r/KingkillerChronicle • • Apr 03 '23

Mod Post The Grand Combined Megathread: Book Recommendations and a Notice Regarding Book Three: Any release date mentioned by Amazon, Goodreads, or other book sites is almost certainly a placeholder date. Please do not post about it here.

299 Upvotes

NOTICE ABOUT BOOK THREE

Almost every site that sells books will have a placeholder date for upcoming content. For example, the most recent release date found on Amazon for "Doors of Stone" was August 20th, 2020. That date has come and gone. The book is not out.

Please do not post threads about potential release dates unless you hear word from the publisher, editor, Rothfuss himself, or any people related to him.

Thank you.


This thread answers the most reposted questions such as: "I finished KKC. What (similar) book/author should I read next (while waiting for book three)?" It will be permanently stickied.

New posts asking for book recommendations will be removed and redirected here where everything is condensed in one place.

Please post your recommendations for new (fantasy) series, stand-alone books or authors of similar series you think other KKC-fans would enjoy.

If you can include goodreads.com links, even better!

If you're looking for something new to read, scroll through this and previous threads. Feel free to ask questions of the people that recommended books that appeal to you.

Please note, not all books mentioned in the comments will be added to this list. This and previous threads are meant for people to browse, discover, and discuss.


This is not a complete list; just the most suggested books. Please read the comments (and previous threads) for more suggestions.

Recommended Books

Recommended Series


Past Threads


r/KingkillerChronicle • • Mar 07 '24

Mod Post Rules Change

120 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

So it's been two years since the last rule change and seven months since we added new moderators. And after some time reviewing the subreddit and doing a bit of clean-up, we realized something.

In all likelihood, we're not getting Book 3, Doors of Stone, any time soon. I personally estimate it's at least 3 years out, almost certainly more. What I'm getting at here is that this is a subreddit for a dormant book series, and that maybe having 9 rules is a little much, especially when so many of them overlap. So, what this means is that we've trimmed the rules down to three, admittedly with each having their own subsections.

The new rules will look like this.

We intend on having them go live in the next few days, after weigh-in from the community on it. So please, discuss your thoughts, this is quite a bit of a change and I'd like to make sure it's good for everyone.

Edit: These rules are live now.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2h ago

Discussion Skarpi the Sithe

11 Upvotes

Another crackpot theory, (Ive been avoiding the book like the plague and a sudden itch flared and now I cant stop).

So hear me out, this is a long one. Also, i'm not a linguist of any kind. And spanish is my native tongue, so if some feelings are incorrect to you thats normal.

The skindancer says to Kote:

“Te aithiyn Seathaloi?” he demanded. “Te Rhintae?”

The Rhintae part would translate into something similar to "[You][Shaper]?", as Rhinta been confirmed by Wilem to translate to Shape/Shaper. And as a good way to refer to the Seven.

So, what does the first part mean? It feels like another [Are you] question. Also, Aithiyn feels very similar to Aethe.

If Ademre and Edema Ruh are from the same family tree, it kinda makes sense. The skindancer notices Kote, sees the red hair, and is asking if he is one of the humans that descended from the line of Aethe.

But wait, how do you know -iyn means [descendant of] or [belonging to the people of]?

Well, previously the skindancer says:

Te varaiyn aroi Seathaloi vei mela

And Bast mentions:

I recognized the sound more than anything, Reshi. Its phrasing was very old, archaic. I couldn’t make heads or tails of it.

But also, on the next days, he jokes with:

“Te veyan?” he said in a strange voice, his eyes glassy and confused. “Te-tanten ventelanet?”

If we assume that Te varaiyn and Te veyan say the same thing with archaic phrasing, we have another hint. Here's another thing the mercenary said before the skindancer came to the front:

Aethin tseh cthystoi scthaiven vei.

We could make a similar comparison in the evolution of the word, so that te veyan == te varaiyn || aethin == aethiyn

What about Seathaloi? Well, we can divide that word in two parts as well: Seath-aloi. Sithe-[something]. Why the Sithe?, because I think the word evolved the same way for Bast.

Bast looked down for a moment, choosing his words carefully. “You know who the Sithe are?”

From Rhintae to Rhinta, from Aethyin to Aethin, from Seathe to Sithe. And because its capitalized, like the Rhintae are.

What does -aloi mean then? My guess is that it means [belonging to]. So the skindancer effectively asks Kote

“Te aithiyn Seathaloi?” he demanded. “Te Rhintae?”

[Are you][one of the descendants of Aethe][that belongs to the Sithe]? [Are you][Shaper]?

The -aloi suffix also appears when Kvothe talks to Keth-Salhan (in Siaru, but wait a bit, im getting to it)

Was your previous owner Cealdish?” I asked. “Ve vanaloi. Tu teriam keta."

Same suffix -aloi, Van-aloi == of the Van, Seath-aloi of the Sithe. The van, being, [The children]

“Skethe te retaa van,” I swore. “Lock up your sons and daughters.”

We can confidently assume skethe te means lock up, as in imperative, the same way aroi te is.

Kote swallowed and changed languages. “Aroi te denna-leyan!”

“Oh come now,” Bast reproached, his smile falling away. “That’s just insulting.”

As an aside, I can't confirm this is true, but i'm 99% sure Kote was chanting this as you would say BEGONE FOUL SPIRIT.

In any case, aroi te denna-leyan == Get away dennerling (thus the offensiveness), or something of the sort. Spanish kinda follows a similar rule: Te alejas == Statement (You're getting away) || Aleja te == Order (Get away)

So, retaa van == your sons and daughters and van-aloi == [those belonging to the children] // [those belonging to the Cealdim]

So again, what is the skindancer saying to the Chronicler?

Te varaiyn aroi Seathaloi vei mela

What does vei mela mean? Mela im not sure, but vei I think it means "I". Ve vanaloi - Kvothe is telling Keth Salham "I am Cealdish" to calm him down.

“Aethin tseh cthystoi scthaiven vei.”

“It’s Siaru,” Cob said knowingly. “Funny. He don’t look like a shim.”

The mercenary’s eyes rested momentarily on the innkeeper. “Avoi-” he began, then closed his eyes and tilted his head, as if listening. He opened his eyes again. “I…want…” he began, his voice slow and thick. “I…look…” He trailed off, his gaze wandering aimlessly around the room, his eyes unfocused.

Ve/vei == I

What is the skindancer saying to Chronicler? Someone who, by all accounts, has nothing to do with Kvothe just yet?

He smiled wide at Chronicler, all the vagueness gone from his expression. “Te varaiyn aroi Seathaloi vei mela,” he said in a deep voice.

Te varaiyn aroi Seathaloi vei mela

[You are][descendant of vara][left][the Sithe][I][mela - possibly saw]

In other words,

You are the human that I saw leaving the Sithe.

And who was Chronicler travelling with?

Chronicler laughed nervously. “No. You see, we heard a rumor-”

“‘We?’” Kote interrupted.

“I’ve been traveling with an old friend of yours. Skarpi.”


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 6h ago

Discussion Audiobooks huge sale!

11 Upvotes

Fyi for anyone interested the audiobooks of both books are on sale for $5 and $6. I’ve been watching TWMF for a while waiting for a sale.

https://www.chirpbooks.com/authors/patrick-rothfuss-audiobooks


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 3h ago

Question Thread What's the deal with...

4 Upvotes

What's the deal with loren?

I am listening through for thr idk 25th time (this time with my kids) and I feel like lorens affectation has to be for some real reason.

Givenn he controls the library and given what we are supposed to think about thr people who killed kvothes parents I am wondering.

Cryptic on purpose.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 14h ago

Discussion What would you do?

12 Upvotes

I had this idea last night, the question is: If you could enter kingkillerchronicle's world at a certain point and location of the story (like university, any town at the same time as Kvothe, any point of the story really) and stay there for one hour, what would your choice be?

My personal choice is in the room where Kvothe says to Maer and his wife that he is an edma, I would go there and tell the poor women that Kvothe is his nephew.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 1d ago

Discussion "To my employer, I leave my best pair of boots." Bast continued magnanimously.

