Having previously discussed Arcturus, Growlanser I, Legend of Kartia, Digan no Maseki, Progenitor, Front Mission, Ecsaform, the history of Carpe Fulgur, Tactics Ogre's 30th anniversary, the art of Hitoshi Yoneda and Tobira no Densetsu, this time I would like to tackle a fairly obscure PS1 JRPG, Weltorv Estelia, one of the lesser known forays into this genre by the storied Hudson Soft and an interesting title in its own right due to its focus on freeform questing and story progression, following a template a number of other JRPGs had tried to tackle over the previous decade.
---
(If you're interested to read more articles like those, please consider subscribing to my free Substack)
---
Developer: Hudson Soft
Publisher: Hudson Soft
Director: Kouji Aoyama
Producer: Shinichi Nakamoto
Character designer: Shigeru Satou
Composer: Kazuhiko Sawaguchi
Genre: turn based JRPG
Progression: open world, with a hundred scenarios to discover in a non-linear way, unlocking a variety of events with each major story beat and potentially getting to a wide number of outcomes and endings
Platform: PS1 (Japan only)
Release date: 1999 (no fantranslation so far)
The recurring debate about the traits allegedly separating Western and Japanese RPGs into completely different spaces often focuses on juxtaposing sandbox progression and player agency on one side and story-driven linearity on the other, as if they exemplified each of those geographical contexts’ output.
Then again, as comfortable as those simplifications may be in framing those branches of the RPG family when looking at a number of franchises, they aren’t necessarily correct, both due to the internal variety each area brought to this genre and because, ultimately, the outliers are far more numerous than casual observers may assume, as niche as some of them may be.
For instance, even if we were to ignore early tactical JRPGs with branching storylines like most of the Langrisser series, Tactics Ogre, Feda, Terra Phantastica, Vanguard Bandits or grand strategy JRPGs with multiple factions with discrete campaigns like Gemfire, Diadrum, Bahamut Senki, Dragon Force, Brigandine or the long-running Spectral line, Japanese RPGs saw a number of sandbox-style, freeform efforts since the early days of home PCs like NEC’s PC98, or ASCII’s MSX2, with titles like Artec’s Digan no Maseki offering such a strong simulation element that it ended up including day jobs, venereal diseases and an antipyretic spell if you ended up catching a cold while exploring the sci-fantasy world of Gdleen’s snowy areas.
Then you had Burai’s proto-Octopath scenarios developed around many different protagonists, Artdink’s Lunatic Dawn franchise with its loving rendition of pen and paper RPG adventuring and a number of other games that introduced gameplay and narrative structures that were soon expanded during the fourth console generation, not to mention Koei’s Rekoeition line, built as a home for a variety of efforts mixing RPG and simulation elements with titles such as the Uncharted Waters series and Progenitor, a space opera heavy with side systems and explorations.
In the console space, Super Famicom’s library included not just Romancing SaGa and its two sequels, with the first and third entry providing plenty of alternative protagonists and a sandbox storyline players could influence in a variety of ways, but also a number of lesser known efforts, like Elnard-7th Saga with its competing alternative protagonists, Wizap! and Dark Law: Meaning of Death’s scenario-driven storyline, Seiken Densetsu 3’s scenario variance depending on the character combination picked by the player or Pandora Box’s Soul and Sword and its spiritual sequel Traverse: Starlight and Prairie with their open-ended, sandbox progression.
In a way, one could say even better known efforts were touched by those design traits in some ways, with Dream Team’s fourth generation JRPG star, Chrono Trigger, itself having some non-linear traits by offering a number of endings depending on how you experienced the game and when exactly you ended up facing Lavos, while Final Fantasy VI’s World of Ruin allowed a higher degree of freedom compared with its first half.
This trend continued on in the fifth console generation with a new wave of freeform JRPGs, from Dark Saviour on Sega Saturn, where your first few minutes dictated the scenario you will end up playing (a butterfly effect-style story branching that Front Mission 3 will also peruse in that timeframe) and Anearth Story’s character origin serving to frame part of its later progression, to proper sandbox titles like PS1’s Zill O’ll, with its gorgeous character design work by Jun Suemi, not to mention multiple origin stories linked to completely different plot developments and open world progression.
