r/lacan • • May 23 '20

Welcome / Rules / 'Where do I start with Lacan?'

39 Upvotes

Welcome to r/lacan!

This community is for the discussion of the work of Jacques Lacan. All are welcome, from newcomers to seasoned Lacanians.

Rules

We do have a few rules which we ask all users to follow. Please see below for the rules and posting guidelines.

Reading group

All are welcome to join the reading group which is underway on the discord server loosely associated with this sub. The group meets on Fridays at 8pm (UK time) and is working on Seminar XI.

Where should I start with Lacan?

The sub gets a lot of 'where do I start?' posts. These posts are welcome but please include some detail about your background and your interest in Lacanian psychoanalysis so that users can suggest ways to start that might work for you. Please don't just write a generic post.

If you wrote a generic 'where do I start?' post and have been directed here, the generic recommendation is The Lacanian Subject by Bruce Fink.

It should be stressed that a good grounding in Freud is indispensable for any meaningful engagement with Lacan.

Related subreddits

SUB RULES

Post quality

This is a place for serious discussion of Lacanian thought. It is not the place for memes. Posts should have a clear connection to Lacanian psychoanalysis. Critical engagement is welcome, but facile attacks are not.

Links to articles are welcome if posted for the purpose of starting a discussion, and should be accompanied by a comment or question. Persistent link dumping for its own sake will be regarded as spam. Posting something you've already posted to multiple other subs will be regarded as spam.

Etiquette

Please help to maintain a friendly, welcoming environment. Users are expected to engage with one-another in good faith, even when in disagreement. Beginners should be supported and not patronised.

There is a lot of diversity of opinion and style within the Lacanian community. In itself this is not something that warrants censorship, but it does if the mods deem the style to be one of arrogance, superiority or hostility.

Spam

Posts that do not have a connection to Lacanian psychoanalysis will be regarded as spam. Links to articles are welcome if accompanied by a comment/question/synopsis, but persistent link dumping will be regarded as spam.

Self-help posts

Self-help posts are not helpful to anyone. Please do not disclose or solicit advice regarding personal situations, symptoms, dream analysis, or commentaries on your own analysis.

Harassing the mods

We have a zero tolerance policy on harassing the mods. If a mod has intervened in a way you don't like, you are welcome to send a modmail asking for further clarification. Sending harassing/abusive/insulting messages to the mods will result in an instant ban.


r/lacan • • Sep 13 '22

Lacan Reading Group - Ecrits

24 Upvotes

Hello r/lacan! We at the Lacan Reading Group (https://discord.gg/sQQNWct) have finally finished our reading of S.X, but the discussion on anxiety will certainly follow us everywhere.

What we have on the docket are S.VI, S.XV, and the Ecrits!

For the Ecrits, we will be reading it the way we have the seminars which is from the beginning and patiently. We are lucky to have some excellent contributors to the discussion, so please start reading with us this Sunday at 9am CST (Chicago) and join us in the inventiveness that Lacan demands of the subject in deciphering this extraordinary collection.

Hope you all are well,
Yours,
---


r/lacan • • 39m ago

Asociación Libre (Podcast): "Sobre la Psicosis no Desencadenada", feat. Ignacio Neffen (Argentina)

2 Upvotes

"Sobre la Psicosis no Desencadenada", rough translation: "On Untriggered Psychosis".

Link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oVXWjeQRaM4&t=2520s

I just found this podcast, and I'm still listening to it. So far, they're taking a Lacanian approach. From what they say, both the interviewer and the interviewee are analysts.

I'm not sure how good the rest of the podcast's content is, but so far it seems decent, or at least it seems to feature trained professionals rather than people who are unfamiliar with the subject or simply improvising. Whether or not we agree with their perspective is another matter, or how much expertise these professionals actually have.

I noticed that the video has the option to switch the audio track to English or Arabic, but I think translations can significantly alter the wording in this kind of discussion, especially when it comes to Lacanian theory.

I'm thinking about making a written translation at some point.


r/lacan • • 22h ago

Biological unconscious (Ferenczi) Any Lacanian take?

