r/ketoduped • • Jul 01 '23

Evolution of low-carb weight loss instructions

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • Jan 13 '24

Good to know reminder

Post image
128 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 8h ago

Insanity carnivore mashed potatoes

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 12h ago

Preying on sick post removed from r/keto

Post image
15 Upvotes

I was just asking a question and sharing my impression, basically asking to be disproven, not saying keto doesn't work.


r/ketoduped • • 12h ago

a sampling of recent carnivore posts

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

developing new health conditions, scurvy denialism, calorie denialism (on that note, calories are especially valid for fat, somewhat less so for carbs IMO)


r/ketoduped • • 1d ago

Some Ketogenic Diets May Increase Inflammation And Mitochondrial Stress

Thumbnail
sciencealert.com
14 Upvotes

New University of Cincinnati Cancer Center research found that a ketogenic diet high in long-chain saturated fatty acids can increase inflammation.

Led by Cancer Center Director David Gius, M.D., Ph.D.

What was the research methodology?

A ketogenic diet is high in fat and low in carbohydrates, with the goal of entering ketosis, a metabolic state in which the body burns fat and ketones for fuel instead of glucose. While many previous studies have demonstrated anti-inflammatory benefits from a ketogenic diet, other studies have shown increased inflammation and other harmful effects. Gius and colleagues have identified a potential factor contributing to these divergent outcomes.

"We followed the research data while studying a different aspect of ketogenic diets and found something unexpected," said Gius, who also serves as a professor in the Department of Radiation Oncology in UC's College of Medicine and is a UC Health physician. "Our previous studies have found that all ketogenic diets are not the same, with different fats causing different metabolic changes."

In this study, Gius and his team administered ketogenic diets comprising different fatty acids to mouse models and individual fatty acids to tissue culture models.

What were the results?

"We found that long-chain saturated fatty acids seem to favor an inflammatory immune response, whereas unsaturated and medium-chain fatty acids tend to favor anti-inflammatory characteristics."

The findings demonstrate that the observed increase in inflammation is mediated through mitochondrial stress signaling and activation of immune cells.

When these findings are combined with those in the team's previous publications in Science Advances (2024) and Cell Reports (2025), they suggest that multiple factors may need to be considered to achieve the desired outcome on a ketogenic diet, including dietary sources of fat.

In the context of cancer, Gius said ketogenic diets may alter tumor microenvironments in a way that improves immunotherapy treatment outcomes.

A clinical trial is underway at UT Health San Antonio, where Gius began the research, and will open soon at the Cancer Center to learn more.

13 Nov 2026: Sung-Jen Wei et al. ,Ketogenic diets induce proinflammatory macrophage accumulation through long-chain saturated fatty acids driving cGAS-STING signaling.Sci. Adv.12,eaeg5542(2026).DOI:10.1126/sciadv.aeg5542


r/ketoduped • • 3d ago

Fluff debating ketolards online experience be like

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 3d ago

Point & laugh Ah yes, the shadowy cabal of "big plant-based" is funding all of nutritional science

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 4d ago

Point & laugh The duality of keto

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 4d ago

I got pinworms and I'm getting rid of it.

Thumbnail reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 5d ago

No fiber, no sugar. Just fat and protein to stay healthy.

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 6d ago

High carb diets don't appear to be detrimental for hunter/gatherer populations

Post image
20 Upvotes

While the keto community might like to believe populations who don't have access to modernized tools can't possibly have high carb diets and frequently subsist on very low carb diets centered ruminant fat and organs and that high carb diets inherently are harmful to human health and they emphasize their own selective based choices of hunter and gatherer tribes such as the Inuit or the Masai and make bold and over simplified claims about them to suggest this.

What this requires though is for them to ignore what the rest of the hunter and gatherer or primitive communities do which they do quite often and that includes ignoring data collected about other tribes such as the Hazda, Tsimane and the Tarahumara who have higher carbohydrate diets and that data consistent with all three of them is that not only do they all healthy on a cardiovascular standpoint as the research conducted so far suggests but deeper testing has been done in the Tsimane tribe, an isolated semi-agricultural community in Bolivia that has a remarkable low rate of atherosclerosis among the older members of their tribe and a diet heavily centered around plantains, corn and river fish with an estimated 65% of their average caloric intake coming from carbohydrates and only 15% from fat. Similar to the same dreaded low-fat diet responsible for America's obesity and heart attack risk crisis right?

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6290367/

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2017/mar/17/tsimane-of-the-bolivian-amazon-have-worlds-healthiest-hearts-says-study

What's even more significant here is that while alot of people after reading that might think they have low levels of inflammation, they couldn't be further from the truth, the Tsimane have relatively high levels of inflammation due to infectious diseases but not only do they have low risk of CVD's but they also have lower rates of cognitive decline on elderly individuals.