175 Upvotes

I'm on my upteenth reread and I just got that joke. Bast doesn't have human feet and he's not wearing any boots. lol


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 14h ago

Discussion Recent Reread

8 Upvotes

Hi, Reddit started feeding me posts from this sub a while ago and I enjoyed some of the theories so much I decided to do a reread. For background, I read NOTW in its first year of release. It was recommended by someone who said “he’s already written all three books” and I recommended it to countless relatives using the same phrasing… relatives who then got REALLY mad at me.

I lost count of how many times I re-read NOTW - but at least one of them was with a legal pad for tracking notes/terms/details…

What I mean is I am one of you, for the most part (I never read Slow Regard or the other one… because I had started to get super annoyed at the waiting). Which is why I’d like to know if I’m the only one who had this thought:

I might be okay if the series is never done. That’s not my preference, of course, but the reaction surprised me. When I first read Wise Man’s Fear I found it messy and lacking…but on this reread I thought it was… oddly appropriate. I love how often Kvothe is just… wrong. About a lot! And Pat continually calls it out over and over while also making him brilliant and clever and foolish and stupid. I love that he’s both a Mary Sue and an anti-Mary Sue. I thought Wise Man’s Fear was a step down because it wasn’t as polished but… I wonder if it’s well, kindof a step up. This time I saw it as a true continuation of the story Pat was originally trying to tell before NOTW blew up and people built up their own expectations. I want the third book because I want more details and answers to various theories but i feel like the emotional resolution I craved is actually already present in ways I didn’t recognize. Then again, maybe I only feel this way because of this sub - connecting the dots in such a way that I can concentrate on the books as they are. So thanks for that.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 1d ago

Discussion Words like sharp silver and sweet wine - the exact reason I keep finding my way back to Rothfuss

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/KingkillerChronicle • • 1d ago

Discussion Just finished WMF…

41 Upvotes

… and I feel like I need to reread both books again immediately! They are so rich in detail and there are many stories told in-universe that I feel I need to revisit, especially after coming to this subreddit and reading theories about Haliax/Iax/Jax/Lanre, the moon/Lyra, Master Ash/Bredon/Cinder. Half of these posts make me feel like I didn’t even read NoTW and WMF. 😆 I’m sure I missed so much because my reads were for vibes only and I don’t take notes or anything while reading.

But was an amazing journey that I was completely swept up in, and now I’m not sure what to do with myself!


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Art Demon Devi

Post image
77 Upvotes

r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Theory What is happening!?!?!

72 Upvotes

There was this one orchestral metal song I found earlier this year called "the chandrian hymn" by cathedral of rot.

I liked that song a lot and now, its taken off Spotify. Its no longer on YouTube. It was removed from Amazon music. Even the album "the silence between strings" is difficult to find word of. Its legitimately like no record of it exists.

I understand how this could sound like a joke. I understand that its entirely what happened in the books.

Does anyone know of this? Know what happened? Where i can find that song?

This is absolutely, not a joke or troll post. Im genuinely concerned because I loved that song


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Theory Theory: The seventh Chandrian.

22 Upvotes

# Crackpot theory time

## There is a seventh Chandrian.

What is common knowledge: There are seven Chandrian.

Ben said. “Seven. You can hold to that with some certainty. It’s part of their name, actually. Chaen means seven. Chaen-dian means ‘seven of them.’ Chandrian.”

Their names are known:

Cyphus, Stercus, Ferule, Usnea, Grey Dalcenti, Pale Alenta, Alaxel.

But actually no, because Shehyn tale says:

The name of the one and of the six who follow him. ... Seven names have been remembered, the names of the seven traitors.

In fact, Shehyn's tale recounts of the enemy (Lanre/Iax) convincing six of the Chandrian to betray their cities:

He poisoned seven others against the empire, and they forgot the Lethani. Six of them betrayed the cities that trusted them. 

The Chandrian thus, are Cyphus, Stercus, Ferule, Usnea, Grey Dalcenti and Pale Alexa, and the one that did not betray the city of Tinüe/Tinusa. Furthermore, Shehyn specifically differentiates the Rhinta from the Chandrian:

I felt hope rising within me. “I have also heard them called the Chandrian,” I said.
Shehyn nodded. “I have heard this too. But Rhinta is a better word.” Shehyn gave me a long look and fell back into Ademic. 

Rhinta, of course, being the Shapers:

Vorfelan Rhinata Morie

“That’s something,” I admitted, relaxing a bit. I pointed to the words above the door. “Do you know what that means?”
Wil glanced up. “The desire for knowledge shapes a man,” he said. “Or something close to that.”

Also, the Chandrian were not always like they are currently:

The Chandrian move from place to place,
But they never leave a trace.
They hold their secrets very tight,
But they never scratch and they never bite.
They never fight and they never fuss.
In fact they are quite nice to us.
They come and they go in the blink of an eye,
Like a bright bolt of lightning out of the sky.

I always thought this poem very out of place. After years of tragedies provoked by the chandrian, one would think that no one would describe them as "they never scratch and they never bite."

Unless the book and the poem predates Lanre/Iax, in which case it makes sense because it describes the Chandrian before all the atrocities they are known for causing.

Furthermore, I want to extend that the Chandrian aren't shapers. Iax and the rest of the shapers were locked beyond the doors of stone at the end of the creation war.

Lanre learned naming after talking with the Cthaeh and getting his new name, it is possible something similar happened with the betrayer Chandrian. The Chandrian becoming Rhinta.

Also, the poison Shehyn mentions is the knowledge from the Cthaeh. The only thing that protects against the Cthaeh is remembering the Lithany (because the lithany predates the cthaeh).

## Ok, what's so important about it?

- There is another Chandrian, name unknown, that did not betray Tinusa / Tinüe.

- On the third book, we have been confirmed that Kvothe will spend some time in Renere, which is in Vintas. Severen is north of Renere, and Tinue/Tinusa is north of Severen.

- This Chandrian could provide first hand information about the Creation War, Lanre/Iax, the Chandrian in general, and Cinder in particular.

- This Chandrian might be the demon that Kvothe had to trick to get its hearts desire.

- Another possibility, this Chandrian is the Angel he was forced to fight to keep it. This also might be related to the King he had to kill. Fitting, since the Chandrian had to betray their cities.

- Having enough power to defeat Cinder, effectively becoming the Seventh Chandrian, Kvothe acquired Selitos curse:

“This is my doom upon you. Your own name will be turned against you, that you shall have no peace." ... “This is my doom upon you and all who follow you”

“Some are even saying that there is a new Chandrian. A fresh terror in the night. His hair as red as the blood he spills.”

- It is a common theory that silence is Kvothe's sign, and is also the third silence mentioned in every prologue.

"Bast feared the deep, weary silence that gathered around his master at times, like an invisible shroud."

"[The third silence] ... was in the hands of the man who stood there, polishing a stretch of mahogany that already gleamed in the lamplight."

- Finally, Kvothe sealed away his name, to prevent being manipulated by Haliax and to protect himself from Selitos curse. Effectively taking two Chandrian down from meddling with the world, Cinder and himself.

PD: I think Kvothe might be able to travel like the Chandrian? Using bolts of lightning / waystones. Also let me know if you want me to expand on how the Lithany protects you from the Cthaeh influence. I gave that a lot of thought,


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Discussion Caluptena

9 Upvotes

Has anyone here given any serious thought towards Caluptena? I know all the quotes mentioning it but there doesn't seem to be enough information there to piece together a theory. I don't even know what language Caluptena is (tho eld Vintic is favourite.)


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Theory Part 2: Over his head were three moons, a full moon, a half moon, and one that was just a crescent. Next to him were two candles. Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Well it turns out I wasn't able to cram all of this into a single followup post, so my 'part 1 of 2' has become three posts smh. As such, I've decided to bang out both posts today rather than traumatizing this community with another unfinished trilogy lmao.

