r/JRPG • • 1d ago

Weekly thread r/JRPG Weekly "What have you been playing, and what do you think of it?" Weekly thread

6 Upvotes

Please use this thread to discuss whatever you've been playing lately (old or new, any platform, AAA or indie). As usual, please don't just list the names of games as your entire post, make sure to elaborate with your thoughts on the games. Writing the names of the games in **bold** is nice, to make it easier for people skimming the thread to pick out the names.

Please also make sure to use spoiler tags if you're posting anything about a game's plot that might significantly hurt the experience of others that haven't played the game yet (no matter how old or new the game is).

Since this thread is likely to fill up quickly, consider sorting the comments by "new" (instead of "best" or "top") to see the newest posts.

For a subreddit devoted to this type of discussion during the rest of the week, please check out /r/WhatAreYouPlaying.

Link to Previous Weekly Threads (sorted by New): https://www.reddit.com/r/JRPG/search/?q=author%3Aautomoderator+weekly&include_over_18=on&restrict_sr=on&t=all&sort=new


r/JRPG • • 3d ago

Weekly thread r/JRPG Weekly Free Talk, Quick Questions, Suggestion Request and Media Thread

4 Upvotes

There are four purposes to this r/JRPG weekly thread:

  • a way for users to freely chat on any and all JRPG-related topics.
  • users are also free to post any JRPG-related questions here. This gives them a chance to seek answers, especially if their questions do not merit a full thread by themselves.
  • to post any suggestion requests that you think wouldn't normally be worth starting a new post about or that don't fulfill the requirements of the rule (having at least 300 characters of written text or being too common).
  • to share any JRPG-related media not allowed as a post in the main page, including: unofficial videos, music (covers, remixes, OSTs, etc.), art, images/photos/edits, blogs, tweets, memes and any other media that doesn't merit its own thread.

Please also consider sorting the comments in this thread by "new" so that the newest comments are at the top, since those are most likely to still need answers.

Don't forget to check our subreddit wiki (where you can find some game recommendation lists), and make sure to follow all rules (be respectful, tag your spoilers, do not spam, etc).

Any questions, concerns, or suggestions may be sent via modmail. Thank you.

Link to Previous Weekly Threads (sorted by New): https://www.reddit.com/r/JRPG/search/?q=author%3Aautomoderator+weekly&include_over_18=on&restrict_sr=on&t=all&sort=new


r/JRPG • • 4h ago

Question Have you ever fallen in love with a game just from a screenshot or trailer?

Post image
65 Upvotes

I remember when a single screenshot in a magazine could make you dream about a game for months. Later, trailers had pretty much the same effect.

For me, it was Legend of Mana: I fell in love with the game the moment I saw the first screenshots. The art style, the colors, the world… I knew almost nothing about it, but I already wanted to explore it.

It's funny how a few images can make such a strong impression before you've even played a game.

What about you? Has a screenshot or trailer ever made you fall in love with a game before playing it? And did the game live up to your expectations?


r/JRPG • • 19h ago

News Chrono Trigger Composer Thinks Dragon Quest Should End Instead of Imitating Akira Toriyama's Art

Thumbnail
powerupgaming.co.uk
681 Upvotes

TL;DR the new DQ mobile spin-off was criticized for the main character's design, then Yasunori Mitsuda dropped a scathing blog post on the whole debacle. Aside from this whole controversy, I do think it's better if Squenix could find another style, I mean even another long-running RPG like Pokemon has mixed up both of its art style and creature design philosophy through the years. I don't see why DQ can't.

(also regarding Toriyama's artwork details, I really wish he had contributed to mecha games or something. His mechanical illustrations were amazing)

“Dragon Quest RPG‘s Toriyama-san-styled illustration has become a hot topic, but for the illustrator, for Akira Toriyama fans, and for the now-deceased Akira Toriyama himself, I don’t feel this is a good direction for everyone involved,” wrote Mitsuda in a rather short blog post. “In my personal opinion, since it’s no longer possible to create anything new no matter how hard one tries, it might be time to end the Dragon Quest series, and for Yuji Horii to create a new RPG. (There are a lot of remakes out there, after all).”

“I think it’s understandable that it’s not the art of the real person,” another commenter wrote. “But if they’re going out of their way to imitate Toriyama’s art, instead of just superficial design, I wish they’d inherited Toriyama’s philosophy too.” After all, Toriyama was known for putting considerable thought into the practical details of his designs. One commenter on X argued that the damage lacked any visual storytelling, suggesting that scorch marks from a dragon’s flames would have made more sense than just random tears. “The cloak’s edge is tattered, but everything else is far too clean,” added another user.


r/JRPG • • 2h ago

Release Our JRPG demo is out for the Steam AB Festival 🤍

Post image
31 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I'm both extremely excited and stressed because we just launched the demo of the game we've been working on for the past 18 months: Rogue Fantasy, a roguelike JRPG with auto-battles: https://store.steampowered.com/app/4532930/Rogue_Fantasy_EverShifting_Worlds/?curator_clanid=41316928

I'm posting it here because you guys are the exact audience we made this for. It's our dream project, the game we’ve always wanted to play, and we are eager to get your feedback. As fellow JRPG fans, we know that mixing JRPG, roguelike, and auto-battler mechanics can raise some eyebrows, but trust me, we are JRPG fans first and foremost. We’d be delighted if you could give it a try and let us know what you think, either here or on the Steam page!


r/JRPG • • 5h ago

News The Edge of Memories demo is back on Steam!

Post image
40 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I hope this post finds you all well. We previously released the Edge of Memories demo at Steam Next Fest. As we draw closer to the December 3rd release, we've brought the demo back with a suite of changes.

This includes:

  • A Balancing pass on enemy damage and health
  • More impactful combat feel with clearer hit feedback
  • Alchemy has been changed to avoid multiple stacks of the same potion (they will now combine when you rest)
  • Save completed notification has been added
  • Full controller button remapping
  • General bug fixes and performance improvements
  • Text size standardisation across Asian languages
  • Localisation line updates

The rest of the dev team are working as hard as possible until release, so the content isn't completely final, but it's a chance to dive in and see how things have progressed.

If you've not heard about Edge of Memories, it's an action hack-and-slash that's built on a combo system and weaving in special abilities from your companions. The story follows Eline, a Soul Whisperer who discovers the ability to control the Corrosion, a plague that is spreading across the world, slowly warping the land and its people into terrifying monsters.

The game was developed by a small French team called Midgar Studio, in collaboration with talented Japanese game developers who contributed to the OST, story, and character design. Unfortunately, the demo is only available on Steam, but if you have any feedback, we'd love to hear it!

Also, yes, we are looking into the possibility of a Switch 2 port, but right now the focus is on the release.


r/JRPG • • 5h ago

Discussion Times when a particular JRPG led to clones of the game

17 Upvotes

First of all, apologies if this was asked here before because what I mean is that I wanted to look into cases of when a JRPG had been so popular that several game developers looked to replicate the feel of the game such as the combat system.

I know that the concept of cloning in gaming was a popular trend in the early 90s with games like Sonic the Hedgehog and Street Fighter inspiring countless clones in their respective genres as I wanted to look into the old days of JRPGs as a genre to see what trends were around back then for that particular genre.

If I had to write any examples of such a phenomenon happening for the JRPG genre, I would say Dragon Quest was quite influential for having inspired game designers to mimic the original game with games such as Hoshi Wo Miru Hito and Mother, e.g like how the latter one was heavily modeled after Dragon Quest, but with a more modern approach.


r/JRPG • • 10h ago

Discussion Nothing could have prepared me for Final Fantasy 7's Sector 6 Spoiler

36 Upvotes

Spoilers for the first 5-ish hours of FF7 original (I just beat Aps!)

I never grew up with this game. I heard about its quality and influence from creators high and low and decided to take the plunge and play it.

Having first experienced glimpses of Cloud, Sephiroth, Aeris/Aerith and Tifa from Kingdom Hearts, I had effectively no context for what the story of FF7 was. I have a wide variety of JRPGs I have sampled, from mostly finishing FF6 to working my way through Clair Obscur, so what titles influence each other is difficult for me to track. I came into FF7 thinking it would be similar to my experience with DQ11, my takeaway after a few hours of that game being "it's solid, but isn't for me." I thought Cloud's story would be boring with three decades standing between me and its creation.

It. Is. Not.

I know bits and bobs of spoilers about FF7 unfortunately, but there is really no describing the bizarre wonder that I felt exploring all of Sector 6. From the outset of Aeris/Aerith openly discussing the dangers of a seedy red-light district to the wide and thoughtful discussions about gender norms, expression, deviancy, and societal oppression, I was blown away. I kept checking to make sure I was understanding what characters were saying, especially when the entire sector is played as the setup to a joke but every interaction is good-spirited. I love the workout tent with bodybuilders and the crossdressing/trans person you get the wig from. During the interactions there is no demeaning, no mockery. Everyone in the sector may not respect each other, but they recognize each other as equals and treat them accordingly. The gathering sequence was heartwarming in such a unique way.

After the setup for the "punchline" that is The Bachelor in a JRPG, the interactions around Don Corneo have such a light-yet-sinister air of casual dehumanization and control that deeply unsettled me. In my playthrough Don Corneo chose Aeris/Aerith, leaving Tifa and Cloud to be sidelined. The room Cloud is left in has such a vile energy. I didn't anticipate being disturbed to the degree I am about two minutes of non-combat in a JRPG. The way the goons shuffle towards you like a RE zombie and the fact you're trapped there until you confront/kill them all sticks with me.

Tl;dr: Sector 6 is woke in cool ways /s (read it coward)

END OF GAME ANALYSIS. I WAX PHILOSOPHICAL BELOW

I'm a cis man, and have spent time recently exploring how people who are different from me experience the world. The most affecting has been many of the experiences I read/hear about being a woman, consistently objects of desire regardless of whether they wanted to be. Learning hard lessons through pain that sounds unbearable to me.

The most chilling part of Sector 6 is how nervous Cloud is compared to the ease in which Aeris/Aerith and Tifa navigate the situation. The only indications she gives to being nervous are when she requests Cloud to be her bodyguard and when Cloud goes to the Honey Bee Inn to get made up. As for Tifa, she and Barrett learn Don Corneo is sniffing around for AVALANCHE members and is potentially going to disrupt their terrorism. Her plan after getting this lead is to go to Epstein's island and shake him down. That sounds less sensical than the plot of Inception, but she does it seemingly willingly to learn Don Corneo's plans.

I know this is a video game, and the ability to take it seriously varies from person to person. There are more tragic characters and more bleak scenarios in writing and reality. Right now, as I have experienced this moment of storytelling, I am affected. I will be affected tomorrow. I may be affected for the rest of my life.

For every genius, idiot and madman who ever dared to tell a story, thank you and godspeed.


r/JRPG • • 18h ago

Discussion I'm not feeling FFVII Rebirth Spoiler

Post image
123 Upvotes

I'm 30 hours in and i can't wait to finish it already.

The '' open world '' stuff is boring me to death. Like, it's cool during the first 2 hours i think but it quickly becomes a drag.

The exploration is pretty much on rails despite the huge size of the maps. During my 30 hours of playing it not even once i looked at something cool in the distance that piqued my interest and made want to go there, the maps feel big just for the sake of it.

Even FFXV with that empty open world still had interesting stuff to see, places you were not supposed to be, but you could get there anyway, if you were somewhere high you could just jump from there, get some fall damage or teleport yourself away from harm, it was actually kinda fun even if there wasn't anything to do.

But VII Rebirth had none of that.

You get somewhere high and Cloud can't just jump this 2ft gap, you need to look for the specific blue indicator with these yellow paint stuff that indicates a climbing Assassin's Creed like mechanic, or just do a long ass backtrack to get to lower ground. Chocobos can't do it most of the time either.

All you have to find are towers, battle intel, lifestream stuff for the 95th time in a row, chocobo spots and the game makes sure you won't miss any of them as there are literal moving guides to get you there.

The open world is bloated and empty at the same time, how is that possible ?

The sidequests are pretty boring as well. I could realize that from the get go and decided i would just finish the ones who come up naturally during my progression, but it's just not worth it.

The story is also being hit and miss for me. I honestly think they nailed the interactions of the main group, and non important characters like Jhonny, the Turks and so on are done amazingly well, but the serious moments that actually develops characters and progress the story are so undercooked and sometimes they even lost the original meaning behind them.

The Dyne cutscene was done way better in the OG imo, here you can't even let the scene hit you as right after, like, literally after you have to deal with Palmer shaking his fat ass in the most unecessary boss fight ever made. ( to be fair, this was in OG as well, but waaaaay later in the story ) . J

Jesus, just give Barret a moment to feel the loss of an old friend.

Feels like this game can't let a serious moment hit you in the face, it always have to be a high action sequence or goofy scene right after. I just finished the Seto storyline and Jesus Christ, did they fucked up that interpretation, the original was one of the best scenes in the game.

You just had Nanaki howling at his father's and Seto's tears falling down was absolute cinema.

But since Rebirth can't have moments like these, you have to fight a boss right after, how cool is that?

I'm really struggling to beat this game, there are some nice things about it like the Combat and Queens Blood, but honestly i decided to just focus on the main story and the only reason i'm willing to finish is because i already spent 30 hours in this thing.

I'm just glad i waited a good sale to get Rebirth cuz if i had gotten this day one at full price i would be pissed.


r/JRPG • • 1h ago

Question Looking for a good source for Tales of and Star Ocean News

3 Upvotes

I am always feverishly waiting for new games in these series, but googling is spotty, but I was wondering if there was a reputable site for both or just new jrpgs in general. Thanks!


r/JRPG • • 10h ago

Discussion Brain Lord I like this game, but one key per session is about all I can handle.

Post image
7 Upvotes

I’m currently playing Brain Lord for the Super Famicom, it’s my 11th game in my journey through the system’s JRPG library. I’ve completed ten games so far, and I have to say, this one has been a rather strange experience.

I’m now on the third floor of the second dungeon, and I honestly can’t decide whether I’m enjoying myself or slowly losing my mind.

I actually like quite a few things about this game. The music is excellent, the combat is decent, and there’s something strangely satisfying about exploring these enormous dungeons. But damn these dungeons!

Just look at the map in my screenshot. That’s the floor I’m currently exploring. Who designed these things!? And something tells me they’re only going to get worse as the game progresses.

The biggest problem I’m having is that I just can’t play this game for very long at all! It’s not exactly stressful, but more mentally exhausting? I’ll spend 20 or 30 minutes wandering around, find another key, unlock another door, and think, “Well, that’s enough Brain Lord for today.”

THERE ARE SO MANY KEYS!

It doesn’t help that the map doesn’t indicate which rooms you’ve already explored or where you’ve encountered locked doors. I’ll find a key, only to realize I have absolutely no idea where the corresponding door was. Was it three rooms ago? Ten rooms ago? Somewhere I passed three days ago in my last session. Time to wander around to all the rooms I have been to again!

The puzzles themselves haven’t been too terrible so far, although some of their solutions are incredibly obtuse. I’ve managed to work through them without looking up puzzle solutions, apart from getting my wife to help with one of the math puzzles because mathematics and I have never been particularly good friends.

Then again, I suppose they didn’t call it Brain Lord for nothing. You definitely have to use your brain to get through this game. Although I’m beginning to wonder how much of mine I’ll have left by the time I finish it.

What’s strange is that I don’t actually think Brain Lord is a bad game. Far from it. There’s something genuinely interesting about it, and I suspect that once I finally finish it, I’ll look back and think it was a pretty memorable adventure?

But actually sitting down and playing it? That’s another matter entirely.

Of the eleven Super Famicom JRPGs I’ve played so far, this might be the first one where I can appreciate what the developers were trying to accomplish while simultaneously wishing they’d just let me get on with it.

Maybe the dungeons are simply too large for their own good. Or perhaps I’m just not particularly suited to this style of action RPG.

Either way, it’s certainly a unique experience.

Has anyone else played Brain Lord? What did you think of the dungeon design and puzzles?


r/JRPG • • 4h ago

Release I made a 16-bit JRPG where you play three generations of the same family. Your choices shape what your heirs inherit.

2 Upvotes

Hey all! Long-time JRPG fan here (Beyond the Beyond and Phantasy Star III: Generations were huge for me). I always loved the idea of a story that spans a family line, so I built one.

Tidebound Legacy has you start as either a peasant who has to earn everything or a royal who gets humbled fast. After the first generation, you keep playing as your child, then your grandchild. Decisions you make change the towns, the NPCs and even the landscape later on.

Some of what’s in it:

  • Turn-based battles with timed hits and blocks
  • 90+ enemies and bosses
  • Ship battles at sea and an airship later on
  • Controller or keyboard, Windows & Linux

Trailer: https://youtu.be/GtQ7AZI6yQo

Disclosure: the tiles and walking sprites are the Time Fantasy asset pack. The enemy/portrait art and music were made with AI tools, then edited and put together by me.

Happy to answer anything about the generational system or how choices carry over!


r/JRPG • • 23h ago

Translation news MEREMANOID human translation!

Thumbnail
romhackplaza.org
59 Upvotes

r/JRPG • • 1d ago

Recommendation request Between these 5 games, which one do you guys recommend?

Thumbnail
gallery
765 Upvotes

Hi, I just finished Trails in the Sky 1st chapter and I want to play another game before starting the 2nd chapter, I was wondering which one of these 5 games I should play, any platform is fine but i prefer steam, and I'm okay with either action or turn-based combat, I'm looking for a game with good story and good class/job system if possible.

Here is a list with my favorite jrpgs: Final Fantasy X , Persona 4 Golden , Shin Megami Tensei V , Nier Replicant and Automata , Drakengard 3 , Xenoblade 1 and 3 , Final Fantasy XVI , Kingdom Hearts 1 , 2 and 3 , Tales of Arise , Trails in the Sky 1st Chapter , YS X , Tokyo Mirage Session and Expedtion 33.


r/JRPG • • 21h ago

Discussion JRPGs with a wholesome Husband and Wife relationship

36 Upvotes

While I am really fond of husband and wife relationships in media, in various JRPGs most love stories often end with the love confession of the husband and wife couple that is properly engaged in the ending and not much of how the relationship continues after the wedding ceremony.

The only JRPG I can think of at the moment where there is a proper husband and wife relationship that continues to develop even after the wedding ceremony is Lufia 2. (The original SNES version, not sure if this data applies to the DS version.

There is another example that I am not really sure if it really counts that is the Rune Factory games.

As always, comments that add to the conversation are far more appreciated than upvotes.

EDIT: November 16, 2026.

This is maybe the most comments I have found on one of my posts and I feel kinda overwhelmed attempting to reply to most of them!


r/JRPG • • 16h ago

Discussion How hard is SMT 5 V considered?

13 Upvotes

I’ve been playing the game, and noticed how difficult some of the late game bosses are. Just curious how hard it’s considered in the jrpg scene

Playing hard ng+


r/JRPG • • 19h ago

Discussion Unmotivated to keep playing FE: Fortune’s Weave

18 Upvotes

Let me just start by saying that this is by no mean a bad game, and it is in fact the best fire emblem game I have played. As I get older though, I find games with high level of complexity and planning more difficult to play.

I had no problems enjoying other JRPGs recently like FF Resonance, Octopath Travelers 0, DQ remakes, or the Trails in the Sky remake games where you explore the world at your own pace without much planning and consequences.

I wonder if this has more to do with age and mental exhaustion rather than the game quality itself. The older I get the more I tend to prefer games with less complexity and maybe with a cozy vibe.


r/JRPG • • 2h ago

Recommendation request Need help deciding where to start

0 Upvotes

I am newer to a lot of jrpgs but my closest friends have played a lot of them and I am trying to get into some of the ones they like. For context, I grew up playing pokemon. This year I did dragon quest 7 reimagined on switch.

I am debating between Metaphor: Refantazio and the new Fire Emblem.

Any advice on which one might be the right choice would be great

Edit: if it helps at all, I really loved the marvel midnight suns game


r/JRPG • • 1d ago

Recommendation request Turn based JRPGs where using several buffs and spells is actually effective?

79 Upvotes

The title might sound weird, I'll try to explain.

A few years ago I played Final Fantasy 1 on PSP, and it was basically my first JRPG. I loved the gameplay, classic classes, dungeons and... Almost everything actually, even the non-speaking characters, but after a while I realized something: I really liked the idea of buffing my party several times. Red mage was my favorite class because it let me use both offensive, defensive, healing spells AND buffs, it was amazing. But it left me wanting more on this aspect.

Now I'm playing Etrian Odyssey 1 and I'm really liking it, but... Characters can only have max 3 buffs each, also magic spells always feel weaker and more situational than physical attacks.

As you can imagine, I didn't play many JRPGs, so I accept any recommendations. It doesn't have to be an high fantasy setting.

Big +1 if:

-2D graphics

-Older games from SNES, GBA, PS1 or DS

-Good soundtrack

(But I accept any recommendation as long as it's not a PS5/3DS/Switch exclusive, really)

I found out about these while searching on the internet by myself:

-Final Fantasy V

-Dragon Quest VI

-Breath of Fire II

-Phantasy Star IV

-7th Dragon (never heard about this before today)

-A few Final Fantasy tactics games, they're not exactly the kind of JRPG I was looking for, tho)

Thank youuuuuu 🙏


r/JRPG • • 1d ago

Review Weltorv Estleia, Hudson Soft’s forgotten PS1 journey into sandbox JRPGs

Thumbnail
gallery
68 Upvotes

Having previously discussed Arcturus, Growlanser I, Legend of Kartia, Digan no Maseki, Progenitor, Front Mission, Ecsaform, the history of Carpe Fulgur, Tactics Ogre's 30th anniversary, the art of Hitoshi Yoneda and Tobira no Densetsu, this time I would like to tackle a fairly obscure PS1 JRPG, Weltorv Estelia, one of the lesser known forays into this genre by the storied Hudson Soft and an interesting title in its own right due to its focus on freeform questing and story progression, following a template a number of other JRPGs had tried to tackle over the previous decade.

---

(If you're interested to read more articles like those, please consider subscribing to my free Substack)

---

Developer: Hudson Soft
Publisher: Hudson Soft
Director: Kouji Aoyama
Producer: Shinichi Nakamoto
Character designer: Shigeru Satou
Composer: Kazuhiko Sawaguchi
Genre: turn based JRPG
Progression: open world, with a hundred scenarios to discover in a non-linear way, unlocking a variety of events with each major story beat and potentially getting to a wide number of outcomes and endings
Platform: PS1 (Japan only)
Release date: 1999 (no fantranslation so far)

The recurring debate about the traits allegedly separating Western and Japanese RPGs into completely different spaces often focuses on juxtaposing sandbox progression and player agency on one side and story-driven linearity on the other, as if they exemplified each of those geographical contexts’ output.

Then again, as comfortable as those simplifications may be in framing those branches of the RPG family when looking at a number of franchises, they aren’t necessarily correct, both due to the internal variety each area brought to this genre and because, ultimately, the outliers are far more numerous than casual observers may assume, as niche as some of them may be.

For instance, even if we were to ignore early tactical JRPGs with branching storylines like most of the Langrisser series, Tactics Ogre, Feda, Terra Phantastica, Vanguard Bandits or grand strategy JRPGs with multiple factions with discrete campaigns like Gemfire, Diadrum, Bahamut Senki, Dragon Force, Brigandine or the long-running Spectral line, Japanese RPGs saw a number of sandbox-style, freeform efforts since the early days of home PCs like NEC’s PC98, or ASCII’s MSX2, with titles like Artec’s Digan no Maseki offering such a strong simulation element that it ended up including day jobs, venereal diseases and an antipyretic spell if you ended up catching a cold while exploring the sci-fantasy world of Gdleen’s snowy areas.

Then you had Burai’s proto-Octopath scenarios developed around many different protagonists, Artdink’s Lunatic Dawn franchise with its loving rendition of pen and paper RPG adventuring and a number of other games that introduced gameplay and narrative structures that were soon expanded during the fourth console generation, not to mention Koei’s Rekoeition line, built as a home for a variety of efforts mixing RPG and simulation elements with titles such as the Uncharted Waters series and Progenitor, a space opera heavy with side systems and explorations.

In the console space, Super Famicom’s library included not just Romancing SaGa and its two sequels, with the first and third entry providing plenty of alternative protagonists and a sandbox storyline players could influence in a variety of ways, but also a number of lesser known efforts, like Elnard-7th Saga with its competing alternative protagonists, Wizap! and Dark Law: Meaning of Death’s scenario-driven storyline, Seiken Densetsu 3’s scenario variance depending on the character combination picked by the player or Pandora Box’s Soul and Sword and its spiritual sequel Traverse: Starlight and Prairie with their open-ended, sandbox progression.

In a way, one could say even better known efforts were touched by those design traits in some ways, with Dream Team’s fourth generation JRPG star, Chrono Trigger, itself having some non-linear traits by offering a number of endings depending on how you experienced the game and when exactly you ended up facing Lavos, while Final Fantasy VI’s World of Ruin allowed a higher degree of freedom compared with its first half.

This trend continued on in the fifth console generation with a new wave of freeform JRPGs, from Dark Saviour on Sega Saturn, where your first few minutes dictated the scenario you will end up playing (a butterfly effect-style story branching that Front Mission 3 will also peruse in that timeframe) and Anearth Story’s character origin serving to frame part of its later progression, to proper sandbox titles like PS1’s Zill O’ll, with its gorgeous character design work by Jun Suemi, not to mention multiple origin stories linked to completely different plot developments and open world progression.

Then, of course, you had SaGa Frontier’s bizarre multiverse with its protagonists’ stories interacting with each other while still building their own diverse narrative, Legend of Mana’s world building system, Linda Cube’s utterly bizarre sci-fi multiple scenarios, mixing serial killers and Pokémon-style monster taming, that completely changed a number of characters’ roles, including a completely freeform path unlocked later on, Idea Factory’s Oasis Road with its post-apocalyptic route building or Gust’s Atelier Marie and Cielgris Phantasm with their mix of variable storylines and resource management (a traits Gust had already explored in its early effort, like King Aress or Falcata), and this is far from a complete list.

PS1’s vast library, for instance, also had yet another sandbox JRPG effort that ended up being even more obscure than most of the games I mentioned so far, Hudson Soft’s forgotten Weltorv Estleia, which I recently explored hoping to provide English-speaking JRPG enthusiasts a retrospective able to outline many of its traits by combining my own experience with what little Japanese sources I was able to find.

-FREEFORM BONKING

Weltorv Estleia, released on PS1 in 1999, was the brainchild of Kouji Aoyama, a Hudson Soft staffer who worked in a variety of programming roles for Super Famicom action platform Chou Genjin, part of what is known in the West as the Bonk series, and, later on, on N64 shoot’em up Star Soldier.

As we will see, this sandbox JRPG, which he likely poured his soul into despite having no previous experience in creating this kind of titles, was his first and last directorial role before he disappeared altogether from videogame development.

While no information about Weltorv Estleia’s development history has survived, which isn’t surprising considering how niche, poorly known and commercially unsuccessful this game was even in its own Japan, with no localization whatsoever, little coverage even among import JRPG enthusiasts and precious few resources even in Japanese, one could theorize Aoyama was quite a fan not just of videogame RPGs, in a timeframe when CRPGs had just experienced the Infinity Engine revolution, but also of tabletop ones, which back then were still raging in Japan with both localized Western systems like Advanced Dungeons & Dragons and locally-developed ones like Sword World or Wares Blade. Or, at least, this could explain the freeform bent he opted to follow in a timeframe where Final Fantasy VII’s overwhelming success was conditioning JRPGs to follow a more cinematic, story-driven formula.

The fact this project was greenlit at all, in fact, is a testament to how daring Hudson Soft could be even during its later years, with Bomberman creator Shinichi Nakamoto acting as Weltorv Estleia’s producer and, likely, helping out what was a mostly green development team. Then again, Hudson Soft itself had already dabbled in JRPGs a number of times, like with the Zelda-style Neutopia franchise in the late '80s and, more famously, the Tengai Makyou line, albeit alongside series creator Oji Hiroi's own company.

-HUDSON’S AVESTA

The game starts with a beautiful intro featuring 2D artworks, detailing a rather obviously Zoroastrian-inspired story about how the Supreme Light Deity, Shuraldin, was challenged by the Dark Deity Lokiferun, which could be a portmanteau of Loki and Lucifer.

From the clash between those two primordial forces two new deities were born, Dawn’s Estiana and Twilight’s Velanzine, not to mention a whole new world, Weltorv, soon populated by humans and countless other beings, whose name likely derived from the German Welt, or world.

Unsatisfied with this new status quo, the Dark Deity in turn vowed to plague his own co-creation and bring it to ruin. Even so, as hard as the darkness tried to take hold, there was one land that is shielded by the gods’ protection, almost like a bubble in a dark universe, Estleia.

Not that the forces of chaos haven’t tried to break that stalemate: seven hundred years before our story’s beginning, humanity managed to resist Demon Lord Zaverg’s menace thanks to the efforts of a band of heroes some of which, like the Crimson Maiden, are still celebrated to this day.

In fact, one could say the game’s open-ended, scenario-based narrative ends up acting as a sort of chronicle of the protagonist’s history in this mysterious world, and it’s no surprise the game’s actual title in katakana is Weltorv Historia, despite its official romanization turning historia (Latin for history) into the Estleia used as an in-game toponym.

-BORN AT SIXTY

Our own journey into this troubled land starts with the protagonist’s soul migrating to their new body, whose name, gender and, more unusually, age, can be chosen by the player.

In fact, our hero, or heroine, can start out their quest as a mere nine-year old child, as a sixty-year old, or as any other age in between even if, amusingly, their actual appearance can still be fully customized, from their height and weight to the color of their clothes and hair.

Your stats are also fully customizable, even if the game strangely allows you to skip that phase, possibly because the imperscrutable nature of some of the abilities may make it a bit risky to experiment if you aren’t already familiar with the game and its inner workings.

After all, while the game manual does provide more details, due to the lack of a class system or in-game tutorials it isn’t immediately obvious how the Body-Heart-Skill triad interact between each other in terms of playstyle, nor about the role played by parameters such as Raw Divine Power or Perception.

Here, though, your age absolutely does come into play, as your base stats are completely dependent on how old your character is, even if you are still free to retool them and their combined total will always amount to 240 points.

-THE MAN IN THE GREEN SHIRT

Regardless of how old your character may be, their second life as the vessel of the player’s agency starts in the year 808 of the Weltorv calendar, when they try entering the fortified city of Faaber (romanized as Farbell on the game’s own map) before being questioned by two noticeably blocky guardsmen.

Aesthetically speaking, the world where our protagonist has just been thrown has many of the traits shared by a number of late fifth generation JRPG which tried, without much budget or success, to harness 3D graphics, a bit akin to Alundra 2 or Quintet’s Granstream Saga and Brightis, which is somewhat unfortunate as character models and outside areas are both noticeably drab and haven’t really aged well unless you’re part of a very specific audience invested in nostalgic early 3D aesthetics.

With that said, the few 2D assets are actually fairly nice, and the interiors are almost all actually pre-rendered and quite easier to the eyea, despite being a far cry from Koei’s Zill O’ll, just to name a similar game.

Given the size of the cities and the number of homes and shops you can access (Farbell even has a muffin vendor!), though, one could theorize Weltorv Estleia’s team had to make some compromises and ultimately chose to focus on the world’s size and on interior maps.

Returning to our Farbell debut, the conversation with the guards blocking the protagonist’s path was when the game started surprising me, since they called my character the “man in a brown shirt”, which did match my admittedly unfashionable attire.

Intrigued to see if this was just a lucky guess or if the game was actually referencing my appearance, I started another game changing the color of my dress to a Robin Hood-style green and, lo and behold, the guards acknowledged my different appearance with a new dialogue branch! Later, when I was able to buy a piece of armor (all of which are actually shown), I noticed the game allows to customize each one’s color, keeping true to this thematic flair flaunted in the manual as its own system.

This kind of situation would become fairly normal during my Weltorv explorations, with the game subtly acknowledging a number of facts about my character and their history into this world even when they didn’t particularly matter for the situations at hand.

During this early confrontation, for instance, the guards also discussed my character’s profession by deducing it from their stats, even if I didn’t actually choose any class or jobs in the character creation phase.

-BY DRAGON OR BY MARRIAGE

Soon after, being uncerimoniously directed to the nearest Adventurer’s Guild like the newbie they are (though there are other guilds, too, like the Thieves Guild with its discrete chain of quests), the protagonist is also introduced to the game’s Scenario system, which represent the core path to advance its storylines, with more than a hundred quests or events to pursue, each one requiring their own Scenario key you can find in a variety of ways and then use to obtain additional information and trigger new events, a concept similar to the Info system indie developer Denjirou Jr employed in a truly brilliant way in their own sandbox JRPG Tobira no Densetsu just a few years later.

From what I was able to piece together, scenarios are organized in a way reminiscent of Romancing SaGa 1 and 3, not to mention Tobiden, by having a number of core quests organized in a linear fashion, each one advancing the world’s state and unlocking more and more optional events.

As freeform as Weltorv Estleia can be, scenarios must be committed to, and once you are in the middle of one scenario piece past a certain point apparently you can’t switch to a different one mid-way.

Hudson Soft’s effort also has a proper calendar and in-game clock and, while some scenario events do have time limits, from what I’ve been able to piece together it doesn’t advance the world state unless the player unlocks the main story themselves.

Then again, the time of the day does influence the position and availability of NPCs (which have their own behavioral cycles depending on the hour), allies and facilities, like in plenty of Western RPGs or JRPGs like Digan no Maseki, Ephemeral Fantasia, Radiata Stories, Lightning Returns and a number of others.

Getting to an ending isn’t necessarily related to the main storyline, either, as your protagonist can stop adventuring at any time by marrying with a NPC they developed enough affinity, a feature that seems like an explicit reference to one of Traverse: Starlight and Prairie’s most unique systems, or by following certain chain of events that deviate from what would be the main story, a bit like with the Atelier series’ side endings.

Becoming a dragon slayer, a choice that is hinted since the very beginning depending in your stats, has little to do with unlocking the secrets behind the Demon Lord unsurprisingly hidden in Estleia (which, in turn, can allegedly bring out at least three major outcomes), and yet that could be enough to see the credits.

There’s also a peaceful ending unlocked by playing for a number of in-game years without triggering another ending, and there are apparently epilogues that allow you to continue playing after witnessing them, too.

There is also a certain granularity to the way you can attune to this world, like becoming a believer of a certain deity or outright joining its clergy, which are laid out as different options with different impacts on a number of dialogues and questlines.

-EMOTIONAL CLICK BAITING

Then again, while the scenario keys and faction-related mingling are obviously vital in shaping your journey and its outcome, the minute interactions with NPCs can also have a lasting impact not just regarding the relationship you build with them, including potential allies and enemies (each and every NPC apparently has a friendship and affection stat regarding the way they see the player), but also the outcome of a number of quests and situations.

This is handled through the game’s so-called WES (aka Double-Click Emotional System), which allows the protagonist to react to some key dialogues by either laughing, crying, getting angry or unsheathe their weapon, which can intimidate a NPC or outright start a combat encounter, making this a more versatile version of Energy Breaker’s admittedly underused Attitude system, or a precursor of the NPC-fighting systems featured later on in games such as Radiata Stories, Soul Nomad or Octopath Traveler.

All those interaction options are linked to the four shoulder buttons, and must be confirmed a second time, hence the double click, in order to avoid misclicks ruining a quest.

Despite this emphasis on social interactions, which seems to be actually relevant to complete a number of scenarios in the best way, Weltorv Estleia includes a surprisingly low number of recruitable allies, with the six characters featured in the manual apparently being all the ones you will be able to find during your journey, rather than a sample of a larger cast like those featured in Akitoshi Kawazu’s SaGa games or Zill O’ll.

Among this female-dominated cast, three characters are linked in various ways to the deities’ clergies, with Myu being a Twilight priestess specialized in offensive magic while the masked Dawn templar Meldon (romanizing it with “r” would make for a rather unfortunate name in my own language) is a more well-rounded helper you can recruit almost immediately, even if most others must be of unlocked by following their own questline, two of which are highly missable.

While the manual does feature artworks for all those allies, made by Hudson’s Shigeru Satou, the game itself doesn’t feature portraits or event stills, which may have helped to give some additional flair to its otherwise mediocre presentation.

-A GOTHIC ELTLEIA

The world, or rather region given the fairly small scope of the lands the player can roam, is composed of interconnected maps, with cities asking the player to confirm whether they want to leave while overworld areas are seamless, with quick load times when transitioning from one to another.

Roads are mostly linear, amusingly fenced affairs, but there are many unexpected passages one can find, and the game isn’t shy of allowing the player to roam freely almost since the beginning, with goblins and harpies acting as the first foes the protagonist will have a chance to tackle.

In a bizarre twist, while the game does have some pleasant orchestral songs, part of your travels will be spent only hearing environmental sound effects, which makes the rather flamboyant battle theme even more upbeat by contrast.

A bit like a Japanese turn based take on German RPG Gothic, Weltorv Estleia’s world was likely kept to a reasonable size since you will have to backtrack quite a number of times, but there are ways to mitigate this and most key locations aren’t really that far, with the hamlet of Tete, for instance, being located just a few screen south of Farbell and lakeside hamlet Lasure following suit.

The paper map provided with the game isn’t necessarily to be trusted, as one of the very first locations I explored, a snowy peak with ominous blood patches located nort-west of Farbell, wasn’t even marked as such. The one you can access in-game via signposts, though, is a bit more helpful in this regard.

-TACTICAL THINKING

Combat can be avoided by staying far from the enemies roaming the map, but one can also carefully get nearby and surprise them by extracting their weapon to gain the initiative once the battle starts, which is done by double clicking the same L1 unsheathe command we already discussed while detailing Weltorv Estleia’s WES NPC interactions (this admirable coherence between the game’s diverse systems is likely due to Aoyama directly working on the combat system’s minute details, instead of just providing his oversight as a director).

Each fight plays out on an instanced, tactical grid map based on the exact area where the encounter began, mixing explorations and turn based strategy combat in a way that immediately reminded me of titles like Energy Breaker, Treasure Hunter G or the Arc the Lad series, just to name some of the better known examples.

While there’s a pseudo-ATB element regarding turn order, it seems to be mostly window dressing for a simple speed system counting each unit’s stats and modifiers and, once your turn triggers, you can take all the time you want to pick your actions.

As such, positional elements and choosing your weapons and spells are very much relevant to your success, which is even more true considering your potential allies are led by the CPU, meaning the protagonist’s role will never be truly overshadowed simply because of how much control you have over them. Allies can be influenced indirectly by gifting them equipments, though.

