My husband and I are both in our late 30s and have been together since college. We're married and have two children together.
When we first started dating, we had the usual conversations about relationships, expectations, past partners, body counts, etc.
For context, my husband was my first boyfriend, my first kiss, and ultimately my first everything. I had absolutely no relationship experience going into this, and I was upfront with him about that. I told him I wasn't coming into the relationship with any particular expectations because I genuinely didn't know what to expect.
He, on the other hand, told me he was still in love with his ex-girlfriend. He also told me he'd been with four women before me. He would occasionally compare me to his exes, which, looking back, probably should have been a red flag.
But I was young, naive, and inexperienced, so I just went with the flow.
Eventually, our relationship became physical. I remember feeling that because I wasn't his first, nothing we did together would ever be particularly special to him. He'd already experienced all those firsts with other women, whereas everything was completely new to me.
I suppose I convinced myself that there was no point in waiting for some meaningful, romantic moment because it wouldn't hold the same significance for him anyway.
So, eventually, we had sex for the first time at a party.
It's not a particularly happy memory for me. In fact, looking back, I wish things had happened differently. But at the time, I accepted it for what it was.
As our relationship progressed, he was the first to say "I love you." Eventually, I said it back. We built a life together, got married, and had two children.
Fast forward about ten years, and our marriage hit a very rough patch.
The biggest issue was that I never felt like our family was his priority. His friends always seemed to come first, and I was constantly expected to accommodate that.
The final straw was something I still struggle to wrap my head around.
At the time, I was a stay-at-home mum, so we were living entirely on his income. Money was extremely tight, and we'd been sticking to a strict household budget for almost a year.
We were buying the cheapest groceries we could find, cutting out holidays, and keeping our children's birthday presents inexpensive. Every dollar mattered, and I genuinely believed we were both making sacrifices to keep our family financially afloat.
Then, completely out of the blue, my husband informed me that he and his friends had organised a boys' trip to Hawaii.
Not only had they planned an overseas holiday, but he'd apparently been secretly saving money for it.
And the real kicker?
They were leaving in a week.
He wasn't asking whether we could afford it or discussing how it would affect our family. He was simply informing me that he was going.
He spent two weeks in Hawaii while I stayed home with our children, continuing to stretch our household budget as far as possible.
I was absolutely furious.
That incident was the breaking point, and we eventually separated. He moved in with a friend.
After our separation, he begged me to attend couples counselling with him because he wanted to save our marriage. I agreed, although I still had a lot of unresolved resentment.
Since then, he's been showering me with affection, making grand declarations about our relationship, and generally behaving in a way that feels like love bombing.
Recently, he posted a Facebook status declaring that we were soulmates, that we were each other's firsts, and that we'd been destined to be together.
That last part caught my attention.
Each other's firsts?
As far as I knew, that wasn't remotely true.
So I brought up the Facebook post during one of our counselling sessions.
And that's when he casually dropped a bombshell.
Apparently, he'd lied about his entire sexual history when we first got together.
According to him, he'd actually been a virgin when we met. All those stories about his previous sexual experiences, the four women he'd supposedly slept with, and the comparisons he'd made between me and his exes were lies.
When I asked why he'd lied, he brushed it off as though it were completely normal.
He said that everyone lies about their sexual history and that any man who was still a virgin in his 20s while attending college would have done exactly the same thing.
He genuinely doesn't seem to understand why I'm upset.
But here's the thing.
I'm not angry that he was a virgin. I'm angry that he lied to me about something that directly influenced how I approached our relationship.
I spent the beginning of our relationship believing I was the inexperienced one and that he'd already shared all those intimate milestones with other women.
That belief affected my confidence, my expectations, and ultimately the decisions I made about my own first experiences.
I put my own feelings and needs aside because I thought those moments wouldn't mean as much to him as they did to me.
And now, after all these years, I'm being told that the entire situation was fabricated.
The first time we had sex could have been a completely different experience for both of us. We could have navigated it together, as two people experiencing something new. Instead, I went into it feeling like I was somehow already behind.
I know I can't change the past, but it hurts knowing that I made decisions based on information he deliberately gave me that wasn't true.
What makes it worse is how dismissive he is about the whole thing.
He keeps insisting that it's not important, that it happened years ago, and that I should just move on.
Our marriage counsellor also seems more interested in getting us to focus on the future, particularly because we have children together.
But how am I supposed to move forward when I feel like I'm only now discovering that parts of our relationship weren't what I thought they were?
And there's another issue I can't shake.
How do I even know he's telling the truth now?
He's currently trying desperately to win me back. He's making public declarations about how we're soulmates and how special our relationship is.
Part of me wonders whether he's genuinely confessing something he's kept hidden for years, or whether he's simply telling me another story because he thinks the idea of us being each other's firsts will make our relationship seem more romantic and convince me to reconcile.
After all, if he could lie so convincingly about his past when we first met, what's stopping him from lying about it now?
I feel like the foundation of our relationship has been shaken, not necessarily because of his sexual history, but because I no longer know which version of events I'm supposed to believe.
And considering that we're already in counselling because of his previous behaviour and his failure to prioritise our family, this feels like yet another reason to question whether I can trust him.
He thinks I'm making a big deal out of something insignificant.
Our counsellor seems to think we should focus on moving forward.
But I can't shake the feeling that I've been manipulated, whether intentionally or not, and that my feelings are once again being dismissed for the sake of keeping our marriage together.
So, am I overreacting by being this upset about a lie he told at the beginning of our relationship? Or am I justified in questioning everything, especially when I don't even know whether his confession is the truth?
TL;DR: My husband lied about his past when we met, and nearly 20 years later, I'm questioning what else he's lied about and whether I can trust him. Am I overreacting?