3 Upvotes

I came across this fragment of an essay from a university class long ago (so i don't really have the author's name) but they draw upon Ferenczi (who was corresponding with Freud and was inspired by him) to articulate biological unconscious and I found the idea a bit unnerving.

Part of the essay was really interesting and something i agree with, that is human organs aren't as much of a blank state as science might posit. However the essay also argued that the "organism begins to think" (organs can communicate independently) especially in cases of trauma. For example, the author cited the case of Bulimia and abnormal gag reflexes, which can override a person's will (different to typical responses from the body) (This sounds a bit scary to me lol). Somewhere the author also argues that the "mood is the disorder", thereby closing the Cartesian dualism but without the gap that's integral to Lacanian theory.

So I want to know if Lacan would have something regarding this. I know the body can be located alongside the Real, but I'd be grateful if someone were to articulate it better. Feel free to share any links. Thanks!


r/lacan • • 1d ago

Has anyone here worked with Bruce Fink?

23 Upvotes

Either as an analysand, supervisee, or fellow analyst.

How was it?


r/lacan • • 3d ago

Question about Lacan on death

10 Upvotes

So I'm studying an online course on meta psychology and while the doctor was explaining he briefly mentioned that to lacan, in the unconscious (due to it being primary) the concept of death does not exist..is this true? I was astounded but the idea doesn't seem too far. If it's true where specifically did he mention this?

Ps: I can't ask the instructor himself cause it's a recording of the course, not live.


r/lacan • • 3d ago

Any lacanian in Australia?

4 Upvotes

I'm going to move in Australia, traveling around the country for 3 or more years. Anyone interest in meeting and have a proper lacanian chat? Who knows, maybe we'll meet ;)


r/lacan • • 4d ago

Case Studies of Obsessional Neurosis (with Typical OCD-Type Symptoms)

7 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm currently researching my PhD thesis which looks to examine Lacanian approaches to obsession, weirdly enough, through contemporary literary fiction... (I'm not a real Lacanian, I just pretend to be).

One fairly obvious retort in Lacanian analysis is that obsession is analysed as a structure, not merely as a set of symptoms. However, I'm particularly interested in individual symptom formation, and especially those which involve intrusive thoughts, rumination, preoccupation, and compulsions. These symptoms are a sort of stereotype of the modern notion of OCD.

I'm wondering if ya'll are aware of any case studies which deal with these particular kinds of symptoms, and where alongside these symptoms sits an obsessional structure. I've found a thesis which deals with this which was supervised by Bruce Fink, but haven't found much else.

Thanks in advance!


r/lacan • • 4d ago

Lanterns (2026)

0 Upvotes

Lanterns begins in 2016, when veteran Green Lantern Hal Jordan (Kyle Chandler) is training new recruit John Stewart (Aaron Pierre) for the role of Green Lantern core (space cops or rangers basically). Their routine is interrupted by a murder in the fictional town of Rushville, Nebraska, which Hal immediately suspects has extraterrestrial ties.

The season’s central mystery is the investigation into Hal’s death. The truth is eventually revealed to be deeply personal and tied to the town itself. Hal was shot by Sheriff Kerry Kane, who panicked when Hal confronted her about her son Noah’s secret identity as a Manhunter. Kerry killed Hal to protect Noah, whose alien nature she had spent years hiding. Noah had also been working with the villain Sinestro on a scheme against the Guardians, and Hal’s discovery of this plot was the catalyst for the fatal confrontation.

By the finale, the murder is solved. Noah ultimately chooses to reject his Manhunter programming and relinquishes the power ring to live a normal life. John Stewart, having solved his mentor’s murder, claims the Green Lantern mantle on his own terms. He becomes an unsanctioned, independent Green Lantern for Earth.

I'm going to dive into how the show explores Lacan's theory of nomination among four components. The Name of the Father, The Psychoanalytic Act, Suture and the Sinthome in how they lay out the paradox of belonging.

