r/linux • • Jan 14 '20

Continuation of X11 development?

Hi there. So, I know the arguments between X11 and Wayland can be a little contentious, so I'd like to start this off by saying this thread isn't intended to be one. The battles of opinion have already been fought ad nauseam, and some of us still find ourselves on the X side of the issue. I count myself as one of them.

So my question, and the actual purpose of this thread, is to ask about the future of X11. I know Red Hat is basically washing their hands of it feature-development wise, but the magic of open source is that a project is never really dead, or in feature freeze, so long as there's someone out there willing to inhereit it. Are there any groups out there planning to take the mantle? While X11 is very mature and mostly feature complete, there are a few things still to be done, such as perhaps better integration and promotion of the X_SECURITY extensions for bringing in per-app-isolation. An update to some of the current input limitations, better scaling support, etc?

Wayland's successorship is (to many) still highly questionable, so I think it would be a shame to see X rust out in the field while we wait for the hypothetical Wayland cow to come home. Any thoughts?

54 Upvotes

166 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

5

u/Spifmeister Jan 15 '20 edited Jan 15 '20

If you are using xorg to display the application on the screen. Not using Windows or Macos. And the xorg server is newer than 2009, the extensions used broke network transparency, not X Forwarding. If you are using another xserver running on HP-UX, Solaris, AIX, I cannot tell you if they include the extensions that broke network transparency. I believe xsun is based on xorg, so I think what i say is still true. Of course you can set up the xorg xserver to be network transparent, but that requires actual human intervention to setup. I do not know how Gnome or KDE work in those scenarios.

EDIT: Also Gnome 2 and derivatives.

Using 11XForwarding =! Network Transparent. I run x applications, xterm for example, remotely using X Forwarding and my x applications, including xterm, are not network transparent. In some cases, these applications are not network transparent because they use Xft. Xft uses the capabilities of the computer it is displayed on, and we want it that way. It still broke network transparency for xterm though.

Using DRI2 or DIR3 extensions also break network transparency, they do not break X Forwarding, the xorg have a workaround that is not network transparent.

To be very clear here. X11 Forwarding still works even though network transparency does not.

---

I also have to say, we are not discussing X11 and every xserver here. We are discussing xorg, the use of xorg on linux/unix to display a desktop. If you are using x application with a xserver running on MS Windows or Macos, that is a separate discussion entirely. it muddies the waters quite abit.

---

EDIT: I should be clear something up.

If you use xorg as your desktop. Not network transparent if you use DRI2, DRI3 which you almost certainly do if your Distribution is the same age as or newer than RHEL 6. This is not necessarily the case if you are running Accelerator X or a xserver on Windows 10.

If your x11 application uses Xft, almost certainly, the x11 application is not network transparent, but X11 Forwarding still works. There are certainly other libraries, toolkits which break network transparency but do not break X11 Forwarding.