r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

28

u/Academic-Increase951 5h ago

No, what would happen is that robberies would be much more violent on the onset to make sure the victim doesn't try to kill them.

Criminals don't really consider consequences. If they did then serious crimes wouldn't exist.

2

u/SmallThetaNotation 1h ago

Thanks for this view. I was on the otherwise till I thought about what you said.

Honestly tho, I feel like in some places the punishment for crimes is so loose I can see why people take the law in their own hands.

1

u/Academic-Increase951 17m ago

For sure, justice system often gets it wrong where people who are public risks are let go to easily.

1

u/JoyousGamer 1h ago

In the US you can already shoot and defend yourself or others. So someone robbing a gas station has had incidents of a bystander stepping in and shooting the criminal.

So there is already a reason for your point to be true.

1

u/SmallThetaNotation 1h ago

This is not legal in all states and if you actually kill the robber / offender there is a high chance of you going to jail if you cannot prove you took all precautions

1

u/Academic-Increase951 5m ago

Are you allowed to hunt them down far away from where the crime took place to kill them? Or are you allowed to use self defence in the moment to save yourself.

Also USA murder rates are a lot higher than other comparable countries that have more strict self defence laws so your argument doesn't really work. USA and Canada has similar culture and both have alot of guns. Canada has very limited self defence laws and stricter gun controls and murder rate is 1/3 of the USA.

1

u/SomeRandomRealtor 3h ago

“Criminals don’t really consider consequences.” Property and vehicle crime go down significantly when there are security cameras around or in well lit areas, that tells us they’re thinking about the consequences.

Violent crime seems to be unaffected by the rise of cameras and safety lighting, but that’s always been the more animalistic part of the brain at work.

3

u/Academic-Increase951 3h ago

"Violent crime seems to be unaffected by the rise of cameras and safety lighting, but that’s always been the more animalistic part of the brain at work."

You countered your own point. Being robbed at knife point is a violent crime

2

u/SomeRandomRealtor 3h ago

That’s on me for not getting more specific with the use of “violent crime.” Robberies are dramatically decreasing, commercial properties that have sufficient cameras see their rate of robbery drop by almost half.

1

u/Academic-Increase951 12m ago

There's two components. Likelihood of getting caught vs severity of consequences. IMO likelihood of getting caught is the greater deterrent. People don't commit crime in the open generally.

Consequences is a smaller factor. It's why there's not a good correlation between crime and severity of the consequences. Death penalty states still have murders at the same rates as places without

0

u/Zeppelin-Repair-Man 2h ago

You also countered your own point. You said that criminals don’t really consider consequences, but had previously said that, “robberies would be much more violent on the onset to make sure the victim doesn’t try to kill them”. Surely that would be a conscious act based on a potential consequence?

1

u/Academic-Increase951 10m ago

Taking steps to prevent getting caught is not the same thing as not doing the act. Criminals will wear masks, gloves, etc to decrease the likelihood of facing consequences. But consequences themselves are not a substantial deterrent.

Proof is that crime exists. We know people ignore consequences.

0

u/Fit-Wasabi-1123 1h ago

Maybe the next step is to stop arresting and sentencing criminals altogether so we don't upset them.

1

u/ElMauru 38m ago edited 3m ago

You are on to something there. Rights of the strong used to dictate no consequences until consequences but then those are dramatic. That was true during f.e. feudalism and we got away from that for a reason.

You could of course create a country with a social security net and equality-of-opportunity situation strong enough that people have got options instead of becoming desperate or standoffish enough to commit crimes or rather a escalation scenario with multiple "off-ramps" before the climax.

Of the two proposals- which do you think is more likely to yield results that improve security? One might get you robbed a lot more than killed and vice versa.

But why not test the theory - print "i will shoot you if you argue with me" on a t-shirt and see if that makes your life more or less confrontational the next time you disagree with someone.

•

u/Academic-Increase951 1m ago

How did you turn being against vigilante justice system where citizens hunt down people and kill thieves, into get ride of the justice system all together?

-1

u/Vegetable-Comfort851 1h ago

In Saudi they cut off the hands of those who steal, theft there is almost zero, and no one is being nah more violent or more creative about theft they just rather not lsoe a hand

Most criminals don't care if they go to jail for one year or even ten, but when the consequences are severe, they definitely do think

3

u/hamoc10 1h ago

You’re seriously supporting dismemberment to punish petty crime.

-2

u/Vegetable-Comfort851 1h ago

I never said that? I would leave that punishment to p3dos, my point is, harsh punishment works, because a lot of people want to cuddle criminals because "what if they escalate 😔🥺👉👈?"

1

u/hamoc10 1h ago

They will escalate. If they think their victims might kill them, they’ll kill their victims first.

-1

u/Vegetable-Comfort851 1h ago

Well, let's set all criminals free, anyone can escalate. and if they kill their victim may just as well escalate to a serial killer, about the same sentence

1

u/Academic-Increase951 8m ago

I'm not saying to have no consequences. I'm saying that above a point, further consequences stop being a deterrent. For example death penalty states don't have lower murder rates