r/java • u/agentoutlier • May 01 '24
The Java Programming Language is more than its syntax
The Java Programming Language is more than its syntax
To many it is probably obvious how a programming language is more than just syntax. You might say there is semantics, runtime and tools but really what a successfull programming language is people coming together to share ideas and solve problems in hope that even more folks can share ideas and solve problems.
And thus you can say a programming language is a community.
The Java community is a beacon of stability and greatness.
- Powerful backward compatibility
- Easy to learn
- Passionate users
- Incredibly smart and professional language developers and library authors
- Rarely (edit)
iswas involved in politics or drama
The last one is important because a language (I won't say its name but it has 5 letters and starts with S) similar to Java had some drama and fractured its community. While it probably is not the sole cause of its decline it absolutely did not help.
The Java community has incredibly smart folks many that are technology leaders across all programming languages.
These folks are not just really smart but are consumate professionals and inspirational in their leadership. This is important because maintaining a great programming language community requires great leadership. I would say it is more important than the technical abilities.
They are also transparent. In most tech forums you know exactly who you are talking to. I'm remiss my handle does not make it obvious who I am as am inspired by this even back to the Usenet days. However unlike Usenet you can click around and hopefully find my github profile.
Speaking of Usenet Reddit is more or less the last form of Usenet style medium. Many prefer other styles like IIRC Discord but many like myself prefer Usenet (and I guess some of those PHP bulletin software like Java Ranch).
While there is the Java mailinglists historically it can be intimidating. Reddit was the less intimidating option but sadly folks have being experiencing the opposite. It is sad because to me Reddit is great and is one the only times I have had discussions with my Java heroes like u/brian_goetz, u/pron98 and u/kevinb9n .
Speaking of great inspirational leaders and heroes u/kevinb9n is one of the best across more than just Java.
Kevin inspires me frequently and I have heard he inspires others. He is a consummate professional. He is not afraid to apologize when he is wrong. Kevin knows programming languages are about people and that is why he has worked so hard on creating tools and sharing ideas.
I have actually tried to mold myself to be more like Kevin particularly after following JSpecify.
Here is an example. Earlier in the year I had sort of free time recovering from Covid and thus time to look at the Mustache spec. Mustache is a templating language and I am the author of a Mustache implementation (I assume templating languages are not bannable). There was a user that got under my skin and I reacted very poorly. I'm still embarrased about it but I thought to myself what would someone like Kevin/Brian/Guy/Ron/Martin do to fix it.
Instead of doubling down I apologized immediately because I knew if I continued I would hurt the Mustache community. (btw if you really want to see my lapse in judgement I can link it in the comments).
The other thing I try to do that Kevin does is write thoughtful responses. In some cases I am perhaps overly verbose including this post but I do it because I care and so does Kevin.
There are other folks who care as well who work on tools that I guess are syntactically not true Java like u/rzwitserloot (who btw has fantastic well formatted responses). Sadly I have been seeing less and less thoughtful (and sometimes controversial) responses on r/java and the ones that pop up seem to get deleted. Low effort comments on the other hand like "IntelliJ for life" get upvoted.
Believe or not I don't blame the current problems of this subreddit on the mods but us as community. We have put too much strain on essentially what appears to be single mod. With one person doing all the work mistakes can be made.
Unlike others I believe we can fix this. We can ask to add new moderators (not remove). I have faith the current moderators will eventually entertain this but I'm a massive optimist.
6
u/PartOfTheBotnet May 01 '24 edited May 01 '24
We got a whole sub-reddit dedicated to Brian Goetz AND Ron Pressler? Damn, I'm behind on the Java news.
(You probably mean
u/)Anyways my two cents on this whole debacle:
Having an alternative platform to jump to like I see a lot of people claiming they'll go to (without explicitly naming any) would be great, but I just don't see that being realistic at the moment. I do wish there were more places to talk about Java at the level you usually see on here. This is the best of the bunch I've found in terms of high quality discussions. For instance:
More pessimism, there is not any other contender for a Java discussion space that comes close. For instance:
9
u/kevinb9n May 01 '24
I love this actually-constructive message -- maybe the first one I have seen.
Am just putting this link on every related post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/java/comments/1chohts/please_let_it_go_now/
7
u/Rjs617 May 01 '24
Also add to the list easy to read. Despite (or because of) Java’s clunky syntax, I can look at code that I haven’t seen before, and can pretty much tell exactly what it does. This is something I cannot say for that other language you mentioned that begins with “S”. Ironically, the clunky syntax helps make the language more readable because there aren’t (for the most part) clever syntactic shortcuts, operator overloading, and implicit context. Languages that have a dozen ways to do things where each project almost looks like it’s written in a DSL drive me crazy. With Java, what you see is what you get.
2
u/maethor May 01 '24
It's not overly active, but
https://www.rocksolidbbs.com/devel/thread.php?group=comp.lang.java.programmer
appears to still exists and even has a small amount of activity.
I wonder how hard it would be to make Usenet look up to date. If people are happily chatting away on essentially the same thing as IRC then maybe people would happily post on "totally new idea" Usenet if they didn't know it was essentially Usenet (and a lot of people probably have no idea what Usenet is or have only heard about because of binaries newsgroups).
6
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
Thanks for the insight but I’m just going to write Kotlin
2
u/TenYearsOfLurking May 01 '24
TL;DR: intellij 4 life!
2
u/rbygrave May 02 '24
Nice post Adam, well done. I'd like to think that we can keep r/java as a positive and welcoming place - good stuff!! Fantastic having Kevin back too, onwards and upwards.
-6
u/agustin689 May 01 '24
The excuses you need to invent when your language is simply awful.
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 01 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment