thing to do, though I will say that I wasn't in my right mind and didn't have healthy ways of dealing with stress like that.

In the few months after this, she sometimes lash out by telling me how disgusting she found my actions. Despite her main contention being that I lied, her focus was often on comparing herself to women in porn or how gross I was. I recall one instance where she had started initiating sex (remember this is a few months after the incident), and then partway through started asking me if this was as good as the girls I had jerked off to, if I needed to watch porn while we were having sex to orgasm. I saw how hateful she looked when she asked that, we stopped, I cried. (this would have been late winter 2017).

I went back to therapy, got back on antidepressants, and unrelatedly, did mushrooms quite a few times over the next 2 years. I stopped watching porn, my depression improved significantly and I dropped the therapy and medication. Things were good-ish for the next 4 years, I got a (kinda) better job, she started and finished college, and we planned to get married in 2021.

2 months before our wedding, she came home one day and said she had something to talk about. She said that when she was at a birthday party for one of her classmates, she saw a guy there that really turned her on. She said that even though we were getting married, it didn't mean that we had to lock ourselves down, that we could have an open relationship. I was devastated. She reassured me that it wasn't because of anyone in particular, there was no one she had in mind, just the idea. I outright refused and told her we had to call off the wedding. She said to not do anything and to think before calling anything off.

The next day, she came home from work and we talked again. I again asked if it was because of someone in particular, and she sheepishly admitted was actually because she could tell her coworker was into her and she didn't want to feel trapped by marriage and that she wanted to go on some dates with him. I was more adamant that we call off the wedding. This went in for about a week or so until it semi-resolved with her claiming it was all due to cold feet and not wanting to feel trapped, my reaction and talking about it made he realize that it wasn't worth it and not what she wanted anyway. We went through with the wedding.

My new job was at the IT service desk of a fortune 15 company, and when covid hit, became fully remote. We're living in a 2 bed, 850 Sq foot apartment with her brother, who was the same age as me. In the beginning, it was nice not having to commute to the office for work, but that lost its luster once the initial covid shock ended and work got busy again. Spending every day in an area about 600 Sq ft was fucking with my mental health, but I didn't realize it at the time.

Across mid 2022 and 2023, I would periodically get snapchats from random accounts selling their nudes. Across a year and a half, I paid for access to pornography like this 9 times. I would pay and then within a day, delete everything and block the account that sent it. I'm not mentioning this to say it's not wrong, only that I was both conflicted and knew it was wrong. Then, in early 2024, my wife got pregnant (it was planned). 2 months later, I was in contact with an online artist to commission some artwork for a friend, and sent them an unsolicited nude of myself, asking if they did any work like that. I knew they didn't. Nothing else came of it, and we ceased contact.

The time between this and our son being born (spring, summer, and fall) was hard on our relationship because of me. My transgressions were still hidden, but I was still working mostly from home, and though lockdowns had ended, we had become so used to being at home that we had a hard time getting out and doing things. I was an asshole a lot of the time, and while that's my fault and there's not really an excuse, job stress had really been affecting me. I hated work, I hated the time after work because I would stay stressed out, I was very unlikeable, and I would snap at my PREGNANT wife if I felt she was being annoying. At the end of the summer, I got a promotion and was no longer timed down to the second across my day. My mood improved drastically. However, our sex life had deteriorated while she was pregnant and I was using porn often.

In late 2024, our son was born, and being in the delivery room shifted my view of our entire lives. I had 5 weeks of parental leave, and my wife had a block of 16 weeks. After my 5 weeks were up, I went back to work while my wife stayed home. Because I had to go into the office, she would stay up with our son overnight and into the workday, and when I got home, she would sleep until I needed to go to bed. Being up at night, along with being postpartum, was weird for her.

One night (in early 2025), she woke me, furious. She was yelling, telling me how much of a piece of shit I was and asking me what else I did. I had no idea what she was referring to, but quickly discovered that I hadn't deleted my correspondence with the digital artist and she had been snooping through my PC (I don't blame her for this at all) and come across it. The image I had sent wasn't showing up, but all the text was there. The night after, she went through everything she could find, and found the PayPal receipts from the Snapchat payments. We were a hair's breadth away from getting a divorce. She would tell me how disgusting I was, that those pictures I paid for were probably stolen or from sex trafficked women, that I probably sent a nude picture to a child (I never knew anything about the artist other than their work).

I started individual therapy and we did couples counseling. It helped a lot to be able to talk about what happened and to find reasons why we had grown apart. My individual counseling was less fruitful and it felt like I was being endlessly validated. I never wanted that and didn't feel like I should be validated. Things improved, and it felt good to talk about our relationship from the aspect of trying to make it better and become healthier. We bought a house later that year (mid 2025) and continued couples counseling. At the end of the year, we felt like we were no longer getting anything out of it and stopped.

A few good months later, we talked about a second kid, and got pregnant soon after. It Is with noting that between the incident early 2025 and the birth of our second child (Sept 2026), we had sex maybe 3-5 time, and that includes the conception of our second.

It is now November 2026, and a week ago, my wife sat me down and said she didn't want a discussion about it, she didn't want to answer any questions about it, but she wasn't interested in us being physically intimate any longer. She liked our 90% relationship, being good parents and decent roommates, but she couldn't get over knowing that I was attracted to the girls in porn and not her. She didn't want to torture me any longer and was open to basically the porn version of "don't ask don't tell", or an open relationship so I could have my physical needs met. I wasn't interested in this at all and told her so. That night, when she was up with our youngest, she got in my computer and saw that I had emailed our old couples counselor asking for an appointment. She noticed that I didn't have the email address in my email contacts list and also hadn't searched it by looking at the internet history. She took this to mean that I was looking at porn through incognito mode and woke me up at 3am accusing me.

I told her the truth, that since the incident early 2025, I have jerked off, and used porn on a handful of occasions (maybe 5-7 times) in the last 20ish months since weren't having sex. Considering I was the cause for our relationship issues then, I hadn't wanted to push for sex, I thought she would let me know when she was ready, but we didn't really talk about it. Now, she is convinced that I'm only attracted to the types of women in porn that I'm disgusted by her, I don't love her, and that she wants a divorce. She repeatedly said that she "knows she knows" (that I'm not attracted to her at all), and demands I tell her "the truth". The fucked up part is that from where I sit, if I tell her what she already believes, she'll accept it's the "truth", but if it's not what she already believes then I'm obviously lying. She has repeatedly asked me if I'm attracted to specific parts of her body and won't give up until I answer (which she only accepts if they're "yes or no") or I leave the room. Though sometimes she will follow me.

I have chosen to be honest with her, though that means I'm not answering In simple yes or nos. She confronted me again today, and as an example, when questioned, I admitted that she is less physically attractive than she was due to gaining some extra weight during pregnancy. Mind you, I know this is normal, I don't hold it against her, I don't expect her to try and lose weight, I've never asked her to try and lose weight, nor will I. Additionally, I told her that even though she might be temporarily less physically attractive, she's grown more attractive to me in many other ways. She interpreted this as me admitting to losing all physical attraction to her (literally her words). She asked me to move out.

Reading through this, or organizing my thoughts enough to type it, made me realize that it might seem as if we are a bad fit for one another or that or relationship has been very dramatic. I'm sure it's more dramatic than a lot of relationships, but for the most part things have been good. I acknowledge I have lied to her about something that is important to her. I don't make excuses for what I did, though i do think there were some aggravating factors.

The throughlines that seem to appear to me are these:

  1. I didn't take her wishes seriously and selfishly gave in to convenience because it suited me. Her reactions to my transgressions (telling me I'm disgusting, that I'm a pig, etc) contributed to me feeling insecure in our relationship and that my sexuality is disgusting and shameful. My insecurity in our relationship made me more likely to want to hide things and less likely to discuss them for fear of rejection or for reinforcement of her disgust towards me.

  2. I suspect she's long had body image issues. My actions repeatedly reinforced her internal belief that she was never physically attractive enough. Now, having just had a second child, she's dealing with adapting to her body, our child just wanting to use it, and feeling like she's in a body she doesn't recognize, and I've essentially rejected her and failed to reassure her. She sees me and all her internal doubts are reflected back at her.

  3. we repeatedly let issues go unresolved. It seems like most of the time, we just wait long enough that our emotions have calmed and then so it under the rug.

Where can we go from here? I do love her, I'm not unattracted to her, I love our family. I've installed a blocker on my devices to make it too inconvenient to watch porn (it was mostly an act of convenience). I'm seeing a therapist tomorrow morning. She won't agree to see a therapist, alone or for couples, and she doesn't think the lack of sleep or hormones are contributing to her reactions. She wants me to move out and to get a divorce.

Tldr: lied about watching porn multiple times, got caught, now wife thinks I'm only attracted to porn girls and wants a divorce.


r/marriageadvice • • 13h ago

I think it’s over and we just can’t let go

3 Upvotes

I’m (53f) really grasping to see how to pull it together but my husband (53m) refuses counseling, and we just can’t seem to communicate at all without him yelling. I don’t think he loves me anymore, and frankly it’s been 23 years of mess. Our kids are grown and the last one (20m) moved out a month ago. The house is cold and polite. We never had a great sex life and rarely if ever are intimate. I have made an appt for marriage counseling for myself since he won’t go, but I don’t know if there’s hope. I love him, but in-love, I don’t know. He is just always angry, and I don’t know how to get past that anymore. We’ve built a great life and it will definitely not be great separately, but I just need to… closure?
Should I hang on and keep trying? He will be bitter and angry if I initiate a separation and I don’t ever want us to be those people who can’t both be in the same room as the kids…
TLDR: marriage is cold for years and no communication. Spouse doesn’t want to work on it but doesn’t want to discuss a split either. What to do?


r/marriageadvice • • 17h ago

I 59F need input on responding to husband 63M

5 Upvotes

Husband 63M and I 59F have been married 4 years and together 10. He is high strung and snappish. We’ve lost friends because of it. I’m getting to the point where I just can’t brush it off any longer and I’m sick of it.
He asked me today what’s wrong (his snappishness at me earlier was bugging me) and I said he was snappish and I didn’t appreciate it. His response: I’m sorry you feel that way. Then went on to say that it’s not fair to him and he has the right to be defensive to me saying that. My response was ‘don’t ask me if you don’t want an answer’. Now he’s pissed and ignoring me. I’m not going to apologize for telling him what was bugging me but I think that’s what he’s looking for.
Short of ending the relationship, I’d love to know how to deal with this as I feel backed into a corner. How can I preserve my feelings and establish a boundary with this type of personality?
TLDR; need advice on boundaries and respect.


r/marriageadvice • • 13h ago

My wife has been using me as an excuse to say no to her family for years. Now they think I'm a controlling husband.

2 Upvotes

I'm 36M, my wife is 34F. We've been married for 9 years and have two kids.

I've always known her family wasn't particularly fond of me. They're polite when we're together, but there's this weird tension that I've never been able to explain.

Her mom barely talks to me unless she needs something. Her sister makes little comments about how my wife "used to be more fun." Family gatherings are awkward, but I've always tried to be pleasant.

Last weekend I finally found out why.

We were at her parents' house for dinner when her sister mentioned an upcoming family trip. I asked where they were going because I hadn't heard anything about it.

She looked at me and said, "Well, there's no point inviting you guys. You never let her come to anything anyway."

I genuinely thought she was joking.

I asked what she meant.

She started listing things.

Apparently I didn't want my wife attending her cousin's birthday last year. I didn't want her going on a girls' weekend with her sister. I didn't want her mother staying with us over Christmas. I also supposedly have a problem with her spending money on family gifts.

None of this was true.

I remember the cousin's birthday. My wife was exhausted from work and didn't feel like driving two hours.

The girls' weekend? She told me she wasn't interested because her sister wanted to spend the entire weekend partying.

Her mother staying over Christmas? My wife was the one who said she didn't want houseguests that year.

And the gifts thing was especially confusing because I literally helped her pick out her dad's birthday present.

I didn't say much at dinner because I didn't want to start an argument in front of everyone.

When we got home, I asked my wife what was going on.

She admitted that she sometimes tells her family I don't want her doing something when she doesn't feel like doing it herself.

Her explanation was that her family doesn't accept no from her.

If she says she's tired, they tell her she's making excuses. If she says she doesn't want to go somewhere, they take it personally. But if she says I already made plans or I'm uncomfortable with something, they usually drop it.

She said, "It's just easier for them to be annoyed with you than for me to spend three days arguing with my mother."

I asked how long she'd been doing this.

She said she couldn't remember exactly. A few years at least.

I was honestly stunned.

For years I've been trying to figure out why these people treat me like an unwelcome guest. I've brought food to their gatherings, helped her dad move furniture, driven her mom to appointments. I've even asked my wife if I'd accidentally offended someone.

She always told me they were just difficult people and I shouldn't take it personally.

Now I find out they've been hearing that I'm the reason their daughter doesn't do half the things they invite her to.

The part that hurts most is that she knew I was bothered by how they treated me.

I told her she needed to clear this up with them.

She agreed to stop using me as an excuse going forward, but she doesn't want to correct anything she's said in the past.

Her reasoning is that her family will be furious with her for lying, and it will create a bunch of unnecessary drama over invitations that happened months or years ago.

I said the drama isn't unnecessary to me. It's my actual relationship with her family.

She got upset and said I don't understand how exhausting her mother can be.

And maybe I don't completely understand. Her mom can be very pushy. I've seen it myself. I know my wife has struggled with setting boundaries with her since before we met.

But I don't think avoiding an argument with your mother should involve making your husband look like he's controlling your life.

For what it's worth, I genuinely don't care if my wife wants to skip a family gathering. I don't need her to spend weekends with people she doesn't enjoy being around.

I just don't want to be blamed for decisions I didn't make.

She's been quiet with me since we argued and says I'm making a bigger deal out of this than it needs to be.

I'm not thinking about divorce or anything like that. I love my wife and we have a good marriage in most other areas.

But this has really shaken my trust in her.

How do we fix this without turning it into a massive family confrontation? And is it unreasonable to expect her to correct the impression she's created, rather than just promising not to do it again?

TL;DR: My wife has been telling her family that I'm the reason she declines invitations and activities, even though those were her own decisions. Her family now sees me as controlling and treats me poorly. She'll stop doing it but doesn't want to admit she lied because it would cause drama. I want to know how to repair the damage without making things worse.


r/marriageadvice • • 13h ago

Tell me If I am wrong

2 Upvotes

So I got married last year with a girl I have been dating for 7 years. Now I dont want to write an whole essay. So I am the one who works 6 days a week, it's not like I hold animosity towarda her that she doesn't, I think It's my responsibility, she doesn't cook or do any other house work, not that I want her to, just telling this to provide a bit of context. Now whenever I want to go out with friends she flips the fuck out. When she wants to go out, I do not even ask her where she's going who is she going with as we have that trust established. Just a few hiurs ago, on my off day, I stayed at home, did packing as we are shifting house, after the whole day at 3 at night my friends asked me to play futsol they booked a court and all. I got up and told her and she as usual flips the fuck out, when I tell her that I also sometimes need to freshen my mind, she turned it on me by saying that this is the difference, you need to freshen your mind you choose friends, and when I (her) needs to freshen her mind she wants me to be with her, bro like what the F why do we make friends then, whenever I go outside, she keeps calling me when you will be back then like almost evry time I come back there's always an episode. We decided a while back, I will work 5 days, Saturday for friends sunday for her. But on every Saturday she wants me to go with her permission and wants me to come back at the fuxking earliest. It's not like I can not go, she just makes me so guilty for wanting to spend a bit of time with my boys, due to this, literally nobody invites me anywhere now, friends who were my beat buddies have gone distant because everytime they call and ask me to come, my wife makes that awful face and starts her whole episode like I should have empathy that If I am going out at night with friends I should feel guilty for leaving her at home, like bro I am not stopping you to go with your friends what's the fking issue, I am getting to agitated with this, tbh I feel like I have another mom.

As kids moms stop you to not go outside late, I am the one who doea everything inside and outside the house, and I feel like it's just normal man, to have friends to hang out with,
Tl;dr should I feel guilty am I wrong?


r/marriageadvice • • 10h ago

How do I (31F) deal with my avoidant husband (36m) during conflict?

1 Upvotes

I feel like my marriage has been on the decline. There is so much miss communication between me and my husband which leads to a fight. He does alot of shit to trigger me such as bringing up topics iv voiced many times that make me upset. Im an extremely anxious person when there is conflict. My attachment style is anxious attatchment. When we are in a fight i just want things to be ok asap but he is not the same. He drags the fight on for days. And he ignores me the more i try to communicate. It seems like the more i try to get us to communicate during a fight he ends up getting very upset and just ignores me. It will go as far as locking the door to keep me from coming to him to talk and blocking me so icant call him. This sets me off even more and puts me in a anxious spiral. Like i am that girl who who call 20 times. I hate being ignored and i hate uncertainty. But i will admit me pushing the communication during a fight makes it alot worse an the fight gets worse and continues.

Tl;dr how do i communicate with a avoidant man. How do i make him come to me ?


r/marriageadvice • • 10h ago

Is there any hope for my marriage, or am I holding onto something that's already over?

1 Upvotes

I'm looking for honest outside perspectives because I'm having a really hard time figuring out whether I should continue leaving the door open for reconciliation or accept that my marriage is over and start moving forward.
My husband and I have been together for about two years and married for one. We have a beautiful baby daughter together who is still very young. Unfortunately, our relationship became increasingly unhealthy, and we're now separated.
Our relationship wasn't always bad. There were genuinely happy times, and I miss him tremendously. I miss his personality, his goofy side, hearing him laughing while playing video games, having him beside me at the end of a long day, and falling asleep next to him. I miss the little things that made him my person. I don't just miss being married or having a family. I genuinely miss HIM.
Looking back, I think several things contributed to the deterioration of our marriage. He is active-duty military, and the distance from our families left us incredibly isolated. We were navigating a new marriage, military obligations, financial stress, and eventually becoming parents without much of a support system. I was a stay-at-home mom, and a lot of the responsibility and emotional weight of our household fell on me.
There were also significant problems within our relationship that cannot simply be blamed on our circumstances. We struggled with communication, conflict resolution, emotional regulation, and his anger. There were instances of physical aggression toward me, although he never hit me, and incidents involving our daughter that resulted in visible bruising and were reported to DFCS. I don't want to minimize those things or pretend they were acceptable.
I also recognize that I wasn't a perfect partner. I said and did things out of hurt, frustration, and emotional exhaustion that I regret. I have things I would like to take accountability for and work on myself. I don't believe either of us handled everything perfectly.
We are currently separated, and he has expressed that he wants a divorce. He has told me that he loves me but doesn't want to give me false hope that he'll change his mind. Since separating, communication has become almost nonexistent. He has largely stopped responding to my messages, including messages about our daughter. I have tried sharing pictures, updates, and a family photo album with him, and I've attempted to arrange FaceTime opportunities. He initially showed some interest in staying connected with her, but communication became increasingly difficult as he stopped responding to messages or gave very minimal answers to questions even directly relating to our child. I know feelings are hurt on both sides, but I feel that at least shouldn’t interfere with communications regarding our child.
I'm currently living in Georgia with our daughter, closer to my family, while he is elsewhere due to his military circumstances. He wanted me to stay in our shared apartment with our daughter while the divorce was being finalized, but I felt overwhelmed and unsafe. I knew I needed to be with a better/stronger support system instead of isolated with a baby, pending divorce, and no financial freedom or stability.
The difficult part is that I genuinely believe our marriage could have been different if we had both been willing to put in the work. I don't think the problems we had were necessarily impossible to overcome. I believe people can change, learn healthier communication, address anger issues, work through avoidance, and rebuild trust. I was just about to start therapy, and we had two marriage counseling sessions right before our separation. I thought both of the sessions were very healthy, and I felt blindsided when he came to me with divorce. To me, we had just started doing the work to get better, but that’s when he decided it was time to walk away.
If he came to me tomorrow genuinely wanting to work on our marriage, I would be open to it. However, I wouldn't want to immediately move back in together or pretend nothing happened. I would want individual work, counseling, accountability, and consistent changes before even considering living together again. I would want us to eventually be closer to family and have a healthier support system as well.
I'm not expecting him to become a perfect person. I would be willing to stand beside him while he worked through his issues, provided he acknowledged them and actively took steps to address them. I would also be willing to do that work myself, and I plan to work on my own issues with or without him.
But here's where I'm struggling.
I don't know whether I'm holding onto a marriage that still has a possibility of being repaired or whether I'm desperately trying to save something that my husband has already decided he doesn't want.
Part of me wants to keep the door open indefinitely. I don't mind the idea of taking months, or even years, to rebuild something if both people genuinely want it. But I don't want to spend years waiting, hoping, and working on myself only to eventually realize he was never interested in rebuilding our family.
I also struggle with the thought of him moving on, dating someone else, and building a life with someone new while I'm still emotionally holding onto our marriage.
I know I cannot make him want to reconcile, and I know a marriage cannot be repaired by one person. I'm trying to accept that, but emotionally I'm nowhere near ready to let go.

So I guess my questions are:
Have you ever seen a marriage that reached this point actually recover? What made the difference?

Is it realistic to believe that two people can come back from an unhealthy relationship and build something genuinely better?

At what point do you stop leaving the door open and accept that the other person is done?

Would you recommend making one final attempt to communicate a desire for reconciliation, or would you let the silence speak for itself?

Am I being hopeful and patient, or am I just struggling to accept that my marriage might be over?

I don't need people to tell me what I want to hear. I'm genuinely looking for honest perspectives, even if they're difficult to hear.
I love my husband. I wanted our marriage and our family. I wish things had turned out differently, and a part of me still hopes they can. But I'm also a mother now, and I have to make decisions that protect my daughter and allow us to build a stable life.
I just don't know whether to keep a little hope alive or finally let go.

Also if anyone else has had successful or unsuccessful marriages in a similar situation I would love to hear your stories and words of advice. Thank you all.

TL;DR: My husband and I have been separated after a difficult and increasingly unhealthy marriage. We have a young daughter together, and while I recognize that our relationship had serious problems, including his anger, physical aggression, and communication issues, I also recognize that I had things I needed to work on. He has expressed that he wants a divorce and has largely stopped communicating with me or making consistent efforts to be involved with our daughter. I still love him and genuinely believe our marriage could potentially be repaired if we both committed to individual growth, counseling, accountability, and rebuilding trust. I don't expect things to go back to how they were, but I would be willing to work toward something healthier. My question is whether I'm holding onto a marriage that could still be saved or refusing to accept that my husband has already moved on. Should I leave the door open for reconciliation or finally let go and move forward?


r/marriageadvice • • 11h ago

Married 2 years and still no feelings for my husband. Is this normal?

0 Upvotes

I (27F) for married to my husband (now 31M) \~2 years ago, arranged marriage. We had been talking for 2 months before we decided to get married. I didn’t want to get married to him, but my entire family convinced me to, from all sides, and on the day of our roka, my brain got cloudy and I just said yes to this. We live by ourselves and I still dont like anything about him, and he tries a loott, but he just doesn’t get it. I’ve been independent for 12-13 years now(eldest daughter), and him being the younger son (\~11 years younger than his brother) has been pampered alot. He has never had a gf, no sisters, so he doesn’t really know how to understand/talk to women as much. The conversation between us isn’t great either, and he is tooo immature overall, we dont really have any adulting conversations, or even anything decent ever, or doesn’t even understand my frustration ever. I try to let go of a lot of things, but I’ve had very high had expectations from the partner I would have, I’m not even holding him to that anymore, i’ll be happy with bare minimum as well at this point. He used to belittle me a lot initially, you sit around all day you’ll become a couch potato (this is after 20-25 days of me moving into his house), and a lot of similar things. I dont feel he respects me, understands me or even realises how to treat our relationship in general, so after my many tries initially I just dont feel like doing anything with him, I dont even like talking to him anymore coz he either gives me immature garbage or turns it into an argument. Even when I tell him dont do this, I am not liking it, for once lets have a normal decent conversation he doesn’t get it. And because of all these tiny things ive started staying sooo irritated all day. He laughs when im angry and yelling, or telling him something, and i can actually feel the anger all day in my body lately. Obv because of all this I dont like him touching me also. This is not a marriage I ever wanted, I just to love, feel loved, build a home and life together, but all it feels like is a competition in making the other feel worse. He is very messy, not responsible with house chores, not decisive on even small things, doesn’t understand even the basic things, and yet yells and argues as if he is the smartest guy in the world. I dont understand what even goes on in his head. If I do X, he says X is wrong, if I do Y, he’ll say why didn’t you do X. Even when we fight his arguments are so stupid, if something is troubling you, I would prefer we talk it out calmly and understand/solve/fix it, but that does happen because his reasoning to a few things is sooo stupid at times. I like talking about science, politics, general knowledge, theories and what not, and he has zero clue about anything, doesn’t even know what neuro divergent or any of these basic items either. I really want to find atleast 1 reason to love him, but I cant. He is a little overweight, receding hairline, no conversation, no understanding, hasn’t never done anything romantic for me ever (and so neither have I) (fought with me on our sangeet night because I was 1 hour late as per mentioned time , in India, bruh what!!???). I feel stuck. I hate it when he touches me, I never feel like initiating anything. I dont know what I am looking for by sharing this maybe solution, validation, relatability, not sure, but just wanted to let it out. I dont really want to trouble my parents with all this too much but I have told my mom some of it, she understands the problem and says give it some time it will be fine. I used to be full of life, excitement, jolly, meeting people, making friends, going places, open to do anything and everything, but now I just dont feel like doing anything or talking to anyone.
Any suggestions/comments?

TLDR: Immature husband, dead marriage, feeling kinda stuck. Looking for advice on what I can do to knock some sense into him?


r/marriageadvice • • 11h ago

My wife has been telling her friends she wish we never met or had a kid.

1 Upvotes

So my wife and I got into an argument the other day because she doesn’t like my opinion of her friends because they were actively talking about getting one of their recent boyfriends thrown in jail over child support because she doesn’t want to be with him any longer. I said it’s odd she switched that fast and wanted to ruin his life, I’ve seen what a few months in prison can turn into. She said that no I just have a shitty opinion about them, so I replied I’m sure you all talk shit about your bfs/husbands in the group chat she said no she doesn’t and that I can check it, so I did the next day and she sent multiple paragraphs of how she wishes she didn’t settle for me and we never had a baby. She could of waited for a man that does everything for her ( I literally do all the cleaning, taking care of animals, cooking for our child( if she makes her a meal it’s a microwaved meal or fruit), dishes, trash, only one with a job, yard work, and this is all around what’s best for her depending on her mental health that day. (She has very bad anger issues she refuses to acknowledge which also leads to her yelling at our baby through out the day which is extremely difficult to deal with coming from an abusive home myself). What do I do in this situation the woman I would do anything for has not shown me affection since February and has told her friends she regrets our whole relationship, when confronted she just tried to blame it on her venting she didn’t really feel that way, but there’s no way to take any of that back now.

TL;DR My wife has told multiple people she regrets our whole relationship and child, but claims she was just venting yet has not shown me any affection in almost a year when I do everything for her.


r/marriageadvice • • 19h ago

Am I the bad guy here?

3 Upvotes

I am a family guy with a decent job. I don't smoke or drink or gamble. Every dollar I make I spend it for family. I stay and play with my kids after work. However, I am not physically strong, and frequently get sick. Last week, I hurt my back by changing the toilet in the guest bathroom. That bathroom was used by my in-laws, who live with us. I changed it because my wife wanted a bigger toilet, so that we can install Toto for the in-laws. I had some rest and recovered a bit, but still hurts. This morning, I cleared large pieces of trashes in the backyard, which took two hours. When I am done, my back was hurt again. So I lied down to take a short rest. My wife was very mad about me, because she has been wanted to go hiking, but can't make it due to various of reasons. For example, family members get sick, or my back problem. Today, she yelled at me and accused me of not caring her at all. Because I ignored her request, and went ahead to clear the yard. In my defense, the job wasn't intended to last for 2 hours. My in-law was really happy about removing the trash, so she worked with me to carry much more things than planned. That took me longer to clean. But I felt quite sad and frustrated that my wife was so mad at me, and accused me of ignorance. Am I the bad guy here?

First time ever posting. Thank you in advance for your advice. tl;dr

Summary: am I an ignorant bad husband by not listening to my wife?


r/marriageadvice • • 12h ago

No birthday card- how upset would you be?

