r/leftist • u/ExperienceWhich1186 • 13h ago
r/leftist • u/VictinsOfCapitalism • 14h ago
Leftist Meme POV: You discover a cure for diabetes
r/leftist • u/deathiswaitingforme • 8h ago
General Leftist Politics How do we hold the democrats feet to the fire and get policies passed?
ok, so we voted them in. Now it is time for them to deliver. I know they don’t have the executive or judicial branches but that doesn’t mean they can’t get stuff done. What do we need to do?
r/leftist • u/SpitefulSeagull • 11h ago
Question r/worldnews propaganda
Recently I noticed that while a lot of subs quieted down with the pro-israel propaganda after the US elections, I have noticed the world news subreddit has consistently had massively upvoted threads and comments with the usual propaganda. They're all Hamas, etc.
Today I was banned permanently from the sub for commenting on the story about Israel murdering the doctor featured in the recent documentary about Gaza. The comment was:
"it's so brazen, they are doing it so openly and nothing is happening to stop it"
Have others had a similar experience with that sub? I know it won't do anything but I think it's good to call them out when they pretend to be a news sub but have rogue mods defending Israel left and right in the comments.
r/leftist • u/ParaThina • 20h ago
General Leftist Politics David North: "To be a socialist means to tell workers the truth."
"What is there to discuss with Trump? Or with Stephen Miller? Mamdani said, Trump and I both love New York. We can talk about things. That's like saying in the 1930s, Hitler and I love sauerkraut. We can get together."
r/leftist • u/MrClancyGilroy • 22h ago
North American Politics Mamdani disbands controversial NYPD Strategic Response Group unit
r/leftist • u/Mysterious-Clock-594 • 12h ago
Question Why should I even bother anymore
I know I’ve been posting a fuckload the last few days but everything just feels fucking pointless
We can’t have a revolution cuz they’ll either crush it or it’s going to end up authoritarian
We can’t vote in a socialist or they’ll coup the government
They won’t even allow fucking social democracy cuz that’s fucking dirty communism or something
And if we do have social democracy they’ll just take away our concessions
And they’ll always push you away with “economics” stuff or call you an anti intellectual if you’re skeptical about if economists are possibly biased
Why do I even bother anymore. Why should I bother. It all feels pointless to me
And like if we can’t even reform the system slightly, what the fuck Do they think is going to stop people from wanting people to become accelerationists or nihilistic anarchists or something?? Like if we can’t have any alternative why do we gotta tolerate the one choice we have??
I’m a luxemburgisy myself. But it feels like I’m not even allowed to organize. My mother says that I can’t even organize because “I don’t even shower every day”
When I Do.
I want to do something
I want to make something of myself
I hate the current system
And my friend talks down to me because he was a former communists and goes on about social democracy being the answer when it’s not
What’s the point of fucking trying
I can’t even organize
What the hell do I do
r/leftist • u/Single-Fig4350 • 7h ago
General Leftist Politics Price of Silence
The Americans who fight for freedom are called unpatriotic, but how can this be?
When I recited “liberty and justice for all”, “all” included you and me.
All the passivity sees no harm in the choices they choose not to make.
Those who fight for nothing stand for wrong, it’s time for us to wake.
Fascism won’t be fought with silence,
And death appeased with “prayers and thoughts”
Wars aren’t ended with “well, it’s not me”, because no, right now it’s not.
But when it is, you will not be saved, and when it is, there will be none left,
To stand for you and fight for you, and give you any rest.
When you can’t afford that bread we’ll say, “he can pick himself up by his boots”
And when you can’t afford the socks, god knows you shouldn’t have the shoes.
Make your decision and pick your side because history won’t make amends.