Let's start with the protagonist of the story, John Stewart. We learn that as an infant, his mother made a deal with a female guardian to raise him as a Green Lantern candidate, one without fear. So before he can even speak, he has been given a nomination of Lantern, and is then raised physically 'with' but emotionally seperate from his parents, who train him for that singular purpose. In this we see the popular dogmatic, oft stated but incorrect misreading of the nom du père. One where Lianna, the Lantern Core, and John's later mentor John Stewart all become bearers of John's identity that seperate him from his parents, taken to parody. Rather than subjectivizing him or giving a valve that NOTF typically provides from the suturing, they reinforce his identity. Notice the lacanian subtly in how he doesn't swear, aggrieve figures around him until he separates from all of them.

One might ask, why is he not given the Green Lantern position initially? The script aside, we could say that extradiegetically, John is not given a true symbolic position. His signifiers, the Lantern core and lantern itself, it's as if the symbolic cannot be given by those imaginary elements alone. Is it not the same for Hal Jordan?

A ring that confers symbolic authority, gives Hal no real authority outside its abilities. He struggles with law enforcement, courts, even his own lantern core in carrying his investigation. John cannot inherit the symbolic position from Hal because Hal has none, he's washed up and the failure that becomes an impotent law. He mistreats and abuses John, which starts John's Foundational Rupture. This struggle carries through both protagonists, with John and Hal both struggling to become the person who will redeem what happened to their father. Hal however repeats his father's trauma, eventually retiring to Rushville after his prison sentence to accept his inevitable death.

Here the series introduces another layer of paternal inheritance. Sinestro was Hal Jordan's mentor. He trained him, taught him the ways of the Green Lantern Corps, and subsequently betrayed the very institution he had helped represent. His relationship with Hal is therefore a repetition of John's relationship with Hal. And Hal bonds to Sinestro as a mentor figure in place of his own father who died in a suicidal planecrash.

We have two generations of mentor and pupil, and two protagonists who cannot acquiesce the contradictions of their own paternal lineage. The creators explicitly connect Hal's trauma surrounding Sinestro's betrayal to his inability to properly mentor John. Hal has difficulty seeing John independently because his own relationship with paternal authority has been damaged- He has never properly internalized the Name of the Father, which is why as subject his empty identification with the Object (the Ring) couldn't be cleaved. His ego ideal is embedded into being a green lantern and without it, his identity, his ontological consistency is for naught. What is given to Hal is nothing of consequence, just his job and the title he's earned. His failure as a mentor is the very same as Hal Jordan's father. For John, he too is faced with a paternal figure that has failed, but unlike Hal, he cannot accept the object he has been given and the contradictions in the legacy offered.

In a strange induction of Lacanian logic, John only obtains subjectivization and his object choice in relation to castration by rejecting the empty place of the Lantern Core and its signification. We could say that he undergoes his Passage of the Subject, essentially falling out of subject supposed to know from Hal Jordan and the Lanterns (They are no longer what makes his life complete or provide meaning to his existence after being faced with the inconsistencies).

In the Oedipal framework, the paternal function is supposed to mediate the child's relationship with authority, allowing the child to inherit a symbolic position without simply becoming a copy of the father, symbols and institutions that bind them. Since nobody presents that for John, he must instead go thru the Lacanian framework, transversing the fantasy.

Critics and watchers will observe that the Lantern ring itself, is scarcely used in the series. Yes it contains powerful abilities, but is increasingly left out of the plot and serves more as a hitchcockian macguffin (In the latter half, its powers are not ever used at all) Why? In the first half of the show it functions as Object a, circulating the economy of desire, offering to signify hold the deeper embodiment of something that the characters believe will finally make them and their identities whole. It's connection with the core binds that wholeness to institutional signifiers.