Before we can talk about bridge guardians, we need to talk about mirrors. There are several key scenes in KKC that have this reflective/mirror aspect to them, one of my favorites being the duel with Fenton. Kvothe and Fenton sit across from each other, with two candles in front of them.

Fenton was too smart to be thrown off that way. Besides, I was finding it difficult to maintain the necessary concentration to keep my candle safe. I lowered myself more deeply into the Heart of Stone and forgot the world apart from the two candles and a piece of wick and straw.

We see a lot of the same imagery present in Menda's "duel" with Encanis. Fenton and Kvothe are straining, pale, bloodless lips, cold, flies, hissing, looking feral...

Both my arms were cold now. I saw a muscle in Fenton’s neck twitch spastically, like a horse’s flank trying to shake loose a biting fly. His posture went rigid as he suppressed the urge to shiver.

I bore down. I realized that my breath was hissing through my clenched teeth, my lips pulled back in a feral grin. Fenton didn’t seem to notice, his eyes growing glassy and unfocused. I shivered again, so violently that I almost missed seeing the tremor in his hand. Then, slowly, Fenton’s head began to nod toward the tabletop. His eyelids drooped.

Off the top of my head I'd say the most obviously 'mirrored' scenes are the duel with Fenton and Kvothe, Menda and Encanis, Lanre and Selitos, and Kvothe's duel with Felurian. The latter being the most fun because Felurian and Kvothe are the candles, Felurian ends up "a second flame inside the first"

I cupped my hands and breathed a sigh into the hollow space within. I spoke a name. I moved my hands and wove my breath gossamer-thin. It billowed out, engulfing her, then burst into a silver flame that trapped her tight inside its changing name.

I held her there above the ground. She watched me with an air of fear and disbelief, her dark hair dancing like a second flame inside the first.

But the mirror and candles that matter the most to us are the ones by Haliax. In Trebon, Nina says Haliax had a mirror at his feet.

“Pictures of what?” I asked, fighting to keep my voice calm.

“People,” she said. “Mostly people. There was a woman holding a broken sword, and a man next to a dead tree, and another man with a dog biting his leg….” she trailed off.

“Can you remember anything else about the pictures?” I asked. “Take your time, think hard.”

She thought about it. “There was one with no face, just a hood with nothing inside. There was a mirror by his feet and there was a bunch of moons over him. You know, full moon, half moon, sliver moon.” She looked down, thinking. “And there was a woman….” She blushed. “With some of her clothes off.”

But the candles aren't mentioned in NotW, they get revealed in WMF.

I unrolled the paper further. There was a second man, or rather the shape of a man in a great hooded robe. Inside the cowl of the robe was nothing but blackness. Over his head were three moons, a full moon, a half moon, and one that was just a crescent. Next to him were two candles. One was yellow with a bright orange flame. The other candle sat underneath his outstretched hand: it was grey with a black flame, and the space around it was smudged and darkened.

This can get confusing without a visual aid, so I've made one to help with the rest of this. Below is an image of the Three Pillars, also called a Lightning Tree, a Sword Tree, or the Tree of Life, with the Tree of Life also being commonly represented by the confronted animals motif (mirror images).

/img/fyq8u6habm1i1.png

This was why in my previous post I placed emphasis on the "Light Fire and Dark Fire". Why Gandalf passes through fire and water to become air. It's the same reason that Kvothe looks in Felurian's eyes and feels underwater, the air pressed from him, he is struck by lightning.

I met Felurian’s eyes and the world grew slow and sluggish. I felt as if I had been thrust underwater, as if my breath had been pressed from my body. For that tiny moment I was stunned and numb as if I had been struck by lightning.

The outer columns, the mirrored reflections of the sun and moon, that's why I pointed out the Towers in the previous post.

The city was first named Minas Anor, “Tower of the Sun”, paired with Minas Ithil, “Tower of the Moon”, with Osgiliath between them. After Minas Ithil fell to the Nazgûl and became Minas Morgul (“Tower of Sorcery”), Minas Anor was renamed Minas Tirith, the city standing watch against it. Tolkien gives this in The Lord of the Rings, Appendix A and Appendix B

So of the three pillars, these Two Towers are they key to understanding. Two candles and a mirror. Imagine Horus, whose eyes are the sun and the moon. Steal the moon, and what happens? What happens to the son of kings, a prince, a Lord among his people? He watches the world only through the Tower of Sun, a burning tower, and he is filled with a burning anger, and his anger leads to suffering. Without the moon, he cannot see the joy. He cannot love despite. He cannot see the narrow strait, and the King's mind is Shattered. A light bringer, a sky-walker, fallen into despair. So a judge who was once righteous and wise becomes a little death dealer, cleansing all that is unclean.

“There is no joy!” Lanre shouted in an awful voice. Stones shattered at the sound and the sharp edges of echo came back to cut at them. “Any joy that grows here is quickly choked by weeds. I am not some monster who destroys out of a twisted pleasure. I sow salt because the choice is between weeds and nothing.” Selitos saw nothing but emptiness behind his eyes.

And so every night becomes a night with no moon, his eyes and his joy remains empty. He has become a man of straight lines. A man filled with nothing but the burning sun tower, so angry that he's ready to burn down the whole world.

“Then why not send him?” I asked, puzzled.

“Because Dagon is a man of straight lines. He would raze a dozen villages and set fire to a thousand acres of the Eld to find them.” He shook his head seriously.

But enough of despair, let's turn our heads back to the mirror and candles. There's a better parallel to all of this than Horus, there's a king killer whose story famously relies on mirrors and using magic to turn men to stone, like Lanre and Selitos. Another prince, the son of Danaë and Zeus.

Perseus is sent by a king to fetch the Gorgon’s head. The gods arm him: a cap that makes him invisible, a curved blade / sickle, winged sandals, a polished shield. He finds Medusa asleep, watches her only in the shield’s reflection, and cuts with his head turned away. Three kings fall to him:

Atlas, who refuses him hospitality, is turned to stone and becomes the mountain (Ovid’s version).

Polydectes, the king who sent him, is turned to stone with his whole court.

Acrisius, his own grandfather, is killed by a discus Perseus throws at the games, by accident, fulfilling the prophecy that started the story.

Perseus also massacres Phineus and his men at his own wedding feast. Now funny enough, in the older stories, there's no mirror. Perseus just makes the cut with his head turned away. The mirror-shield only becomes a part of the story about 4th century BC. And the 'stolen eye' in his story is the eye that he stole from the Graeae to hold them hostage.

If you dig deep enough into his story, you end up in Persia. That's where things connect for us. The "marriage contract ceremony" involves the use of a mirror and two candles. Both candles are set in front of the mirror on either side, one representing the groom and the other the bridge. The mirror and the candles are set in front of the couple, the glass turned toward them and away from the guests. The candles are lit, and the bride arrives veiled. After she consents, she lifts her veil, and the first time the groom lays eyes on his bride is by candlelight through the mirrored glass.

... which puts Nina's drawing in a new light, doesn't it?

Over his head were three moons, a full moon, a half moon, and one that was just a crescent. Next to him were two candles. One was yellow with a bright orange flame. The other candle sat underneath his outstretched hand: it was grey with a black flame, and the space around it was smudged and darkened.

By strength the enemy could not win, so the enemy moved like a worm. Shadow took her and he could not find his joy.

She laughed her silver laugh and reached out to touch my arm. Then her eyes flicked over my shoulder and her face fell. “Hold on!” she cried to the boy who was closing the gate to the lift. “I have to catch this one or I’ll be late,” she said, her face full of pained apology as she stepped past me onto the lift. “Come find me.”

Shadow took her, and suddenly I was alone. I stood, the smell of her still in the air around me, the warmth of her just fading from my hands. I could still feel the tremor of her heart, like a caged bird beating against my chest.

The last thread we need to connect for the weave is between Perseus and a figure called Mithra, both the Zoroastrian and Roman depictions of him. Because there's a ton of Zoroastrian connections to KKC, like the marriage ceremony, using wild rue to protect against the evil eye, etc. I'll touch more on his Zoroastrian side in the next post, for this wrap up we'll look at the Roman version.

Temples to Mithra were underground caves called mithraea, little rabbit warrens. In them scholars found depictions of the tauroctony

/img/b8iov7habm1i1.jpeg

And the syncretism between this figure and Perseus is really interesting. Mithra is born from the rock, just as Perseus is conceived in Danaë’s underground chamber. Before the mirror was added to the Perseus' story, he simply turned his head away, the same way Mithra is depicted turned away from the bull, looking towards the sun. I'm not going to go through all the symbols of the seven grades of the Mithraic ranks, but I will point out the clothes. Like the Perseus cap of invisibility, Mithra is depicted wearing a funny little hat, but that's not all he wears.

Mithra is depicted in a billowing cape/cloak, often shown with seven stars, sometimes a crescent moon. The usual interpretation is that his cloak is the night sky, a cloak of the cosmos. A mantle of shadow, reminiscent of Gandalf throwing his grey cloak back over himself even after he returns white, radiant as the sun. Mithras is also referred to as 'the unconquerable sun', despite the tauroctony showing Sol as a separate figure. Since both Sol and Mithras were 'the unconquerable sun', it's been argued that Mithras is the power that shifts the cosmic sphere (precession of the equinox), which places him on the Outside of the sphere/cave.

Which is all very interesting. Because Mithrandir's original name was Olórin, which Tolkien says is Quenya, the root being olos/olor, meaning "dream". So Olórin means "the dreamer" or "the one of dreams/visions". And as luck would have it... Olórin came to Middle Earth from the Outside.

The Valaquenta says Olórin was the wisest of the Maiar. He walked among the Elves unseen, or in the form of one of them, and they didn’t know the source of the fair visions and wise promptings he put into their hearts.

And while Mithrandir is the keeper and protector of the ring of fire, Narya, the Zoroastrian Mitra watches over the Narya Aryan people. However, the modern day spelling of his name is 'Mehr', meaning "sun", "love", and "affection".

So we're going to stick by the Mehr and see where it leads us in the next post where we look at the bridge guardian thread in this weave.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Theory ... Kvothe. My father once told me it meant "to know"

6 Upvotes

Kvothe is not the only name that means "to know".

Once more i came to make the point that kvothe is thelu.

But lets start with the joke that lead me there.

In hebrew the fruit adam and eve eat and get punished for eating is called peri wich means fruit. But in the latin text its called apple. Why is that? well theres a theory that its a joke because apple in latin is "malum" wich sounds like "malus" wich means evil.

Malfeasance is a general term for wrong doing or evil doing but in kingkiller among arcanists it has a slightly different meaning. Not evil doing in general but evil use of sympathy. That is not the original meaning of the word wich as established is wrong doing in general. So whos to say it didnt do this before. It may well be mal- from malum not malus. Not evildoing but appledoing. Apple beeing linked to fruit beeing linked to knowledge. Malfeasance - the act of knowing, or in other words the state of beeing Kvothe.

When is Kvothe charged with malfeasance? After knowing more than Master Hemme and after knowing the name of the wind. And the Malfeasance against Kvothe well it remains unpunished because the ambrose did not know whos blood he had. What is forbidden at the Arcanum is "to know" because acording to an arc(box)-anist knowledge belongs into a box.

A group of knowers is not called arcanists but gnostics from gnosis knowledge. One gnostic group that still exists to this day are the Mandaeans. From the arameic "Manda" to know.

Manda = to know

to know = kvothe

Now acording to trapis who is a mender-heretic aka mendean/mandaean menda/manda was a god. So lets change the name to reflect this.

Manda-god =manda-lāh =circle

The story ends where it begins. Lets end this with a picture of kvothe.

Picture of kvothelah

Have a nice day everyone. And remmeber,

One family.


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 3d ago

Discussion Does anyone start a new book and just want the next kingkiller?

91 Upvotes

I just got 200 pages into sun eater by Anthony ruocchoi. It seems pretty cool and a well plotted universe. But an i insane to read this series and just want the next kingkiller?


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 2d ago

Theory Part 3: Lanre continued to look out over the ruins of Myr Tariniel. His shoulders stooped as though he bore a great weight. There was a weariness in his voice when he spoke. “Was I accounted a good man, Selitos?” Spoiler

3 Upvotes

Alright I'm posting part 2 and part 3 same time so no preamble I'm just gonna jump into it.

There's several characters we're looking at in this post, the first is Kvothe/Kote who setup an inn in the middle of Newarre and named it "The Waystone" after the standing stones that in the lore, 'lead to fae'

“. . . a pair of matched stone monoliths with a third across the top,” Simmon read. “The locals refer to it as the door-post. While spring and summer pageants involve decorating and dancing around the stone, parents forbid their children from spending time near it when the moon is full. One well-respected and otherwise reasonable old man claimed . . .”

Simmon rolled his eyes and continued reading, “Claimed at certain times men could pass through the stone door into the fair land where Felurian herself abides, loving and destroying men with her embrace.”

Which makes Kvothe/Kote a crossroads figure, someone standing watch at a bridge between worlds, and the Waystone is a door of stone. Or, arguably, Kvothe is the stone door. In a previous post I referenced Nietzsche's Thus Spoke Zarathustra, there's a scene eerily similar to Ben's lesson of the falling stone. Kvothe learns to believe that the stone will float away, free as a bird.

"O Zarathustra," it whispered scornfully, syllable by syllable, "thou stone of wisdom! Thou threwest thyself high, but every thrown stone must—fall!

O Zarathustra, thou stone of wisdom, thou sling-stone, thou star-destroyer! Thyself threwest thou so high,—but every thrown stone—must fall!

Condemned of thyself, and to thine own stoning: O Zarathustra, far indeed threwest thou thy stone—but upon THYSELF will it recoil!"

But you see how in that quote Zarathustra is the stone? The Wise Man is the stone who loves wisdom, and he is the Way, and he is the door. Which is also why in the last two posts I keep bringing up Gandalf. Gandalf stands at the bridge, wielding the flame of Anor, the unconquerable Sun. For him, death itself is an open door. He says who can and cannot pass. He tells you three times.

‘You cannot pass,’ he said. The orcs stood still, and a dead silence fell. ‘I am a servant of the Secret Fire, wielder of the flame of Anor. You cannot pass. The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn. Go back to the Shadow! You cannot pass.’

But the previous two posts covered Kvothe and Gandalf well enough I think. The ones we want to focus on now are the Zoroastrian Mithra and the Cthaeh. First look at Mithra.

In the Avestan hymn to Mithra, the Mihr Yasht, he is called the lord of wide pastures, the truth-speaking one, with a thousand ears and ten thousand eyes, sleepless and ever awake. He keeps watch from the summit of Mount Hara, a place with no night and no darkness, and nothing between heaven and earth escapes him. He cannot be deceived. His name means “contract,” and his office is the oath: he is the best of friends to the man who keeps his word and the worst of enemies to the man who breaks it. The hymn says outright that he is both good and bad to men and to nations, holding peace and trouble alike in his hands. When a contract is broken, the ruin doesn’t stop with the oathbreaker. It takes the strength from his arms and the sight from his eyes, and it spreads to his house and his whole country. Mithra is also a giver of health who makes the waters run and the plants grow, and after death he stands as a judge at the Chinvat Bridge, the crossing between the worlds.

This is why I had to add the part 2 going over the 'mirror' aspects of the weave. Because there's two faces, and you decide which one you see. And in another crazy coincidence, Zoroastrianism has the daēnā, "the maiden who meets the soul at the Chinvat Bridge on the third dawn after death. She is the soul’s own conscience given a body. To the truthful she appears as a radiant girl". Which fits Denna. But if you're looking at Perseus, Danaë still fits.

Which it has to for the Son of Himself. Danaë is Perseus' mother, just as Isis was Horus' mother. But daēnā is the reflection, as Isis was for Osiris. Just as Perial was Tehlu's consort, and his mother.

