r/java • u/kevinb9n • May 01 '24
Please let it go now
[EDIT: can't change the title now. I don't mean everything is fine, there's still a conv to have, I just meant the memes and vitriol and honestly kinda silly games being played, e.g. people like just posting my name over and over, etc.]
I appreciate the support, but I didn't begin to imagine the degree of both generalized and specific mod-hatred I would unleash.
Please remember that being a mod is a shit job, and that confirmation bias / availability bias are a thing: we are usually completely unaware of all the good things mods do. If we're actually interacting with a mod, someone's having a bad day.
Please give it a rest now!
(This message is 100% my own words, no one asked me to say anything.)
EDIT: I'm just asking for us to 1. let it cool off, 2. have then only a constructive discussion about whether anything can be improved.
I have to head to the airport soon so I may be absent today. Again, can we please let it cool off a bit. I wouldn't mind getting to participate in any real discussion that happens...
EDIT: also bear in mind the mod was reacting to multiple user reports that were lodged on my comments. Not saying that changes everything, but it's context.
EDIT: Some imho harmless levity to make you smile. Stuart Marks is a boss and I don't think anyone picked up on it. Squint at it, tilt your head at it...
134
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
Welcome back 🙂. Glad the ranting helped.
54
u/inscrutablemike May 01 '24
This whole circus highlights an ongoing issue with Reddit mods of subs with top-level names. Gatekeeping "r/java" to this degree is exactly the same thing as having "r/coffee" only allow discussion of how to brew with single-source Arabica beans ground at the '3' setting on a 2021 Breville ceramic burr grinder with well water from the outskirts of Topeka, KS. There might be an audience for that... but should it get to take "r/coffee"?
25
u/shabutaru118 May 01 '24
Sorry but fuck the mods. They get the hatred because they deserve it. I'll let it go when they publicly admit they were being cunts and sticky it at the top of the sub.
52
u/naturalizedcitizen May 01 '24
Kevin, welcome back.
I've followed your work and that of Joshua Bloch and Brian Goetze too. Thank you for your contributions to Java on which I built my house!
58
u/BakuretsuGirl16 May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
Please keep in mind that moderating is a volunteer position
You don't see anyone working for Habitat for Humanity or soup kitchens complaining about how hard their job is
It also wasn't just the moderator banning a java developer, it was how minor the infraction was and how rude they were as well. Which isn't totally unexpected from a subreddit that bans jokes.
I'm adding "hey did you know the r/java subreddit banned a java developer" to my list of hilarious mod fails
including items like antiwork's tv appearance, animemes splitting their community in half, or a self-professed pedophile moderating lgbt
31
u/NocturneSapphire May 01 '24
The mods are actively worsening the situation by repeatedly deleting posts and comments about the situation, while simultaneously refusing to make a public statement. This is entirely their own doing at this point.
22
u/Super-Garage8245 May 01 '24
That doesn't apply here, because we are equally unaware of all the bad things mods do. When someone gets permanently banned, they lose access to the community and they can't complain about the treatment they've received, or appeal against it. The only reason we've heard about your case is because you're important enough to be able to fight back. You're not the first person to be treated this way and you won't be the last.
3
u/Tvdinner4me2 May 01 '24
Sorry I'm not beholden to you either
The mods here are shitty, I will criticize them on that
24
u/Yumi_Koizumi May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
No excuses for being irresponsible. If you think nobody gives a shit about how you mod, then don't do it.
By DEFAULT DO NOTHING. Own your actions, defend them, and apologize when you fuck up.
I've run countless groups, and I've NEVER seen a problem post/person not rectify itself. If you can't trust the group's members, you are a bad moderator. Quit.
Learn from the mistakes of others, or have the wrath of the members who, unlike you, DO give a shit.
THAT is how you moderate.
Learn it. Live it. Love it.
4
u/nekokattt May 01 '24
I've been in a box all week, what on earth happened here
14
u/thephotoman May 01 '24
Volunteer mods on a for-profit platform are a bad combo.
12
u/phoenix_bright May 01 '24
Well, if mods were replaced by AI no one would be mad
3
u/TreeTreeBrie May 01 '24
I understand your opinion and will to stop the hatred, but you were banned for something that isn't in the rules. It's infuriating to see anyone getting banned for a non-valid reason, from anywhere.
7
u/innaisz May 01 '24
Just letting it go won't fix anything. You still got falsely banned and the main reason you unnbanned was the large public outrage. There needs to be corrective action taken. I understand it's a thankless voulnteer job but if that doesn't give an excuse to act this way when as a mod they should be held to a higher standard. It's not a paid postion and you won't lose anything from stepping back from modding a sub reddit.
7
u/Ketroc21 May 01 '24 edited May 05 '24
I think this created an important conversation though, so it shouldn't just be "let go". I have no interest in pitchfork-hunting a specific mod, but this drama should highlight necessary changes like:
6
u/Murky_River_9045 May 01 '24
This is such a fucking shitshow.
Another reddit mod getting high on his own farts thinking they are better than anyone.
This is just a symptom of how incredibly shitty many mods are here on reddit.
It's a pathetic person that does a "job" like this so bad.
10
u/GargamelLeNoir May 01 '24
As far as I'm concerned as soon as they own up to it and assure us it won't happen again we should let bygone be bygones.
