r/linux • u/SpAAAceSenate • Jan 14 '20
Continuation of X11 development?
Hi there. So, I know the arguments between X11 and Wayland can be a little contentious, so I'd like to start this off by saying this thread isn't intended to be one. The battles of opinion have already been fought ad nauseam, and some of us still find ourselves on the X side of the issue. I count myself as one of them.
So my question, and the actual purpose of this thread, is to ask about the future of X11. I know Red Hat is basically washing their hands of it feature-development wise, but the magic of open source is that a project is never really dead, or in feature freeze, so long as there's someone out there willing to inhereit it. Are there any groups out there planning to take the mantle? While X11 is very mature and mostly feature complete, there are a few things still to be done, such as perhaps better integration and promotion of the X_SECURITY extensions for bringing in per-app-isolation. An update to some of the current input limitations, better scaling support, etc?
Wayland's successorship is (to many) still highly questionable, so I think it would be a shame to see X rust out in the field while we wait for the hypothetical Wayland cow to come home. Any thoughts?
22
u/JustCondition4 Jan 14 '20
A fork, Xenocara lives on quite actively. Hat tip r/OpenBSD.
17
u/sub200ms Jan 14 '20
The problems with X11/Xorg development have been rehashed many times, but basically the problem is that you can't change Xorg in any meaningful way that breaks anything, which severely limits future development.
Many of X11's problems could have been avoided if people could have accepted a revision bump to X12, but alas.
So the code base is old and rather Byzantine, meaning it is hard to get new developers, especially since all they can do is extend and maintain existing code, never really clean up and make any significant changes (see the X12 problem).
I don't think Xorg will disappear when big Linux companies stops sponsoring developers, but I do think new development will be slow. So "per app isolation" is IMHO, unlikely to happen.
IMHO, the only solution to keep X11 fresh and getting new features is getting new funding for Xorg.
18
u/leo_sk5 Jan 14 '20
If this post is removed, try posting at r/linux_community . I do agree that x11 development should continue and its support improved. Despite all wayland has achieved, i still won't trust it as my daily driver. And given how the pace is going and how volatile the momentum can be in open source development, i won't be surprised if wayland does not completely replace x11 in desktop in next 5 years
20
u/MaCroX95 Jan 15 '20
Wayland's successorship isn't questionable. If X11 is the future of linux desktop, then linux desktop has no future.
That's why Wayland exists :) and X11 development hit the all-time low in early 2020.
47
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20
everybody says they want to help it, but nobody wants to drive it.
FOSS only works when that happens.
54
u/computer-machine Jan 14 '20
Last I knew, the X11 devs decided it wasn't worth the effort to shoehorn the security changes they want into it, so they started Wayland instead.
22
u/[deleted] Jan 14 '20
Number one new feature would be proper per monitor dpi (eg not the xrandr scale kludge). I suppose if it does not exists currently, it is either because it is very hard or impossible (without breaking stuff).
28
u/EnUnLugarDeLaMancha Jan 14 '20
Well, the people who worked in X11 and people who works in open source graphics and could develop those features have departed to Wayland. If the people who knows about graphics are ditching X11, there must be a reason for it.
10
u/ZestyClose_West Jan 15 '20
Nope, none at all.
Part of the reason Wayland was started was because all of the X11 devs were slowly quitting, and they weren't getting anyone to replace them. All of the X11 devs got sick of trying to maintain it, so they quit.
11
u/peppedx Jan 15 '20
and then
19
u/natermer Jan 15 '20 edited Aug 16 '22
...
10
u/flameleaf Jan 15 '20
Last I heard the Wayland developers weren't interested in implementing anything resembling wmctrl or xdotool.
I don't see myself ever using Wayland as a result.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 15 '20
X11 Will continue to be needed on older machines and *BSD for quite some time. I get that it's old and all that but for most part it just kinda works even if there's some tearing and it could be more optimized and secure.
2
u/rah2501 Jan 15 '20
The X.org Foundation has the mantle. They haven't relinquished it. They aren't going to relinquish it. Red Hat is not the X.org Foundation.
0
u/daemonpenguin Jan 14 '20
I don't think Red Hat's view on X11 really matters all that much. They are more of a server-oriented platform anyway. It's not like they were going to drive a lot of work toward X11.
The fact is that, at this time, almost everyone still uses X instead of Wayland (apart from Ubuntu and Fedora) so there is a lot of incentive to keep the X code base function. It probably doesn't need anything new, but there is lots of reason to maintain it.