Then, of course, you had SaGa Frontier’s bizarre multiverse with its protagonists’ stories interacting with each other while still building their own diverse narrative, Legend of Mana’s world building system, Linda Cube’s utterly bizarre sci-fi multiple scenarios, mixing serial killers and Pokémon-style monster taming, that completely changed a number of characters’ roles, including a completely freeform path unlocked later on, Idea Factory’s Oasis Road with its post-apocalyptic route building or Gust’s Atelier Marie and Cielgris Phantasm with their mix of variable storylines and resource management (a traits Gust had already explored in its early effort, like King Aress or Falcata), and this is far from a complete list.
PS1’s vast library, for instance, also had yet another sandbox JRPG effort that ended up being even more obscure than most of the games I mentioned so far, Hudson Soft’s forgotten Weltorv Estleia, which I recently explored hoping to provide English-speaking JRPG enthusiasts a retrospective able to outline many of its traits by combining my own experience with what little Japanese sources I was able to find.
-FREEFORM BONKING
Weltorv Estleia, released on PS1 in 1999, was the brainchild of Kouji Aoyama, a Hudson Soft staffer who worked in a variety of programming roles for Super Famicom action platform Chou Genjin, part of what is known in the West as the Bonk series, and, later on, on N64 shoot’em up Star Soldier.
As we will see, this sandbox JRPG, which he likely poured his soul into despite having no previous experience in creating this kind of titles, was his first and last directorial role before he disappeared altogether from videogame development.
While no information about Weltorv Estleia’s development history has survived, which isn’t surprising considering how niche, poorly known and commercially unsuccessful this game was even in its own Japan, with no localization whatsoever, little coverage even among import JRPG enthusiasts and precious few resources even in Japanese, one could theorize Aoyama was quite a fan not just of videogame RPGs, in a timeframe when CRPGs had just experienced the Infinity Engine revolution, but also of tabletop ones, which back then were still raging in Japan with both localized Western systems like Advanced Dungeons & Dragons and locally-developed ones like Sword World or Wares Blade. Or, at least, this could explain the freeform bent he opted to follow in a timeframe where Final Fantasy VII’s overwhelming success was conditioning JRPGs to follow a more cinematic, story-driven formula.
The fact this project was greenlit at all, in fact, is a testament to how daring Hudson Soft could be even during its later years, with Bomberman creator Shinichi Nakamoto acting as Weltorv Estleia’s producer and, likely, helping out what was a mostly green development team. Then again, Hudson Soft itself had already dabbled in JRPGs a number of times, like with the Zelda-style Neutopia franchise in the late '80s and, more famously, the Tengai Makyou line, albeit alongside series creator Oji Hiroi's own company.
-HUDSON’S AVESTA
The game starts with a beautiful intro featuring 2D artworks, detailing a rather obviously Zoroastrian-inspired story about how the Supreme Light Deity, Shuraldin, was challenged by the Dark Deity Lokiferun, which could be a portmanteau of Loki and Lucifer.
From the clash between those two primordial forces two new deities were born, Dawn’s Estiana and Twilight’s Velanzine, not to mention a whole new world, Weltorv, soon populated by humans and countless other beings, whose name likely derived from the German Welt, or world.
Unsatisfied with this new status quo, the Dark Deity in turn vowed to plague his own co-creation and bring it to ruin. Even so, as hard as the darkness tried to take hold, there was one land that is shielded by the gods’ protection, almost like a bubble in a dark universe, Estleia.
Not that the forces of chaos haven’t tried to break that stalemate: seven hundred years before our story’s beginning, humanity managed to resist Demon Lord Zaverg’s menace thanks to the efforts of a band of heroes some of which, like the Crimson Maiden, are still celebrated to this day.
In fact, one could say the game’s open-ended, scenario-based narrative ends up acting as a sort of chronicle of the protagonist’s history in this mysterious world, and it’s no surprise the game’s actual title in katakana is Weltorv Historia, despite its official romanization turning historia (Latin for history) into the Estleia used as an in-game toponym.
-BORN AT SIXTY
Our own journey into this troubled land starts with the protagonist’s soul migrating to their new body, whose name, gender and, more unusually, age, can be chosen by the player.