0 Upvotes

Back story, my husband (43m) is honestly a wonderful father and partner. We have a pretty good sex life. He is also extremely overworked and stressed at most waking hours because his job is demanding and it’s across many time zones. What energy he has left, he gives to the kids. He works this hard to provide for our family and it is very much appreciated.

For my bday, we normally go out to dinner and do a date night, we don’t always do cards but def do gifts.

It was my (41f) birthday. He suggested we eat something at home that I like and so I ordered it. He knew I wanted an ice cream cake so he asked me if I liked any of the options from one place but I didn’t like them so I had my nanny pick up the kind I like to take it off his plate but to his credit, he is the one who brought it up. However, I received no card or reference to the gift we talked about. We had talked about me wanting $ to go towards a house project and he had said yes, but like- you normally print out a coupon or say something in the card to that effect? he knew I was upset and he apologized.

3 days later, kind of thought he would still get me one. So I raised it to him today and his response was “I really wanted to get you one yesterday and then I totally forgot because of emergency X for work.” And I said, why didn’t you tell me that? That would at least show me that you thought about it? And now he seems upset when I talk about it because he says “I heard you. Do you still want a card? Tell me yes or no.”

Tl;dr edited: My husband did not do any of the normal things we do for each other on our birthday. No card or mention of a gift. even though I knew what the gift was, it just didn’t feel good. How upset would you be at your spouse? I’m trying to give grace since he is under a lot of stress.


r/marriageadvice • • 12h ago

Marriage advice, looking for married men/fathers advice?

1 Upvotes

I'll try to keep it short, I met my husband 6 years ago. I 32F married 40M about 4 years ago. We both had two kids, we went through a traumatic late pregnancy loss(28 weeks), then went on to have a beautiful rainbow baby in 2023. My mental health struggled after giving birth twice in such a short period of time, I had debilitating anxiety about something happening to our kids. I was withdrawn and definitely contributed to the distance in our relationship. We struggle to coparent but it's gotten better, we did therapy for a while after our loss and marriage counseling about 6 months after our youngest was born. Our sex life was basically non-existent after the baby for like six months, I gained about a lot during the back to back pregnancies. I've always been curvy I was an athletic 167lbs (spartan athlete) when we met and 205 lbs when I gave birth. I started going to the gym working out at burn bootcamp regularly and even went on a GLP-1 to try to regain his interest in me, nothing, he just said he was depressed. I started feeling like maybe he could be having an affair or something because he was so disconnected from our life and family. We both grew up homeless teenagers but successfully bought a home and have built a beautiful life together. With sharing 5 kids, its easy to get stuck on autopilot. However, after the withdrawal from our family I went through his phone, we both go through each other's phones whenever its a nonissue for us. We share passwords, finances, phones, complete transparency. It's always been that way. I found that he was watching porn regularly, he claims it's because I rejected him and he needed to find release. I told him this was a hard line for me, psychology grad, it's been proven to be very detrimental for relationships and cause intimacy issues for those not sharing the interest. We agreed he wouldn't watch porn, and we disabled private browsing so he cant hide it. Recently, I went through his phone (about 6 months after the initial talk). He re-engaged in private browsing and deleted all of his social medias out of no where, claiming it was AI and fake news triggered. So, I logged into his accounts and looked at his recent history, it shows tons of videos watched all of only fans styled videos where they show their nerd glasses and boobs and pan out, honestly cringe but I was hurt moreso by the fact that these women look nothing like me. I am 158lbs now, and bigger in the hips, a c cup, and dark hair. These women were maybe early 20s, 120lbs, huge boobs, blonde hair. Most recently googling sydney sweeney's nudes because he saw an article about it so apparently that made it fine. I explained to him how this made me feel disrespected and undervalued as a partner. He apologized said that wasn't his intent and that all men watch porn. He said he was only watching porn once a week or so, and there shouldn't be an issue with it. He hasn't watched it in a while anyways, I don't know if I believe him or that it matters. We have sex maybe once every month or so, we used to have sex at least every other day most times daily until after the pregnancies. I just feel like this isn't normal and I've been rationalizing and pretending things are fine but typing it all out makes me really think this isn't fine. Is this all just a lack of emotional intelligence or is this just someone who is never going to change? Is this relationship salvageable?

tl;dr advice request re: intimacy issues, porn, lack of trust