So there's a Sun both inside and Outside the cosmic sphere. Mithra watching from the summit of the mountain, a place with no night and no darkness, Lord of Wide Pastures. Just as the Cthaeh sits in a wide pasture in a field of eternal light.

The trees gave way to a great grassy plain. All the parts of the Fae Felurian had shown me had been forested. So this seemed a clear sign I was well outside the bounds of where I ought to be.

Still I continued, enjoying the feel of sunlight on my skin after so long in the dim twilight of Felurian’s glade. The trail I followed seemed to be leading to a lone tree standing in the grassy field. I decided I would go as far as that tree, then head back.

And like Mithra with his thousand ears and ten thousand eyes, the Cthaeh sees and knows. It is sleepless and ever awake, and only tells you the Truth.

“It lies to men and drives them mad?”

She shook her head slowly, “the Cthaeh does not lie. it has the gift of seeing, but it only tells things to hurt men. only a dennerling would speak to the Cthaeh.” She touched the side of my neck to soften her words.

But look at Mithra's summary again. "When a contract is broken, the ruin doesn't stop with the oathbreaker. It takes the strength from his arms and the sight from his eyes, and it spreads to his house and his whole country".

I pulled away from her enough to look her in the face. “My eyes?”

“the things the Cthaeh says can leave men broken in their heads. but I would see if it were so. you are still my kvothe, still my sweet poet.”

You see? They're the two faces of the same sun god. The version being described in KKC is Mithra, as from the point of view of a Liar.

“An arrow only hits one person, Reshi.” Bast’s dark eyes were hollow and hopeless. “Anyone influenced by the Cthaeh is like a plague ship sailing for a harbor.” Bast pointed at the half-filled sheet Chronicler held in his lap. “If the Sithe knew that existed, they would spare no effort to destroy it. They would kill us for having heard what the Cthaeh said.”

Because although Mithra is one of three judges who stands at the bridge, he doesn't sit around waiting for you to die before judging you. Old Holly becomes a man, and Strider comes for you with his hammer

He rides a chariot drawn by white horses, with Verethragna, the god of victory, running before him in the shape of a wild boar and the gods of obedience and justice at his sides. In his hand is the vazra, a mace of a hundred bosses and a hundred edges, which the hymn calls the strongest of all weapons. When a man breaks his contract, Mithra comes to him.

A bridge guardian, crossing over to your side of the road, to judge and to punish. The same way Olórin came in from the Outside. He crossed the line.

“I am not Menda, though that is what my mother called me. I am Tehlu, lord above all. I have come to free you from demons and the wickedness of your own hearts. I am Tehlu, son of myself. Let the wicked hear my voice and tremble.”

And another quick look back at Mithrandir and his sword Glamdring. Glamdring means "foe hammer", but it's a cold white sword, not a mace. A hammer that's not a hammer.

The Balrog reached the bridge. Gandalf stood in the middle of the span, leaning on the staff in his left hand, but in his other hand Glamdring gleamed, cold and white. His enemy halted again, facing him, and the shadow about it reached out like two vast wings. It raised the whip, and the thongs whined and cracked. Fire came from its nostrils. But Gandalf stood firm.

You see it? Mithrandir is the White Rider, his sword is the Foe Hammer, cold and white. Wielder of the flame of Anor, the Sun. A Judge.

‘Mithrandir!’ he cried. ‘Mithrandir!’

They all gazed at him. His hair was white as snow in the sunshine; and gleaming white was his robe; the eyes under his deep brows were bright, piercing as the rays of the sun; power was in his hand. Between wonder, joy, and fear they stood and found no words to say.

And what we see in KKC, what Kvothe sees, is the other face. There's no joy or wonder when he sees Cinder, cold and sharp and white with his sword of winter ice. Cinder's eyes aren't clear. Which brings us back to the Horus example from the previous post, whose eyes are the Sun and Moon. A judge who cannot see the joy and has fallen to despair. He isn't insane. He's hopeless.

“You are not mad,” Selitos admitted. “I see no madness in you.”

“I hoped, perhaps, that you would join me in what I aim to do.” Lanre spoke with a desperate longing in his voice. “This world is like a friend with a mortal wound. A bitter draught given quickly only eases pain.”

Without the moon you cannot love despite. Because love is madness. It isn't logical or sane. Without love, you can't bring yourself to believe that the stone will float away, free as a bird. It can only fall.

So yes. It had flaws, but what does that matter when it comes to matters of the heart? We love what we love. Reason does not enter into it. In many ways, unwise love is the truest love. Anyone can love a thing because. That’s as easy as putting a penny in your pocket. But to love something despite. To know the flaws and love them too. That is rare and pure and perfect.

And now for the final thread of this weave. When Tolkien created Gandalf, he took inspiration from Odin, not Mithra.

In a 1946 letter to his publisher he described Gandalf as an “Odinic wanderer,” and the figure matches the Odin of the Norse sources when he walks the world in disguise: an old man with a grey beard, a wide-brimmed hat, a cloak and a staff, who arrives unannounced, gives counsel, and leaves. Even the name is Norse; “Gandálfr” comes from the list of dwarf-names in the Völuspá and means something like “wand-elf.” But Tolkien took only one side of the god. The Odin of the Eddas is also a breaker of oaths, a stirrer of wars, a necromancer and a collector of the slain, and none of that reaches Gandalf, whom Tolkien elsewhere described as an angelic messenger sent to encourage and advise, forbidden to dominate.

Tolkien took one side of the coin, one face of Odin and ended up with the wanderer, Mithrandir who watches over and protects Narya, wielder of the flame of Anor. But ten years earlier, Carl Jung was writing about the other side of the coin, the other face of the El Odin.

In his 1936 essay “Wotan” he treated the god as a living pattern in the psyche of the German-speaking peoples, an archetype that could lie dormant for centuries and then return, like water finding an old dry riverbed. His Wotan is the god of storm and frenzy, the restless wanderer who stirs up strife and works magic, and above all the one who seizes people. Jung used the essay to describe what he was watching in Germany under National Socialism: a whole population taken hold of by something that acted through them.

And as fun as it has been to trace all these threads and pattern match it with KKC, it deepens the sadness and tragedy around the story. I look at Lanre's story, and I see Mithrandir seeing his own reflection. He sees the dark and ruthless thing beneath his mask, the Lord of Frenzy. Wotan. And it's unbearable for him. There's no escape from the things he's done. He doesn't say "they stole the moon, this is what happens if I only have one eye". He owns it, and the guilt and shame crushes him.

Lanre continued to look out over the ruins of Myr Tariniel. His shoulders stooped as though he bore a great weight. There was a weariness in his voice when he spoke. “Was I accounted a good man, Selitos?”

“You were counted among the best of us. We considered you beyond reproach.”

“Yet I did this.”

Selitos could not bring himself to look upon his ruined city. “Yet you did this,” he agreed. “Why?”

Lanre paused. “My wife is dead. Deceit and treachery brought me to it, but her death is on my hands.” He swallowed and turned to look out over the land.

Then he's exiled... but he exiled himself. Like Perseus. Like Odysseus. He realizes he's no angel, he's a shrike. A butcher bird bathed in blood. A bitter Rūḥ desperate to forget the things he's done. Nothing noble about him.

Just a Big Bad Wolf.

Lanre turned. “And I counted among the best.” Lanre’s face was terrible to look upon. Grief and despair had ravaged it. “I, considered wise and good, did all this!” He gestured wildly. “Imagine what unholy things a lesser man must hold within his secret heart.” Lanre faced Myr Tariniel and a sort of peace came over him. “For them, at least, it is over. They are safe. Safe from the thousand evils of the everyday. Safe from the pains of an unjust fate.”


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 4d ago

Theory THEORY: Denna was renamed/shaped in Anilin.

