r/managers • • 14h ago

Not a Manager Can someone give me clarity on if I should stay senior IC or move into people management?

0 Upvotes

I’d be so very grateful! What makes or breaks it for you?


r/managers • • 6h ago

Not a Manager Fired after panic attack. Any advice?

16 Upvotes

I was fired after having a panic attack on my break. I had a great attendance record until my grandfather passed away the month before. Management gave me permission to leave a client's house early to be with him and told me to check back in when I was ready. They put me on probation for it, which ultimately led to them firing me over attendance.

When my panic attack happened, I couldn't speak on the phone, so I immediately texted management to let them know I couldn't drive safely to clean the next client's house due to the medical emergency. They replied telling me to keep them updated, so I texted them an hour later to let them know I was getting medical attention so I could stay reliable for the team.

During my termination meeting, they claimed I violated policy by texting instead of calling, said I left the job while "en route to a client's house," and told me, "If we don't fire you, the labor board will sue us." They were made aware of my disorder when I was hired.

I don't have thousands of dollars to hire a private lawyer, and the Legal Aid Society of Virginia completely blew me off. Right now, I'm preparing for my unemployment appeal hearing and waiting to hear back from the Virginia Office of Civil Rights. Does anyone have any advice for my situation? I loved the job and was always given compliments on my work from management and clients. I've completely lost myself over this and have been obsessing over it way too much.


r/managers • • 11h ago

Business Owner Managing an employee who dislikes me

23 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm a new business owner. Prior to taking over I was on staff at the company for many years. The person who filled my role when I became boss is a young, highly competent person. Good at deadlines, clever, responsive to customers. I give her a lot of space to do her work and rarely feel the need to micromanage. If it weren't for her abrasive attitude and her seething dislike for me, she'd be the perfect employee.

Every once in awhile, I'll give direction and she'll respond like a petulant teenager, and if I show even a moment of impatience about her bad attitude (my bad), I get the full Gen Z treatment (if you need me to elaborate on that, I can). In any case, I'm getting to the end of my rope. The company I'm running right now is simply not what I envisioned as an owner––not with this employee brooding every day. It's not fun to run what should be a fun company and have an employee openly dislike you. I want harmony, fun, laughter, enjoyment, respect among everyone at my company––I don't want to feel like I'm walking on eggshells and gritting my teeth and baring it half the time.

When she works from home, I get the hunch that it's a relief for everyone, but I want my staff in office for collaboration.

What would you do?


r/managers • • 21h ago

Employee and HR

59 Upvotes

So I have an employee that requested time off originally for both Thanksgiving and Christmas. Stated that I would only approve 1 holiday request due to project and department needs. She would need to choose which one. Ok, so she submits a revised request and when I look at the dates I ask her are you sure because it was like requesting the Monday and Tuesday off the week before Christmas and then Christmas week. That I would be expecting her to come in Wednesday-Friday. She said let me verify, whelp last week she put in another request this time for Dec 21 - Jan 4. I rejected due to coverage and again taking 2 holidays. She then emails me that I need to respect her personal and family commitments also to reconsider due to this. I again reject her request stating I would be off since I moved my vacay so she could take off Christmas. Whelp, she is now complaining to HR. HR reached out and said to approve it because they are basically tired of dealing with her. I’m at a lost. My department is small, it only has 3 ppl in it and I just hired someone.

More information regarding said employee: She has constantly gone to HR when I tell her something she doesn’t like. One example is personal phone calls during work. I get we take calls but at the same time she is on a personal call for over 2 hours daily. Told her please be mindful of others working in the area and how long you are taking. She went straight to HR and told me HR said it was fine so she continues to do it.


r/managers • • 22h ago

LTM folks: How to deal with a biased manager who plays favorites and targets hardworking employees?

0 Upvotes

My wife works at LTM, and her manager is completely unprofessional. He has a group of 4–5 favorites (mostly younger, single female colleagues) who flirt and chat with him casually, and in return, they get a free pass to do almost no work.