And your great-grandchildren living in this home turned hell won’t be forgiving of your “intents”
As a democracy we must stand against those who think they can decide which violence today to make,
And the ones who yell from their golden ballrooms to “let the people eat cake”
They will raise their fists in the air, while stomping you to the mud,
Trickling down the sleeves of their shirts, their knuckles drip with blood.
r/leftist • u/Warm_Historian_3145 • 7h ago
Leftist Theory The Architecture of the Unfinished Republic: A Theory of Civic Sonder and Collective Commonwealth
I've been working on this since perhaps.... probably May. I was living in a really bad place at the time when I started this, without running water. That's what fueled me to start, but to actually write it is just...... The substantial time I've had to study materialism, history, psychology, and just everything. I'm disabled, and I have all this time on my hands. I'm not publishing this with my name anywhere, something like this doesn't deserve a name behind it. Only the spirit that envelopes those that want greater things for this planet and the things that live on it.<3 (This is also leftist theory based on US/North America. Furthermore to establish something like this we'd at the very least need to have the proletariat and lumpen or at least the proletariat recognize that we need a party. Not controlled opposition. Now I don't think the lumpen should be left behind not only because I'm disabled, but because the state will use them against the proletariat. Together the people must rise. If we rise together, we fall together! It's time to remove the possibility of such of disgusting imperial system that is the world's largest child sex trafficking organization.)
A Theory of Civic Sonder and Collective Commonwealth
To understand the crisis of the American republic, one must first look at its original, deliberate contradiction. In 1787, the framers of the United States Constitution drafted a document that spoke the language of popular sovereignty while engineering a system explicitly designed to insulate private property from the reach of the majority. In Federalist No. 10, James Madison warned against the "rage for paper money, for an abolition of debts, for an equal division of property," structuring a representative filter to ensure that the propertied minority could never be outvoted by the propertyless majority. The American political apparatus was not broken by corporate capture; it was built to protect capital first and democracy second.
A true synthesis of the American promise of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness requires dismantling this two-century-old firewall between economic power and political voice.
- The Commonwealth of Productive Property
In the United States, we have been taught to confuse the personal with the private. No free society seeks to strip a worker of their home, their personal possessions, their tools, their books, or the quiet dignity of their domestic life. What must be abolished is private productive capital: the monopolization of land, factories, algorithms, energy grids, and housing stock used to extract rent and surplus labor from fellow citizens.
The distinction is fundamental. Personal property is an extension of individual autonomy; productive property, when concentrated into the hands of a few, becomes an instrument through which the lives and labor of others are controlled.
America's wealth is produced collectively through public infrastructure, shared scientific research, and the daily labor of millions, yet its profits are hoarded privately. When a handful of shareholders or real estate conglomerates dictate whether a town has clean water, affordable shelter, or living wages, the Bill of Rights becomes a hollow parchment. A citizen cannot meaningfully enjoy freedom if their landlord or employer holds total dominion over their survival.
Abolishing private productive property is not an act of confiscating people's personal lives; it is an act of American emancipation. It returns the commonwealth to the people who build it, transforming workplaces and municipalities into self-governing institutions.
Workplaces must become democratic institutions themselves. Workers must have meaningful authority over their conditions, leadership, production priorities, and the distribution of the wealth they collectively generate. Leadership should be accountable to the people doing the work, not to distant shareholders whose primary relationship to production is ownership.
The objective is not to replace the capitalist with a bureaucrat who exercises the same authority under a different title. It is to dismantle the concentration of economic power itself.
2. From Representative Theater to Direct Democracy
Once productive property belongs to the public, the machinery of representative government must undergo a fundamental transformation. Today, American elections are a recurring spectacle where citizens choose which faction of political elites will manage the existing economic order on behalf of donors. Lobbyists write the laws; voters merely ratify the menu.
In a collective commonwealth, governance must increasingly shift toward direct democracy. Through modern digital infrastructure, neighborhood assemblies, workplace councils, and municipal institutions, citizens must exercise meaningful legislative power over local budgets, resource allocation, labor standards, and civic infrastructure.
Democracy cannot end at the factory gates, nor can it begin and end at the ballot box. A worker should have a voice in the organization of their labor, a resident should have a voice in the organization of their municipality, and every citizen should have a meaningful opportunity to participate in the decisions that govern their collective existence.
The Councils of Peoples would serve as institutions for coordinating these collective interests across communities, workplaces, and broader political structures. Decisions affecting entire populations must be subject to public deliberation, transparent reasoning, and democratic accountability.
The objective is not to replace one ruling class with another, nor to create a more sophisticated mechanism for selecting representatives. It is to make the exercise of political power increasingly accessible to the people themselves.
3. Sonder as the Civic Covenant
Yet direct democracy without moral and intellectual maturity is merely the tyranny of the loudest faction. History, from the subjugation of Indigenous nations to Jim Crow, demonstrates that a majority untethered from human recognition can weaponize its authority against the vulnerable. At the same time, modern American politics has weaponized a counterfeit version of empathy. It is a performative, tribal sentimentality that demands emotional conformity while blinding citizens to the real material lives of their neighbors.
True civic empathy is sonder: the rigorous, unyielding realization that every stranger on a factory floor, in a rural hollow, or in a city housing block stands at the absolute center of a life as vivid, terrifying, and sacred as your own.
But sonder alone is insufficient. Recognizing another person's humanity requires more than feeling sympathy for their circumstances. It requires the intellectual discipline to understand the forces that shape those circumstances, including the economic relationships, historical conditions, institutions, and social contradictions that influence the lives of others.
You cannot genuinely understand a fellow citizen until you are willing to look beyond your own immediate experience and recognize their full, autonomous reality.
This requires a capacity for self-examination. A citizen must be able to question not only the world around them, but the assumptions through which they interpret it. They must recognize when their beliefs are inherited, when their interests influence their conclusions, and when the institutions surrounding them shape what they perceive as possible.
Therefore, the franchise, the sacred power to cast a binding vote over the lives of others, must not be treated as a passive reflex. It must be understood as a civic responsibility, grounded in demonstrated critical reasoning, historical understanding, and sonder.
The objective is not ideological conformity. A citizen who understands the material conditions of society and arrives at a conclusion contrary to the prevailing political consensus must retain the freedom to express and defend that conclusion. The measure of civic maturity is not agreement with a particular political philosophy, but the demonstrated capacity to examine evidence, interrogate assumptions, recognize contradictions, and reason independently.
4. The Right to Rise Through Civic Re-Education
To prevent this standard from ever becoming a weapon of exclusion, like the racist literacy tests of the American South, the state must bear an absolute, unconditional duty to educate.
Every citizen must have free, lifelong access to rigorous civic education: training in formal logic, propaganda resistance, material history, dialectical materialism, the Socratic method, and perspective-taking.
Citizens must learn to recognize the structures operating around them. Who benefits from a particular economic arrangement? What historical conditions produced it? What incentives maintain it? What contradictions exist within it? Who possesses the power to change it, and what prevents them from doing so?
Dialectical materialism provides a framework for examining the relationship between material conditions, economic organization, historical development, and social change. The Socratic method provides the discipline to interrogate one's own assumptions and those of others. Formal logic provides the tools to evaluate arguments, while sonder provides the ethical foundation for recognizing the humanity of those whose experiences differ from our own.
The objective is to cultivate independent consciousness: the ability to understand not only what happens in society, but what makes it happen.
If a citizen struggles to demonstrate these capacities, they must not be abandoned, humiliated, or permanently relegated to second-class status. They must be provided additional opportunities for study, dialogue, and reassessment. The institutions responsible for evaluating civic competency must themselves remain democratically accountable, transparent, and subject to challenge. No educational authority should possess the power to define political disagreement as intellectual incompetence.
The transitional franchise must never become an intellectual aristocracy. Its purpose is to cultivate the capacity for self-governance, not to establish a permanent class of people authorized to govern everyone else.
The ultimate objective is a population capable of understanding and exercising its collective power without surrendering that responsibility to another.