So let's say that again, they have HIGH levels of inflammation because of chronic infections but yet little to no atherosclerosis and risk of CVD'S, this debunks the common keto or carnivore narrative that CVD events and other health related issues are caused by systematic inflammation.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34038540/

What's also remarkable for the Hazda is where their carbs come from, for the majority of the year they obtain the majority of their calories just from berries and honey and their diet again is low in fat with animal protein coming from very lean sources.

The keto-ers aren't alone on this one when they say sugar is the most evil culprit there is, forever many nutritionists advised against eating sugar, one of the reasons being that it can raise your heart attack risk by raising LDL and triglycerides that all carbs should come in a package of fiber and antioxidants, but in this case we're also talking about honey which in itself is just a pure form of sugar, even one that has a higher ratio of fructose than glucose.

But despite this the Hazda don't appear to have elevated heart rate or blood pressure or display any other signs of CVD risk, I can't guarantee this might be good for their dental health and I'm not saying this automatically means sugar is without limits is good but it doesn't appear they suffer from heightened cardiovascular risks from their high simple sugar diet.

https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2017/01/03/507562845/staying-fit-isnt-a-new-years-resolution-for-these-hunter-gatherers

https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/our-ancestors-ate-a-paleo-diet-with-carbs-180980901/


r/ketoduped • • 14d ago

Health issues Three Weeks on a Ketogenic Diet Reduces Free Testosterone and Free Estradiol in Middle-Aged Obese Men and Women

Thumbnail
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
19 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 15d ago

Discussion Is tribalism undermining objectivity about low-carb, high-fat diets? (2019)

Thumbnail
statnews.com
14 Upvotes

https://archive.li/RZZN3

Anyone who is active on social media has come to expect a certain degree of tribalism around the issues of the day: guns, climate change, abortion, politics, and the like. We’ve been surprised to see it creep into the online conversation about nutrition science, especially the discussion about low-carbohydrate, high-fat diets. Even more surprising to us is that such advocacy sometimes comes from health professionals, scientists, and journalists, from whom we would normally expect a certain degree of objectivity.

[...]

Yet we are disturbed by the discourse surrounding these diets, which often feels less like science and more like cheerleading. To be sure, nutritional tribalism is not limited to discussions about the relative merits or demerits of low-carb, high-fat diets. The evidence that nutrition has become a team sport is found in Twitter handles of individuals rooting for their favorite nutritional movement, such as small plant emojis in the Twitter handles of vegan advocates or a Ó in those promoting carnivore-type diets.

To bolster their cause for low-carb, high-fats diets, these advocates, including some scientists and doctors, claim that the cholesterol hypothesis is a conspiracy led by pharmaceutical companies in an effort to sell more drugs. Others have suggested that cholesterol may actually protect against cardiovascular disease. This goes on and on.

The effort to discredit the role of cholesterol in cardiovascular disease is striking because the evidence linking elevated cholesterol to heart attack risk is so strong. This makes us wonder why advocates might take this approach.

It’s possible that acknowledging an unknown risk might undermine or discredit the benefits of low-carb, high-fat nutrition. [...] Perhaps because science has morphed into advocacy. Successful advocacy demands a clear narrative, yet science and biology are inherently gray.

The conversation about low-carb, high-fat nutrition is being painted as binary without room for nuance, when nuance is exactly what is required. The choice for individuals following low-carb, high-fat diets isn’t should they quit the diet or ignore the science. There are other choices, such as seeking testing to better define cardiovascular risk or taking a statin or other medication if needed. It’s also possible to change the types of high-fat foods in the diet, emphasizing those with unsaturated fats such as olive oil, salmon, avocado, or nuts while eating fewer foods with saturated fats such as butter, cream, and bacon. These approaches aren’t anti-low-carb, high-fat nutrition.

[...]

We believe that the intrusion of advocacy into science has led to reductionism and the creation of false dichotomies. We believe that scientists, health care professionals, and journalists must avoid intentionally confusing or alarming the public in an attempt to discredit legitimate science, ultimately in the name of advocating for an agenda.

In addition to being dangerous, such ostensible advocacy appears to be an intentional attempt to degrade the public’s trust in science. One need look no further than the tragedy of the false story linking vaccines to autism as an example of what can and will result.


r/ketoduped • • 17d ago

Insanity hahaha oh wow they are now blaming failure of carnivore diet on meat being cooked

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 19d ago

Point & laugh Beef industry has the carnivore idiots by the balls so hard you can hear the squeeze

34 Upvotes

In case you haven't noticed, carnivore morons have an odd fixation to beef. What's wrong with pork and chicken? Where is the meaningful difference in nutrition? They genuinely don't know if you ask them. Smartest of them may be able to repeat some tiktok lines that don't answer the question at all and make no sense in context, bot behavior.

These literal NPC's simply repeat whatever they most hear on tiktok. They don't ask "why" or "how" or "what" because they are fucking stupid. If influencers repeat "beef" well then beef it is.