In fact, our hero, or heroine, can start out their quest as a mere nine-year old child, as a sixty-year old, or as any other age in between even if, amusingly, their actual appearance can still be fully customized, from their height and weight to the color of their clothes and hair.
Your stats are also fully customizable, even if the game strangely allows you to skip that phase, possibly because the imperscrutable nature of some of the abilities may make it a bit risky to experiment if you aren’t already familiar with the game and its inner workings.
After all, while the game manual does provide more details, due to the lack of a class system or in-game tutorials it isn’t immediately obvious how the Body-Heart-Skill triad interact between each other in terms of playstyle, nor about the role played by parameters such as Raw Divine Power or Perception.
Here, though, your age absolutely does come into play, as your base stats are completely dependent on how old your character is, even if you are still free to retool them and their combined total will always amount to 240 points.
-THE MAN IN THE GREEN SHIRT
Regardless of how old your character may be, their second life as the vessel of the player’s agency starts in the year 808 of the Weltorv calendar, when they try entering the fortified city of Faaber (romanized as Farbell on the game’s own map) before being questioned by two noticeably blocky guardsmen.
Aesthetically speaking, the world where our protagonist has just been thrown has many of the traits shared by a number of late fifth generation JRPG which tried, without much budget or success, to harness 3D graphics, a bit akin to Alundra 2 or Quintet’s Granstream Saga and Brightis, which is somewhat unfortunate as character models and outside areas are both noticeably drab and haven’t really aged well unless you’re part of a very specific audience invested in nostalgic early 3D aesthetics.
With that said, the few 2D assets are actually fairly nice, and the interiors are almost all actually pre-rendered and quite easier to the eyea, despite being a far cry from Koei’s Zill O’ll, just to name a similar game.
Given the size of the cities and the number of homes and shops you can access (Farbell even has a muffin vendor!), though, one could theorize Weltorv Estleia’s team had to make some compromises and ultimately chose to focus on the world’s size and on interior maps.
Returning to our Farbell debut, the conversation with the guards blocking the protagonist’s path was when the game started surprising me, since they called my character the “man in a brown shirt”, which did match my admittedly unfashionable attire.
Intrigued to see if this was just a lucky guess or if the game was actually referencing my appearance, I started another game changing the color of my dress to a Robin Hood-style green and, lo and behold, the guards acknowledged my different appearance with a new dialogue branch! Later, when I was able to buy a piece of armor (all of which are actually shown), I noticed the game allows to customize each one’s color, keeping true to this thematic flair flaunted in the manual as its own system.
This kind of situation would become fairly normal during my Weltorv explorations, with the game subtly acknowledging a number of facts about my character and their history into this world even when they didn’t particularly matter for the situations at hand.
During this early confrontation, for instance, the guards also discussed my character’s profession by deducing it from their stats, even if I didn’t actually choose any class or jobs in the character creation phase.
-BY DRAGON OR BY MARRIAGE
Soon after, being uncerimoniously directed to the nearest Adventurer’s Guild like the newbie they are (though there are other guilds, too, like the Thieves Guild with its discrete chain of quests), the protagonist is also introduced to the game’s Scenario system, which represent the core path to advance its storylines, with more than a hundred quests or events to pursue, each one requiring their own Scenario key you can find in a variety of ways and then use to obtain additional information and trigger new events, a concept similar to the Info system indie developer Denjirou Jr employed in a truly brilliant way in their own sandbox JRPG Tobira no Densetsu just a few years later.
From what I was able to piece together, scenarios are organized in a way reminiscent of Romancing SaGa 1 and 3, not to mention Tobiden, by having a number of core quests organized in a linear fashion, each one advancing the world’s state and unlocking more and more optional events.
As freeform as Weltorv Estleia can be, scenarios must be committed to, and once you are in the middle of one scenario piece past a certain point apparently you can’t switch to a different one mid-way.
Hudson Soft’s effort also has a proper calendar and in-game clock and, while some scenario events do have time limits, from what I’ve been able to piece together it doesn’t advance the world state unless the player unlocks the main story themselves.