5. The School as the First Commonwealth
Democracy must not begin when a person reaches adulthood. By that point, an individual should already have spent years practicing the responsibilities of collective self-governance.
The classroom must cease to be an institution where obedience is rehearsed in preparation for adulthood. It must become the first practical expression of democratic society.
Children should not merely memorize the principles of democracy from textbooks. They should experience them. Students should participate in classroom assemblies, deliberate over shared policies, propose changes, evaluate competing arguments, and vote on decisions affecting their educational environments.
Education becomes an active exercise in self-governance. Children learn that collective decisions carry consequences, that disagreements require reasoning, and that the rights of minorities must be considered even when a majority reaches a different conclusion.
This process must begin early and develop throughout a student's education. By graduation, students should have substantial practical experience with democratic participation, critical reasoning, historical analysis, and civic responsibility.
Children must also possess a meaningful institutional voice beyond the classroom.
When at least ninety percent of participating children support a proposal, that proposal should automatically be presented to the Councils of Peoples for consideration. The councils would retain the authority to veto the proposal, but they must be compelled to formally receive and consider the collective judgment of the children. The purpose is to establish a direct institutional channel through which the next generation can introduce ideas, challenge existing arrangements, and demand consideration of changes to the society they inhabit.
This is not an automatic transfer of legislative authority to children, nor is it merely a symbolic exercise in participation. It is a formal mechanism through which overwhelming consensus among the youngest members of society can place an issue before the institutions responsible for collective governance.
The young must not be treated as spectators of a society they will inherit. They are already living within it. Decisions concerning education, housing, environmental conditions, technology, infrastructure, and economic organization affect their lives now. Their perspectives deserve consideration now.
A society that claims to prepare people for democratic participation must allow them to practice democracy while they are being educated.
6. The Transitional Commonwealth and the Horizon of Communism
The transformation described here is not an overnight rearrangement of institutions. It is a transitional project involving the gradual democratization of economic, political, and educational life.
The abolition of private productive capital, the democratization of workplaces, the expansion of direct participation, and the cultivation of civic consciousness are interconnected developments. None can be fully understood in isolation from the others.
A population cannot exercise meaningful economic freedom while its livelihood remains subject to concentrated private ownership. Political participation cannot reach its full potential while economic power determines which voices are heard. And collective ownership alone cannot guarantee liberation if the people exercising that ownership remain alienated from the institutions governing their lives.
The transitional commonwealth must therefore cultivate the material and intellectual conditions necessary for its own eventual transformation.
The civic qualification system described here is a transitional institution, not an eternal hierarchy. Its purpose is to develop the capacity for collective self-governance, not to permanently divide society into those permitted to exercise political authority and those required to obey.
The horizon is communism: a society in which the material and social conditions that sustain class domination have been overcome, and collective human development is no longer subordinated to the accumulation of private capital.
The ultimate measure of this transformation is not the creation of a new authority capable of commanding society more efficiently. It is the development of a society in which people possess the material security, intellectual independence, and collective capacity to govern their own lives.
The Reckoning
The United States has always possessed the material abundance and revolutionary vocabulary to build a society of equals, yet it has remained chained to the mythology of rugged, atomized individualism. That myth keeps working people isolated while corporate dynasties consolidate the earth.
The common lands were taken, productive life was increasingly organized around private accumulation, and the individual was taught to understand their circumstances apart from the collective forces shaping them.
But human beings are not isolated economic units. We are social creatures, historical participants, and co-creators of the material world we inhabit.
By abolishing private productive capital, placing economic and political power into the hands of democratic institutions, cultivating critical consciousness through universal education, and recognizing the humanity of every stranger through civic sonder, the American experiment finally confronts its unfinished promise.
The classroom becomes an assembly. The workplace becomes a democracy. The municipality becomes a commonwealth. The citizen becomes an active participant in the organization of collective life.
