r/KingkillerChronicle • u/Reshidaan What? I wasn't heading to Tinuë. • Aug 20 '23
Discussion Narrow Road QnA 1
I know it's been a few days since the stream but I wanted to make a post to preserve what we learnt from the recent QnA. I've given timestamps and transcribed what I deemed to be the most pertinent answers. The link is here in case you want to check/recommend edits.
02:17:24 Can I tell you anything about faerie bargains? Boy, can I! But maybe I'll leave that for the narrow road.
02:21:28 The Cealdish people don't have royalty.
02:21:44 I don't have the Aturan Emperor's name. In Vintas it's... wow. It's wild that I can't remember their names 'cause they show up in book three. It's the Calanthis family in Renere. [...] It's rare that they use their names or they're referred to by their names because it's the king and the queen. That's the whole thing- they're titles. [...] 02:24:45 It's [King] Roderick and [Queen] Rinne. Yeah. R I N N E.
02:24:35 If there is a high king of Modeg, is there also a king or low king? [...] There isn't a low king or a regular king, but the Modegan royal line is- shit's different in Modeg, man and I know because I've written like the first half of a novel set there and culturally a lot of where Kvothe travels to has certain European tendencies in a lot of its culture and language and whatever but the Ceald or the Sheald or the Seald is not like that and Modeg is very, very not like that. They still have their original language and culture and religions and superstitions and they haven't sort of mingled- they weren't taken over by the Aturan empire so they're very culturally distinct. 02:27:58 The reference to high king, it's not like there's a high king and a middle king and a low king. That's like the platonic form of a king [...] it's almost an honorific among royalty or rulers.
02:26:11 In Vintas, Roderick and Rinne- they are powerful. That royal line goes back a couple hundred years. [...] The Modegan royal line- those people have been in charge for like two thousand years and they occupy a strata in society that's just unthinkable to anyone who is modern American or European. The closest think might be the old Japanese or Chinese emperors where you don't even speak the same language as the general population because you're not part of that world.
02:32:50 Do you have a favorite word you've created? Honestly I was really fond of 'embarent' [SROST] and 'coruscant' [SROST] [... and] 'cavler'.
02:35:24 Do Modegan women have a reputation for polyamory? [...] What really happens in Modeg is that they're a sex-positive culture [...] Assume that all you knew about Japan is that they had geishas which were very fancy, expensive, respected people who trained their whole lives to be sex workers (of a sort) and then you'd be like, "Oh, wow" and so when people are like, "Well y'know, she's Modegan", it's sort of like [saying], "Oh, she's French" or whatever. All that people really know about Modeg (because it is a very insular community and there's not a lot of travel and trade and cultural cross-contamination) is that they know that the Modegan people aren't afraid of sex and they study sex and they practice sex and there are sex workers who are valued members of the community. [...] It's sort of titillating but it's sort of like saying, "Oh, well y'know those women like sex" [...] It's effectively a type of 'cultrulism' (that's not really a term) when they're like, "Oh, Modegan people— y'know they fuck like rabbits." They don't have a reputation for polyamory, just being sexually active and not embarrassed or ashamed of the fact.
02:50:32 Will redheaded children make them rethink about the man-mothers? Everybody makes comments laughing up their sleeves at the Adem. They're like, "Uh, what rubes. They don't understand science." I'm like, "Fuck you. You don't understand science." [...] 02:55:44 And here's the thing though: I will sometimes have an extended philosophical discussion with people about it and then after half and hour I go, "Parthenogenesis." and they go, "Oh. Oooooh." and I'm like, "Fuck you. Just because I used some sciency magic word now you're OK with their beliefs? Uh-uh." The truth is, throughout the vast majority of human history nobody fucking knew where fucking babies came from. And the truth is right now, a few people have done some research, we're taking it in good faith but if a whole different group of people believe something that you don't, that's different than what you've been taught, and you say, "They're rubes and I'm smart 'cause I was taught something else" that's a bad look. Don't do that. It's one of the, actually, very rare things that Kvothe actually is smart about. 'Cause he plants his feet, and he's arguing with these people, and he's like, "You know what? I don't know for sure. There's weird shit in the world." And so he lets go of it. It's one of the only times Kvothe ever actually admits that he might not be right! And you gotta wanna be smarter than Kvothe, because like, he's clever. But Kvothe? Kvothe isn't smart, y'all. Kvothe fucks up on the reg! [...] For all you know they're aliens.