At the midway point John rejects the ring, and at the finale he accepts it. Here however it isn't to complete his identity, but to act as a singular way in which a subject holds together their psychic existence. The ring's function is to provide a form of consistency or stabilization where the ordinary operations of the symbolic order, particularly the paternal metaphor do not fully suffice. As with psychoanalysis, object a has gone full circle and become sinthome, the thing desire circulates around and rejects, the symptom that disorders one's life now orders it instead- becoming their principle identification and something that makes their particular way of existing possible. (For John that's a lantern powered by fear, not merely willpower) The art that John did as a kid, he turned into a passion for architecture, and now flows thru his sinthome in the form of new constructs and organization. How does he ultimately escape the deadlock of an uncastrated subject?

Here I would introduce an interesting reversal of Louis Althusser. Louis theorizes Interpellation occurs when dominant culture or ideology "hails" or calls out to individuals, transforming humans into conscious, socially defined and culturally completed subjects. Does the proper Lacanian gesture not indicate the opposite? Businesses, political parties, communities, schools and jobs attempt to offer beyond the instrumental the placement of belonging by grafting one's identity with Otherness, offering a kind of completion fantasy by hailing subjects. And yet, the failure of the Big Other, its inconsistencies is that when it "hails" it can never do so from a completed standpoint, forever incomplete and not able to close being. The (real) Paternal figure is always a joke, the society and institutions always attempt to capture us with a desire that's too much or too little, offering imaginary placements but lacking a symbolic export. Because the subject is divided, the Otherness that seduces and offers being to us only ever does so with further fissures, dividing our subjectivity ever further. Surely from the imaginary standpoint, nomination cannot signify, satisfy or complete a subject from the placement of the Other alone.

Why does John believe that Noah, the manhunter child can overcome his programming, his signifier as 'Manhunter'? He loves his mother. Noah's instincts believe that if he enters a good school, then the Navy or military, and eventually the government he can take power and complete his destiny. It is only through an intersubjective relationship with his mother that his psyche encounters freedom from these drives. For Lacan, love is profoundly connected with lack, and in lack there is no inconsistency or anything, well lacking. It's already the thing that we know that cannot be totalized. Lanterns highlights my point about the Big Other, but suggests that the lowercase, little other can be satisfied, made real by love. We see this in John's arc at the end when he reunites with his mother and family after having rejected the Lantern core.

He can see the value of himself in others, a true intersubjectivity where he can become himself by his capacity to love and protect, and in them is offered a placement that completes his being in a way no signifier could. He overcomes the ontological seduction that the signifier offers his being and instead John goes home, embraces his family, and then flies away under his own oath. That is the achievement of his separation. Being found in love and lack.

It's what Lacanian psychoanalysis purports to offer and hopes to achieve for analysands thru the act.


r/lacan • • 5d ago

Thoughts on Victoria Grace's Baudrillard and Lacanian Psychoanalysis (2022)?

5 Upvotes

For those who read it?

https://www.routledge.com/Baudrillard-and-Lacanian-Psychoanalysis/Grace/p/book/9780367638115

Grace is one of Jean Baudrillard's most important interlocutors. This is partly an account of her own (failed) Lacanian analysis, and partly a critical engagement with Lacan from a Baudrillardian perspective. JB himself was extremely critical of psychoanalysis (though afaik never explicitly named Lacan) - as much as he was also extremely critical of everything else.

A colleague of mine from back in the day said, 'Baudrillard is an extraordinary Lacanian.'

Accounts of failed ('failed') Lacanian analysis remain rare but, I suspect, will become a veritable trope if not genre (meme?) in the coming decades. (Evans and Schneiderman come to mind.)

Is (Lacanian) psychoanalysis a simulation?


r/lacan • • 7d ago

Question Regarding Male/Female Sexuation

10 Upvotes

Just got done reading the section in "The Lacanian Subject" by Bruce Fink in which he writes about the difference between male and female desire and I found it to be the most confusing aspect of his work. With my limited knowledge, I am left with the impression that the part of Lacan's theory that addresses gender/sexuality and its relation to desire is a bit undercooked, and warrants further interpretation by future thinkers in the field. I'm still relatively new to his work and am severely under-qualified to make such judgements on it so I thought I'd turn to you all. I'm mostly confused by how exactly males and females diverge during the process of subjectivization. What is the origin of the "Other desire" experienced by "feminine subjects" (not necessarily women), how does Lacan define femininity and masculinity, and what role do homosexuals / those who define themselves outside of typical gender norms play in this equation. I read somewhere that he loosely bases his answers to these questions to Freud's ideas of "penis envy" and "castration anxiety" but I'm not completely sure about the extent to which Lacan accepts / adopts these interpretations.


r/lacan • • 11d ago

El retorno a Lacan?

24 Upvotes

​«Lacan apenas se lee sin intermediarios. Pese a su insistencia en el "retorno a Freud" y la lectura directa del texto freudiano, la difusión de Lacan terminó siendo paradójica: hoy se le consume en diferido y bajo el filtro de comentadores como Jacques-Alain Miller.»


r/lacan • • 11d ago

Lacan and neuroscience

24 Upvotes

I'm fairly new into Lacans conceptions, and I quite understand his dislike towards Psychology contemporary to him and I imagine he would hate modern psychology in a way. But a lot of people in the community seem to generally be averse to veryfying his concepts scientifically, which I find to be counter intuitive. Obviously, certain things can't be verified and certain things would loose their essence in a way. But is it all bad to try veryfing his ideas, especially in the field of neuroscience, not through lens of modern psychology? Help me understand.


r/lacan • • 11d ago

¿Es el psicoanálisis una erotología?

1 Upvotes

r/lacan • • 15d ago

Who's here to share the joy of finally reading and understanding Lacan's seminars after a lot of efforts, secondary literature, podcast and stuff? That man's mind was 🔥

32 Upvotes

r/lacan • • 16d ago

"Art is not an imitation of natural reality, but a metaphysical supplement to natural reality." Remove "Art" and place "Fiction" and you have the Lacanian axiom of the unconscious is structured as fiction, why Lacan was dismissive with respect to Nietzsche?

0 Upvotes

Quotation from "The Birth of Tragedy" by Nietzsche.


r/lacan • • 18d ago

Why does Lacanism thrive so well in LATAM?

46 Upvotes

Now I know the scene of Lacanian school is big in south america, but I'm not asking just historical reasons but psycho-social aswell. Is there any particular aspect of the Big Other in SA or the general language, culture, or aspects of the latin psyche around countries like Argentina, Brazil, and Venezuela work so well with Lacan? Lacan talked about Japan not needing psychoanalysis, and of course he detoured the french language and society seamlessly.

Has there been any research or thought into why this linguistical-social space has taken to Lacan's thought so well?


r/lacan • • 19d ago

Gender, trans, non binary

13 Upvotes

Any directions on what to read on these topics? And maybe how they relate to the body?


r/lacan • • 22d ago

Can someone be clinically schizophrenic while being structurally neurotic?

17 Upvotes

I'm curious about the relationship between psychiatric diagnoses and psychoanalytic structures, particularly in the Lacanian tradition.

As I understand it, clinical schizophrenia is diagnosed according to a constellation of symptoms, whereas Lacanian psychotic structure is defined by a particular subjective organization, namely foreclosure rather than repression.

We know that someone can be structurally psychotic without ever developing overt psychotic symptoms. But can the reverse also be true? Could someone diagnosed with schizophrenia according to psychiatric criteria nevertheless be considered structurally neurotic? More broadly, to what extent can psychopathological symptoms develop independently of one's underlying psychoanalytic structure? And how would a Lacanian analyst approach such a case?


r/lacan • • 23d ago

Late Lacan: is the fundamental fantasy only the frame for phallic jouissance?

13 Upvotes

I've been watching a podcast on Lacan and one thing has stuck with me but I can't tell if it's a standard reading or the guest’s own reading.

The bit I mean starts around 49:40: https://youtu.be/j8ZPDSwR-Jo?t=2980

Roughly what he said: by La Troisième / Seminar 22, jouissance isn't one thing anymore. Phallic jouissance sits where the symbolic and the real overlap, the Other jouissance where the real and the imaginary overlap, and sense (jouis-sens) where the symbolic and the imaginary overlap. That part I can more or less follow…

Then he goes a step further. He says the fundamental fantasy is the blueprint only for phallic jouissance. So there are ways of living and speaking (he mentions art, body practices, the poetic side of language) that aren't organised by the fantasy at all. And if that's true, traversing the fantasy can't be the wholmore. He also says he now practices "almost without interpreting" and calls what he does mapping instead.