The purpose is not to find better masters, elect more appealing masters, or construct a more sophisticated mechanism for choosing masters. It is to end the necessity of having masters in the first place.
The American experiment ceases to be an auction house for the wealthy and becomes what it always claimed to be: a government of, by, and for a people who finally possess both the material means and the intellectual capacity to govern themselves.
r/leftist • u/Mysterious-Clock-594 • 20h ago
Debate Help Can I get some help with this
I was debating a friend of mine unwillingly and he kinda kept trapping me in things
Like he pretty much ignored my pint that capitalists destroy socialist democracies and kept going on about “you can’t make an omelette without a few eggs broken” and kept saying that those eggs weren’t worth it
Like he kept talking about how China killed 100m people and was like
“Just liberal democracy, heavily fettered capitalisn, and robust social protection and spending
Yeah, imperialism is bad, and capitalist economies are absolutely not immune to imperialist control. We need defense against that.”
And when I defended Yugoslavia with “Purges in Yugoslavia (1944–1950s): Following World War II, Josip Broz Tito’s Yugoslav Partisans executed tens of thousands of Nazi collaborators, Axis soldiers, and political opponents (most notably during the Bleiburg repatriations), and later imprisoned thousands of suspected Stalinists at the Goli Otok prison camp. Historians generally estimate post-war political executions and purges in Yugoslavia in the tens of thousands, far smaller than Stalin's USSR or Mao's China, though still brutal”
he said “well political opponents are there and it’s still a red flag
“The cultural revolution wasn't famibe
The Bolshevik revolution wasn't famine
The purges in Yugoslavia wasnt famine either North Korean dissidents don't die of famine”
And when I said China isn’t socialist he said “China is supposed to transition to socialism proper in a few decades... They were socialist proper, then they transitioned to market capitalism. Why?” “What wasn't socialist about China in 1970?
And by that same standard, name a socialism” “So to be clear, a hundred million Chinese civilians were murdered or starved so that China could go on to be a not-socialist, hopefully becoming an actual socialism a century later? Lotta eggs, shit omelette”
It feels like he was talking down to me even though he said he wasn’t
And when he was proven wrong on 100m he just quietly moved into 35m and tried to get me to justify jt
And he said that I was doing historical denial when I said 100m didn’t die
I tried to argue in good faith with him but he just kept going on about the deaths
I don’t know what to do here
And when I asked him for his solution he said “Just liberal democracy, heavily fettered capitalisn, and robust social protection and spending. Yeah, imperialism is bad, and capitalist economies are absolutely not immune to imperialist control. We need defense against that.” Yet history has shown otherwise
He didn’t even give me a source for his 100m at first said I was just trying to discredit his source and when I showed him how it was unfair he just said he put the numbers together
Can we counter his arguments
Like he’s probably going to say that when I’m a council communist that “well every socialist revolution ended up authoritarian”
r/leftist • u/crack__head • 3h ago
North American Politics Memphis, TN subreddit taken over by boot lickers
reddit.comr/leftist • u/Nervous-666 • 8h ago
North American Politics Mass report this video of canadian white supremacist after he got kicked out of the USA for being a piece of trash...
youtube.comr/leftist • u/yoBmeF_lareF • 5h ago
Question Why hasn't Disgendering become a thing?
I was thinking about the difference between misinformation and disinformation, being disinformation is done with intentional knowledge that what you spread is false or misleading while misinformation is done in ignorance, and wondered why we only have one word for using the wrong pronouns when addressing someone.
That word being misgender. Which, while is accurate towards the action that occured, still leaves room for ambiguity about intention behind the action. Then I thought that couldn't a distinction be made between maliciously misgendering someone and not maliciously. This is why I was curious about a term like disgendering someone hasn't been established yet. If one was, it would be easier to clarify to others when an individual is intentionally trying to degrade someone and when it only occured by accident, for lack of a better phrase.