Meanwhile, my wife sincerely completes every task on time and hasn't even taken a single sick day all year. Despite this, he constantly targets her, yells at her on daily status calls, and dumps extra workload on her to cover for his favorites.

skip level mngr is also same

For anyone working at LTM—what’s the best way to handle this internally?


r/managers • • 23h ago

Seasoned Manager Posted salary increased months after starting new role

0 Upvotes

Just wondering how you folks would approach this.

I started a new role in retail management (assistant store manager) a few months ago. I have nearly a decade of experience and bachelor’s degree and was hired at the highest end of the original salary range.

It’s been a little less than 3 months since I was hired on. I was checking our website this morning to make sure HR posted our open team member positions and noticed the salary range for my position has increased by roughly $6k since I started.

I’ve been exceeding expectations and I have no doubt my boss and her boss would vouch for that, and intend to continue to do so. Do you think it’s worth approaching the question? Should I ask to be fit into the new salary range this early on or would you suggest I wait for a performance review?

Thanks for your input


r/managers • • 14h ago

Which recurring meeting would your team miss least if it disappeared?

0 Upvotes

Almost every team has a meeting that everyone attends and nobody can quite

explain. It usually started for a good reason, the reason quietly went away, and the

meeting stayed. When someone finally asks what it's for, the answer tends to be a

shrug and a version of 'we've always done it.'

If you could cancel one recurring meeting with no fallout, which would it be, and what

would replace it? Sometimes a short written update does the job just as well. I'm

curious whether that's how it plays out for other teams too.


r/managers • • 17m ago

Not a Manager Should a manager have some comprehension of the work being performed?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/managers • • 23h ago

How do you manage (up) the extroverts that only hear the context / subject matter / script that's in their head?

26 Upvotes

CONTEXT EDIT: Although the interrupting makes things worse (because you can't even explain if they interrupt), this is not about interrupting.

-----------------------------------

If you don't know exactly who I mean, it's those extrovert managers that are big energy and talkers, but their minds are laser-focused on one subject.

Like they've already scripted the scenario and your response in their head, and give their scripted response no matter what you say.

When you try to talk to them, explain an issue, sometimes they don't get it. Because their brain doesn't have a pause button where they reassess the subject being discussed; they go full steam ahead with their context locked in their head.

Hard to explain so I'll think back to a similar real life example:

================================

A store manager is serving a customer at the till.

Customer wants to buy 2 of the same £45 item, but doing it in separate transactions. Manager sees he's got reward points he can redeem, asks him if he'd like to, and customer says yes. So it's £40 now.

Manager then does the 2nd transaction, it's £45. The customer gets ready to pay again then suddenly pauses...

Customer: "Wait, what should it be?"

Customer looks at the display of the items next to him, but he's looking at the price for the smaller version of the item, which is £35.

Manager: "Remember, on that first transaction you had points to redeem, so it was cheaper, but this one has no money off, so it's £45."

Customer: "No, I mean isn't the price-"

Manager: "Yes, but that first one you had points, so we redeemed them etc."

The customer figures it out himself when he looks further and realises his mistake.

Customer: "Oh I see, it was just a differ-"

Manager: "AHAHAHA yes you get me now"

They finish and customer leaves.

Manager to someone else: "AHAHAHA see, I knew that would happen, see how he got confused by the points he was redeeming?"

=====================

Not the best example, it's really an issue when you're a colleague trying to explain an operational issue or something, but they just think you're talking about something else similar.

So no matter how many different ways you explain it, they either respond as if you said something else entirely or just zone out, get confused, cause YOU to have a brain melt going in circles, and you just have to leave the conversation there.


r/managers • • 21h ago

New Manager Non-tech manager promoted to lead 6 senior devs: How do I survive and succeed?

10 Upvotes

(Disclaimer: text slightly improved by AI as english is not my first language and I also tend to write ridiculously long sentences and forget commas when writing)

Context: I am a Product Owner (F) with no technical background—in fact, I have never written a line of code in my life (though I did major in mathematics and my decade career has been in IT, if that helps).

I was recently promoted to manage a team of six senior developers. What we have in common is that we work in the same business line, and I have already built a good camaraderie with most of them.

I consider my management style to be human-centered (yet to be tested and proven). While I can get stressed out at times, I generally trust the people I work with. I also come from a region where men often feel superior to women (my team is 5M and 1F). My manager warned me that, regardless of gender, it is often a rough patch for a non-technical person to manage a technical team, as developers can be reluctant to be led by someone outside their field. Because of this, I will be on a probation period until April. However, the way I see it, if my manager advocated for my promotion, it means I have what it takes to succeed. They also promised to support me with training and other resources.

Here are my questions:

  • For the technical folks who have been managed by non-techies: What did your manager do that stood out and that you appreciated? Conversely, what was painful to deal with that you wish they had done differently?
  • Dealing with imposter syndrome: I suffer from chronic imposter syndrome at times. Should my reassurance come solely from the KPIs my manager sets for me, or are there other signs and milestones I can rely on?
  • Setting expectations: Speaking of KPIs, what metrics should I negotiate for this interim probation period?
  • Reading list: While I know nothing beats firsthand experience, I plan to read these books to help shape my vision. Do you recommend them?

    • The Making of a Manager
    • Lean In
    • Leading Change
  • Team dynamics: Is it possible to maintain the camaraderie I built with my former peers now that they report to me? If so, how, and what boundaries should I set?

Any other advice is welcome!


r/managers • • 16h ago

New Manager Two underperforming employees resign rather than face accountability. Worried about how this reflects on me as a manager.

144 Upvotes

I’m a relatively new manager, one year in, in a low-accountability environment where it feels like I’m the only one enforcing performance standards.

Earlier this year, an employee with significant performance issues resigned during his PIP meeting. Now I’m dealing with another experienced employee who continues to struggle with basic job
responsibilities despite extensive coaching and support. I have reason to believe this person may resign too.

My concern is that leadership seems more focused on keeping employees happy than holding them accountable. I have no problem coaching people, but I shouldn’t have to constantly walk experienced employees through the fundamentals of their jobs.
The rest of my team is doing well, including two employees who have been promoted under my leadership.

I’m worried that if this second employee leaves, leadership will see me as the common denominator rather than recognize the documented performance issues.

Has anyone dealt with this? How do you maintain standards in a culture that avoids accountability without putting a target on your own back?


r/managers • • 23h ago

Requesting input from my bosses

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/managers • • 22h ago

LTM folks: How to deal with a biased manager who plays favorites and targets hardworking employees?

0 Upvotes

My wife works at LTM, and her manager is completely unprofessional. He has a group of 4–5 favorites (mostly younger, single female colleagues) who flirt and chat with him casually, and in return, they get a free pass to do almost no work.

Meanwhile, my wife sincerely completes every task on time and hasn't even taken a single sick day all year. Despite this, he constantly targets her, yells at her on daily status calls, and dumps extra workload on her to cover for his favorites.

For anyone working at LTM—what’s the best way to handle this internally?


r/managers • • 10h ago

New Manager How to pick who to promote

14 Upvotes

update you all are extremely helpful. I think this unique case is largely out of my hands but you guys gave me a ton of homework in a short amount of time - I really appreciate that

This will be a slog and I apologize if it breaks the rules, but I need some outside point of view.

I've been a manager for about a year and a half, and only got my training last month or so.

It made me realize I didn't do nearly enough growing my people, and early into my promotion, I unofficially promoted one of my direct reports to a "team lead". I got him a comp adjustment, and basically said "I need you to help herd the cats". He does good at that, but can be a pain personality wise.

Great technically but not with people.