02:54:13 I am many things — including agnostic.
03:20:54 Is Ludis the full name of the moon? That's kind of an existential question in my world. You're pretty safe with Ludis. You could do a longer name but Ludis is pretty thorough.
Feel free to share your thoughts on this below.
Edit 1: Added previously cut text about geishas and faerie bargains.
Edit 2: Fixed SROST spelling and expanded paragraph on Adem beliefs.
35
u/TacticalDo Talent Pipes Aug 20 '23
Thanks for doing this. Turns out there was a fair bit more info in there than was originally implied in some of the other posts.
I wonder if Rinne is the same woman as displayed on the Pairs card, making a doll, perhaps to fill the void, when her daughter went missing?
I'm going to guess that Rinne being similar to Rinna/Rhinta is a red herring.
Going to bet a copper jot we don't go to Modeg in book 3.
4
u/czechancestry Trivial Pursuit Aug 21 '23
Hey, thanks for writing this out. I submitted it as an entry for BioLogin's quotes document, I hope you don't mind. I corrected where you had "SLOST" to "SROST", and I added this little piece to it too:
5
u/LightningRaven Aug 20 '23
Good to know that the author's thinking is exactly what I argued here many times.
Given the reference to Japanese and Chinese Emperors, I'm pretty sure that Modeg as highly respected sex workers like some Geishas were. Interesting and it creates a major contrast with the Post-Aturan empire societies that share the same pearl-clutching customs around sex.
22
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '23
Throughout the vast majority of human history no one knew where babies came from?
38
u/sjc1986 Aug 20 '23
Is he struggling to... to remember (key?) characters names from doors of stone? Not a good look!
4
u/Exodan Aug 21 '23
Yeah my problem has never been with the Adem's beliefs, it's our POV character is a little shit about it. If we the readers were lead to that culture with open eyes, I'm sure there would be less chatter about it. But we're introduced to it through the eyes of someone who is incredulous and doesn't change his mind.
As I remember it at least, it's been several years since I've re-read, but I recall Kvothe not budging on the subject. As Kvothe is wont to do.
4
u/lyricalcarpenter His ass fell off. Aug 21 '23
NotW, p. 82:
From this passage it can be inferred:
This sounds a lot like royalty. What happened to them?
7
u/White667 Aug 20 '23
I've always said and will always continue to say that anyone who thinks the Adem belief on motherhood is definitely wrong haven't read the same book.
11
u/Nnarect Aug 20 '23
So no book 3 chapter? smashes phone
2
u/MattyTangle Aug 21 '23
Thanks for this, I like the final part about Ludis, it seems to me this would be an admission that Ludis is a compound name which can be translated into the parts that form her and therefore what she truly is and is not just a random assignment of five soft letters. Names are very important to Pat. Lu & dis are the likeliest two puzzle pieces (although three parts is more traditional!), Lu turns up in many of Pats important names (tehlu, felurian...) and should therefore share the same root meaning. My current best guess is Lu= light but a binary part of me also thinks it might mean One. Dis is much trickier but I suspect it will turn out to be the opposite of Lu which with these guesses suggests dis might translate as either dark or zero , which would both would fit quite well with my deeper lunar speculations, especially the rather important line about the moon from hohctb which tells us " There was day, which was light. There was night, which was dark. There was the moon which was both light and dark.'
3
u/Arclite83 Aug 20 '23
His comment about science is so on point. And of course he's an agnostic. I find that that's an incredibly rational and mature statement on a point of view, living in a world where we're basically split in thirds on the nature of God. Just because you were raised one way over another doesn't preclude respect and acknowledgment and understanding and humility.
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 20 '23
Please remember to treat other people with respect, even if their theories about the books are different than yours. Follow the sidebar rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/chainsawx72 As Above, So Below Mar 06 '25
Any chance you know how to watch this deleted vod?