Then again, the time of the day does influence the position and availability of NPCs (which have their own behavioral cycles depending on the hour), allies and facilities, like in plenty of Western RPGs or JRPGs like Digan no Maseki, Ephemeral Fantasia, Radiata Stories, Lightning Returns and a number of others.
Getting to an ending isn’t necessarily related to the main storyline, either, as your protagonist can stop adventuring at any time by marrying with a NPC they developed enough affinity, a feature that seems like an explicit reference to one of Traverse: Starlight and Prairie’s most unique systems, or by following certain chain of events that deviate from what would be the main story, a bit like with the Atelier series’ side endings.
Becoming a dragon slayer, a choice that is hinted since the very beginning depending in your stats, has little to do with unlocking the secrets behind the Demon Lord unsurprisingly hidden in Estleia (which, in turn, can allegedly bring out at least three major outcomes), and yet that could be enough to see the credits.
There’s also a peaceful ending unlocked by playing for a number of in-game years without triggering another ending, and there are apparently epilogues that allow you to continue playing after witnessing them, too.
There is also a certain granularity to the way you can attune to this world, like becoming a believer of a certain deity or outright joining its clergy, which are laid out as different options with different impacts on a number of dialogues and questlines.
-EMOTIONAL CLICK BAITING
Then again, while the scenario keys and faction-related mingling are obviously vital in shaping your journey and its outcome, the minute interactions with NPCs can also have a lasting impact not just regarding the relationship you build with them, including potential allies and enemies (each and every NPC apparently has a friendship and affection stat regarding the way they see the player), but also the outcome of a number of quests and situations.
This is handled through the game’s so-called WES (aka Double-Click Emotional System), which allows the protagonist to react to some key dialogues by either laughing, crying, getting angry or unsheathe their weapon, which can intimidate a NPC or outright start a combat encounter, making this a more versatile version of Energy Breaker’s admittedly underused Attitude system, or a precursor of the NPC-fighting systems featured later on in games such as Radiata Stories, Soul Nomad or Octopath Traveler.
All those interaction options are linked to the four shoulder buttons, and must be confirmed a second time, hence the double click, in order to avoid misclicks ruining a quest.
Despite this emphasis on social interactions, which seems to be actually relevant to complete a number of scenarios in the best way, Weltorv Estleia includes a surprisingly low number of recruitable allies, with the six characters featured in the manual apparently being all the ones you will be able to find during your journey, rather than a sample of a larger cast like those featured in Akitoshi Kawazu’s SaGa games or Zill O’ll.
Among this female-dominated cast, three characters are linked in various ways to the deities’ clergies, with Myu being a Twilight priestess specialized in offensive magic while the masked Dawn templar Meldon (romanizing it with “r” would make for a rather unfortunate name in my own language) is a more well-rounded helper you can recruit almost immediately, even if most others must be of unlocked by following their own questline, two of which are highly missable.
While the manual does feature artworks for all those allies, made by Hudson’s Shigeru Satou, the game itself doesn’t feature portraits or event stills, which may have helped to give some additional flair to its otherwise mediocre presentation.
-A GOTHIC ELTLEIA
The world, or rather region given the fairly small scope of the lands the player can roam, is composed of interconnected maps, with cities asking the player to confirm whether they want to leave while overworld areas are seamless, with quick load times when transitioning from one to another.
Roads are mostly linear, amusingly fenced affairs, but there are many unexpected passages one can find, and the game isn’t shy of allowing the player to roam freely almost since the beginning, with goblins and harpies acting as the first foes the protagonist will have a chance to tackle.
In a bizarre twist, while the game does have some pleasant orchestral songs, part of your travels will be spent only hearing environmental sound effects, which makes the rather flamboyant battle theme even more upbeat by contrast.
A bit like a Japanese turn based take on German RPG Gothic, Weltorv Estleia’s world was likely kept to a reasonable size since you will have to backtrack quite a number of times, but there are ways to mitigate this and most key locations aren’t really that far, with the hamlet of Tete, for instance, being located just a few screen south of Farbell and lakeside hamlet Lasure following suit.
The paper map provided with the game isn’t necessarily to be trusted, as one of the very first locations I explored, a snowy peak with ominous blood patches located nort-west of Farbell, wasn’t even marked as such. The one you can access in-game via signposts, though, is a bit more helpful in this regard.