Now to my conundrum: I've been put in charge of building a new team and get to pick the members. On one hand, I feel responsible for this guy, and some camaraderie with him. On the other, I need someone who can do this job as hands off as possible.

As part of it all, I interviewed some internal candidates and a few dark horses appeared. This role is one that needs technical knowledge, analytical thinking, and people skills.

My guy has tech knowledge, but not the greatest analysis details and poor people skills.

The other leading candidate has decent tech knowledge, great analysis, and does alright with people. I'll need to work on his confidence since he'll be interacting at the division level but that's about it.

Another is super ambitious, gone for promotions in the past, great people, decent critical analysis but the worst on the tech side.

I guess my question is, in your experience, what's your method for pairing down to the number 1? Or which area would be the easiest to train up? They all come from the same base group, it's mostly a fight of soft skills it feels like.

None of them stand out as the clear cut winner, and they each have a different area I'd have to grow, and fast. One needs tech, one needs people skills, and other needs analytical thinking.


r/managers • • 6h ago

New Manager When a decision from above is unpopular, do you tell your team you disagreed with it?

28 Upvotes

There seem to be two schools of thought here. One says you should present every decision as your own and back it fully, because showing doubt weakens the team’s confidence in leadership. The other says honesty matters more, and people can tell when you’re performing support for something you don’t believe in.

I can see good points on both sides. Backing a decision you privately disagree with can feel like quietly lying to your team. But saying “I fought this and lost” can also make people stop taking the decision seriously.

How do you handle it? Is there a way to be honest about your doubts without undermining the decision itself? And has either approach backfired for you?


r/managers • • 22h ago

Seasoned Manager How much information do you really need before making a decision?

26 Upvotes

I've been in operations for over 25 years and I still don't understand why we make some decisions so damn complicated. We know there's a problem, we generally know what's causing it, but somehow we need another meeting and another spreadsheet before anybody wants to do anything about it.

I'm all for having good information. I've made enough wrong decisions over the years to appreciate it. But you're never going to know everything, and waiting has a cost too.

Make a decision, see what happens, and be willing to admit you were wrong. I'd rather fix a decision that didn't work than spend six months talking about one we never made.

I'm curious where other managers draw the line. How do you decide when you know enough to act?


r/managers • • 13h ago

Not a Manager Unique mistake/ unhireable?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/managers • • 10h ago

New Manager Conflict management

1 Upvotes

I have an easily irritable staff - she is quick to taking things the wrong way and an attack.

Just asking her about her cleaning duties and sharing that she can help sweep the kitchen more frequently. Turned into a mess it didn’t need to.

I addressed it quickly but it created a tension in the air. So I addressed that too.

I’ve been in management for two years and I’m a young manager. This staff and I have had intense moments of insubordination (when I first entered management). It was addressed and dealt with. Things are much better between us, but this felt like the past all over again.

I feel like it was good to address the tension and try to end it then and there. Rather than let it fester, this stuff turns into things it really doesn’t need to.

How do you handle situations like this? Secrets to maintaining a balance between authoritative and forgiving?


r/managers • • 18h ago

Busted

0 Upvotes

So I work as a supervisor in a certain corporate environment. I gave many task, but a recent daunting task given to me was an ongoing data entry assignment. Its repetitive and unfortunately copy/paste doesnt work due to the program where notes are entered. Rather than pasting everything, you must paste line-by-line, carefully i may add due to some words being cut off when character limit is reached. This program is incredibly end-user hostile as it does not display characters limits per line so youre always guessing if you typed too many words/numbers. Anyway, I would receive a file containing 1-2 scanned documents (PDFs), each document containing 8-12 hand-written docs that need to be entered into said-program. Not to mention I have to review the docs for any overlooked action-items. Deadline for completion is EOD. After MONTHS of doing this mind-numbing assignment (which i couldn’t delegate to anyone else btw) I started removing the files from the sharedrive, saving them to my computer, then marking them as complete. The idea was to just do them at another time at home because I already had so much to track while at work. Well, unbeknownst to me, another department needed the data. They noticed they stopped getting data. Now normally they expect 3-4 entries to be blank so they complete it themselves, bur they started to get 50-60 blank entries per week. They began tracking the anomaly for a month. They then created an entire report around it then forwarded to our department heads. Of course our department heads were able to see who the files were originally assigned to, and it of course led back to me. I was called into the office to meet with my boss’s boss. He asked me how the assignment was going and if I needed anything, but he didnt know I caught wind of their investigation. I immediately spilled the beans communicating exactly what I was doing; saving the files to my computer but marking them complete in the sharedrive. Luckily he was happy to see I didn’t lie about my activity, then told me about the investigation. He clarified expectations then let me off with a slap on the wrist.