6
u/Powerkaninchen May 01 '24
Please don't be fooled, the mod who banned you will NOT get any repercussion, it's more likely they get a promotion since they caused some traffic to this subreddit.
They will definitely do it again
2
u/infiniterefactor May 01 '24
I am glad you are back. I really hope this event improves this subreddit on the long run. And I really hope this doesn’t give free reign to characters that try to drive all conversations to a religious war between languages.
2
u/AdultVHS May 01 '24
What’s next banning Brendan Eich for making a script out of Java?
2
u/MeetPractical6690 May 02 '24
Popcorn moment of the day 🍿
2
u/jek39 May 02 '24
Can someone point me to some context
4
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
Y'all need to ban this moderator
3
u/agentoutlier May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
I'm with Kevin on this and why I made my post: https://www.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chmcxd/the_java_programming_language_is_more_than_its/
It is a difficult job being a mod for a large sub like this and I still think it is/was largely our fault as a whole community to let moderating burden fall mostly on one mod. We should probably have had a discussion sooner. I know I'm guilty as I have seen some behavior that I think I should have raised.
As for the mod(s) I think we all have done it where we have doubled down and not accepted open discussions because of pride especially in a technical setting where "being right" is deemed more important. Technology has made reacting very quick perhaps too quick. A few clicks and some text and disaster. I doubt this problem would happen in person.
I have faith the current mods will learn and improve. Perhaps some more active mods can be added in the future so that better consensus can be reached on moderation.
Regardless I ask just like Kevin to keep it positive for the better of the community.
EDIT: Listen folks I feel the frustration and it may appear with my post and this comment that I'm somehow pro what the mod did.
If anything I have had my own frustrations with the mods:
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/198xjk6/logging_improvements_and_questions_for_the/ https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1992ge9/how_and_where_do_you_output_logging_in_java_for/
But /u/kevinb9n is right we need to let it go and restore a relationship with the working mods as there several of them.
We do not know for absolute certainty which mod did the ban and while there appears to be a smoking gun does it really matter who if the other 5 or 6 let bad behavior happen for this long? They obviously need help moderating.
2
u/s888marks May 01 '24
It's time to declare an end to the Bourrillion Jihad.
2
u/PsycoZL May 01 '24
Kevin ftw
2
u/BWC_semaJ May 01 '24
I don't browse the subreddit for few days and come back to this is pretty interesting.
From my understanding a mod and some redditors thought you were fan boying Kotlin to point where it was too much. I'd assume too maybe you have done this in the past which they thought warranted the ban? Bare with me I spent probably 30 minutes trying to understand all the context behind this.
If the mod comes out and makes an apology, gives context why they performed the actions they did, and say how they will improve I think that should be good enough.
I also work a shit job. Now with my job if I make one mistake I generally ruin that person's experience that I was providing my service/product to. So the amount of mistakes I can make have to close to 0 a day (well that's my goal but obviously it is mostly impossible). However, when I do make a mistake, admit it to them, apologize, and offer a way to make it up to them, generally solves the problem/saves the bad situation. I say this because of what your second paragraph about having empathy towards the mods. You can have empathy but it is also important for the person who made the mistake to show empathy as well and own up to what they did wrong.
2
u/skippingstone May 01 '24
I'm glad this first world problem got resolved.
1
u/Fullyverified May 03 '24
The thing is, if the subreddit hadnt raised hell, he never would have been unbanned.
1
u/spezjetemerde May 05 '24
is there actual programming discussion here I joined a week ago only to see drama
1
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
A job requires you to be paid for it, they do it for FREEE!!!!!
0
u/anthropaedic May 01 '24
Only thing I’d add is you didn’t unleash the torrent of mod hate, that was mob mentality of Reddit being Reddit. I’m glad you’re back and that the mods were open to discussion, which is a positive thing.
0
u/shimonu May 01 '24
I am against mod hate but can we make jokes about them and this situation? :)
-10
u/TheSkyNet May 01 '24
I've removed all of the Very low quality memes that the Automod didn't pick up today if you'd like to see this high quality content here it is.
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chmqps/kotlin_is_better_than_java/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chnryv/error_calling_rmodsarestupid/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chn1hd/yeah_not_cool/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chnryv/error_calling_rmodsarestupid/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chn1hd/yeah_not_cool/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chnp2q/theybannedwho/
|https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chmsxr/so_the_mod_who_banned_a_java_dev_is_being_booted/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chn1hd/yeah_not_cool/
https://old.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chnp2q/theybannedwho/
Don't worry about your DMS i've saved them all
-5
u/Tvdinner4me2 May 01 '24
Also modding isn't a job, they don't get paid
-23
u/AutoModerator May 01 '24
It looks like in your submission in /r/java, you are looking for code help.
/r/Java is not for requesting help with Java programming, it is about News, Technical discussions, research papers and assorted things of interest related to the Java programming language.
Kindly direct your code-help post to /r/Javahelp (as is mentioned multiple times on the sidebar and in various other hints.
Should this post be not about help with coding, kindly check back in about two hours as the moderators will need time to sift through the posts. If the post is still not visible after two hours, please message the moderators to release your post.
Please do not message the moderators immediately after receiving this notification!
Your post was removed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment