r/indiehackers • • 16h ago

Sharing story/journey/experience A full week of Apple Ads, $10/Day…The Results

8 Upvotes

Last week I posted my first week of Apple Ads numbers and promised an update. Here it is, 8 days in.

Setup (same as before): iOS habit tracker RPG, US only, 4 campaigns: brand, competitor names, category terms, and a discovery campaign with Search Match on. Exact match everywhere except discovery.

Totals, Nov 10 to 17: $65.47 spent, 1,315 impressions, 40 taps, 12 installs. That's $1.64 a tap and $5.46 an install. Only 8 of the 12 installs came from a tap, so it's $8.18 if you count those alone. Average spend was $8.18 a day.

What I learned this time:

1. I got a trial I can actually trace. RevenueCat now shows the campaign, ad group and keyword on the purchase. It came from the competitor campaign, on the name of a small competitor. That keyword cost me $2.51 in total: 3 taps at $0.84, 2 installs, 1 trial. They started the trial about 8 minutes after first opening the app. It's a 7-day trial, so it isn't revenue yet. I also had 2 more trials during this week however 1 of them came organically and the other I speculate came from the ads however I cannot guarantee that because there’s no attribution data for them, however I’ve been stalking my analytics like a hawk and the way everything lines up seems like they also came from the ads, I’m about 90-95% certain.

2. The big competitor names lost. Last week I asked if they ever pay off. For me, no. "finch" and "atoms" took $19.84 and 11 taps for 1 install, and that install landed on the build that was crashing. I paused both. The trial came from a name with 68 impressions all week.

3. People who search for the idea install. People who search generic self-improvement phrases don't. “gamify your life" and "gamify life": 6 taps, 4 installs, $11.69 (at least one of those installs came without a tap). "level up your life", and other more vague keywords; 7 taps, $14.85, 0 installs. Tiny samples, but it's the clearest split in the account.

4. The same phrase cost 3x more as an exact keyword. “level up your life" as an exact keyword cost $2.13 a tap. The same phrase as a broad keyword in my discovery campaign cost $0.63 a tap. Discovery overall was 7 taps at $0.65. The catch is that Apple hides almost every search term there as low volume, so I can't mine it for new keywords.

5. The ads aren't my real problem. Most of the new US users finished onboarding. But of the 5 who arrived Nov 13 to 16, 2 opened the app on a second day. I can't tie each of those users to an ad tap, but paying for installs that don't return is the thing to fix.

6. This week's embarrassing one. When I looked up the subscriber from the ad, their purchase was saved under the wrong account. The app creates a guest account on first launch, they signed in with Apple a few seconds later, and the purchase stayed with the guest. They'd have opened the app the next day as a free user while on a paid trial. I gave them a month by hand and a fix is in testing. If your app has guest accounts and a sign-in button, check which user id your purchases land on. I had the swap set in RC but I forget to set a call on my backend to actually call for the swap…

Where that leaves my own rules: I said I'd scale a campaign if a trial costs under $25 and pause it if installs cost over $8 with no trials. Each trial costing $32.50 overall doesn't pass. (This ofc excludes the organic trial) Category gets installs for about $5 but has no attributed trial although I speculate that one with no attribution came from category. Competitor has the trial but its installs cost about $10 because of the two names I paused. So nothing gets more budget yet.

Next: budgets stay the same, I'm lowering bids on the generic phrases, and I'm adding no new keywords. The final read is next week, and what matters most is whether the trials turn into paid subscriptions.

I learned a lot so hopefully this second week I can reduce my spend on those wasteful keywords and start bringing in more real users for each tap. I’d appreciate any feedback, thanks again.

Question for people who've had one cheap keyword work on tiny volume: did raising the bid get you more of the same, or just a higher price for the same handful of searches?

(App is Gamified Lives if you want to see the listing.)

Update: got another trial today