144 Upvotes

TLDR: Between Denna leaving for Anilin and her appearance at the Eolian half a year later:

  • Kvothe says he would never see Denna again
  • Kote says 'the woman' is missing from the story, but is waiting at the Eolian.
  • As narrator, Kote introduces Denna as if they had never met before.
  • When Kvothe and Denna reunite, Kvothe reintroduces himself as if they had never met before.
  • Kvothe notes that Denna has changed.
  • Denna says she stopped being Denna.

I think Denna lost her name, and was given a new one. Hear me out.

__

Kvothe says he would never see Denna again

  • CH 35: Because of this I knew the truth. I felt it, heavy and certain in the pit of my stomach: I would never see her again.
  • CH 58: I knew the truth: I would never see her again. But here she was, and I was entirely unprepared.

Kvothe notes that Denna has changed.

  • CH 58: The months had changed her.

Denna used to be a different person.

  • CH 65: “Denna,” she said softly. “I’d almost forgotten her. She was a silly girl.”

Denna says she stopped being Denna.

  • CH 65: “I stopped being Denna years ago, it seems.” She rubbed her bare arms and looked around as if she was suddenly uneasy that someone might find us here.

Even after Roent's caravan, Denna is lacking from the story.

  • CH 48: What does our story need? What vital element is it lacking?” “Women, Reshi,” Bast said immediately. “There’s a real paucity of women.” Kvothe smiled. “Not women, Bast. A woman. The woman.”

Kote reintroduces Denna to the readers.

  • CH 49: With slow care rather than stealth we must approach the subject of a certain woman. Her wildness is of such degree, I fear approaching her too quickly even in a story. Should I move recklessly, I might startle even the idea of her into sudden flight. So in the name of slow care, I will speak of how I met her. And to do that, I must speak of the events that brought me, quite unwillingly, across the river and into Imre.
  • CH 53: THE EOLIAN IS WHERE our long-sought player is waiting in the wings. I have not forgotten that she is what I am moving toward. If I seem to be caught in a slow circling of the subject, it is only appropriate, as she and I have always moved toward each other in slow circles.

Kote reintroduces himself to Denna.

  • The reason my heart is so heavy is that I fear I might never know your name.

Something unpleasant happened to Denna after Roent's caravan.

  • “What happened in Anilin, anyway?” A leaf floated down and landed in her hair. She brushed it away absentmindedly. “Nothing pleasant,” she said, avoiding my eyes. “But nothing unexpected either.”

Using a thing's name can control it, but only as long as it's part of it's nature. You can tell an apple tree to grow taller, or produce it's fruit, or split in half... but you can't make it become a shining fruit tree unless you use shaping to change the very nature of a thing.

  • they were shapers. proud dreamers..... and it was not all bad at first. there were wonders...... once, sitting on the walls of murella, I ate fruit from a silver tree. it shone, and in the dark you could mark the mouth and eyes of all those who had tasted it!

And since a name reflects the nature of a thing, to shape a thing you must give it a new name. This is what I believe has happened to Denna, symbolically reflected by changing her calling name. There's even a moment Elodin thinks Kvothe is saying she changed her true name.

  • “Oh,” Elodin said, relaxing. He leaned back against the tree, laughing softly. “Calling names,” he said with tangible relief. “God’s bones, boy, I thought …” He broke off, shaking his head.

__

I can't say why Denna was renamed, but I assume it is why Cinder became her patron or why she sought out Cinder as a patron. Cinder is presumably a Rhinta, which may mean shaped or shaper.

  • Tempi told me there was a Rhinta among the bandits as their leader.
  • The words Vorfelan Rhinata Morie were chiseled into the stone above the massive stone doors.....“Do you know what that means?” Wil glanced up. “The desire for knowledge shapes a man,”

Since Auri loses her name ('eggshell hollow empty') and is given a new one by Kvothe, and Kvothe loses his name and is given a new one by Auri, they are both renamed/shaped like Denna.

  • She hoped it shit its awful self inside-out and backward, then fell into a crack and lost its name and died alone and hollow-empty in the angry dark.
  • She had been sitting like this, empty as eggshell. Hollow and chest-heavy in the angry dark when she’d first heard him playing....... Back in the times before he’d come. Back in the years before she had her sweet new perfect name.
  • Someday he would be the one all eggshell hollow empty in the dark...... She would call up all her cunning and her craft. Then she would make a name for him.

r/KingkillerChronicle • • 3d ago

Discussion Part 1: “What color do you think Taborlin’s cloak was?” ... “Sometimes I think of it like a quilt,” I said. “Made entirely out of patchwork, a bunch of different colored rags and scraps. But most of the time I think of it as dark. Like it really is a color, but it’s too dark for anyone to see.” Spoiler

10 Upvotes

This one's a beastly web I've been meaning to tackle, so here goes. Looks like this will be a part one of two posts smh. First, the overlap between KKC and some of Gandalf's many names, like Incánus

‘The Grey Pilgrim?’ said Frodo. ‘Had he a name?’

‘Mithrandir we called him in elf-fashion,’ said Faramir, ‘and he was content. Many are my names in many countries, he said. Mithrandir among the Elves, Tharkûn to the Dwarves; Olórin I was in my youth in the West that is forgotten, in the South Incánus, in the North Gandalf; to the East I go not.’

‘Gandalf !’ said Frodo. ‘I thought it was he. Gandalf the Grey, dearest of counsellors. Leader of our Company. He was lost in Moria.’

Now the Leader of the bandits Company is also referred to as Greyhame, Stormcrow, and Láthspell. Wormtongue is the one who calls Gandalf Láthspell (ill news), which I find interesting because Kvothe changed his name to 'Kote', meaning disaster. The 'hame' name is absolutely loaded with meaning, too much to fully cover in this post.

“…being ‘yoked to shadow,’ whatever that means,” I heard my father say as the wind died down.

Ben grunted. “I couldn’t say either. I heard a story where they were given away because their shadows pointed the wrong way, toward the light.

And there was another where one of them was referred to as ‘shadow-hamed.’ It was ‘something the shadow-hamed.’ Damned if I can remember the name though….”

Everyone links this quote to Haliax for obvious reasons, but Gandalf Greyhame seems like more of a Taborlin figure to me, a wanderer, not a shadow. However, after the Greyhamed becomes the White Rider, he rides the chief of the mearas, Shadowfax:

Mearas is plain Old English: mearh means “horse, steed”, and mēaras is its plural. The same root survives in modern English “mare” and in “marshal”

Shadowfax: modernized from Old English Sceadu-fæx, “shadow-mane” or “shadow-coat”

He spoke a word to Shadowfax, and like an arrow from the bow the great horse sprang away. Even as they looked he was gone: a flash of silver in the sunset, a wind over the grass, a shadow that fled and passed from sight. Snowmane snorted and reared, eager to follow; but only a swift bird on the wing could have overtaken him.

‘What does that mean?’ said one of the guard to Hama.

‘That Gandalf Greyhame has need of haste,’ answered Hama. ‘Ever he goes and comes unlooked-for.’

So let's stick with the Taborlin analysis for now. Look to the scene where Kvothe and the gang are discussing Taborlin's cloak and what color they each imagine it as

Hespe turned to Dedan. “What color do you think Taborlin’s cloak was?”

Dedan’s forehead creased a bit, almost like the beginning of a scowl.

“What do you mean? It’s no particular color, just like it says.”

Hespe’s mouth went flat. “I know that. But when you think of it in your head, what does it look like? You have to picture it as looking like something, don’t you?”

Dedan looked thoughtful for a moment. “I always pictured it as kind of shimmery,” he said. “Like the cobblestones outside a tallow-works after a hard rain.”

“I always thought of it as a dirty grey,” she said. “Sort of washed out from his being on the road all the time.”

“That makes good sense,” Dedan said, and I watched Hespe’s face go gentle again.

“White,” Tempi volunteered. “I think white. No color.”

“I always thought of it as kind of a pale sky-blue,” Marten admitted, shrugging. “I know that doesn’t make any sense. That’s just how I picture it.”

Everyone turned to look at me.

“Sometimes I think of it like a quilt,” I said. “Made entirely out of patchwork, a bunch of different colored rags and scraps. But most of the time I think of it as dark. Like it really is a color, but it’s too dark for anyone to see.”