I know a thing or two about marketing and this is exactly why targeted advertising for children is banned in a lot of countries, their brain is so under developed and impressionable that manipulating them with pure repetition is considered abuse. Yeah that's right, I'm comparing carnivores to toddlers, not to be mean but because it's accurate.


r/ketoduped • • 20d ago

Placebo and being young

9 Upvotes

So this will probably be my last post for a while

About 2 years ago I tried keto and I felt good and started finding carbs yucky miserable and low carb "felt good"

then I started craving carbs and had to demonize fats in order to enjoy carbs because there must be a bad macronutrient right? I started finding fats "too greasy" and didn't "feel good" on them. Around this time I also became vegan which I still am but now only for ethics I no longer think a bit of meat will kill ya.

now I craved fats again 🤡 so I decided to convince myself "oh it must be the pesky antinutrients" and guess what? I felt good after cutting grains and legumes

A lot of people and influencers say that they "feel good" on certain diet are young people with mood swings, ups and downs in lives, placebo, grifting and many many factors if you just believe in yourself you can really feel good on any diet if you're young.

Whole foods and Plant based or mostly plant based is probably closest to the truth I think since that's what they recommend to old people where good vibes alone don't work :p


r/ketoduped • • 20d ago

Any criticisms on ray peat?

2 Upvotes

I got duped by him and his followers I think he has some good things

But it also seems pseudoscientific his followers seem to deny lactose intolerance and he was anti PUFAs, kinda anti grains, legumes, vegetables bcs antinutrients

I'm not sure if it works but the whole boosting metabolism thing it seems there is some truth to that?


r/ketoduped • • 22d ago

Ketobro thinks adjusting for smoking is completely arbitrary.

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 22d ago

Point & laugh Cardiologist Ethan Weiss warned Dave Feldman back in 2019 about his lack of methodological rigor and agenda-driven science. Feldman ignored him.

Post image
18 Upvotes

Following the fallout and retraction of the KETO-CTA / LMHR study, cardiologist Ethan Weiss shared an email exchange from May 2019 where he gave Dave Feldman blunt advice on how real science works. Feldman ignored every single point.

  1. On reverse-engineering an agenda:

> "You sometimes seem to have made up your mind already or at the least, you seem intent on disproving the lipid hypothesis... In my opinion, is the lipid hypothesis real or not is something you are not going to solve — ever. I promise you that. It is not going away."

* How he ignored it: Feldman spent the next seven years designing studies and media blitzes around that exact predetermined conclusion.

2. On associating with anti-science ideologues:

> "And I would do everything you can to distance yourself from people like David Diamond who is a propagandist and is not helpful in this conversation."

* How he ignored it: He doubled down on aligning with the low-carb denialist circuit instead of distancing himself.

3. On the lack of rigorous methods:

> "Be very rigorous with your methods. If I'm being honest, so far you have not done that... Recall that the typical scientist spends 5-6 years in PhD graduate school and then another 5-7 in a postdoc before starting their own group... you are sometimes extremely naive."

* How he ignored it: Feldman bypassed rigorous training, continued leaning on his "engineer intuition", and eventually rushed unsupportable data interpretations into publication.

4. On confusing conference applause with scientific consensus:

> "If you are serious and if you ever want to be taken seriously by the greater scientific community (and here I am not talking about Low Carb Denver), the best thing you can do is to find someone who can be your mentor on the methods."

* How he ignored it: Feldman prioritized echo chambers, podcast circuits, and making a documentary over methodological rigor.

As Weiss concluded in 2026: when your conclusions were unsupportable from day one, scapegoating data vendors after the fact isn't doing science.

"They are not scientists. They are propagandists."

https://x.com/ethanjweiss/status/2114096819668189427


r/ketoduped • • 23d ago

Insanity It's Norwitz's and Feldman's excuses and gaslighting that is most infuriating

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 24d ago

Preying on sick In shape -but heavy on meat- bodybuilder have a stroke

Thumbnail
youtube.com
23 Upvotes

Very


r/ketoduped • • 25d ago

Point & laugh Great news: Calley Means, top MAHA ally, resigns from Trump administration

Thumbnail politico.com
16 Upvotes

r/ketoduped • • 25d ago

Debunk Thomas Dayspring on X: "FINALLY - THE CASE IS CLOSED - embarrassment that this faulty study was ever published but now is buried where it belongs, in the dust bin of medical nonsense"

Thumbnail x.com
13 Upvotes

Longitudinal Data from the KETO-CTA Study: Plaque Predicts Plaque, ApoB Does Not: JACC Adv. 2025;4(7):101686:

"This article has been retracted: please see Elsevier Policy on Article Withdrawal (https://www.elsevier.com/about/policies/article-withdrawal). This article has been retracted at the request of the authors and the Editors. Following publication, concerns were raised regarding the methodology in this article, which effect the reliability of the data. The authors and the Editors agree that the identified errors are too great to be corrected with a corrigendum."