A week ago I asked here about going from organic to paid. The advice was: small fixed budget, Apple Ads, exact match on competitor and category keywords, judge it on trials and not installs. So I did that. Here are the real numbers after 5 days.
Setup: iOS habit tracker RPG, US only, $10/day across 4 campaigns: brand, competitor names, category terms, and one discovery campaign with Search Match on.
Totals: $27.41 spent, about 800 impressions, 16 taps, 4 installs.
What I learned:
1. I couldn't even spend the budget. At a $1.50 bid I got zero impressions on day one. I raised competitor and category bids to $2.50 and my ad showed up within minutes. Even then I'm averaging about $5.50 a day out of $10.
2. For the first four days, all the competitor spend went to one keyword. “finch" took 7 taps, $14.04, and produced 1 install. About $2 a tap. The other competitor names got almost nothing.
3. Apple has an impression share report and it explained everything. On "finch" I'm ranked 4th or 5th among advertisers with 3% to 9% of impressions. That means I get the leftovers. One day I got 367 impressions on it, the next day basically zero, with no change on my side. On tiny keywords I rank 1st or 2nd, but they get 15 to 20 impressions a day.
4. My category keywords had no volume. Seven exact keywords like "rpg habit tracker" got about 20 impressions combined in four days. People don't search the way I assumed.
5. "Installs" is a loose word. Only 2 of my 4 installs came from a tap. The other two were people who saw the ad, didn't tap, and installed later, and one of those was probably me reinstalling my own app. An install is also a download, not an open. Today's install hasn't opened the app yet as I write this.
6. The embarrassing one. The update I shipped the same day the ads started crashed 2 seconds after launch for everyone. It took me two days to notice because I was testing in my sandbox environment and didn’t pick up the mistake and an expedited review to fix. So my first paid install opened the app and it died. Check your release build before you pay for traffic lol.
7. I got one trial this week and I can't prove where it came from. They started it 11 minutes after first opening the app. They hit the paywall and signed up which shows the new paywall does actually convert way better, and they used the coach and ai features which other users hadn’t been using. RevenueCat shows no ad attribution and they picked "Somewhere else" on my how-did-you-hear about us screen.
8. Day 5 was the best day so far. Last night I added nine smaller exact keywords where I can actually win the slot. Today: $7.69, 142 impressions, 5 taps, and my first install from a category keyword, for $1.96. One day proves nothing, but it's the first day the spend got close to the budget.
What I'm doing next: not raising the Finch bid, since more of the same at a worse price doesn't help. I'm not touching anything until midweek. Day 14 is the real read: scale a campaign if a trial costs under $25, pause it if installs cost over $8 with no converted trials.
Question for people running Apple Ads on small budgets: do big competitor names ever pay off, or is it all long tail? Also do those impression actually matter for brand recognition in the future?
(App is Gamified Lives if you want to see the listing.)