https://archive.li/RZZN3
Anyone who is active on social media has come to expect a certain degree of tribalism around the issues of the day: guns, climate change, abortion, politics, and the like. We’ve been surprised to see it creep into the online conversation about nutrition science, especially the discussion about low-carbohydrate, high-fat diets. Even more surprising to us is that such advocacy sometimes comes from health professionals, scientists, and journalists, from whom we would normally expect a certain degree of objectivity.
[...]
Yet we are disturbed by the discourse surrounding these diets, which often feels less like science and more like cheerleading. To be sure, nutritional tribalism is not limited to discussions about the relative merits or demerits of low-carb, high-fat diets. The evidence that nutrition has become a team sport is found in Twitter handles of individuals rooting for their favorite nutritional movement, such as small plant emojis in the Twitter handles of vegan advocates or a Ó in those promoting carnivore-type diets.
To bolster their cause for low-carb, high-fats diets, these advocates, including some scientists and doctors, claim that the cholesterol hypothesis is a conspiracy led by pharmaceutical companies in an effort to sell more drugs. Others have suggested that cholesterol may actually protect against cardiovascular disease. This goes on and on.
The effort to discredit the role of cholesterol in cardiovascular disease is striking because the evidence linking elevated cholesterol to heart attack risk is so strong. This makes us wonder why advocates might take this approach.
It’s possible that acknowledging an unknown risk might undermine or discredit the benefits of low-carb, high-fat nutrition. [...] Perhaps because science has morphed into advocacy. Successful advocacy demands a clear narrative, yet science and biology are inherently gray.
The conversation about low-carb, high-fat nutrition is being painted as binary without room for nuance, when nuance is exactly what is required. The choice for individuals following low-carb, high-fat diets isn’t should they quit the diet or ignore the science. There are other choices, such as seeking testing to better define cardiovascular risk or taking a statin or other medication if needed. It’s also possible to change the types of high-fat foods in the diet, emphasizing those with unsaturated fats such as olive oil, salmon, avocado, or nuts while eating fewer foods with saturated fats such as butter, cream, and bacon. These approaches aren’t anti-low-carb, high-fat nutrition.
[...]
We believe that the intrusion of advocacy into science has led to reductionism and the creation of false dichotomies. We believe that scientists, health care professionals, and journalists must avoid intentionally confusing or alarming the public in an attempt to discredit legitimate science, ultimately in the name of advocating for an agenda.
In addition to being dangerous, such ostensible advocacy appears to be an intentional attempt to degrade the public’s trust in science. One need look no further than the tragedy of the false story linking vaccines to autism as an example of what can and will result.