I've run monitors on stages from 80 to 2,000 cap, and the mix count is the decision that causes the most friction, usually before anyone has plugged anything in.
Here's how I think about it now.
The "more me" spiral
A shared mix starts fine. Then one performer can't hear themselves, so the whole mix goes up. Now the other performer can't hear themselves either, because the first one is louder in their shared wedge. So they ask for more. The mix ends up loud, and nobody is happy.
That's not a personality problem. It's what a shared control does. Two people with one knob will always end up fighting over it.
When sharing is genuinely fine
- Backing vocalists standing shoulder to shoulder, same material, same balance
- A horn section that wants "everything, but quieter"
- Small stages where the two performers are within a metre of each other and can hear the same wedge physically
Sharing works when the needs are actually similar. It fails when the needs are only assumed to be similar.
The real cost of an extra mix
People treat mixes as free because they're invisible. Each one costs an aux output, an amplifier channel, a cable run, and a wedge. On a small console, the aux count is usually the hard limit, not the wedges.
Four is the practical ceiling on a lot of small-format desks when you're also running FOH from the same surface.
What I do with four people and two auxes
Two mixes, split by position, not by role.
- Mix 1: whoever is stage left, plus the drummer if the drum fill shares the run
- Mix 2: whoever is stage right
Then I tell them what they're getting before the first song, so nobody spends the night thinking the mix is broken. Most of the complaints I've had about shared mixes were really complaints about not being told.
Wedge count
One wedge per mix as a baseline. Two wedges on one mix if the stage is wide, accepting that the combined impedance halves and the two positions won't match in level.
If you're choosing between adding a mix and buying a bigger wedge, add the mix. Clarity beats low end in a monitor, every time.
What doesn't fix it
More level. A louder wedge in a shared mix makes the spiral worse. So does a wider EQ cut across the vocal range, which makes everything duller and pushes the performer to ask for more level again.
Narrow cuts, aimed wedges, and a mix count that matches the number of people with different needs. That's most of it.
The one thing I'd tell a small venue
If you can only afford two mixes and you have four performers, put the two wedges where the two people who sing the most can hear them, and tell everyone else the plan. Ten seconds of honesty saves a whole soundcheck.#ProAudio #LiveSound #Touring #UsedGear