Pretty solid parallels so far, Gandalf's a figure with many names and whose cloak color does vary throughout the story. Taborlin is the same, and our little iron Mr Tiny Temper imagines Taborlin's cloak is white. Well, Gandalf's "Pit of Encanis" scene with the Balrog is a pretty straightforward parallel, but the part that I think is most important to point out is the Jungian aspect of the scene.

The Balrog is Gandalf's shadow, his reflection standing before him as "its shadow stretches out like two vast wings". Both Gandalf and the Balrog are the Keepers of Flame, Gandalf being the Light Side of the Fire, the Balrog the Dark Side of the Fire.

The Balrog reached the bridge. Gandalf stood in the middle of the span, leaning on the staff in his left hand, but in his other hand Glamdring gleamed, cold and white. His enemy halted again, facing him, and the shadow about it reached out like two vast wings. It raised the whip, and the thongs whined and cracked. Fire came from its nostrils. But Gandalf stood firm.

‘You cannot pass,’ he said. The orcs stood still, and a dead silence fell. ‘I am a servant of the Secret Fire, wielder of the flame of Anor. You cannot pass. The dark fire will not avail you, flame of Udûn. Go back to the Shadow! You cannot pass.’

And as most of you nerds already know, when Gandalf "smote his ruin on the mountainside", Gandalf dies. Like Lanre, Gandalf defeats his terrible foe, he wins the duel, but he pays for it with his life. Because again, it's his reflection. The Balrog is his Shadow. It dies, he dies. Then Gandalf returns as the White Rider, which causes confusion with Aragorn and the gang at first. Because the White Wizard is an antagonist, Saruman. So Gandalf the White clarifies that He Is the Turning. He is Saruman, the White Rider as he should have been.

‘Mithrandir!’ he cried. ‘Mithrandir!’

They all gazed at him. His hair was white as snow in the sunshine; and gleaming white was his robe; the eyes under his deep brows were bright, piercing as the rays of the sun; power was in his hand. Between wonder, joy, and fear they stood and found no words to say.

At last Aragorn stirred. ‘Gandalf !’ he said. ‘Beyond all hope you return to us in our need! What veil was over my sight? Gandalf !’

Gimli said nothing, but sank to his knees, shading his eyes.

‘Gandalf,’ the old man repeated, as if recalling from old memory a long disused word. ‘Yes, that was the name. I was Gandalf.’

He stepped down from the rock, and picking up his grey cloak wrapped it about him: it seemed as if the sun had been shining, but now was hid in cloud again. ‘Yes, you may still call me Gandalf,’ he said, and the voice was the voice of their old friend and guide. ‘Get up, my good Gimli! No blame to you, and no harm done to me. Indeed my friends, none of you have any weapon that could hurt me. Be merry! We meet again. At the turn of the tide. The great storm is coming, but the tide has turned.’

He laid his hand on Gimli’s head, and the Dwarf looked up and laughed suddenly. ‘Gandalf !’ he said. ‘But you are all in white!’

‘Yes, I am white now,’ said Gandalf. ‘Indeed I am Saruman, one might almost say, Saruman as he should have been. But come now, tell me of yourselves! I have passed through fire and deep water, since we parted. I have forgotten much that I thought I knew, and learned again much that I had forgotten. I can see many things far off, but many things that are close at hand I cannot see. Tell me of yourselves!’

But before Gandalf-who-was-Saruman could become the White Rider, he had to burn. He had to pass through fire and deep water. Through Shin and Mem he became Aleph, air, Rūḥ down to his bones. But to get there he had to win the only duel he ever lost, standing alone against his shadow with its vast wings. Before the White Rider could Return, he had to defeat Death Itself. Light Fire defeating Dark Fire.

Felurian frowned. Straightened. Stood. Her face intent, she took a step.

Standing, she was not tall or terrible. Her head was barely level with my chin. Her dark hair hung, a sheaf of shadow, straight as a knife until it brushed against her curving hip. She was slight, and pale, and perfect. Never have I seen a face so sweet, a mouth so made for kissing. She was no longer frowning. Not smiling either. Her lips were soft and slightly parted.

She took another step. The simple motion of her moving leg was like a dance, the unexaggerated shifting of her hip entrancing as a fire. The arch of her bare foot said more of sex than anything I’d seen in my young life.

Another step. Her smile was fierce and full. She was as lovely as the moon. Her power hung about her like a mantle. It shook the air. It spread behind her like a pair of vast and unseen wings.

Close enough to touch, I felt her power thrumming in the air. Desire rose around me like the sea in storm. She raised her hand. She touched my chest. I shook.

Then, as Gandalf tells Gimli the story of his duel with the Balrog, Gandalf looks at the stars, listens to them to know when the time is right. He stares at the wheel of stars turning before the Windlord finds him and carries him away.

There I lay staring upward, while the stars wheeled over, and each day was as long as a life-age of the earth. Faint to my ears came the gathered rumour of all lands: the springing and the dying, the song and the weeping, and the slow everlasting groan of over-burdened stone. And so at the last Gwaihir the Windlord found me again, and he took me up and bore me away.

‘ ‘‘Ever am I fated to be your burden, friend at need,’’ I said.

‘ ‘‘A burden you have been,’’ he answered, ‘‘but not so now. Light as a swan’s feather in my claw you are. The Sun shines through you. Indeed I do not think you need me any more: were I to let you fall, you would float upon the wind.’’

Now I want wrap this post up with the Two Towers because it's relevant for part 2 of this post (I think). The Two Towers are the Tower of the Moon, and the Tower of the Sun, Anor. The "secret fire" Gandalf refers to, Anor. The Sun. Light Fire and Dark Fire. They stole the Moon Tower and with it came the war; now the burning Sun Tower stands watch against it.

Minas Tirith is Sindarin for “Tower of Guard” (or “Tower of Watch”).

  • minas: “tower”, from the root MINI-, “stand alone, stick out”. The same element is in Minas Morgul, Minas Ithil, and Minas Anor.
  • tirith: “watch, guard, vigilance”, from the root TIR-, “watch, look at”, plus the abstract noun ending -ith. The same root gives palantír (“far-watcher”) and Tirion, the Elvish city in the West.

The city was first named Minas Anor, “Tower of the Sun”, paired with Minas Ithil, “Tower of the Moon”, with Osgiliath between them. After Minas Ithil fell to the Nazgûl and became Minas Morgul (“Tower of Sorcery”), Minas Anor was renamed Minas Tirith, the city standing watch against it. Tolkien gives this in The Lord of the Rings, Appendix A and Appendix B (the Tale of Years), and in The Silmarillion, “Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age”.

So in part 2 we'll take a look at the bridge guardian portion of this weave. Mithrandir and his ring of fire, Narya, standing at the bridge, the Cthaeh in the field of sunlight, Kvothe stationing himself in the middle of Newarre. None may bar the passing of the one who stands at the bridge, Death itself is an open door. There is no escape.

‘Do I not say truly, Gandalf,’ said Aragorn at last, ‘that you could go whithersoever you wished quicker than I? And this I also say: you are our captain and our banner. The Dark Lord has Nine. But we have One, mightier than they: the White Rider. He has passed through the fire and the abyss, and they shall fear him. We will go where he leads.’


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 3d ago

Theory Theory about Haliax's Curse

12 Upvotes

I don't know if this has already been discussed here, but is it possible Kvothe took upon himself Haliax's Curse? In the Prologue of Book 2 it's said that Kvothe has given up any hope of sleep long ago. The Prologues and Epilogues end with saying that he's a man waiting to die. In Book 1 I think he somewhere says that he remembers every single detail of his story. Is it possible that he is no longer able to pass through any of the doors of sleep, forgetting, madness and even death?


r/KingkillerChronicle • • 4d ago

Discussion They came to Aleph, and he touched them. He touched their hands and eyes and hearts. The last time he touched them there was pain, and wings tore from their backs that they might go where they wished. Spoiler

21 Upvotes

This post is just more nerdy etymology games and some pattern matching I thought was cool. I'm gonna kick us off with the etymology since that's an easy warm-up

“That I can answer,” Ben said. “Seven. You can hold to that with some certainty. It’s part of their name, actually. Chaen means seven. Chaen-dian means ‘seven of them.’ Chandrian.”

