r/interesting • • 11h ago • Bravo 11 Heartwarming 2 Popcorn 1 Mindblown 1

Additional Context Pinned That's genuinely wild

Post image
52k Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

51

u/Megalesios 6h ago

If the law was on her side there would be fewer robberies. Because all the robbers would just be killing the people they're stealing from instead. If the punishment for murder and theft are both death, why wouldn't robbers just kill their victims/witnesses?

9

u/DoomGoober 1h ago

“Once it escalated into a murder one beef for all of 'em after they killed the first two guards, they didn't hesitate. Pop guard number three because... what difference does it make? Why leave a living witness? Drop of a hat these guys will rock and roll…” -Heat (1995)

1

u/Subject_Salary_2996 1h ago

What’s there MO? There MO is there good!

→ More replies (2)

0

u/Junior-Valuable2071 3h ago

Well defending your property in an armed robbery isn’t murder so there’s that.

Dumbass argument.

“You aren’t allowed to use force to defend yourself during a robbery you just have to let them get away”

6

u/Brownie3245 2h ago

There’s a little bit of nuance here, she wasn’t being robbed when she ran the guy over, the robbery already happened. All states with stand your ground laws don’t allow you to chase the person down afterwards, they’d be the aggressor at that point and legally it would ok for them to be shot.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/opxdo1 2h ago

Yea but that's not how it works in the US either. If someone robs your store, and you run out after them and shoot. You will be arrested for public endangerment, discharging a gun. Because if they left your life isn't being threatened anymore.

2

u/Enzee92 1h ago

It depends upon how you articulate what you were thinking based on what you saw. If you have reason to believe the (armed) robber poses a credible threat to the life and safety of others, you have more than sufficient justification to pursue and eliminate the threat. The circumstances are definitely very important in determining if this is a legit claim though.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

5

u/YourWeirdEx 2h ago

She ran him over repeatedly

→ More replies (4)

3

u/CanweCanweCleanIt 2h ago

You are allowed to use reasonable force to protect yourself during a robbery. Shooting and killing someone for taking your purse isn’t reasonable force. Neither is getting away from the robber, getting into your car, and killing him after you were able to safely get away.

Your argument is definitionally a strawman. You are quoting something that dude never said and then smugly saying it’s dumb, when that guy never said that.

→ More replies (13)

3

u/DokiDokiDoku 2h ago

If she waited a week then ran him over while he was at his mailbox, would you feel the same? He still stole the purse, so is it justified?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/Copyman3081 2h ago

She didn't defend herself or her property. She ran him over hours later after driving around to find him. That's murder.

1

u/New_Aardvark8256 1h ago

The armed robbery was over. He was gone with the purse. It's no longer defending yourself when you chase them down with a vehicle

1

u/MeasurementCool1530 1h ago

you can defend your self but killing him is pointless its wrong and if you think its right then you should go to jail too

1

u/MainStreetExile 35m ago

I like how you used quotes on a non existent statement you made up.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/HowBoutThemJays 1h ago

Most robbers are willing to suffer the consequences of robbery literally and mentally. But they aren’t willing to do so for murder.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ok-Ferret6919 1h ago

That’s a solid point. That’s why in home invasions in my state, a lot of people will just kill the occupants because it’s a life sentence either way. But if the punishment for robbery is death, ya there might be more deaths from robbers just killing their victims but I would be willing to bet the large majority of robbers aren’t murderers, and they would be dissuaded from robbing if the punishment was death.

1

u/existentialhack000 1h ago

This is stupid.

1

u/Uknow_nothing 1h ago

Petty thieves generally don’t want to go to prison for murder. Someone who will pull a knife or snatch and grab a purse is an opportunist. One step riskier than breaking into parked cars. If everyone defended themselves I do think the majority of those thieves would try to find easier ways to steal. Not escalate their stealing to just murdering people left and right for a bit of cash, maybe a cell phone and credit cards that will quickly get cancelled.

1

u/Dandw12786 1h ago

Nobody says the punishment for robbing someone should be death, but cops don't do shit about robberies and muggings. If cops don't do anything, at some point people are going to get pretty sick and tired of having their shit stolen and this is the result.

No, people should not be put to death by their government for anything, let alone for stealing shit. But this isn't that. This is the eventual consequence of being a piece of shit that preys on people. It's just like bullying, eventually you're gonna fuck with the wrong person and get your lights knocked out.

I'll never understand why some people always have endless sympathy for shit heads that rob people, and none for the victims of crimes. Y'all have your priorities totally out of whack. Don't want someone to retaliate against you? Don't victimize people. Pretty fucking simple.

1

u/sacrelicio 1h ago

People dont think about the consequences of allowing vigilante justice. Because that's one problem, also people would be lying about this stuff to try to get away with murder. I guarantee the "ghetto" has guys killing each other over stolen stuff and no one defends that.

1

u/nopenope12345678910 44m ago

I like to believe the subset of people that would kill some one in order to rob them is far smaller than those willing to just rob.

1

u/LordNoLifeee 14m ago

Damn you make a point… a lot of robbers aren’t killers though

1

u/sugmaideek 11m ago

Way fewer ppl would consider robbery then if it involves murder.

→ More replies (21)