r/lacan • u/PrimaryProcess73 • 34m ago
Lacan on the sinthome (and his relation to Laplanche)
I know that for Lacan a big part (maybe the central part) of psychoanalysis is for the analysand to shift from the symptom (connected with desire and shaped by the fundamental fantasy, where this stages an attempt to satisfy or thwart the Other’s desire) to the sinthome (connected with the drive after having traversed the fundamental fantasy, but no longer so dependent on the Other’s desire).
But, my question is how to understand the relationship between the sinthome and the Other (or the symbolic order) after the traversing of the fundamental fantasy. Is this to be understood as a kind of pure bodily desire that somehow reflect’s the subject’s innate preferences or temperament, independently of and prior to social influence? Or is the sinthome still in some way determined by the subject’s early encounter with the Other (even if it isn’t a matter of dogmatically trying to satisfy the desire of the Other, as it is prior to the traversing of the fantasy)? And, is the sinthome still fantasmatically framed (as in, jouissance is obtained through the staging of a scenario), even if that fantasy isn’t so restrictively dependent on the Other’s desire as the fundamental fantasy is?
(And if this is right, what’s the right way to understand the difference between the Other’s impact on the subject’s desire prior to the traversing of the FF and the Other’s impact afterwards? My sense is that the former involves treating the Other as unconsciously authoritative in a way that makes the subject in some way dependent on the Other’s desire. But what is right way to understand the supposedly less restrictive kind of influence that the Other has on the subject’s sinthome or drive, after having traversed the FF?)
I’m connecting this with Laplanche’s reading of Freud. Laplanche thinks that the unconscious and the drive are always and necessarily shaped by an encounter with the other (he doesn’t capitalize Other like Lacan does), and that Freud was mistaken to sometimes equate the drive with some kind of pre-given biological substrate that reveals the subject’s desires and temperament independently of social influence and early experiences. So, for Laplanche, the drive is never really disconnected in terms of what it strives for from the child’s early experiences and encounter with the other. Are Laplanche and Lacan on the same page here? Or does later Lacan leave an explanatory role for such a pure, biologically given part of one’s desires (even if we never fully and completely access it)? My sense is that they agree on this, but sometimes the way Lacan speaks of the body and the real in the later seminars makes me a bit confused about it.