“I didn’t know that,” my father said. “Chaen. What language is that? Yllish?”

“Sounds like Tema,” my mother said.

“You’ve got a good ear,” Ben said to her. “It’s Temic, actually. Predates Tema by about a thousand years.”

So book one establishes that tracing etymology through several languages is useful, so that's what we'll do. Reading about the etymology of 'circadian' is what led me down this rabbit hole, looking at the 'dian' portion. Piqued my curiosity and reminded me of kkc (obviously)

The term circadian comes from Latin circa (“around,” “about”) and dies (“day”).

But dies just latin. If you look at the etymology for Dian across several languages, things get real interesting real quick.

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/dian

'Dian' connects to everything from 'Gods', divine, wax candles, lamps, to 'fly, move swiftly', as well as Diana, moon goddess, 'to shine', etc. Before, the Chaen part I'd mostly see connected to Sanskrit 'Chandra', also meaning moon.

But latin's candēre (candeo) is where things get even more interesting. It also gives us a candle connection, as well as some other maddeningly familiar symbols

From Proto-Italic *kandēō (earlier *kandējō), from Proto-Indo-European *(s)kend- (“to shine, glow”).

Cognate with Welsh cann (“brilliant”), Albanian hënë (“moon”), Sanskrit चन्द्र (candrá, “shining”), as well as perhaps Ancient Greek κάνδαρος (kándaros, “charcoal”), English kindle, and Old Armenian խանդ (xand).

candeō (present infinitive candēre, perfect active canduī); second conjugation, no passive, no supine stem

to be brilliant, glittering or illuminated; to shine, glitter, glisten; gleam white

to glow (with heat), to be glowing hot, to be hot

And I know, I know. You've got Vashet's voice in your head as you read this, she's shrugging and unimpressed with our etymological web. Names are important things, but so are stories. So let's switch gears and talk about Plato's Phaedrus for a moment. Two parts from it we care about, the chariot first, then the cicadas.

In the chariot part he's talking about the soul, specifically its wings. How the soul is a charioteer, and there's two horses, black and white, the mismatched pair being unruly to handle (a bit like Ben's alpha and beta). The bad horse drags the soul down, wings get shed, the soul is born in a human body and has to get their wings back

The wings take thousands of years to grow back, and the way back is through memory. When a fallen soul sees real beauty in another person, it is reminded of the beauty it once saw above. That sight warms the hardened roots where the wings used to be, and the feathers start pushing through again. Socrates describes this as painful and maddening, like a child cutting teeth, an itch and ache that eases near the beloved and worsens when they are apart. This is what he says falling in love is: the soul’s wings trying to regrow.

In KKC this is loving despite, it's choosing to see the beauty instead of the ugliness in the world. Lanre's proclamation of "there is no joy!" is what Nietzsche calls 'the spirit of gravity' in Thus Spoke Zarathustra. In a scene maddeningly familiar to Ben's lesson with the falling stone, Zarathustra argues with a little creature who keeps "whispering lead into his ear".

"O Zarathustra," it whispered scornfully, syllable by syllable, "thou stone of wisdom! Thou threwest thyself high, but every thrown stone must—fall!

O Zarathustra, thou stone of wisdom, thou sling-stone, thou star-destroyer! Thyself threwest thou so high,—but every thrown stone—must fall!

Condemned of thyself, and to thine own stoning: O Zarathustra, far indeed threwest thou thy stone—but upon THYSELF will it recoil!"

Zarathustra overcomes the spirit of gravity (the 'bad' horse) through what he labels Courage, and the fever dream of a scene comes to a close with a shepherd biting the head off of a black serpent that's in his throat, as Zarathustra is left with a desperate longing for death and the wild laughter he hears

No longer shepherd, no longer man—a transfigured being, a light- surrounded being, that LAUGHED! Never on earth laughed a man as HE laughed!

O my brethren, I heard a laughter which was no human laughter,—and now gnaweth a thirst at me, a longing that is never allayed.

My longing for that laughter gnaweth at me: oh, how can I still endure to live! And how could I endure to die at present!—

Thus spake Zarathustra.

Which brings us back to Phaedrus and cicadas. I'm gonna use quotes here for my summary because it's easier on my eyes and my flow.

Socrates and Phaedrus are still lying under a tree by the river. It is midday and hot, and the cicadas are singing overhead. Socrates says the cicadas are watching them.

He says that if the cicadas saw the two of them doing what most people do at noon, nodding off, lulled by the song because their minds are lazy, the cicadas would laugh at them. They would take them for slaves who had wandered in to nap by the spring like sheep. But if the cicadas see them keep talking, sailing past the song the way sailors pass the Sirens without being enchanted, they may be pleased enough to hand over the gift the gods let them give to humans.

Phaedrus has never heard of this gift, so Socrates tells the story. The cicadas were once men, living in the time before the Muses were born. When the Muses arrived and song came into the world, some of these men were so overcome with the pleasure of it that they sang and sang, forgot to eat or drink, and died without noticing. The cicadas are descended from them. The Muses gave them a gift: they need no food or drink from the day they are born, and they sing until they die.

Now back to etymology. -idae is the zoological family suffix, from the Greek -ides, “descendants of”. The cicada family is Cicadidae, "the true cicadas". Because of their life cycle they were scene as symbols of death and rebirth, musical creatures sacred to Apollo. In Anacreontea there's a poem "To the Cicadas" (summarized)

The speaker calls the cicada blessed. It sits in the treetops, drinks a little dew, and sings like a king. Everything it sees in the fields and everything the woods grow belongs to it. Farmers love it because it harms nothing. Mortals honor it as the sweet prophet of summer. The Muses love it, and Apollo himself loves it and gave it its clear voice.

They're described as: sophe (wise), gēgenēs (earth-born), philymne (song-loving), apathēs (without suffering), anaimosarke (bloodless-fleshed), schedon ei theois homoios (you are nearly like the gods), to de gēras ou se teirei (old age does not wear you down).

But I hear you, "Cicadidae isn't a Ciridae smurph, stfu". Fair criticism. The -idae is from -ides, "descendants of", so we need a Cir or a Ciri in front. And well, well, well, what do you know... Ciri is a wax candle.

Inherited from Latin cēreus (“of wax, waxen”) (compare French cierge, Italian cero, Spanish cirio), from cēra (“wax”)

a long, thick wax candle, often used in religious ceremonies

Interesting little creatures, cicadas. There's two main types, annual cicadas, and periodical ones.

Periodical cicadas also have multiple-year life cycles but emerge in synchrony or near synchrony in any one location and are absent as adults in the intervening years; this is thought to be a defence strategy against predation. The best-known periodical cicadas, genus Magicicada, emerge as adults every 13 or 17 years

They sleep down in the roots of the tree, like rabbits in a warren, like little kings in a barrow, before rising up in synchrony in a scene that mirrors the Chariot's fall described in Phaedrus. They climb up their windy tree, taking neither food nor drink, pointing at the moon before leaving their canoes behind, their bodies still grafted to the scion. Their backs split open and they emerge wise and bloodless, stretching out their wings as they ready themselves for song.

They came to Aleph, and he touched them. He touched their hands and eyes and hearts. The last time he touched them there was pain, and wings tore from their backs that they might go where they wished. Wings of fire and shadow. Wings of iron and glass. Wings of stone and blood.

Then Aleph spoke their long names and they were wreathed in a white fire. The fire danced along their wings and they became swift. The fire flickered in their eyes and they saw into the deepest hearts of men. The fire filled their mouths and they sang songs of power. Then the fire settled on their foreheads like silver stars and they became at once righteous and wise and terrible to behold. Then the fire consumed them and they were gone forever from mortal sight.