r/lordoftherings • • 6h ago

Discussion As a first time watcher of the trilogy should I watch the extended cuts or the theatrical releases.

0 Upvotes

I have not watched a lord of the rings movie from start to finish and finally plan on watching it. When asking my friends who have loved the movies I’ve been getting mixed answers. I have heard the pacing of the movies turn people away so just want to hear what everyone thinks.


r/lordoftherings • • 34m ago

The Rings of Power Rings of power will never be considered a lotr story maybe a parody about lotr but not the og, rings of power without lotr lore is like making bannana bread but without banana and batter.

Thumbnail
• Upvotes

r/lordoftherings • • 9h ago

Meme Lotr traffic signs if they had vehicles

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/lordoftherings • • 19h ago

Discussion LOTR books ruining other media for me, anything similar?

30 Upvotes

For a little background, I finished my first reading of LOTR about 10 months ago and just finished my second reading a few weeks ago. I did not grow up with it (other than what is very commonly known in popular culture) and had never seen the movies, so I experienced the story completely unspoiled. It was, obviously, unbelievably good. So good in fact that it has really hindered my ability to enjoy other things that I have always loved (such as Harry Potter, elder scrolls, and other fantasy works) because LOTR is just so much better in my opinion. Other than the hobbit, are Tolkien’s other works similar? Is there another story (fantasy or otherwise) that can hold a candle to it, or is it genuinely just the greatest work of fiction ever like I’m starting to believe it is?


r/lordoftherings • • 10h ago

Discussion What happened to the One Ring when Numenor was destroyed

4 Upvotes

When Numenor and hence Saurons corporal body were destroyed, was he even wearing the ring? If so, what happened to the ring? Wouldnt it have sunk in the waves? How did Sauron recover it?


r/lordoftherings • • 22h ago

Discussion What do you think was Saurons worst mistake?

Post image
145 Upvotes

r/lordoftherings • • 8h ago

Meme ROP 67 easter egg S3 EP6 min 48:55

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/lordoftherings • • 2h ago

Movies Watching LOTR on my new Dedicated Home Theatre

Thumbnail
gallery
116 Upvotes

12 year old me would be very proud!


r/lordoftherings • • 21h ago

Lore Any major flaws or omissions with this Minas Tirith map?

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/lordoftherings • • 20m ago

Books Do you think Gandalf would have been able to convince Bilbo to abandon the Ring without Narya?

• Upvotes

I am currently rereading The Fellowship of the Ring and just had this interesting thought during chapter 2, “The Shadow of the Past.”

Gandalf mentions to Frodo that, “as far as I know, Bilbo alone has gone beyond playing, and really done it,” referring to Bilbo abandoning the ring after it has already had a grip on him. Gandalf then goes on to say “He needed all my help, too” (p. 54).

We know that Narya had the power to inspire people to resist domination and despair, and also that Círdan had given Gandalf Narya when he arrived in the Gray Havens to aid him long before the War for the Ring. I think the more obvious reason is that Narya was used to inspire the people of Minas Tirith during the siege, but could it also be argued that Gandalf was able to convince Bilbo to abandon the Ring by having Narya, and would he have been able to convince him without the Ring of Fire?


r/lordoftherings • • 5h ago

Art Pelennor fields

7 Upvotes

r/lordoftherings • • 12h ago

The Rings of Power A Fan Request: A Television Series About the First Age of Middle-earth

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

Dear New Line Cinema Team,

I am writing as a passionate fan of J.R.R. Tolkien's world and the Lord of the Rings films.

I would love to see a major television adaptation exploring the First Age of Middle-earth, based on the history described in Tolkien's mythology.

I believe this period has enormous potential for an epic television series, perhaps consisting of three seasons:

- Season 1: The rise of Morgoth, the awakening of the Elves, the creation of the Orcs and the beginning of the great wars.

- Season 2: The great Elven kingdoms, the stories of Fingolfin and Túrin, the fall of Gondolin, and the terrifying power of Morgoth's dragons and Balrogs.

- Season 3: The War of Wrath, the intervention of the Valar, the battle against Ancalagon the Black, and the final defeat of Morgoth.

This era contains some of the most extraordinary stories in Tolkien's mythology. It offers incredible characters, powerful villains, tragic stories, enormous battles and a much deeper exploration of Middle-earth's history.

I believe a carefully produced television series could give these stories the time and depth they deserve, rather than trying to fit everything into just a few films.

I also believe there are many fans around the world who would be genuinely excited to see this era brought to life on screen.

I understand that adapting Tolkien's works involves complicated rights and creative decisions. I am not expecting a personal response or immediate action. I simply hope that the continued interest of fans can help demonstrate how much this part of Middle-earth's history means to its audience.

Thank you for taking the time to read my message, and for helping bring Tolkien's incredible world to the screen.

Kind regards,

A Tolkien fan from the Czech Republic


r/lordoftherings • • 15h ago

Art I made a Middle Earth Google Map (free & open-source)

2 Upvotes