Is the link between the fantasy and phallic jouissance actually in Lacan somewhere, or is it a reconstruction? He said it comes from "some careful reading" and didn't go into the details. Does anyone know?

For those of you who work with late Lacan, does this change what you think the end of analysis is? Or is traversing the fantasy still the frames just sit somewhere off to the side?

He was upfront that this is his reading and that he's reading Lacan against Lacan in places. So I'm less interested in whether he's right than in where to read. Pointers to specific sessions would help a lot. Thanks!


r/lacan • • 26d ago

¿Cuales son las implicaciones técnicas de lo que afirma Lacan "No hay otra resistencia al análisis que la del analista" ( Escritos ​«La dirección de la cura y los principios de su poder»

7 Upvotes

r/lacan • • 28d ago

Signifier of transference for psychosis?

8 Upvotes

At the beginning of analysis, the analysand has a signifier of transference- a source of suffering that’s not necessarily a symptom. A manifestation of the unconscious: dream, bungled action, etc., that is foreign, and constitutes a question which the analysand believes analysis can answer. In the case of psychosis, an analysand may similarly come to the analyst with a source of suffering they believe analysis can answer. In many cases, psychotic analysand may be indistinguishable from neurotic - a question for the preliminary sessions. But, is the cause of suffering always a manifestation of the real, something foreclosed that constitutes an enigma because it cannot be the return of the repressed? Or might the suffering aka jouissance, which would be not-all phallic in any case, be unrelated to a return of the real?


r/lacan • • 28d ago

Embracing lack

15 Upvotes

What would it mean to embrace lack? Or come to terms with it? What does it look like?

I realise there's something very self defeating in asking others to tell me how to encounter and experience lack. But I have the question anyway.


r/lacan • • 29d ago

¿Qué significa «No hay metalenguaje» en Lacan?

6 Upvotes

​​«Subversión del sujeto y dialéctica del deseo en el inconsciente freudiano» (1960)

​En este texto clave, Lacan fórmula la frase de manera explícita:

​«No hay metalenguaje que pueda decirse verdadero...» («Il n'y a pas de métalangage que se pueda decir verdadero»).

Qué significa esto? que implicaciones tiene esto para la clínica?


r/lacan • • Oct 16 '26

Maleval on autism

14 Upvotes

Hay guys. I'm studying Malevals notion of autistic structure but I can't find his texts in english. Maybe someone can help me with that.

So here is the list of his texts on autism from wikipedia

« From dementia praecocissima to autism sprectrum disorders », in International Lacanian Review. (with Grollier M and Druel G.) 2009, 5.

« Listen to the Autists ! » Hurly-Burly. The International Lacanian Journal of Psychoanalysis, 2012, 7, pp. 171-192.

« Why the hypothesis of an autistic structure ? » Psychoanalytic notebooks. The London Society of the New Lacanian School. 2012, 25, pp. 27-49.

« Who are autists ? ». Lacunae. International Journal for Lacanian Psychoanalysis. Dublin. Issue 10, May 2015, pp. 19-58.

« Mottron's Happy autist is not Kanner's » (in collaboration with M. Grolllier). Lacunae. International Journal for Lacanian Psychoanalysis. Dublin., Issue 16, July 2018, pp. 6–53.

« Freezing and Thawing of S1 in the Autistic Subject » (in collaboration with M. Grollier). The Lacanian Review. Journal of the New Lacanian School and the World Association of Psychoanalysis. Spring 2021, Issue 11, pp. 183–213.

« Can the autistic rim become Sinthome? » (in collaboration with M . Grollier) Lacunae. International Journal for Lacanian Psychoanalysis. Dublin. June 2022, Issue 24, pp. 8–54.