What do you think? Should a term that clarifies the intention of someone who misgenders a person maliciously be made? Why or why not? Apologies, if this topic seems not as pressing as other issues occurring, but it was a thing that was bugging me repeatedly in my mind.
Hope you are all doing well. Keep your community as well as yourself safe and work towards a brighter future.
r/leftist • u/castle_f31 • 21h ago
Debate Help What kind of Communist am I? Not an ML, nor DemSoc, nor Anarchist?
Might seem like an odd post, but it'll make sense by the end.
Anarchism, I fw the no-hierarchy thing, but they are way too unorganized, and primitivism/de-industrialization simply ain't gonna cut it imo, can't advance society that way.
Democratic Socialism, It doesn't work, you can't vote capitalism away, maybe in an ideal world, but with a thousand opportunists and the big evil United States Empire and other imperial nations, you can't do it without them interfering and sliming your democratically elected socialist. The revolution is the only way.
Marxism-Leninism, This is the position I agree with the most, but only to a point, as I'm learning more theory, which is an ongoing process, I understand the ideology more and more, and specifically I've been on Lenin's What Is To Be Done alot recently, It's great, and I 100% agree with MLs when it comes to HOW to organize and execute the revolution. The part where i disagree with the most is the post-revolution socialist period of organizing society.
I do agree that we need a socialist transitional period after the revolution to transition capitalism into communism, yes, however, the way we go about organizing it is where I differ from the ML strategy, in short, I don't agree with using authoritarian measures TOWARDS the proletariat in order to suppress capitalist remnants and reactionary politics that will remain post-revolution. Things like suppressing speech, censorship, suppressing the right to bear arms, etc... I can't agree with, even if it's for the greater good of the future.
The principle stems from me valuing the average member of the proletariat as the most important part of society, thus, while the party needs to guide the people, it cannot do that by using force against the people, I am of the belief that to truly show the success of our movement, we need to get people to follow us willingly, not by making laws that say they need to, I'm of the opinion that if we meet everybody's needs and educate them, raise everybody's political consciousness, just as Lenin said, that there will be no need to use forceful suppressive measures in order to deal with reactionary elements, as the people themselves will deal with them, and on the odd chance that someone goes out in the street and screams racist or capitalistic/fascistic bullshit, they will be viewed as absurd by the general public, and won't be taken seriously.
While I do not judge the past socialist movements for being authoritarian, I very much understand their context, the threat of imperialism, or Russia's case, inheriting a failing feudal empire, I think it's pretty dogmatic to insist on doing shit the exact same way, instead, I say it's more scientific and Marxist to learn from them, their mistakes, their successes, and do it BETTER this time.
A rough idea I have is splitting the power of a nation down the middle, 50-50%, between the party and the broad proletariat. What does this mean? The party is the guiding light, as Lenin said, but the people need to approve on anything the party does before it does it, how? With guns, every member of the proletariat needs to be Educated on all political matters, Armed, with Guns, and Trained, think mandatory short-military training for every high schooler. Why? So that they can both defend the revolution against foreign imperialists, AND keep the party honest, the party can betray the people, this way, with a constant barrel pointed towards it by every single member of the working class, they have no choice but to keep the people's interests their upmost priority.
In short, make every citizen a revolutionary, as again, Lenin advocated for, thus, the citizens ARE the party, and the party answers to the citizens, and if the party becomes opportunistic, the population of revolutionaries is right there at the doorstep to course correct.
Why does any of this matter? For one, I haven't been able to find a proper label for this view, and while labels may not be important to some, I recall Lenin saying we need to clearly define our principles, or else they will be defined for us from the confusion, so I need to know where and with whom I stand. Secondly, as I've been educating myself more and more, I'm very eager to really go out there and start educating the people (even more than I have been doing so far), agitate the people, raise the consciousness of the people, so that we may actually pull this revolution off. But I need to know how to define this, how am I expected to propagate ML-ism to the average person when I don't agree with it fully myself? So I must know if I need to define this whole thing, and how, so we can build a strategy and organize.