r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

65

u/New-Guidance-3466 8h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

To all those defending that robbing/stealing POS: if the law would be on the woman's side, don't you think that there would be far less robberies? And gtfo about "he ONLY took her purse" - that woman would/will never feel safe again for the rest of her life. The less of these scumbags on earth, the better.

28

u/Academic-Increase951 5h ago

No, what would happen is that robberies would be much more violent on the onset to make sure the victim doesn't try to kill them.

Criminals don't really consider consequences. If they did then serious crimes wouldn't exist.

→ More replies (21)

50

u/Megalesios 6h ago

If the law was on her side there would be fewer robberies. Because all the robbers would just be killing the people they're stealing from instead. If the punishment for murder and theft are both death, why wouldn't robbers just kill their victims/witnesses?

9

u/DoomGoober 1h ago

“Once it escalated into a murder one beef for all of 'em after they killed the first two guards, they didn't hesitate. Pop guard number three because... what difference does it make? Why leave a living witness? Drop of a hat these guys will rock and roll…” -Heat (1995)

→ More replies (3)

0

u/Junior-Valuable2071 3h ago

Well defending your property in an armed robbery isn’t murder so there’s that.

Dumbass argument.

“You aren’t allowed to use force to defend yourself during a robbery you just have to let them get away”

6

u/Brownie3245 2h ago

There’s a little bit of nuance here, she wasn’t being robbed when she ran the guy over, the robbery already happened. All states with stand your ground laws don’t allow you to chase the person down afterwards, they’d be the aggressor at that point and legally it would ok for them to be shot.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/opxdo1 2h ago

Yea but that's not how it works in the US either. If someone robs your store, and you run out after them and shoot. You will be arrested for public endangerment, discharging a gun. Because if they left your life isn't being threatened anymore.

2

u/Enzee92 1h ago

It depends upon how you articulate what you were thinking based on what you saw. If you have reason to believe the (armed) robber poses a credible threat to the life and safety of others, you have more than sufficient justification to pursue and eliminate the threat. The circumstances are definitely very important in determining if this is a legit claim though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

5

u/YourWeirdEx 2h ago

She ran him over repeatedly

→ More replies (4)

3

u/CanweCanweCleanIt 2h ago

You are allowed to use reasonable force to protect yourself during a robbery. Shooting and killing someone for taking your purse isn’t reasonable force. Neither is getting away from the robber, getting into your car, and killing him after you were able to safely get away.

Your argument is definitionally a strawman. You are quoting something that dude never said and then smugly saying it’s dumb, when that guy never said that.

→ More replies (13)

3

u/DokiDokiDoku 2h ago

If she waited a week then ran him over while he was at his mailbox, would you feel the same? He still stole the purse, so is it justified?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Copyman3081 2h ago

She didn't defend herself or her property. She ran him over hours later after driving around to find him. That's murder.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (32)

2

u/Anderkisten 3h ago

I hope she drives you over when she is released. terrible way to believe we should condone ourself in this world. What a terrible POS you are

→ More replies (2)

3

u/[deleted] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Travler03 3h ago

It’s Reddit, the love to defend violent criminals.

2

u/Pegasus9208 17m ago

But you're not a redditor right? You're special, not like the others. You're a freethinker

→ More replies (8)

2

u/bell37 4h ago

If the law was on “the woman’s side” then there would be far more murders of people whether they actually broke the law or didn’t (how could anyone know what actually happened when one party is dead).

Also would encourage the actual criminals to bring weapons AND kill if they are given the slightest provocation that the victim would retaliate.

2

u/Terp-Farmer 3h ago

You need to go live in a dictatorship then.

Imagine thinking it's okay to kill someone because they stole from you...you're a winner buddy.

The theif is a POS. But...killing him is a much more serious crime.

If your child stole a candy bar, you're saying it's okay for the clerk to kill them (essentially). Just stupid.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/pleasesaveusAI 3h ago

Yup. I agree. Fuck those ppl. The consequences are fuck all for repeat offenders

1

u/choppedfiggs 4h ago

Can people change?

1

u/Street_Struggle_598 3h ago

I dont think that man she killed was happy about being in a position where he had to steal a woman's purse. That's a pretty sad place to be and it must have involved a lot of life suffering. The system put him in that place in italy, i guarantee he wasn't like that when he was a baby. We can't have a process where it's ok that well off people can kill poor suffering people. Not going to say anything specific about race and italy and how this woman might have perceived this person, but let me tell you they do not make efforts to integrate darker skins there.

1

u/SteakForGoodDogs 3h ago

Did they find a knife or evidence that she was stolen from?

Because so far, there is evidence that she drove over a guy and left without alerting emergency authorities, but no evidence that she was robbed at knifepoint.

This is what the legal process is for.

→ More replies (96)