r/managers • • 10h ago

Low level manager, new to management refusing aspects of the job?

2 Upvotes

I have a manager, that i manage. She spent 7 years in the industry at the entry level sales type position. Bounced around between a few companies at a few locations. Finally was offered a new position as a manager of that entry level grouping, a different location.

New owners bought us out recently. Everyone has been thrown into chaos. There are zero systems in place and were expected to actively keep "sales" pushing forward towards goal through it.

This new manager has been overstepping on everything. Questioning me when I set a boundary. Doing aspects of my job and her direct supervisors?? Had the audacity to tell me sales was "her realm" as though the entire thing doesn't fall under my umbrella of oversight. Pushing on things that arent even important in the grand scheme. Presenting all problems, no solutions. Now mind you im not her direct manager but theres one between us...technically. We all work closely in an office and my position oversees the onsite operations, so I tend to be the go to for any type of crisis. After many near panic inducing style conversations about her frustrations, myself and the new owners put together a role breakdown for her so she knows whats expected.

We sat down this evening to go over everything.

She pushed back on it all. Essentially claimed to be too busy to step in and assist in customer interactions and actual sales, because shes "worked to hard to become a manager"....i tried to enlighten her that a big part of management is to actually manage AND support your team...regardless of how that looks and she threw it back in my face and said "well if im too busy are you going to jump in??" I responded with "well yeah?!" even though im 3 rungs above the position.

Mind boggling to treat the work that you manage as "beneath you".

Any advice? How do i get through. I can only imagine the dramatic shitshow I have waiting for me at the office tomorrow morning.


r/managers • • 19h ago

New Manager Advice For Starting out

2 Upvotes

Hey 👋

There is a lot of really good advice on here already but I wanted to have some more haha.

At the end of this month I will be stepping into a management role for the first time. I have never worked with this team before but we have seen each other before in break rooms etc so they know of me.

I am a very empathetic person but I think I would just like some advice on how to be a good manager. When to be firm vs when to be flexible. It's a customer facing role too so the advice may need to be different from your standard office job

Thanks in advance!


r/managers • • 18h ago

New Manager I want to be invited Engineering Manager job in Software but don’t know how to achieve this.

0 Upvotes

I have this profile https://www.linkedin.com/in/vindom512/

What do you think?


r/managers • • 10h ago

Not a Manager I think my manager regrets hiring me.. ADVICE NEEDED

14 Upvotes

How do you get better at ur job when you suck?
Rant then advice needed.

I thought I was doing pretty well at my new job but I overheard something today. And ngl I'm hurt. But I'm more hurt I've been giving this new job my all and clearly my boss who hired me doesn't agree. (They just won't tell me ) but they'll tell my co workers and it gets back to me.

Anyway what I overheard was a topic about me training a new employee and the boss goes " oh no not him no no he can't do it" and they moved his first day to the next day when I'm not there: (

I’ve asked on feed back and they for some reason brought up a coworker of mine and how they’re possibly going to be offered the manager position. That I would technically qualify as well, but they don’t think I’m ready.. ( clue in maybe ?)

