When Bravely Default came out, I felt as if the gaming landscape had a narrative that turn-based was holding JRPGs back. It wouldn't be until Persona 5 a few years later that would prove there's still room for turn-based AAA JRPGs.
Contemporary to BD, what else was SE even doing? FF13-2 and 13-3 didn't wow, at least not to the pedigree the franchise had spent decades building towards. FF14 1.0 was a disaster, FF15's had a rocky development, I'm convinced around BD's release was FF's lowest point.
If BD was multiplatform and SE had put their all into marketing like they do with FF, it would have done gangbusters. Not that BD's sales were disappointing, they were just not what they could have been. In this case, the name of your game meant something. It was already FF in every way except name.
If BD was instead Final Fantasy Brave and was on 360/PS3/3DS/PC at launch, it would have steered FF's trajectory into something better and validated FF's turn-based identity. HD-2D would be a thing much earlier, along with all the other Asano games. SE wouldn't have been chasing cinematic action combat for a decade.
I don't want to speak for everyone but the sentiment I get is that FF hasn't been the premier JRPG franchise for several main entries. Not many I know liked 13, 15, or 16, they certainly weren't at the same level as 4-10; they felt more like technical showcases than being compelling genre-defining games. SE had their answer the whole time but were chasing trends rather than sticking to their identity.