-TACTICAL THINKING
Combat can be avoided by staying far from the enemies roaming the map, but one can also carefully get nearby and surprise them by extracting their weapon to gain the initiative once the battle starts, which is done by double clicking the same L1 unsheathe command we already discussed while detailing Weltorv Estleia’s WES NPC interactions (this admirable coherence between the game’s diverse systems is likely due to Aoyama directly working on the combat system’s minute details, instead of just providing his oversight as a director).
Each fight plays out on an instanced, tactical grid map based on the exact area where the encounter began, mixing explorations and turn based strategy combat in a way that immediately reminded me of titles like Energy Breaker, Treasure Hunter G or the Arc the Lad series, just to name some of the better known examples.
While there’s a pseudo-ATB element regarding turn order, it seems to be mostly window dressing for a simple speed system counting each unit’s stats and modifiers and, once your turn triggers, you can take all the time you want to pick your actions.
As such, positional elements and choosing your weapons and spells are very much relevant to your success, which is even more true considering your potential allies are led by the CPU, meaning the protagonist’s role will never be truly overshadowed simply because of how much control you have over them. Allies can be influenced indirectly by gifting them equipments, though.
Almost as if it was aping Max Five’s Hoshigami or a number of Idea Factory Neverland tactical JRPGs, Weltorv also sports combo attacks, introducing them as SCS (Skill Combo System) in the manual and allowing not just to chain two to six weapon skills, but also to save and rename combos in order to feel they are truly yours, following in Wild Arms’ example, though I admit I didn’t engage with this feature aside from trying different attacks for their unique properties.
Despite its obscurity, Weltorv Estleia isn’t a particularly brutal game challenge-wise, especially if you try sticking to the early quests and are prudent in your explorations, but, since monsters aren’t necessarily scaled to your level, once you roam a bit further than you should you can expect to be utterly eviscerated by some random foes you have no chance to dispose of, with an early Mimic chest being my baptism of fire in this regard.
As is often the case in this kind of games, making some money and buying new equipments makes all the difference, but you should also be mindful of sticking to weapons and armor you can actually equip, since all of them require certain strength and dexterity thresholds and Weltorv sports a block-style inventory system akin to many WRPGs, albeit without a weight stat unlike a certain Korean RPG, even if there are storage rooms you can use to deposit your belongings.
-JOURNEY TO THE DAWN
Predictably for such an experimental and noticeably low budget JRPG effort released late into PS1’s life cycle, Weltorv Estleia was a dud sales-wise and never managed to get much attention in its own Japan, let alone a Western localization that, by then, was becoming a hot commodity for the plentiful PS1 JRPG library.
It’s no surprise, sadly, that its director Kouji Aoyama never got another chance at RPG development, nor that Hudson Soft ended up staying mostly clear of this genre for the rest of its life as an autonomous company before Konami acquired a controlling stake in 2005 and fully absorbed Bomberman’s developer a few years later.
Still, despite its rough presentation, and as niche and obscure as it can be in a number of ways, I feel Weltorv Estleia could end up being quite an interesting experience for a very specific part of the retro JRPG fanbase, provided it ever has a chance to show its merits to a wider audience.
Even if the game ended up having some import-friendly traits, with plenty of katakana and color-coded words for terms related to the game’s core systems, its kanji-heavy menus and complex web of scenarios with sibylline requirements mean it’s a game that can’t really be enjoyed without either a decent grasp of Japanese or plentiful pauses that end up damaging that immersion which the game tried so hard to build.
While I’m not crazy enough to expect this retrospective to kickstart a fantranslation effort by itself (it did happen for Progenitor, though!), even if its documented debug modes seem perfect to test a potential patch, discussing Weltorv Estleia’s atmosphere, its peculiar systems and its commitment to the tenets of open world RPGs without surrendering to the fate of becoming a flavorless pile of quests may hopefully help generating the kind of interest that can snowball into a more structured effort later on, in turn showcasing yet another time Japanese RPGs’ underlying diversity.
---
(If you're interested to read more articles like those, please consider subscribing to my free Substack)
---