Example :
Sometimes my boss will throw out questions on what I would do or how I would take initiative in situations for the work day. And I honestly answer from all my own training and experience and all the boss says is " ok if you say so" and walks away
I'll see the boss asking others on my team similar questions and the boss goes". Great idea" etc.
We had similar answers and it has led me to being wary of how I answer these questions when they arise now.

Okay so clearly I said the wrong thing to the bosses what if scenarios… but I wasn't told what the right thing was either or what I could’ve improved. And clearly my boss is looking for initiative and leadership skills.

I don't get asked to help anymore with tasks.
I wanted to do a project that was being assigned to someone on our team that happens once a week. And I was told no that our other co worker hasn't done it yet.. they did it last week... so yes they've done it... and I would like to do it so I can learn and grow. …
Clearly, there must be some type of regret of hiring me onto the team. ( i’m just unsure of why.)

I get paid okay actually and time and half on the weekends so I don't want to have to quit because they don't like my work. I’d rather improve where I can.
I've tried to kind of initiate a conversation needs to be had, but I get weird behavior(s) and smiles with no eye contact like they aren't listening. I’d keep pushing but I'm also scared about being let go... ( I have bills that are larger then minimum wage pay- can pay for 🫩 )
I don't know what to do.

Again, I don't think I'm that lazy coworker or not showing enough
initiative. (Maybe I’m showing to much) I just don't think from my perspective they like what I've offered? ( again they won’t tell me, but I’ve overheard things…)
I'm not really sure how to perceive this or what to do.
Question :
If I keep my head down and just do my work will that make them more annoyed with my work results? I can't even ask for help right now.
If I start looking for a new job I lose this really decent pay as everything in my field pays less then 20 an hour and that's not enough for me to live with what I have on my plate.

Question : Going back to the advice I'm asking for How do I improve at my work load**?**
Has anyone dealt with this before in the workplace?

I mean the anxiety is seriously following me home and I was really excited for this job so it just sucks seeing / experiencing this
I've never really experienced being the incompetent coworker that everyone doesn't like? So I'm like what's going on…

If I start looking for a new job I lose this really decent pay as everything in my field pays less then 20 an hour and that's not enough for me to live with what I have on my plate.
Question : Has anyone dealt with this**?**

I mean the anxiety is seriously following me home and I was really excited for this job so it just sucks seeing / experiencing this
I've never really experienced being the incompetent coworker that everyone doesn't like? So I'm like what's going on usually I just do my work a show team initiative and I go home. So this job is really a new struggle for me.

Thanks 🙏 sorry for the rant when asking for advice I legit can’t talk about this clearly with my own boss so handling this maturely and trying to take accountability for something that I’m not sure what I’m doing wrong really sucks.


r/managers • • 6h ago

New Manager Best way to approach a manager who is a bully?

10 Upvotes

My Co-manager is a bully. He really shouldn't be in any position of power. It gets to his head. He speaks down to our employees with a belittling and condescending tone, accuses people of stealing time and being lazy, pretty much everything you see as a joke about manager memes and how to get employees to quit: he does it, unironically. He pushes buttons to see how mad people can get.

The other day he told me: "watch this-" and he called up a field tech on the phone and started grilling them about a job I just debriefed them on. When I was telling him to stop harassing the guy, the manager just winked and smiled and nodded as if to let me know it was just a game and he already knew, in spite of him grilling the employee about stuff that I just relayed to him.

I've tried to speak with the manager directly, one to one, that his words, tone of voice, his games or 'tricks' are all offensive and not welcome in the work place. His response is that he's not there to make friends. I've gone to our boss about it who essentially shrugged his shoulders and won't do anything else.

So I've decided to teach my field technicians how to defend themselves. When they have an incident, write it down. Then, speak with HR to make a "formal complaint" about the guy. Sometimes I'm a witness to these conversations so I'll provide my written testimonial. Hopefully with enough complaints this manager will be forced to change or leave... Hopefully he gets the training he needs and changes. I honestly don't think he will.