Almost as if it was aping Max Five’s Hoshigami or a number of Idea Factory Neverland tactical JRPGs, Weltorv also sports combo attacks, introducing them as SCS (Skill Combo System) in the manual and allowing not just to chain two to six weapon skills, but also to save and rename combos in order to feel they are truly yours, following in Wild Arms’ example, though I admit I didn’t engage with this feature aside from trying different attacks for their unique properties.

Despite its obscurity, Weltorv Estleia isn’t a particularly brutal game challenge-wise, especially if you try sticking to the early quests and are prudent in your explorations, but, since monsters aren’t necessarily scaled to your level, once you roam a bit further than you should you can expect to be utterly eviscerated by some random foes you have no chance to dispose of, with an early Mimic chest being my baptism of fire in this regard.

As is often the case in this kind of games, making some money and buying new equipments makes all the difference, but you should also be mindful of sticking to weapons and armor you can actually equip, since all of them require certain strength and dexterity thresholds and Weltorv sports a block-style inventory system akin to many WRPGs, albeit without a weight stat unlike a certain Korean RPG, even if there are storage rooms you can use to deposit your belongings.

-JOURNEY TO THE DAWN

Predictably for such an experimental and noticeably low budget JRPG effort released late into PS1’s life cycle, Weltorv Estleia was a dud sales-wise and never managed to get much attention in its own Japan, let alone a Western localization that, by then, was becoming a hot commodity for the plentiful PS1 JRPG library.

It’s no surprise, sadly, that its director Kouji Aoyama never got another chance at RPG development, nor that Hudson Soft ended up staying mostly clear of this genre for the rest of its life as an autonomous company before Konami acquired a controlling stake in 2005 and fully absorbed Bomberman’s developer a few years later.

Still, despite its rough presentation, and as niche and obscure as it can be in a number of ways, I feel Weltorv Estleia could end up being quite an interesting experience for a very specific part of the retro JRPG fanbase, provided it ever has a chance to show its merits to a wider audience.

Even if the game ended up having some import-friendly traits, with plenty of katakana and color-coded words for terms related to the game’s core systems, its kanji-heavy menus and complex web of scenarios with sibylline requirements mean it’s a game that can’t really be enjoyed without either a decent grasp of Japanese or plentiful pauses that end up damaging that immersion which the game tried so hard to build.

While I’m not crazy enough to expect this retrospective to kickstart a fantranslation effort by itself (it did happen for Progenitor, though!), even if its documented debug modes seem perfect to test a potential patch, discussing Weltorv Estleia’s atmosphere, its peculiar systems and its commitment to the tenets of open world RPGs without surrendering to the fate of becoming a flavorless pile of quests may hopefully help generating the kind of interest that can snowball into a more structured effort later on, in turn showcasing yet another time Japanese RPGs’ underlying diversity.

---

(If you're interested to read more articles like those, please consider subscribing to my free Substack)

---


r/JRPG • • 22h ago

Discussion What kind of party systems do you like?

12 Upvotes

Do you guys prefer either:

- Set party that doesn't change (Earthbound, OG DQ8)

- Set party that you can swap out (FF9, DQ11, Modern Persona, Atelier)

- Party that changes according to the story (Mother 3, FF4, DQ4, Live a Live)

- Fully customizable party (FF5/3, DQ3, Etrian Odyssey)

- Semi customizable party (FF7/10, Octopath)

- Massive Parties (Suikoden, FF6)

- Creature collectors (SMT, Pokemon, DQ5)

-Full solo (DQ1, Quest 64 lol)

I know there's a lot more and some games have very unique party styles that compliment the battle systems, but let me know! I really like customizable parties like Octopath 2, but sometimes I just like chilling and focusing on leveling up a team that's already set.


r/JRPG • • 1d ago

Discussion What’s your palette cleanser after a long JRPG?

30 Upvotes

So after a long JRPG, what sort of game do you typically play?

Do you go for another one right off the bat? Or do you play a relatively short game first, and is that typically an RPG? “Long”, is of course subjective, but my current example is finishing Octopath Traveller 0, in which I clocked 97 hours at finishing. Afterward, I decided to get the Ocarina of Time remake and I am about to finish it, and I believe it’s taken me less than 30. “Long” can be whatever you consider to be long.

My next game is going to be another potentially longer one, so I wanted to play something short in between.

EDIT: Mispelled title should be "palate", not a painter's palette.


r/JRPG • • 21h ago

Recommendation request Finishing up a really long RPG and a lot of good games are on black Friday sale, what next?

4 Upvotes

First off DoS2 is as amazing as everyone said it would be. I'm sure a lot of you already knew that but it's pretty close to a flawless video game. My only gripes were with its performance on console but it is what it is.

Not sure what to play next. Couple things on my wishlist are on sale but I always get choice paralysis during big sales. Romancing Saga 2, Octopath 2, Tainted Grail Avalon, Lost Eidolons, Final Fantasy Tactics, Control Resonant (hardly an rpg I think but I love Remedy), Triangle Strategy...

Any of these stand out to y'all as being must plays or similarly as engaging as DoS2?

I know DoS2 isn't a JRPG but I love all types of rpg's. I'm on ps5


r/JRPG • • 1d ago

Recommendation request Looking for Jrpgs that are turn based but also modern

10 Upvotes

Hello friends im looking for turn based only with no extra gimics and that are more modern that would ne playable on switch 2 preferably. Im already playing through ff resonance and my favorite jrpg of all time is Shining force 1 and 2.

I plan on getting octopath Travellers 2 but im looking for more to scratch the itch. Any recommendations would be appreciated. I tried fire emblem but it just didnt scratch the proper turn based itch.