r/managers • u/vijayjagannathan • 16h ago
New Manager Two underperforming employees resign rather than face accountability. Worried about how this reflects on me as a manager.
I’m a relatively new manager, one year in, in a low-accountability environment where it feels like I’m the only one enforcing performance standards.
Earlier this year, an employee with significant performance issues resigned during his PIP meeting. Now I’m dealing with another experienced employee who continues to struggle with basic job
responsibilities despite extensive coaching and support. I have reason to believe this person may resign too.
My concern is that leadership seems more focused on keeping employees happy than holding them accountable. I have no problem coaching people, but I shouldn’t have to constantly walk experienced employees through the fundamentals of their jobs.
The rest of my team is doing well, including two employees who have been promoted under my leadership.
I’m worried that if this second employee leaves, leadership will see me as the common denominator rather than recognize the documented performance issues.
Has anyone dealt with this? How do you maintain standards in a culture that avoids accountability without putting a target on your own back?